7 ms·
Everyone Deserves Great Design
- forrecovery123 13y agoGreat share, thank you! “By almost any measure, the world is better than it has ever been. People are living longer, healthier lives. Many nations that were aid recipients are now self-sufficient. You might think that such striking progress would be widely celebrated, but in fact, Melinda and I are struck by how many people think the world is getting worse. The belief that the world can’t solve extreme poverty and disease isn’t just mistaken. It is harmful.” Quite an optimistic statement after the pessimism created because of all the NSA, wars ... news.
- Mikeb85 13y agoAnother thing to keep in mind is that there are brilliant designers and inventors in poor countries. And there is the saying "Necessity is the mother of invention"... What we need to be doing is empowering people (education, investment), and they'll blaze their own trail.
- BorisMelnik 13y agomake sure you watch the monkey video, I forgot how it even related to the original content but it was priceless.
- Mizza 13y agoDoes anybody else find this rather disturbing? Even from the outset, "We live in a new age where globalization & capitalism must harmonize with social good" - bold faced newspeak. Anybody who has ever actually done social work who couldn't help but to see this as a bleak vision of the future. The page goes even further, listing examples of well-intentioned although ineffective, dubbed "useless", designs in a negative light, and then showing Coca-Cola of all things as as the first example of a positive product, designed for everybody. Though most of the design sense and advice here is good from a product perspective, to propose that capitalism is the solution to the problems shown here, or rather vaguely hinted at, is to me a disturbing vision. Capitalism is in many cases the primary contributing factor to them, all this mentality proposes is to give with one hand and take away with the other - and then feel accomplished and morally cleansed by the process. There is much more to building a better world than building consumer products. If this is the best we can do, I am saddened.
- kitsune_ 13y agoNo shit, I have days where I look at advertisement, graphic design and marketing and can't help but subscribe to this view of Bill Hicks: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDW_Hj2K0wo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDW_Hj2K0wo
- DanBC 13y agoThe commerci product coca cola has massive market reach. So much so that live saving and very cheap oral rehydration salts were being put in the same cartons as coca cola as a method of delivery with specialliy designed boxes that fit between the bottles. http://allafrica.com/view/group/main/main/id/00028535.html http://allafrica.com/view/group/main/main/id/00028535.html > NAIROBI, 2 March 2012 (IRIN) - How is it that the world's most popular fizzy drink reaches even the farthest-flung corners of the planet, yet vast numbers of children in developing countries die for lack of one of the cheapest and most effective preparations known to medical science? The original concept has expanded the range of items being delivered (water purification tablets; vitamin A supplements) and allowing local businesses to sell these items.
- hgh 13y ago
- bryans 13y agoI'm confused by how the plastic chair receives such high praise for its design, affordability and ease of maintenance, but adding wheels to that same chair somehow makes it an example of a "useless" product with poor design. For $78, the organization is able to produce and ship a wheelchair around the world. They are able to use or augment existing products, which drastically reduces the cost of development, tooling, and production. As far as I can tell, the next cheapest option would cost a minimum of $150, with an equally cheap production quality. Is it the best quality product ever made? Not at all. But it's not meant to be. It's meant to effectively serve the most number of people with the smallest amount of capital. In that sense, this product meets all of its design and mission goals. To declare otherwise based on some arbitrary "prettiness" factor is pretentious, at best.
- jacquesm 13y agoThis is totally misguided. The simple facts are that 'great design' is not the single factor in success or failure of any kind of product, and that not all things created through charities are failures. Of course if you want to peddle the opposite then you can support your weak position by selecting examples from the real world underpinning it but these are just instances and not generalizations. You could just as easy argue the opposite using different examples (capitalism is the root of all evil and nonprofits are the way forward). Neither of these positions is supported by all the data available, so like in many other cases the situation is more complex than what you can easily catch in a soundbite and a blogpost. The monkey video embedded makes a completely different point than the one that the author wants to extract from it: that two monkeys doing the same work side-by-side expect equal pay. It has nothing to do with 'products' or 'design'. I get the dig at the prosthetic arm (the writer is co-founder of http://madebybump.org/#global http://madebybump.org/#global), but since that's a non-profit I have no idea why the capitalism angle is emphasized so much. """Have you ever wondered about how a homeless person on the side of the street and the leader of the free world consume the same fizzy soda drink just to have a fleeting moment of happiness?""" If your happiness comes from drinking cola then you have other problems. Maybe this is some kind of elaborate satire?
- DanBC 13y agoThe article criticises the cheap prosthetic hand. Sure, it'd be great if better prosthetics were available at an affordable cost. They're not. The competition is DIY prosthetics using old soda bottles and hot air. http://youtube.com/watch?v=Yvev6shNvSg http://youtube.com/watch?v=Yvev6shNvSg
- TempleOSV207 13y agoNiggers like Wonderbread. You cannot get a nigger to eat wheat bread. Tinker toys suck. Legos are awesome. Facebook sucks. It is nonintuitive. They try to make you do shit through coersion. Crappy. Little bastard trying to make me do certain shit. God says, "Woe to those who mislead the little ones."
- fungi 13y agoTalk of "social good" seems fairly shallow when you are failing accessibility pretty spectacularly. Obvious example being not having alt tags on images (and the few that they you do have are the file name). Feels like another agency website... with above average hyperbole.
- chewxy 13y agoDiscussion from the last time this was posted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7624189 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7624189 I wrote: >I wonder what OP thinks about things like the NeoNurture? >I find the site quite disingenuous - it really feels like a First World Problem kinda thing. Yes, the prosthetic arm is lame and a poor design, but compared to having no arm, it's much much better. >OP argues that design should be for everyone, and lays out 4 foundations of good design. He/She missed out the most important one: economics
- bshimmin 13y agoI was interested by the choice of the Casio watch as a "great product". While they are certainly iconic watches that have survived the test of time, the user-friendliness of the alarm functionality is extremely dubious to me - three completely unmarked buttons that do stuff while somewhat cryptic symbols appear on the display, all dependent on what order the buttons are pressed. My wife used to have one of these watches and frequently would accidentally set an alarm for some random time (usually 4am) and have absolutely no idea how to stop this happening. (I don't know if it had a manual or whether she ever read it, but she certainly hasn't read her iPhone's manual and doesn't struggle to set alarms with that.)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sammermpc 13y agoThis is a primer in a kind of design language mumbo-mumbo. It's not clear what the conclusions even are, beyond a few pithy throw-away phrases...mysterious.
- fidanov 13y agoNot buying this. Mainly statements with very little research and almost no connection between them. Written so that it's sounds convincing for the people who want believe in it. Bad design is most of the time a simple lack of research, or not enough research, of what are the actual needs and problems that people encounter.
- ulisesrmzroche 13y agoThat headline and the 1st paragraph don't have enough contrast, and the little bold type with the red color has far too much. It makes it really hard to read.
- klunger 13y agoFor everyone that was confused by the Coke bottle thing... I am pretty sure it was a hat-tip to Andy Warhol, who is probably someone the author studied in design school. The quote / idea is pretty well known in those circles. http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/a/andywarhol597858.html http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/a/andywarhol597858....
- dang 13y agoA dupe of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7624189 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7624189.
- a-nikolaev 13y agoThe article is a reminder to all well-intentioned people: When working on something, design it as if you are going to use it yourself. Abstracting your customer is not acceptable. Especially if they are people with disabilities, or if they live in less developed countries than yours. If you are making a pump for them, make a good pump. If you are making a football, make a good football. If people need simple but functional, sturdy and efficient devices, make exactly what they need, not a funny looking multipurpose artifact you would never use yourself.