3 ms·
Why do languages always have to evolve? On average, do languages get better over time or do they deteriorate? I am sure that Java has deteriorated a lot. Keep
by Tichy 17y ago
Why do languages always have to evolve? On average, do languages get better over time or do they deteriorate? I am sure that Java has deteriorated a lot.
Keep it simple, please!
- noss 17y agoYes, things used to be better. It's the decay of the youth.
- Tichy 17y agoNo, but maybe featuritis is how languages die, to be replaced by newer, simpler languages.
- apotheon 17y agoSometimes, the newer, simpler languages are new versions of the older, more byzantine languages. I think that's basically the Perl 6 approach, for instance. It's called "evolution", in some circles.
- maxwell 17y agoIt's like sketching with pencil. Your first version is complicated and gets a lot wrong, with stray lines all about. The final one is cleaned up and simple, yet that simplicity is a direct result of that messy progenitor.
- maxwell 17y agoSimplicity of use is what seems important, not necessarily simplicity of design. Though JavaScript is more complicated than C in the sense of having more features, those features generally result in source files that're more succinct and faster to write (since you don't have to, say, roll your own hashtables).
- mrshoe 17y agos/languages/software/g
- burke 17y agoLike small-scheme. Problem solved.
- gnaritas 17y agoJava was never simple. Scheme is simple, Smalltalk is simple, Java was always a beast.
- Tichy 17y agoProbably, but they still managed to make it far worse (generics, annotations, ...).
- AlisdairO 17y agoI see that the poor implementation of generics is an issue, but what's so bad about annotations?
- Tichy 17y agoMy main issue is that they add more complexity to the language, making it harder to learn and to understand. They also encourage even more verbosity in an already verbose language. Furthermore, the uses I have seen all seemed a bit borderline - they used to say that configuration should stay out of the code, but now it sneaked in again.
- nradov 17y agoHow else would you propose to make meta-information about code available at run time? Before annotations we had to put that information in separate configuration files. That ended up being more complex, and harder to learn and understand.
- Tichy 17y agoI only know it in the context of Hibernate, and there are ORM frameworks in languages that don't have annotations. The separate config files had something going for them, because it keeps the concerns distinct.
- modoc 17y agoI'm much happier with jdk 1.5 than I was with 1.4 or 1.3 or 1.2 etc.... Not sure why you don't like the new additions. In general you don't have to use them if you don't want to.
- whye 17y agoLua started out as a configuration language in 1993 and since then has evolved into a more general purpose language that is cleaner, yet more flexible and powerful. It has gotten much better with time. for more information, see: The Evolution of Lua - http://www.tecgraf.puc-rio.br/~lhf/ftp/doc/hopl.pdf http://www.tecgraf.puc-rio.br/~lhf/ftp/doc/hopl.pdf