4 ms·
If the charter for the "large language" was replaced with "create a Standard Library for Scheme," would it make any practical difference? In other words, does
by jimbokun 17y ago
If the charter for the "large language" was replaced with "create a Standard Library for Scheme," would it make any practical difference?
In other words, does the "large language" really require any different language features, or just the libraries that "large" Scheme implementations should implement?
- btilly 17y agoFrom the statement it looks like they want the "large language" to standardize "the module language, exception system, s-expression grammar, etc." That would give a standard target for libraries to target, which would make it easier to write libraries and applications that are portable across different popular versions of Scheme. Good luck, but I confidently predict failure. Lisp attracts language perfectionists, and then differing opinions among perfectionists about what is perfect results in fragmentation. People who are not language perfectionists are more likely to be satisfied with a popular language with glaring deficiencies but lots of reasonably well implemented libraries. Which in my opinion describes the comparison languages in that statement, namely Perl, Python, C, and Ruby.
- gchpaco 17y agoTom Lord has pointed out elsewhere that the "large" language might, for example, mandate Unicode for characters whereas the "small" language might not, just to pick one difference. Partial continuations like shift/reset can be implemented on top of call/cc but not efficiently. More to the point, there is a small but exceedingly vocal subset of the Scheme community that hates the idea that the language should e.g. define a module system even though practically this is an absolute requirement to get any real work done. It is worth pointing out that until R6RS, which has attracted a great deal of criticism, there was no way to define user-defined types within the language. "Small Scheme" can wither and die for all I care; I want to use the language, not worship it, and so R6RS is right up my alley.