2 ms·
I'm not sure what your point is here. Take a potter. His visual style, assuming it is distinct, bears copyright protection. Rightly so, then an upstart can't l
by pbhjpbhj 13y ago
I'm not sure what your point is here.
Take a potter. His visual style, assuming it is distinct, bears copyright protection. Rightly so, then an upstart can't legally come in and reproduce his work and steal away his customers without having put in the work needed to create the design initially. But the copyright in that work doesn't, and shouldn't, bear any sense of protection towards the jobs of those that quarry the clay, or the steel-workers that make the steal used in the potter's tools.
An entire network rests on the potters creative work, but the copyright is there to protect only the creative portion. If the potter is producing work without a distinct style then there will be no effective copyright in it's visual appearance and still all the others will get paid if there is demand for the product.
So?
- anigbrowl 13y agoI'm not sure what your point is. You say the creativity resides with the employees who make the film, but my point is that the creation is only possible through their aggregated efforts and there is nothing wrong with pooling their collective effort on a for-hire basis and assigning the copyright for the result to a commercial entity with shareholders. Your pottery analogy is broken because it doesn't reflect how a film is put together. Imagine, rather, a giant sculpture that requires the collective efforts of 100 potters.