2 ms·
Sure... I have a PhD in biophysics and the thing that got me into it was a picture of a glowing tobacco plant on the cover a book. I'm curious because 20+ year
by dekhn 13y ago
Sure... I have a PhD in biophysics and the thing that got me into it was a picture of a glowing tobacco plant on the cover a book.
I'm curious because 20+ years ago I assumed that glowing plants would be solving world hunger, or something. But in grad school they beat all the synthetic biology out of me because it didn't get NIH grants.
It's not really clear to me this has a use. It's neat from a technology perspective, but like glowing yogurt, I struggle to see this being a clear improvement over conventional lighting systems.
- justinsb 13y agoThat is encouraging though: this doesn't get NIH grants, so it hasn't been pursued academically. Thus a group that is able to pursue it, because they got funding from an alternate source (Kickstarter), would be more likely to achieve good results. Indeed, it sounds like they are already 1000x better. If they can get another 1000x, I would wager it'd be a lot more useful than glowing yogurt.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoThere might not be many sensible uses of this technology, but sense doesn't dictate if there is a market. Give it a few years and there could well be plantations of glowing christmas trees causing chaos by utterly confusing the local wildlife.
- technotony 13y agoWe started this project to show people that you don't have to do research like this in an academic lab and be dependent on NIH funding. The more projects like this that happen, the more we can reduce the barriers to starting there will be an exponential take off on the kinds of things that can be done. We are so dependent on plants for so many things that this will undoubtably solve some other problems as well. Plus maybe we can make plants for lighting villages in Africa or for marking the side of the road in Canada.
- aroch 13y agoThere's a reason NIH doesn't fund stuff like this, its useless. A mere novelty. Say what you will about studies of syphilis in the prostitutes of Tijuana, they provide great data about infectious diseases. Super-GFP or Super-Cherry in E. coli˚ glows bright enough to see in ambient light (ie. my lab bench) -- Glowing plants solves essentially 0 real world problemsproblems.
- dekhn 13y agoHope is not a strategy. I admire your enthusiasm, but I am skeptical that your plans will have an impact. Regarding showing people you don't need an academic lab. Well, sure: I could, if I wanted, clone a gene in my garage if I had the time (since I've done it in a lab, it's pretty easy; none of the science of cloning e coli genes is hard, plants are far harder to transform). The funding isn't an issue either because, frankly, contract research labs clone genes affordably (I'm assuming a Bay Area software engineer salary permitting maybe $20-30K opcost and 100 hours/years labor). Personally, I think just focusing on developing a general purpose technology for plant transformation would get you further and faster towards your goal. Gene guns are lame.