7 ms·
There's No Rulebook for Sex Verification
- anigbrowl 17y agoIn the future, there will be illegal clone racing.
- mrtron 17y agoIs it tragic that it will be illegal?
- anigbrowl 17y agoIt will be in the movie version...to be honest the above just popped into my head while I was brushing my teeth earlier and I typed it in without really thinking. Didn't mean to abuse HN as my personal notebook :-/
- danw 17y agoI believe that in addition to the Olympics and paralympics there should be an 'enhanced' Olympics. Any artificial limbs, performance enhancing drugs, etc would be allowed. A celebration of human technological progress.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- joshu 17y agoI've always wanted an "all modifications allowed" olympics. Athletes on three kinds of steroids, runners with /wheels/, whatever. I'd pay to see that.
- boredguy8 17y agoSo good. Binary conceptions of gender really need to go the way of the dodo.
- hughprime 17y agoGiven that 99-point-something percent of people fall into one biological category or the other, it's a pretty reasonable approximation.
- josefresco 17y agoThere are more cross-gender people in America than there are Jews.
- dmm 17y agoA binary conception of Jewness is insufficient.
- DTrejo 17y agoWhy?
- pyre 17y agoWell, does 'Jew' describe one's ancestry or one's religion?
- DTrejo 17y agoBoth.
- pyre 17y agoSo someone with Jewish ancestry that is a practicing Catholic, and someone that is not of Jewish ancestry that converted to Judaism are both Jewish? That sort of makes it an ambiguous term, no? What if someone was born to two parents that are not of Jewish ancestry, but converted to Judaism? Is that person a Jew by birth? What if that person becomes a Buddhist later in life? Are they still a Jew?
- shrikant 17y agoSo, uh, here's a weird suggestion - have THREE categories: 1. Verifiably male 2. Verifiably female 3. None of the above This would probably spur more transgenders into track and field, and sports in general..
- jacquesm 17y agoI think you're going in the wrong direction with this, why not simply have one category and rank them all as 'people', the ultimate in emancipation.
- modoc 17y agoWorks out poorly for most women who then wouldn't get a chance at the podium in the majority of sports. I mean it's fine with me, I'm a male who's not too into sports, but...:)
- jacquesm 17y agoSo, your average female sporter would probably blow you away in most contests then. But that should not degrade you just as it should not degrade her when competing against a more capable person, male or female. It's the personal achievement that counts, you against the clock or your sense of self worth, not you against somebody else. Unless 'racing' someone will spur you to work harder. What about number 4 then, he never gets to be on the podium either, why only 3 top spots ? And if you make 4, what about #5 ?
- dgordon 17y ago"So, your average female sporter would probably blow you away in most contests then." This is irrelevant. In track and field, elite to sub-elite high school boys beat all women ever in the sprints and field events, and even in longer distances the best US high school boys beat the women's world records. In basketball, for instance, the difference is even greater because height makes a big difference -- in fact, D1 women's basketball programs apparently bring in men who are semi-serious intramural basketball players to get better competition in practice.
- clintboxe 17y agoPoor Matthew!
- SwellJoe 17y agoMiddlesex is one of the best novels of the decade, and covers the gender question in vivid and scientifically sound detail.
- SapphireSun 17y agoDoes anyone know why she was called to have her sex verified? I'm not a sports fan, so maybe I'm missing something, but it is not in any article I've read in passing.
- astine 17y agoI caught in on the news earlier today. It's because she is a. significantly faster than her peers and b. looks , walks, and sounds like a man.
- jodrellblank 17y agoThis is why: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRTdsxjYbJA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRTdsxjYbJA - from 1:30s halfway through the second lap, she pulls ahead as if she was ... well, a man running in the womens race.
- lacker 17y agoDang, I was hoping this article would be about the difficulty of passing the Turing test.