16 ms·
State of MetaFilter
- opendais 13y agoWell, damn. :/ That sucks but at least MetaFilter will live on.
- IvyMike 13y ago> Jessamyn, who has worked in some capacity on the site for almost 10 years and was instrumental in shaping the voice of Ask MetaFilter, is taking a voluntary layoff. Holy crap. I think this is a giant mistake; IMO she's the heart and soul behind that site.
- kome 13y agoNo it's fine, changing is needed in a community.
- mutagen 13y agoI hope she has something bigger, better, and more exciting to move on to. She's well-respected due to her role in shaping Metafilter to what it is today.
- toxic 13y agoAnd her work in the librarian community. And the warrant canary. And IIRC, a trickle-charging story-telling bear that almost was. As amazing as her work at metafilter is, it's only a small portion of why she's well-respected. In a sense, this is quite appropriate, and is why she's been so perfect as the heart and soul of AskMe, if not much of MetaFilter for the last decade. I am incredibly curious as to what she does next, because I'm quite sure it will be both revolutionary and personable in a way that is rare and getting more so.
- increduloushulk 13y agoI had the same reaction, but it seems to dovetail with her needs. She said "this is literally just 'I am moving on in my professional life.' MetaFilter remains my online home." http://metatalk.metafilter.com/23245/State-of-MetaFilter#1147550 http://metatalk.metafilter.com/23245/State-of-MetaFilter#114...
- joostdevries 13y agoYes, Jessamyn has an amazing knack for handling users. That sounds rather pedestrian but she makes it into an intellectual art. I hope she's making a positive move. Also the whole site is just so personable. I hope it stays around.
- da02 13y agoCan you go into more detail when you say "handling users"?
- dfan 13y agoJessamyn is amazing at being empathetic when people have issues with the site, but being firm about the actual decision that have been made, without being patronizing (it's very hard to say "I totally understand your concern, but we're not doing what you want" in a way that doesn't annoy people). And she never ever yells at people unless they totally deserve it, in which case they then realize they deserve it. Unless you are a real malcontent (and of course there are a few), it is really hard not to believe that she is genuinely on your side. By "issues" above I don't mean technical things like "I can't log in" but disagreements about how the site should be run. Metafilter has a official side site called Metatalk that is largely a forum for people to complain about Metafilter. It is a testament to the Metafilter mods that this actually works.
- archagon 13y agoEspecially in some of the more heated discussions, it's very common to see a jessamyn comment like "Removed a few comments. This is a sensitive topic. Please take it to MetaTalk if you need to." In my opinion, this is one of the major reasons why MeFi is such a pleasant community compared to something like Reddit. Because the mods don't let discussions spiral out into people yelling at each other, and because drama can be dealt with on a separate subsite, it truly feels like a community of mature adults. (For the most part.)
- L_Rahman 13y agoThe interesting thing about Reddit, is that in a select few subreddits that are fortunate to have moderators as good as jessamyn, the experience is phenomenal and there is a concentration of domain experts sharing knowledge at a rate and depth to put even Hacker News to shame. /r/askhistorians is one that comes to mind immediately.
- jessamyn 13y agoThanks, that's really sweet, but it's been almost a decade and it's definitely time. I've got some stuff coming up (will post more about it later on so as not to take any of the attention away from mathowie's post) which is all good news. It was really time for me to get a little more librarianing in.
- egypturnash 13y agoAfter a decade of gently beating wayward mefites over the head with a clue stick, you deserve a break. Thanks for all those years of work!
- cmicali 13y agoagree - you are one of the reasons mefi is what it is. thanks for all of your hard work.
- notlisted 13y agoThanks for all your work Jessamyn. I've lurked since 1999 and found a lot of useful information over the years (has it been 15 years already? it seems like it just was yesterday!). Made a small donation just now. Too many valuable things die or are simply discarded these days, whilst utter nonsense by 17yo's that have no purpose get funding in the millions, which are rapidly squandered. I respect your decision. I also suspect that Matt seriously underestimates the amount of goodwill the site has generated over the years... There's no shame in collecting on this. PS Get off my lawn young'uns.
- nkozyra 13y agoThis is a major bummer, but never having delved too deeply into metafilter, it seems like it's been basically unchanged for sometime, no? I don't believe in change for change's sake (and this juncture somewhat reminds me of where Digg was a few years back), but the whole thing seems like it could use some modernization. Maybe it has iterated a lot and I've just missed it or not noticed through the years of my casual encounters.
- mbrubeck 13y agoThe biggest changes have been new sub-sites. The most recent of these is FanFare, for discussing TV and movies (and possibly expanding to other media in the future): http://fanfare.metafilter.com/ http://fanfare.metafilter.com/ There have also been subtle changes, like removing the ability to post images in comment threads, or adding a five-minute window where you can edit comments for typos. I appreciate the amount of thought that goes into both implementation and policy changes and how they are likely to affect discourse on the site. It's the people and the conversation that make MetaFilter, not any flashy technical features.
- peterevans 13y agoThey have (or have had) developers on staff to assist Matt. It was originally written in ColdFusion (to be fair, the site has been around since 1999), though I imagine it's moved onto greener pastures since then. The look of MeFi is iconic, much like Slashdot, so any radical changes to its design would likely cause more problems than it might solve.
- sinak 13y agoI've gotten far more value out of my Metafilter subscription than the $5 I originally paid for my account. It really is an excellent (and very well-moderated) community. If you're interested, you can donate to help cover Metafilter's ongoing costs using this link: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=PPKPHJFYASBTU https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_b...
- devindotcom 13y agoI don't mean to question what it almost certainly a well-meaning comment, but could someone from metafilter (I already saw cortex in the thread) endorse this or suggest an alternative? I'd love to send a few bucks that way to keep the wolves from the door but just want to make sure they're going to the correct bucket.
- JackC 13y agoThat donation link appears on this page: https://www.metafilter.com/about.mefi https://www.metafilter.com/about.mefi "Supporting MetaFilter The site and server can always use upgrades of hardware, software, and bandwidth. If you'd like to chip in, you can donate via this PayPal link." Which does in fact link to https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=PPKPHJFYASBTU https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_b... The site's getting hammered right now, but if you can't get through directly you can also check through the Google cache: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:NMFYgwZH8EwJ:www.metafilter.com/about.mefi http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:NMFYgwZ...
- devindotcom 13y agoThanks, I was looking in the wrong place for potential donation links.
- joshmillard 13y agoThat is our existing paypal account, yes. We aren't formally doing any fundraising at this point -- that's an account we've had set up for ever mostly for the once-a-month "hey, here's five bucks, buy yourself a beer" tip from a random happy/guilty user -- but if you toss money in that, it ends up with us, and I won't tell you no. If you want to be extra sure about the paypal link, visit the one at the bottom of Metafilter's about page, here: http://www.metafilter.com/about.mefi http://www.metafilter.com/about.mefi
- sergiotapia 13y agoReally sad to see that even if you 'make it' and make a lot of money, you can (and probably will) lose it all given enough time. Never put all of your eggs in one basket. :/
- Mz 13y agoThe way to become rich is to put all your eggs in one basket and then watch that basket. -- Andrew Carnegie
- kurtko 13y agoWho said the founders/managers were going to lose in aggregate? They may have set aside a nest egg in peak years and not want to dip into that.
- sergiotapia 13y agoI never said that - I said they were going to lose their month-by-month income, not their total savings.
- DangerousPie 13y agoI was actually surprised to hear that they are employing multiple full-time moderators for a site like this. Is there any word on how much they were spending per moderator? When I read things like "current response times to contact form emails of less than a few minutes will increase" I am tempted to say they might have actually had too many until now, but I don't participate enough on that site to judge this. Maybe it would pay off to invest some money in the development of better "crowdsourced moderation" features (like rating/flagging of posts) to save on staff in the long run?
- teraflop 13y agoMeFi already has favorites and flagging. However, flagging is only used to get a moderator's attention, and the final decision on whether to delete something is always made by a human. I think the userbase would be extremely resistant to changing that. More importantly, an integral part of MeFi's culture is that the moderators aren't just behind the scenes, deleting spam and banning problem users; they try to actively steer discussions away from flamewars/trollbait and towards productive discourse, without being too heavy-handed on the "delete" button. It's similar to what I've seen dang trying to do here over the last few months, but it works a lot better without nested comments.
- joshmillard 13y agoWhat teraflop said. cortex here, one of the mefi moderators. I totally understand where arguments along the lines of "automate and eliminate human costs" come from and there is absolutely value in finding ways to simplify/streamline/remove work, and we've developed a lot of custom tools for the site over the years to do just that. It's something that we'll have to do more of now as we transition to the smaller staff, taking a lot from what we've learned over the last several years as guidance. But the fact that Metafilter has attentive, thoughtful human eyes on the site and hands on the till is a defining part of the culture and nature of the site. It's not a question of whether it's a good business expense, it's a question of whether it's what makes for the kind of community we want to maintain.
- barrkel 13y ago
- ap22213 13y agoI used to love ask.metafilter.com! I went there almost every day, up until a couple of years ago. Around then, I sort of lost interest, as most of the popular questions became 1) Can you recommend me a recipe X for Y?, 2) I hate my life, now what?, 3) Can I ask this question so that we can all bash men? That's just my opinion. I'm sure it's not the reason for their downfall. It does make me sad, and I hope the data doesn't disappear. (Losing karma is worth it sometimes, to state an opinion against the masses. Political correctness be damned.)
- mbrubeck 13y agoI think this might be some confirmation bias in action; if you actually look at the front page of http://ask.metafilter.com/ http://ask.metafilter.com/ today (or pretty much any day in recent years), or the popular questions at http://ask.metafilter.com/home/popularfavorites http://ask.metafilter.com/home/popularfavorites , the majority are not in these buckets you're complaining about. ("Recommend good books/movies/tools for X" questions are disproportionately represented in the "popular" list, because users interested in the same topic tend to favorite these so they can follow the recommendations too.) My own favorite AskMe thread recently was this crowd-sourced deciphering of a hundred-year-old postcard written in Norwegian in an obsolete gothic script: http://ask.metafilter.com/257990/Help-me-decipher-this-handwritten-Norwegian-postcard-from-an-ancestor http://ask.metafilter.com/257990/Help-me-decipher-this-handw...
- ap22213 13y agoMaybe. I'll check it out, at least. Edit: unfortunately I can't test your theory, because the 'most popular' links only go back so far. And, I'm interested in the ones in a typical 'day range' for favorites, around 10-60, or so. But, it would be interesting to test.
- mbrubeck 13y agoIf you're logged in, you can also use the "My Ask" tab to browse questions from selected tags/categories, instead of all categories. Useful if you prefer, say, science questions over relationship questions.
- massysett 13y agoI'm stunned there was staff to lay off. I've seen such disappointing vitriol in the comments of the main MetaFilter that I stopped reading it long ago. I do continue to drop by Ask, though. I'm surprised there was anything on MetaFilter that required so many full-time staff and looking back on years of reading MetaFilter still doesn't give me any appreciation for what they must have been doing. In particular, the quality of comment moderation on the main MetaFilter did not, to me, reflect the level of quality one would expect from several full-time staff.
- oskarth 13y agoI think you severely underestimate the effort it takes to run and maintain a successful community site.
- mynameishere 13y agodoesn't give me any appreciation for what they must have been doing I suppose if they made a commitment to having one employee moderating at all times, that would take at least four employees, and even then it would require overtime and some funny scheduling. Imagine if reddit replaced the little arrows with salaried people deciding the fate of every post. It would take 100s of staff.
- ronaldx 13y agoMetaFilter is a site which I always value, when I read it, but am rarely directed to: I don't remember ever noticing it in a search engine result. I'm sorry to hear this and I will endeavour to more actively support MetaFilter and other uniquely valuable sites in the future.
- beerbajay 13y agoAsk Metafilter used to come up often in my google searches for esoteric questions. Not as much lately.
- xcntktn 13y ago> I don't remember ever noticing it in a search engine result. And yet it's easily shown that Google highly values MetaFilter in its results: http://www.metafilter.com/134827/New-Spammer-Panic#5333774 http://www.metafilter.com/134827/New-Spammer-Panic#5333774 The problem is it's kind of a niche-topic site, a bit like NPR. It needs lots of external support to keep going.
- guelo 13y agoDamn, basically fired by a computer algorithm. We are living in the future. But is Google too powerful?
- pgrote 13y agoThis comment was downvoted, but I do understand the tenor of your comment. It was the first thing I thought of, too, when I read the post on MetaFilter. Without more information, though, I am afraid we cannot jump to that simple conclusion.
- wmf 13y agoIs that better or worse than being fired by the invisible hand? If your company stays the same when new competitors (Reddit, StackExchange, and Quora have been mentioned) appear, whose fault is it?
- Raphael 13y agoAh, but they were essentially hired by the same algorithm. Had the algorithm not existed, they would have had to find another job.
- troymc 13y agoTo be fair, the algorithm changed.
- Theodores 13y agoDoes anyone use a search engine to get to HN? Sure there are a few, however, most people on this site have been coming for years and these people - 'the community' - don't need a search engine to get here. So the main point - allegedly - of Metafilter is the community. Do they get to Metafilter by going to Google first? Why would they? I don't Google my favourite destination sites, e.g. BBC news, I just type 'b' in the browser and I am kind of there. Same with HN, I just type 'n' and I am a down-arrow + enter away from being there. I just don't see how a few changes to a search engine can instantly result in a 40% of traffic to a community site. I could understand if it was a 40% drop in new members but not overall traffic. Incidentally, I have used the web since 1993 - twenty years - and I cannot ever remember going to Metafilter from a search. I have seen the site, and I have some perception it is like 'tripod' or 'geocities', as in ancient. Although anecdotal, I don't believe that they get search traffic in a big way or that they have done so for years. I have also never gone to 'Reddit' from a search result - community sites should and do rely on word of mouth introduction (or links). The oft-criticised Alexa stats on Metafilter tell a story when compared to SO, Reddit and Quora. The bounce rate is high, the page views low and the time on site low. IMHO there are a lot of people that just do not like the look of the site It needs a redesign with the existing look kept as 'low bandwidth' option to allow the community that likes the existing look to stay with what they know.
- mutagen 13y agoI just commented on HN yesterday on the success of Metafilter's model of charging a gatekeeper fee for posting. Maybe a one time fee is enough to keep spam at bay but not enough to pay moderators. The bigger issue seems to be Google's algorithm changes. I don't think anyone would argue that Metafilter is a low quality site or that they should appear below some of the spammy and generally worthless sites that continue to stay near the top. Relying on ad revenue is difficult, especially when your core audience is the crowd that is typically running ad blockers and search traffic changes at the whim of a search engine.
- brandnewlow 13y agoIn the last 5 years we've seen both Quora, StackOverflow launch and gain serious traction and Yelp has consolidated its position as a top destination for local search. AskMeFi likely is seeing the results of going up against massively VC-backed competitors. It's hard to imagine Google's search updates were aimed at prioritizing "worthless sites". Edit: And Reddit & Imgur have exploded. Those have probably had even bigger impacts.
- dublinben 13y agoI've visited MetaFilter on an off for many years, and I've never heard of AskMeFi before today. I didn't even know they had a section that was similar to Quora or SO. I've only ever seen it as a link aggregation community.
- davis 13y agoThat's strange because I feel that AskMeFi is what keeps me going back and visiting.
- mutagen 13y agoThat's very true. I'm thinking more of the about.com type of results (which would also qualify for your description of a well funded competitor). Perhaps I was too disparaging of Google's changes, overall they're increased search quality. I just find it unfortunate when sites like Metafilter get downranked as collateral damage.
- oskarth 13y agoI wonder where they would be today if they took a monthly or yearly as opposed to a one-time fee. It seems to me like recurring revenue would turn the main problem into keeping users, rather than recruiting them.
- Mz 13y agoFrom what I gather, their main revenue is ad money. The fee to join is mostly a gatekeeping thing. It is not a big part of the revenue model. Matt managed growth really well (from what I gather) by limiting new memberships and what not. It is a community and limiting new memberships and putting in a gatekeeper fee seems to have done a lot to avoid eternal September and what not. That's the main thing you need to do to make money from a community: Keep your eye on the prize of making it a good community. I have seen that failed elsewhere. I don't know much about google algorithms but if you don't have the good community piece of it, you have no business model for this. It is not HN, HN is the funnel for applicants for Y Combinator, so it is part of the business model here but it is a very, very different model. Mefi exists solely (as I understand) to be a community and not to serve some other business need the way HN does. I think they should make the donate button much, much more visible but I am not a fan of recurring membership fees. But I don't have time to write more at the moment.
- nervousvarun 13y agoWould hate to lose the Big Blue :(. A site I've visited at least once a day every day for over a decade.
- distantparts 13y agoThere is supposed to be a softer Panda algorithm coming soon (Matt Cutts announced it in March 2014 - http://searchengineland.com/google-working-softer-gentler-panda-algorithm-help-small-businesses-186619 http://searchengineland.com/google-working-softer-gentler-pa...). Maybe that will help? Google definitely caused a lot of collateral damage with Panda, especially to large sites with user generated content. And unlike algorithms that target aggressive use of links or ads, it's still very unclear how to fix a site that's been hit by Panda (I should know, my car review site was hit by Panda, and never really recovered, despite 2 years of improvement work). Now that content farms are not such a pressing problem, Google should be able to dial things back a bit, so that good sites like Metafilter aren't ranked lower than they otherwise would be.
- petercooper 13y agoThe only advertising I see on there is The Deck which is divided up over so many sites I can't imagine any of them make much money from it. If I log out, I see Adsense too, which as far as I can tell isn't a good source of returns nowadays either, it's more in the last-ditch "I can't sell advertising myself, give me anything!" school of advertising. I think they should take the Reddit approach: gold + directly sold ads. Directly sold ads would surely make a better CPM than Adsense and it could go on all pageviews rather than just non logged in ones..
- 3pt14159 13y agoWhy doesn't MetaFilter update their layout / aesthetic? If google is hammering them, I'm sure a large part of it is the insta-bounces a site this old looking has.
- psychometry 13y agoThat's been my experience. I take one look at a page, attempt to scan the answers section for what I need, and immediately go back to the search results to find a stackexchange result where I can find what I need effortlessly.
- simoncion 13y agoHere's the method to discovering the answers in Ask Metafilter comment threads: 1) Answered questions have a green checkmark by the answers count. 2) All comments attached to the question are ordered chronologically, with the earliest answers first. 3) Comments accepted as an answer by the questioner are rendered with a dark green background. 4) Comments by the questioner have a light green/grey bar off to their left. Example of 3) : http://ask.metafilter.com/261436/Should-my-math-student-have-some-Unix-skills#3797935 http://ask.metafilter.com/261436/Should-my-math-student-have... Example of 4) : http://ask.metafilter.com/261436/Should-my-math-student-have-some-Unix-skills#3798038 http://ask.metafilter.com/261436/Should-my-math-student-have... HTH. :)
- jakejake 13y agoI'd like to say that I come for the content/community and the design doesn't matter. Obviously HN is not really known for it's cutting-edge design. But I have to agree that MetaFilter just has a very old, dusty look to it to the point that it makes me want to instantly click away. That is a real shame because building a community is incredibly difficult, while doing a bit of design touch-up is relatively easy.
- zorpner 13y agoMetafilter has a lot going for it (personally I think it's probably the best non-private community online, particularly in the sense that once you're an active participant it truly is a "community"), but willingness to change anything about Metafilter is not among its virtues: http://metatalk.metafilter.com/13786/The-Green-Should-Be-White http://metatalk.metafilter.com/13786/The-Green-Should-Be-Whi... Perhaps this event will provide the catalyst necessary for the Mefi community to accept some modernization.
- mrbill 13y agoI can't think highly enough of Matt and the staff / family at MetaFilter. This is why: http://ask.metafilter.com/125445/How-do-you-deal-with-the-unexpected-death-of-a-spouse http://ask.metafilter.com/125445/How-do-you-deal-with-the-un... http://metatalk.metafilter.com/18056/Update-on-my-wifes-passing-away http://metatalk.metafilter.com/18056/Update-on-my-wifes-pass... and finally http://www.mrbill.net/mefi/ http://www.mrbill.net/mefi/ I've made lifelong friends and had many enjoyable meetups with local folks. It's going to be hard to think of Jessamyn as a not-moderator.
- RyJones 13y agoI was just reading SUN related stuff, reminiscing about mid-late-90's SUN, wondering how you were. Sorry for your loss.
- mrbill 13y agoI'm still here. :) Still run SunHELP although it doesn't get many updates nowdays; the geeks and rescue mailing lists are still pretty decent traffic though.
- JDDunn9 13y agoI didn't realize this was a legitimate site with real users. I always thought it was just a spam site scraping from somewhere based on the horrible design and excessive ads...
- darksim905 13y agoIf a site like MetaFilter is barely surviving, how is that Stack Exchange, Reddit, et al can just keep going? Is it because those sites have VC backing or roots in YC?
- kurtko 13y agoReddit isn't profitable yet but is much larger and keeps its staff relatively small compared to its traffic volume.
- dublinben 13y agoI'm pretty sure those sites are much more popular, and have better categorization for advertising targeting. You can charge a lot more for ads in /r/Television, /r/movies, and /r/trucks than you can on the generic MeFi homepage.
- conradfr 13y agoFor one I have never heard of MetaFilter and I can't understand what it is by browsing the site.
- illuminate 13y agoMore users, more user engagement, more valuable content.
- whoismua 13y agoA year and a half ago, we woke up one day to see a 40% decrease in revenue and traffic to Ask MetaFilter, likely the result of ongoing Google index updates. We scoured the web and took advice of reducing ads in the hopes traffic would improve but it never really did, staying steady for several months and then periodically decreasing by smaller amounts over time. Amazing power Google has. We desperately need this power distributed to 4-5 search engines, not one. I have been thinking about the changes, and I suspect that a lot of the "lost" traffic went to ads (Adwords) and YouTube. In other words it shifted from sites like MetaFilter to Google. Great ain't it? Google decides that it's own properties (where it keeps 100% of revenue) are more relevant than sites where it keep just about 30% of it. Proof for the shift are Google's own numbers: in house ad clicks have been grown by double-digits, quarter after quarter. Oh, I have heard the "Chinese Wall," "Church and State" but frankly I no longer buy it. Something stinks , as we hear of a lot of losers and one winner, the one that also ranks. Too many coincidences, too many punishing updates for non Google sites, and a very suspicious increase of Google's own ad clicks.
- joshdance 13y agoInteresting that the only thing I know about MetaFilter is that I heard they are a well behaved community. That is it. Know nothing else about the site. What it does, why I would visit etc.
- noelwelsh 13y agoRavelry, the social network for knitters, in its early days had several fundraisers that keep it going for a while. The amazing thing is these fundraisers (called "For the love of Ravelry") were actually organised by the community. I think if Metafilter gave its community a chance to keep the site afloat they'd step up.
- techaddict009 13y agoWhy dont they try Adsense?
- mbrubeck 13y agoMost of MetaFilter's revenue comes from the Adsense ads on Ask MetaFilter pages.
- Tomte 13y agoSad to hear this. I got into some ugly argument right on the very first try at participating in a discussion on the site, wasn't really impressed by how the mods handled it (although the one I PM'd was actually quite okay), and never really gave it another try. I always felt like I'm really missing out and this was probably all just bad luck and a bad combination of personalities in this specific comment thread, but whenever I went back to the site those memories kind of killed the fun for me and I never commented again. sigh
- Mz 13y agoThat's not that weird. When I moderated Tagmax, I made it a policy to "welcome people at the door" and try to make their first experience a positive one. My observation was those folks who had a positive initial experience came back and participated enthusiastically. Those who had a negative first experience we seemed to never hear from again. So I think you aren't at all strange. I don't know what the policies on MetaFilter are but my experience as a moderator suggests that keeping an eye on the site "virgins" and making sure their initial experiences are positive is super important in shaping the site and growing it. I am sorry you had such a negative experience. I get a lot of value out of MetaFilter, though it has been a long process for me to figure out how to fit in. But, I am not you and some of my issues are specific to me, not to MetaFilter and ...yadda yadda.
- mavenlarkey 13y agoTotally agree with you. I used to read Metafilter for many years, and even paid the $5 to start commenting. I stopped though since unlike many members of that site, I tend to be pretty conservative in my views, and it always seemed as if the mods had a vendetta against beliefs too different from their own. Turned me off completely.
- wwweston 13y agoWhat do you mean by "vendetta"? I'm not particularly conservative, but I am relative to Metafilter and I've argued center-to-right positions there (for example, pro-life). I think it's true to say that it can be very challenging to engage the membership in a way that goes against the lefty gestalt, and if/when you do, there are certainly members who will be less than kind or thoughtful about responding to that kind of participation. But I've rarely had any problem with negative attention from the mods, certainly nothing that I'd describe as a vendetta.
- brianbreslin 13y agoWhat would you guys say is metafilter's core objective now? I used to read it a lot between 2004-2007, then got bored. So if you could describe metafilter & its community, how would you?
- csense 13y agoTwo problems with the site that I can think of: (1) It's somehow 14 years old and this article is #1 on HN, but somehow I've never heard of it. (2) I haven't been able to figure out what the site actually is, or what it does. I looked at the FAQ and the orientation page on the wiki, but I still have no idea what I want to accomplish by going to the site.
- barrkel 13y agoThink: NPR-loving, female-friendly left-leaning cozy-fest discussing this that and the other.
- atmosx 13y agoSorry for the silly question, but what is metafilter?! Like HN for general content with a price tag?!
- grlhgr420 13y agoold and well established user-generated blog with an extremely well moderated (best on the net, imo) discussion forum in the form of comment threads, with a medium-sized user base. the pice tag is only to comment, and as you might imagine it tends to make people value their ability to participate more than on other, free forums. it's the only place on the internet where i genuinely enjoy reading comments.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Mz 13y agoOld HN discussion of mefi moderation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1711995 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1711995 I had not seen it before. I thought it might be of interest.
- jedanbik 13y agoFor those who are wondering what MetaFilter is, it's a meta-filtered internet space, a well-moderated community where people can talk about things on the internet, without making it all about themselves. The About page is a good place to learn more about the site: http://www.metafilter.com/about.mefi http://www.metafilter.com/about.mefi
- jedanbik 13y agoOr really, the Popular Tags page should speak for itself: http://www.metafilter.com/tags/ http://www.metafilter.com/tags/
- franze 13y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aask.metafilter.com%2Ftags%2Fears+inurl%3Atinnitus&pws=0&hl=en&filter=0 https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aask.metafilter.com%2F... internal duplicate content, might not hurt (might hurt), definitely does not help. force lowercase, always. 1 page == 1 URL, 1 URL == 1 page always set a canonical, the canonical is content dependent, not URL dependent. also, your tag pages are wasted, as you do not target a sensemaking phrase i.e.: "Posts tagged with lawschool" nobody searches for that. also there is no sitemap.xml reference in the robots.txt, which is at least a warning signal. also i got a very concerning result while doing a webpagespeed test http://www.webpagetest.org/result/140519_H1_10TE/1/screen_shot/ http://www.webpagetest.org/result/140519_H1_10TE/1/screen_sh... i only got the first result of a tag page i could see this with a first request no cookie (on firefox), too, this is very strange, and if this is communicated to google this will definitely lead to traffic loss. have you done an extensiv "fetch with googlebot" using webmaster tools? my name is franz enzenhofer, i'm the most successful SEO in europe, write me a twitter message, so like now. hope you read this. in just 5 minutes i have seen 3 warning signs, if this is all new to you, please just fire your SEO instead of your moderator staff!
- chrisamiller 13y agoWhen I'm on metafilter and I click on the 'lawschool' tag, it absolutely makes sense that the header says "Posts tagged with lawschool" Their goal is not to optimize for Google, it's to optimize for users on the site. (This is one of the reasons that makes metafilter such a special community)
- kvirani 13y agoAfter a heartfelt letter to the public, and layoff decisions final, you are willing to pitch in some donation? How nice. But would have even clicked the donation link prior, even if it were a prominent "Please donate. We need it!" button? That's the real question folks.
- wmeredith 13y agoThis is a failure of Google's algorithm to recognize and rank appropriately quality web content. Shame.
- patio11 13y agoIt's not my section of the Internet most of the time, but I'm professionally obligated to know a little about it, so in case anyone here runs a massive consumer Internet property and can't make the bills with AdSense: you should strongly consider having a direct ads sales force. AdSense is very effective at fulfilling the role it was designed for, which is algorithmically filling your least valuable advertising slots. It is not good at getting top dollar for brand advertising, in fact, it is optimized in entirely the other direction. Brand advertisers sneeze out numbers which pay for the entire salary bill in a month. This is particularly true if you have an anomalously strong community or an audience which is more valuable than "a generic Internet user in your company." Even if you're not a massive B2C company, there are plenty of niche publishers who quietly receive $500 to $X,000 a month for each of ~6 ad placements rather than taking $125 in "webmaster welfare" from Google. At that level you don't even need a sales force -- just "your ad could be here" leading to a contact page works.
- mkr-hn 13y agoThis might explain the high CPM I get with WordAds [1] and its brand-focused ads. [1] http://wordads.co/ http://wordads.co/
- eli 13y agoComing from the B2B media world, I couldn't agree more. Google Ads are a commodity. They work by making all web sites appear more or less than same to the advertiser. Direct sales is the opposite: it's about explaining why your audience is special. The difference really is orders of magnitude.
- lectrick 13y agoSo Google killed Metafilter?