7 ms·
Self-Destructing Cookies
- scrollaway 13y agoIs there something similar for Chrome?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- joshschreuder 13y agoThere's a setting for both 'Keep local data only until you quit your browser' and 'Block sites from setting any data' under Cookies in stock Chrome. I don't use it though, so not sure of the effectiveness.
- deepGem 13y agoNot exactly. You have to quit the browser. Using this FF extension, you just have to close a tab. So there's no such option available in Chrome.
- fafner 13y agoIf you care about privacy don't use a closed source browser especially not from Google...
- scrollaway 13y agoI use Chromium. As it happens, Chromium and Chrome have the same extension system. Thanks for your half-arsed "concerns", though.
- hosay123 13y agoNote the "clear browser cache when idle" option aggravates a referrer logging side channel for sites embedding Google Ajax libs or Analytics. That aside, I'm in love!
- heinrich5991 13y agoCan you explain why?
- kevingadd 13y agoNuking those scripts from the cache means that they get re-requested more often, and the request has its referrer sent to the server hosting the tracking script which means the referrer+ip pair can be logged.
- dan_bk 13y agoAnd that's where RequestPolicy comes in: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/requestpolicy/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/requestpolicy...
- edoloughlin 13y agoI already use No-Script. I tried addeding RequestPolicy but the combination is just too much work for normal browsing.
- ehPReth 13y agoYou can use something like https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/refcontrol/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/refcontrol/ to control who gets your referer. I default to no one and make exceptions for poorly coded websites.
- jonobird1 13y agoThis'll probably be an unpopular comment but I feel the need to point out that this is good (in the ways that made this post popular) and bad. Bad because for the dot com company I work for, we use cookies to make sure we don't show users 'helper' tooltips more than once per 30 days and cookies is one of the better ways of doing this. It also helps us anonymously track a user location to show better search results, user currency etc. There are many bad ways a website can use cookies, but by using a plugin like this, it'll ultimately just ruin your own user experience.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sergeykish 13y agoThese users can hide 'helper' tooltips by their own.
- Too 13y agoFor years ive been browsing with clear cookies after each session. What you describe with first visit notification is not common at all. And when sites actually do it, its usually very subtle and can be ignored like the notification bar on the top of stackoverflow. I can only name one website where I am annoyed by the lack of cookies and that is when youtube doesn't remember my preferred video resolution. Otherwise browsing with fresh ones has no degraded user experience for me. Actually this is starting to become worse though after EU introduced the must notify about cookies law last year. The ones who do clear their cookies once in a while are punished by being notified about them time after time while the others will blindly click OK and never see the message again.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Steko 13y ago> when youtube doesn't remember my preferred video resolution https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-center/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-cente...
- AgentME 13y agoCan't you already set Firefox (and Chrome?) to only keep cookies around for the session?
- 13throwaway 13y agoThis is a very good extension, I have been using it for a while. It is very much the best of both worlds, using cookies to login, then deleting them when you leave the site. You don't have to worry about whitelists, etc.
- gavinpc 13y agoBut without whitelisting, I wouldn't know how much of the web is completely broken without cookies, where by "broken" I mean a blank page, or just a little strip of the template. This includes blogs, one-off demos, and other sites that don't require (or even offer) log in or settings of any kind. I can only conclude that some common frameworks depend on cookies for their own operation, and that in many cases the developers aren't even aware of the "problem".
- fdsary 13y agoI switch browsers more than I switch underwear, mostly between Safari, uzbl, Firefox, Chrome and TOR Browser (FF fork). When I write extensions I do it for the browser I currently fancy, so I've got a few ones for Safari, Firefox and Chrome. But when I switch I lose the old ones, until I switch back. Right now I'm in Safari (silky smooth rendering), and can't use this. That sucks. But FF, Chrome and Safari extensions are just JS anyways. Why can't they be automatically ported, or something? What's stopping Mozilla from enabling Firefox to run Chrome and Safari extensions, and vice versa?
- mahmoudhossam 13y agoBecause they interact with different APIs. Different browsers provide similar APIs in different ways sometimes, and usually web standards support differs between browsers.
- metabren 13y agoAny idea if someone has written an abstraction layer for this yet?
- debaserab2 13y agoAside from the obvious (API's), the use case you describe see,s incredibly small - likely too small to justifiably target.
- semenko 13y agoCool! I wrote a similar extension for Chrome that simply enforces a user-adjustable maximum cookie lifetime (e.g. 21 days instead of 10+ years...). This seems to provide a good balance for login cookies that you don't necessarily want removed every session. https://github.com/semenko/chrome-limit-cookie-lifetime https://github.com/semenko/chrome-limit-cookie-lifetime https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/limit-cookie-lifetime/pplilgolafepgkdmocfpgblngcpdlopm https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/limit-cookie-lifet... (And the same for Chrome's ever-present history: https://github.com/semenko/chrome-limit-history-lifetime https://github.com/semenko/chrome-limit-history-lifetime https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/limit-history-lifetime/opkjpinehmnbdeebdamcapfgfepdiohp https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/limit-history-life... )
- annnnd 13y agoNice! I wonder if it clears cache too? EDIT: apparently it does. BTW, you can check if you can still be cookie / storage / cache-tracked here: http://www.canyoutrackme.com/ http://www.canyoutrackme.com/
- heinrich5991 13y agoFor me it didn't work. I was still tracked by - Cache, - ETag.
- _puk 13y agoditto. Also, I had to close my browser for the test to be allowed to work (session expiry). I tried closing the tab, but that's not enough. For me that is an unfair test as I hardly ever close my browser down completely.
- Rudism 13y agoIIRC, SDC does not immediately clear cookies/cache on tab closing. It purges them on a scheduled interval. If you close the tab and wait a while (you should eventually see a toast message, if you have them enabled, saying something like "deleted x cookies from blah.com"), then your session should be removed. Closing the browser runs the purge immediately which is why that was working for you already.
- gabriel34 13y agoSome of these methods are simply nefarious. Using cache and cookies to track users is a hack that subverts an useful implementation. I no longer use these features because "good" companies are using it to hack my browser and track me. Here is a new idea: Do you want to track me? ASK ME! Give me a unique hash or something that I can delete anytime I want without losing functionalities on the rest of the web. These companies claim they provide a better user experience by using tracking information. I call their BS; if users wanted to be tracked there would be no need for such techniques to be developed.
- nfoz 13y agoI've been wondering for many years why this isn't the standard behaviour of web browsers.
- lloeki 13y agoJust like "click to flash" and other plugins that should only run when I authorise them once, or always if I whitelist them.
- skion 13y agoSo, what other extensions can we ditch now? I really like the UX of SDC; are Disconnect or DoNotTrackMe just clutter, or adding value still?
- dakrone 13y agoWhile this is an awesome extension, it is annoying living in the EU to continually see "This site uses cookies, click 'accept' to acknowledge and continue to the site" every time I visit a site that has had its cookies cleared, since the acknowledgement is stored in a cookie that is subsequently cleared when the tab is closed.
- netcan 13y agoThe irony is fantastic.
- antocv 13y agoHow came that crap to pass and become some EU thing anyway? Whats the big deal about EU and cookies?
- garethadams 13y agoPeople complained that cookies were being used by advertisers to track them. The EU decided to take action by mandating that companies make it visible when this was happening, in the Directive on Privacy and Electronic Communications[1]. Since it's technically impossible to allow the benefits of cookies without opening privacy holes, I don't really know what else privacy campaigners were hoping to achieve. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Privacy_and_Electronic_Communications http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Privacy_and_Electr...
- DanBC 13y agoPeople used to care about privacy. The EU wants to protect people's privacy. Passing EU law takes a considerable length of time. By the ti e the law passed it had been made weird by bureaucrats and obsolete by time. Now there are many worse privacy invasions and most people don't care so much about privacy.
- netcan 13y agoIt's an example of why we are doomed. The law was caused by a combination of dumb/naive politicians thinking they were preventing tracking/spying and self righteous political opportunists pretending they were in the first group. They had a vague understanding of what cookies are and how they work and made a law that is the equivalent of painting a second lock on a door for extra security. The net result is that they have effectively mandated nag screens and done nothing to protect anyone's privacy. Having politicians with a "high level understanding just doesn't work here. Cookies are controlled by the browser and the browser is controlled by the udder so the sensible solution is for the browser, not the law to make rules about who should be able to set them when. I listened to some parliamentary comitee hearing once about parental controls online. It was being chaired by some arrogant and clueless parliamentarian playing the concerned mother. It was horrifying. Like listening to Pointy Haired Boss reprimanding Charles Darwin. We're doomed!
- klackerz 13y agoPersona is not working when I enable this addon.
- jedp 13y agoPersona uses third-party cookies, so this is expected with this add-on. If you whitelist persona.org (e.g., just visit persona.org and set self-destruct to "never"), then Persona works fine.
- klackerz 13y agoPersona is not working when I enable this addon.
- newscracker 13y agoI love this extension and have been using it for a long time! It makes it convenient to use a single browser to access multiple Gmail (or other mail or any other service provider) accounts without having to clear cookies manually and without having to associate or link accounts together (the latter is something Gmail allows, but I prefer not to use it). Just close the tab and the cookies are gone, allowing a new session to begin. The same holds good even for web searches, though I rarely use Google/Bing and instead use start page or DuckDuckGo.