4 ms·
I'm firmly of the mind that there are Really Good People to be found all over the place, not just traditional "powerhouse" schools. That said, at Fogbeam now w
by mindcrime 13y ago
I'm firmly of the mind that there are Really Good People to be found all over the place, not just traditional "powerhouse" schools.
That said, at Fogbeam now we have one founder (me) who attended UNC-Wilmington and 3 different community colleges and never finished his bachelors, two UNC-CH grads (and one of those two has returned to school at UNC-CH to take graduate classes) and one guy with a community college degree in business administration who's now studying C.S. at UNC-CH. So UNC Chapel Hill is heavily represented among our team, and it's hardly a bad school. But I've always maintained that when we have money to start recruiting "real employees", I intend to recruit at places like NCCU (North Carolina Central University), NC A&T, Fayetteville State, UNC-Pembroke, St. Augustines, Meredith, Shaw, William Peace, UNC-Greensboro, Wake Tech, Durham Tech, etc.
Why? Well, because I believe that are good, smart, talented people to be found there, and with the bonus that we're less likely to be competing against Google, IBM, Microsoft, Facebook, etc. for talent there. And furthermore, I find that you sometimes find people from the less touted schools who have something of a chip on their shoulders, have something to prove, and are just plain hungry to achieve. And those are people I like working with.
Anyway, sure, if you have a chance to go to Stanford or Berkeley or MIT, go for it. Why wouldn't you? But by the same token, if you don't go to one of those schools for whatever reason, it hardly means you can't still have a great career and accomplish things.
- xienze 13y agoI'm a little surprised that you've rattled off just about every single school in NC except NC State. Any particular reason?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mindcrime 13y agoNah, there are a lot of other schools here: Western Carolina, UNC-Asheville, East Carolina, Appalachian State, Campbell, UNC-Charlotte, Elizabeth City State, Elon, Duke, Wake Forest, Winston-Salem State, etc. I wasn't trying to list them all, but trying to emphasize the ones that I perceive as being considered "less touted" in relative terms. NCSU is actually pretty highly regarded, especially the engineering programs and the veterinary program, so that's the only real reason I didn't mention them. Same for Duke, which is generally regarded as a fairly "elite" school as well.
- hkmurakami 13y agoI've definitely met some great minds from NC State :)
- mindcrime 13y agoSame here. I have plenty of friends from all of NCSU, UNC, Duke, etc... sports rivalries and what-not aside, I consider all of them to be - at a minimum - "Pretty Good" schools. UNC is widely considered one of the so-called "Public Ivys" and Duke is generally held up as "elite" if a step below "Ivy League" or whatever. And State definitely has a strong reputation, especially in certain areas like engineering and veterinary science. I think their MBA program is also ranked fairly highly as well.
- xienze 13y agoHeh, fair enough. Was just thinking for a minute that you were suggesting you'd consider Wake Tech grads over NCSU grads and I started getting a little concerned about my school's image :).
- mindcrime 13y agoNo, nothing like that at all. But what I would be saying is that - as a resource constrained startup - I'd likely recruit at Wake Tech before NCSU, since it's more likely the NCSU guy or gal is going to also be talking to various $BIGCORPs that are seen as highly desirable places to work. and I started getting a little concerned about my school's image Well, the old joke does still stand: Person A: Where are you going to school? Person B: NC State Person A: Oh that's great, once you graduate you can get a job at John Deere. (j/k'ing!!!!)
- zippergz 13y agoAgreed. I went to a decent but. It noteworthy state school (and the list of things it is known for does not include CS). But I've worked at more than one of the companies on that infographic, and have had a nice career so far. I don't feel that my lack of a brand name school has necessarily held me back (though I'd also agree that if I'd have known the career path I was going to take, and if I'd have been able to get into a top tier school, I would have).
- timr 13y agoAbsolutely. I didn't go to a powerhouse school for undegrad, and I've subsequently worked with a lot of people from "powerhouse" schools. In my experience, there's not much difference between a top MIT/Stanford/Berkeley undergrad and a top student where I went to school. The difference is in the distribution: the best schools can pick amongst great applicants, and therefore have a better average student. The valley is very credentialist, in my experience. Most bigger companies are dominated by graduates from top programs, partly because they have dumb recruiting policies (i.e. paying big money for career fairs at top programs, and ignoring everyone else), partly because once you get a network of grads from a school, it tends to perpetuate itself. But to the extent that this turns into a bias against students from other schools, it's an institutional weakness. Top programs don't have a monopoly on good students. They don't even have most of them. And the academic job market is so competitive that even the tiniest regional college is going to have faculty from top programs, teaching the same material as every other accredited program. Even the books are the same. But, hey, you big guys keep fighting over the MIT grads and ignoring everyone else. More candidates for the rest of us.
- jhonovich 13y ago"In my experience, there's not much difference between an MIT/Stanford/Berkeley undergrad and a top student where I went to school." So the average student at a top school is roughly equal to a top student at an average school?
- hkmurakami 13y agoAs a former average engineering student at a top school who's befriended and worked with a good number of top students at good but not top schools (ex: students on full rides in state school engineering programs), top students at these schools are probably somewhat better than the average student at a top school. Of course, this is just an anecdotal perspective. Your mileage may vary.
- timr 13y agoI spoke imprecisely -- I don't have enough information to make that kind of a claim about "average students" (hopefully obviously). But of the people I've worked with, there's no difference at the high end. Good students are just as good at no-name schools as they are at MIT. I updated my comment to be more clear.
- sytelus 13y agoNo one doubts if unknown schools have any good candidates at all. It's all about probability of finding number of good candidates. Top schools are all about providing fat pipelines of possibly talented individuals with very high probability. And let's not kid ourselves that every school has very large pool of talent. No one turns down offer from Stanford for the opportunity to study at Fayetteville State. The most likely reason person ends up at non top 5 schools is because they couldn't get in those. This implies that pretty much every one wants to study at top school. So top school gets first cut at widest possible selection of candidates and left over goes elsewhere. So the talent is indeed concentrated at top 5 schools. Again keep in mind probabilities (take a course! This is one of the most important subject to learn, IMO) - it doesn't imply that talent is non-existent in other schools. So the probability of hiring 100 talented candidates who can get through same grueling interview at Fayetteville State should be fairly lower than at Stanford or MIT.
- mindcrime 13y agoNo one turned down offer from Stanford for the opportunity to study at Fayetteville State Probably not, but my hypothesis is that there are people at, say, Fayetteville State, that could have gone to Stanford but never even bothered applying. Maybe they thought they couldn't afford it, maybe they didn't want to move so far from home, who knows. And I also believe there are people who "couldn't get in" to, say, Stanford, who would still have excelled at Stanford had they attended. Some people aren't good high school students for any number of reasons, but are much better college students, but they don't have the grades to get into the "elite" schools. So sure, if you came from a family who emphasized getting into Harvard or Stanford, and drove you relentlessly to get great grades, and provided all the support you needed all through high-school, and you were well fed everyday and had after-school SAT training, etc,, etc., then you probably should have gotten a 1600 on the SAT and gone to Harvard. But a LOT of people were missing one or more of those elements in their upbringing. Not to mention, some people (this was my story) basically just blow off high-school because they're bored senseless, resent being forced to attend, and aren't the people with the right temperament to be part of the cool clique and therefore despise huge swathes of their time at school. Of course, that same kid is probably going home and building Tesla coils and experimenting with high-voltage electronics, or writing code or something after school, but it isn't reflected in their grades, and it won't help them get into an "elite" school. Also keep in mind that I'm not saying that a Fayetteville State or UNC Pembroke represents a "fat pipeline". But I am saying it represents a pipeline, and one where a resource starved startup is less likely to be competing against Google or IBM or Facebook or Yahoo, etc., for people.
- xux 13y agoThis isn't about an individual. Of course Really Good People can come from anywhere, but not with the same probability. And when you're recruiting, you want to hit schools with high concentration of talents. You'd be lying to yourself if you think schools like NCCU and Durham Tech have the same concentration of talents as MIT, Stanford, etc.