7 ms·
$7.25 is fine for teenagers looking to pick up some experience and extra cash. The notion that the minimum wage is supposed to provide a living is a good way t
by protomyth 13y ago
$7.25 is fine for teenagers looking to pick up some experience and extra cash. The notion that the minimum wage is supposed to provide a living is a good way to remove young people from the job pool.
- camus2 13y agoexcept now people work in minimum wage jobs all their life. > The notion that the minimum wage is supposed to provide a living is a good way to remove young people from the job pool. The minimum wage is supposed to provide a living period. How can people be as selfish as you are is beyond me.There is enough wealth in this world to be shared so everybody can make a decent living,and it wont make whatever you think you are worth less valuable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 13y agoNot supporting a particular way of distributing wealth is not necessarily being selfish. There are good arguments for e.g. raisin/expanding the EITC instead. I don't have an opinion on the matter (not being a US citizen, I certainly don't know enough about the situation), but I think your insult is completely inappropriate.
- protomyth 13y ago"except now people work in minimum wage jobs all their life." Source please. "How can people be as selfish as you are is beyond me.There is enough wealth in this world to be shared so everybody can make a decent living,and it wont make whatever you think you are worth less valuable." Nice try on the appeal to emotion and shame, but the tactic is best left to talking heads on TV and not places where people actually care about this problem. I could respond with your utter indifference to the youth problem particularly it seems in minority communities whose starting businesses cannot afford $15/hr makes you a ..... well you get the idea. This is HN, not MSNBC. This whole minimum wage foolishness is a cover for politicians that have failed our poor. We need to understand why adults cannot get jobs that employers when jobs go empty. We also need to look at our safety net and see how full of holes it is. Its time for looking at new way to elevate our at risk population (basic income is often discussed here) and education (vocational education to fill the infrastructure jobs that are long vacant and not outsourceble for example).
- PhasmaFelis 13y ago> Source please. Maybe it's different where you are, but in the Kentucky area I see plenty of people in their 50s and 60s working in fast food, gas stations, and Wal-Marts. Have you really not seen this?
- protomyth 13y agoSo, no actual stats. Further, your solution is basically going to get some of those people fired. How about treating the problem of why those people are working minimum wage jobs instead of glossing over it and making things worse.
- PhasmaFelis 13y ago> So, no actual stats. I don't need to provide stats to prove that the sky is blue. Use your eyeballs and observe the world around you.
- protomyth 13y agoI haven't seen any change since the 80's and I do wonder how you know those people are making minimum wage?
- PhasmaFelis 13y ago...Because I know that the position they are working pays minimum wage in my area. Are you just trolling now? Some of them may have been around long enough to earn small raises, but nobody in central Kentucky gets $15 an hour to flip burgers or ring up gas or gather shopping carts.
- protomyth 13y agoI live in ND, we have a bit of an economic boom going. I'm not trolling, but you seem to miss the point of a lot of commentators on this post that minimum wage changes are not an answer and only a feel good measure for people who don't take the time to look at the economy. It sounds good, but will have all sorts of backlash. Its a bad idea and treating the symptom, poorly.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoThe notion that minimum wage isn't supposed to provide a living is a good way to keep adults and the children they support in abject poverty. That's a little more important than teenagers who want after-school jobs for pocket money.
- grinnbearit 13y agoWhy push that burden on the job creators? If the labour value someone provides is lower than a living wage, why not let them survive on welfare (food + clothing + shelter) If this isn't happening, I'd think its more important to provide those basic amenities rather than raising the minimum wage.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoWell, for one thing, welfare funding ultimately comes from tax money, and those noble job creators fight tooth and nail against social benefit programs just as they do against minimum wage increases, and anything else that threatens to make the world a better place at a cost to their bottom line. The US in particular suffers under an entrenched and insidious myth that work is inherently virtuous and people who can't work deserve to starve. Reagan's imaginary legions of welfare queens have taken root in our national dialogue and made widespread, substantial improvements to public welfare virtually impossible. If you feel that progressives are grasping at straws, it's because that's all we have left.
- grinnbearit 13y agoWell it is their income being taxed, why do you feel they should feel obligated to give a portion of it up? (keyword: obligated) they obviously do not.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoBecause I would like to live in a functional society. Because "my right to a third yacht trumps your right to feed your children and get treatment for preventable illnesses" is a shitty thing to believe. Because I think the members of a society have a positive responsibility to each other and to the society. Because, basically, I don't like selfish assholes, not matter how much they try to convince me that selfishness is a virtue. It's not a popular opinion, I realize. And before you start talking about "other people's money," I'm comfortably middle-class, and I would be delighted to pay an extra, say, 20% of my income in taxes if it meant that the sick or homeless or mentally ill people I see every day could get the care that they need.
- morgante 13y ago> The notion that the minimum wage is supposed to provide a living is a good way to remove young people from the job pool. Exactly. Imposing a price floor on labor does nothing besides driving up unemployment. I wish people would stop pushing for an increase in minimum wage. Fundamentally people are trying to subsist on low-skill jobs where the supply/demand realities aren't in their favor. That's the problem we need to address, either through a universal basic income (decreasing the supply of labor) or increased training. A minimum wage just distorts markets and leaves nobody better off.
- hipsters_unite 13y ago> Imposing a price floor on labor does nothing besides driving up unemployment. Do you have any evidence to back that up? I know it was orthodoxy like twenty to twenty-five years ago, but I remember there were plenty of other theories in my university days. Pushing young people out of the job pool isn't such a bad thing if there's an educational alternative. Besides, people on lower incomes spend a larger proportion of their income, rather than saving. Directly increase their disposable income with a minimum wage and I find it hard to believe there won't be an increase in spending in the economy - and that has its own multiplier effects. Besides, even if what you say is true, then you could pragmatically combine policies for effect; an increase in minimum wage with say, government spending on education initiatives, or raising the mandated school leaving age.
- protomyth 13y ago"Pushing young people out of the job pool isn't such a bad thing if there's an educational alternative." Do you have any evidence to back that up? You seem to have a very narrow view of "education". "Besides, people on lower incomes spend a larger proportion of their income, rather than saving." I think you might want to look at actual statistics on savings in the USA today.
- morgante 13y ago> Do you have any evidence to back that up? I know it was orthodoxy like twenty to twenty-five years ago, but I remember there were plenty of other theories in my university days. There have been dozens of studies which show a positive correlation between minimum wage and unemployment. Here's just one: http://businessinnovation.berkeley.edu/williamsonseminar/rubinstein110311.pdf http://businessinnovation.berkeley.edu/williamsonseminar/rub... > Pushing young people out of the job pool isn't such a bad thing if there's an educational alternative. That might indeed be true, but the problem with a price floor is that you have no control over which workers are displaced. I actually think in many places employers would prefer to keep the teens who can, ex. carry more boxes per hour, than older and potentially more vulnerable workers. Hence, the right solution is to attempt to shift the supply of minimum wages by ex. providing more support/incentives for college education. > Directly increase their disposable income with a minimum wage and I find it hard to believe there won't be an increase in spending in the economy - and that has its own multiplier effects. I'm actually not convinced of that. People living on minimum wage often have negative net worth and depend on credit for day-to-day expenses. Hence all that marginally increasing their wage will do is decrease their indebtedness, not increase their spending. Of course, a huge jump in the minimum wage would be enough to push every employed person into the middle class. But it would provide substantial incentives for automation and essentially eliminate low-skill jobs, creating mass unemployment.