3 ms·
Excellent extract: > All jet pilots are held to the same stick-and-rudder standards of the FAA Airline Transport Pilot practical test (see faa.gov). A 70-seat
by ekianjo 13y ago
Excellent extract:
> All jet pilots are held to the same stick-and-rudder standards of the FAA Airline Transport Pilot practical test (see faa.gov). A 70-seat jet presents the same flying challenge as a 150-seat jet. The captain and first officer trade "pilot flying" and "pilot monitoring" roles on each leg of a trip. When the actual jobs are so similar, how is it possible that some airline pilots earn $16,000 per year and others earn close to $300,000? The captains, of course, do have more experience and that experience has value to the employer, which is why non-unionized air carriers may establish a 2:1 or 3:1 difference in pay between their most senior and most junior pilots. But how can we explain a 19:1 pay differential for workers with similar training and tasks?
The answer is to look at who controls the pilot's union: very senior pilots. The airline management is mostly interested in what percentage of its revenues are paid out to pilots; the distribution of the money among the pilots does not affect profitability. The very senior pilots on the other side of the table say "We need the most senior pilots to get $300,000 in pay and benefits." The airline's response is "The only way that could work is if we pay the new pilots $16,000 per year." The group of senior pilots responds "We can live with that."
And this is scary:
> From the point of view of safety, common sense would argue against pairing up a company's least experienced pilots with the company's least experienced captains and then driving them both to exhaustion. But that's how nearly all unionized U.S. airlines do it.
- handelaar 13y agoRemove the union. Now everybody gets paid $16,000 and the "percentage of revenues paid to pilots" can be slashed. Is that a) Better? b) The other thing? (Yes, the current situation sucks and those unions certainly don't help it any. This is not an argument for the status quo.)
- ekianjo 13y agoIf you remove unions from all airlines, then it's very likely going to bring the salaries up for inexperienced pilots, because then the airlines have more flexibility as to how much they pay pilots per head, and will likely compete just like they do on the marketplace in other categories of jobs.
- krisgee 13y agoNot trying to be snarky but are there any historical examples of across the board raises that have stuck after a union gets busted?
- dopamean 13y agoThe answer is no. If there were you'd already know about it because anti-union people would bring it up at every opportunity.
- Shivetya 13y agoThe reverse is very much true too. Having seen what some new pilots make and the shit routes they get all this talk about how negotiations somehow favor them over senior pilots is odd, those negotiations are refinements of existing contracts which have always benefited those with the most years. They encourage staying at your airline because when you don't you fall in rank and pay, the same when you get bought out. Hence when mergers occur the different unions have to agree to their members don't lose out. In a highly specialized and professional trade as pilots are I am still trying to see why a union is necessary.
- cynicalkane 13y agoNo examples of a union being "busted" but in a few cities there's been a pattern of massively increased junior salaries for teachers, together with a significant weakening of teachers' union power.
- Yver 13y agoAny example that you could, you know, share?
- Dylan16807 13y agoThe comment you are replying to says nothing about 'across the board'.
- hueving 13y ago
- Strang 13y agoI'm not sure why you assume that removing the union will result in all pilots making a pittance. I am not in a union, yet I make more than $16,000.
- mcv 13y agoThe problem is that those unions seem to operate in a very short-sighted selfish way with no regard for the consequences or even the interests of their own junior members. Thing is, I hear lots of stories about how American unions devastate their own industries. Why is that? Dutch unions make sure their members (including the young ones) are fairly compensated, but they are invested in the long term health of the industry, because that is also the long term livelihood of their members. Generally there are regular talks where employers, unions and government discuss this on an equal footing and reach an agreement that everybody can live with. So why don't US unions work like that?
- mattgreenrocks 13y agoYour comment applies to many US businesses as well. It's never enough to simply do well, you're supposed to utterly dominate whatever industry you're in (and then branch out to others), even if it means jeopardizing the industry in the long-term. It reflects a juvenile, ego-centric view of the world that often gets rewarded.