2 ms·
Plenty of children struggle in school and go on to do amazing things afterward, and plenty of “child geniuses” are lavished with attention and go on to do nothi
by jacobolus 12y ago
Plenty of children struggle in school and go on to do amazing things afterward, and plenty of “child geniuses” are lavished with attention and go on to do nothing notable.
The purpose of a school should be to encourage all students to flourish, not to pick the ones who will “advance civilization” at age 5.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoSo, just ignore the potential benefit to society of identifying and using the brains of those who are "gifted"? We don't have to ditch the program of public schooling in order to do so. Arguably by not challenging those at the top end of the academic achievement spectrum one is not "encourag[ing] all students to flourish".
- netcan 12y agoThis is a bit of a straw-man. No one is suggesting teaching just the top 1% and leaving the rest to fend for themselves. Just putting them in a separate class for a few hour a week so they can be with other smart kids and be challenged. The bottom 10-20% in every subject could probably use something similar.