8 ms·
Cisco CEO Predicts ‘Brutal’ IT Consolidation
- 6cxs2hd6 12y agoThe slide that shows them #1 share in "Cloud"... does anyone know what that actually means?
- csears 12y agoIt's not very clear, but it sounds like a roll up of various *-as-a-Service offerings, each of which may have been #1 in their niche markets. Also the fabled OpenStack InterCloud seems to fall into this business unit. There's a fairly long list of the products/services here: http://www.zdnet.com/ciscos-big-cloud-play-why-it-had-little-choice-7000027647/ http://www.zdnet.com/ciscos-big-cloud-play-why-it-had-little...
- Guthur 12y agoCloud is a marketing term more often than not. Reminds me of EA's (computer games) latest Sim City. They stated that the player's city would be saved on the cloud, when in reality players logged onto various regional servers ie Europe1 Europe2 etc. The player's saved city were only available on the server they were created on. This was just really naive explicit horizontal scaling and not the seamlessly scaled client/server arch their marketing implied. So yeah 'Cloud' mostly a marketing term.
- Spooky23 12y agoThey consider UCS a private cloud in the can, which was introduced at a good time when IBM's f-up of x86 was enough to scare away even risks adverse enterprise customers. So they've seen lots of traction. They also consider webex and some UC stuff (Jabber, some voip, etc) "cloud".
- gaius 12y agoCloud is anything you want it to be. That is literally what the symbol means on architecture diagrams.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- csears 12y agoThe idea that big companies who fail to innovate will die off or get acquired is hardly an earth-shattering prediction... it's just the way things have always happened. The more interesting long term question is how much IT infrastructure will organizations want to own and how much they will want to push off to service providers. I think Cisco will find it hard to maintain their margins and growth if enterprises make a major shift to off-prem cloud infrastructure.
- spydum 12y agoCloud hosted infrastructure hurts EBITDA, most enterprises will never move, as OPEX is a dirty word.
- rdl 12y agoI'm sure there will be a financial innovation to address that. Like Reserved Instances, but more so.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoohhhh that's interesting ... especially as all it takes to make cloud a capital investment is a contract with the cloud provider and rental agreement ...
- ahsanup 12y agoUnless you're an insanely large company, in the long-run, you can probably save on OPEX by switching to cloud infrastructure. You get away from purchasing hardware for yourself, which inherently reduces OPEX.
- discodave 12y agoErr, doesn't a hosted solution reduce capex and increase opex?
- api_or_ipa 12y ago[I'm not an accountant] I think spydum's comment refers to the difference in the effect on the balance sheet. If you outright buy servers, you incur a capital investment in a fixed asset, which increases your balance sheet but doesn't hurt your EBITA. If you instead contract out to a 3rd party cloud provider, you incur an OPEX-- which shows up on your income statement and lowers your EBITA. I'm not sure how investors favour this difference, but I do know that airline companies love to move aircraft purchases off their balance sheet, probably for cash flow reasons. They do this by leasing a/c instead of outright purchases. You've now gotten me curious as to why firms behave different when it comes to buying aircraft vs servers.
- general_failure 12y agoStating the obvious stuff mostly.
- higherpurpose 12y agoIf anyone deserves to fall from the 5 it's Cisco (and Oracle, but that's more like wishful thinking).
- qwerta 12y agoYou have to give some credit to HP, they are trying really hard.
- briandh 12y agoWhat does "the 5" refer to?
- JanezStupar 12y agoMy guess is: Cisco, Microsoft, Intel, Hewlett Packard, Oracle (IBM?)?
- droopyEyelids 12y agoAh, just imagine the Cisco sales rep. He's with your CIO in a skybox at the big game. Salmon fillets sizzle in olive oil as he pulls down his sleeve... He's done talking to your CIO about their Rolex watches, and now it's time for business. "You see," he says "Thats exactly how an Open Source solution on white label hardware will end up costing your company AT LEAST 25% more! Once you've got a few UCS chassis installed, you start to see how things work because you don't even install servers or switches anymore! There's not even a choice. It's just blades and fabric interconnects. Imagine all the time you'll save worrying about compatibility, proof of concepts, the support costs, training..."
- enraged_camel 12y agoI didn't understand half the terminology you used, which means I'm well on my way to become a CIO and buy lots of Cisco products!
- redwood 12y agoNot 25%, "about 27%" lol
- us0r 12y agoLOL having sat in on many of these... shows? ... adventures? this is about spot on.
- nrao123 12y agoThis is a must read article for anybody Trying to understand what's going on in the hardware / server side for enterprise IT. Cisco's bet seems to be that they can't do anything about hyper scale data centers (AWS, google, Azure, Facebook etc) since they will have the scale to design their own hardware. So- they are going after large enterprises that want to still have their own servers. In this market they seem to be growing. But - their strategy reminds of me Of trying to provide the most efficient newspaper printing machine just before the printed newspaper itself gets killed. Two points supporting the newspaper analogy: 1) If the applications themselves (SalesForce, workday, Successfactors etc) are moving to the cloud & delivered from their own servers or AWS, Then won't the overall demand for enterprise hardware Itself reduce? 2) Even if companies want their own custom Computing resources (e.g. Analytics) - won't These sub-scale enterprises themselves go with The hyper scale data centers (AWS, azure etc) ? What on earth makes these enterprise companies believe That they can take Cisco hardware & believe that they Can be more cost efficient than AWS/Azure.
- opendais 12y agoGiven a significant number of companies are most cost effective than AWS/Azure/Google/Etc with relatively stable workloads, I think you are completely nuts. AWS's calculator and the assumptions the threw into it pretty much proves they aren't cost effective except compared to other cloud providers. They basically 'made up' the self hosted numbers. At $DAY_JOB, our self-hosting costs at a colo facility are something like 33% the cost of using AWS.
- valas 12y agoPerhaps at current AWS prices your self-hosting is 3x cheaper. But thinking about fundamentals, a few years out, why do you think self-hosting will still be cheaper? What is it in self-hosting that economies of scale of AWS/GCE can't crush?
- opendais 12y ago1) They are dependent on Intel or AMD for the higher end processors. This is a $5 billion-per-factory industry. So that is one thing they can't easily replicate. http://www.informationweek.com/cloud/infrastructure-as-a-service/amazon-web-services-revenue-new-details/d/d-id/1112068 http://www.informationweek.com/cloud/infrastructure-as-a-ser...? They don't make that on AWS, in gross revenues. This is similarly true of most hardware inside a modern server. They can make small improvements but they can't magically take over the CPU market or any of the other core components in a 'big way'. 2) Creating all that in-house software automation is complicated, difficult, and expensive. This software isn't a requirement for in-house hosting. So they need to crush the margins of their supplies [power; bandwidth; hardware] to the point that they can get their own margin on top of that + cover the cost of a bunch of custom in-house software development. For a stable workload...that just isn't going to happen. AWS isn't going to cut their prices 33% after the largest price cut I've ever seen them make in April, let alone the 67% they'd need to. Sure, in 10 years, they might manage it. I don't see it happening faster than that.
- dmourati 12y agoI just took a quick diversion from reading The Functional Art to checkout this story. The book covers information visualization and the three graphics in this story would rate very low according to the book's guidelines, in particular the series of pie charts. I enjoyed the brutal comment though.
- incision 12y agoThe traditional enterprise IT ship is about to slip beneath the waves and Cisco wants everyone to know they have a sizable piece of wreckage to cling to. Not a bad strategy. I find it funny that Cisco loves to paint itself as prescient when they're actually pretty erratic and consistently late. They're just huge, yet nimble enough to consistently make the podium in some sense. Cisco bought Tandberg as the world was moving on with Skype, Hangouts and Facetime. Cisco brought forth converged infrastructure as the world was shifting out of the datacenter. Cisco started making sizable investments in private/hybrid cloud in the last year when it would have meant a lot more in 2010. You've probably never heard of Cius, Quad or SDN (in relation to Cisco) but they were keynotes 4, 3 and 2 years ago respectively. >'And if you look at three years ago, Huawei, Avaya, and Juniper were the worries, and they were going to eat our lunch.' Cisco didn't fend off Huawei so much as the government blocked them from competing on the premise that China would do exactly what it turned out the NSA was already doing.
- RockyMcNuts 12y agoUnlike Wintel, even mobile/cloud still needs network equipment LOL. It's a pretty amazing business, when you think about how much you pay per Ethernet port to run your business, and how much goes to Cisco, and what it costs to make that equipment. Think about what you pay for a firewall, router, switch vs. a server. But software-defined networking seems like a paradigm shift that will be rather disruptive. Just makes no sense to buy all those firewall, router, and switch boxes, when they could all be virtualized and integrated (like VMware did to servers, and they want to do to networks with the Nicira SDN acquisition). Meanwhile, Cisco makes a lot of acquisitions, many of which seem pretty stupid: Scientific-Atlanta and NDS, just when cable TV is about to get its lunch eaten by over-the-top; Flip video camera (Pure Digital) just when it's about to become an iPhone feature (and I guess they couldn't turn it into GoPro) Then they bought back $70b worth of stock since the dot-com crash, distributed a rather hefty chunk of that to management. Enterprise value down to $96b. So...could be a great business but not sure it's a great strategy or great management.
- contingencies 12y agoAgreed. This is mostly marketing drivel. True story from this weekend: I have been setting up some Cisco branded devices. 'Hidden costs' were mentioned in the presentation... I found plenty with Cisco's stuff: the fact that their reams of documentation are almost designed not to get you moving, the fact that they insist on using RS232 console cables in this era of zero RS232 port availability, the fact that they constantly software-license features that complicate getting anything done, the fact that they want you to use some kind of ridiculous Java interface (that won't run on most versions of the JRE, on most platforms), the fact that their systems take minutes to tens of minutes to reboot despite being built for purpose... I'm sure I could go on. I've wasted hundreds of hours on Cisco kit in the last 20 years, and quite frankly I'm happy to avoid it whenever possible. Huawei is kicking ass, Cisco is bullshitting everyone in this presentation as far as legally possible.