9 ms·
I Don’t Want to Hire Women
- briancaw2 13y agoThe problem here is that she is holding one group's (Women's) behavior to the standard of a workplace created by another group (Men).
- mingabunga 13y agoI have a female friend who owns several womens fashion retail stores and so hires all females. She always asks in a job interview what they do in their spare time, if they answer that they hang out with their girlfriends all the time, doing girly stuff etc then they don't get hired because they end up causing bitchy problems in the workplace. If they answer that they hang out with a mix with guys quite a lot, they're never a problem in the workplace. It's worked for her for many years.
- jqm 13y ago"I welcome your comments, as I secretly continue placing the resumes of female applicants into the “call later” folder." Not a lawyer, but I'm not sure this is a good idea for an employer to put in writing.
- facorreia 13y agoIt's anonymous: > The post was written by a guest blogger but the veracity of every aspect of the story has been verified by Blogger Clarissa.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- noir_lord 13y agoLike the postings on subjects regarding drugs on some forums (which make me laugh) "My dog has gotten his hands on some MDMA, should my dog feel like trying said MDMA what should my dog expect?".
- jrockway 13y agoThat's the same dog that I have accept all those "click here if you agree" "by opening this package you agree" licenses.
- h8trswana8 13y agoWho is this SWIM guy I keep hearing about?
- dspillett 13y agoI wouldn't condone hacking of the sort per se, but if were someone were to get into the relevant records and name & shame the anonymous author I would not feel any measure of sympathy for them.
- Omniusaspirer 13y agoI'm in the opposite camp, I think it's unhealthy to avoid discussing these sorts of biases. If anything I think it's disappointing that you need to hide behind an anonymous veil to admit you have a problem. The author is inviting discussion, if not outwardly asking to be shown the error of her ways. What's the harm in having these discussions?
- callum85 13y ago> I would not feel any measure of sympathy She is clearly concerned about the situation. She is addressing it by blogging about it and asking a community for advice. And she's doing an important thing here by confessing and discussing the causes of discrimination from a perspective that you rarely get to hear (for obvious reasons). This is for the greater good. I would feel a lot of sympathy for her if she got in trouble over this.
- paulhauggis 13y agowhat? really? I feel like we aren't allowed to have the freedom of speech anymore. It's A-OK to completely destroy lives and careers through shaming. It's a method of silencing the opposition for having an opinion you don't like. This is evil. This women is just making an observation from her own experiences..and somehow it's wrong.
- gms7777 13y agoWell, we need to separate the two acts: 1.) Sharing an opinion and anecdotal experience on a blog 2.) Disclosing that you're participating in an illegal activity (discriminatory hiring practices) Should she be doxxed and publically shamed for sharing her opinon? Of course not. But should the hiring practices of her company be looked into? Well, thats certainly a much more fuzzy area, because it is no longer a victimless act.
- zachlipton 13y agoUntil "Blogger Clarissa" gets a subpoena demanding that she hand over her emails with the guest blogger and testify as to her knowledge of the employer.
- fleitz 13y agoThe problem is that is you need an aggrieved party... With out knowing who the employer is there is no case, and the police can't investigate in right of the state because no crimes has been committed, nor is the jurisdiction clear.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoWho is going to subpoena her? What sort of case would be brought, exactly?
- livejamie 13y ago> Not a lawyer, but I'm not sure this is a good idea for an employer to put in writing. You could say the same thing about the entire post.
- timdierks 13y agoNote that this is an anonymous "guest post"—I thought for a while that it was an account by the blog author.
- rcthompson 13y agoYeah, that disclaimer really should have appeared at the top of the article.
- wutbrodo 13y agoYea, I was wondering how she's not inviting a flood of lawsuits by saying that she's explicitly acting on these perceptions of hers. It was only until I came to the comments here that I noticed it was an anon author.
- mhurron 13y agoIt's too bad it's anonymous, because it so nice when assholes label themselves as such. It never ceases to amaze me how stupid people can be, women do this, ethnic group a can't do that. We're all human, we're just not that different.
- stcredzero 13y agoWhen prejudice reveals itself, costing you nothing, it's a time to be thankful. However, the prejudiced shouldn't be vilified as somehow subhuman. When you do that, you're taking a simple token and using it to lay a reductive judgment on a complex person. In other words, you are engaging in a form of prejudice yourself. Grandparents watching Fox News or saying something racist over Thanksgiving dinner doesn't make them horrible people or evil. They are a product of their time, as are you. This doesn't excuse their behavior, but it doesn't by itself render them subhuman or worthy of hate. Prejudice is best counteracted by engagement, commerce, and exposure. The vilification of political enemies in the US was understandable given some of the truly horrific things done as recently the 20th century. Today's 1st world should be a different place.
- paulhauggis 13y agoI see you only mentioned Fox News. You do know CNN and MSNBC are horribly biased as well.
- stcredzero 13y agoI was writing for the majority HN crowd. (I utilize what seem to be trivial prejudices in my writing to keep it shorter. In reality, those prejudices are just as bad. Don't vilify, though!)
- orthecreedence 13y agoHow does arguing over which news provider is more biased contribute anything to the argument you're responding to? All news outlets are biased. Fox is known by many people for taking it to an unrelenting extreme and it's perfectly acceptable to use them as an example of such without listing ten more networks.
- xarien 13y agoDisclosure: MBTI has tons of issues and it's certainly not the end all for evaluations. There's a reason why HR folks aren't allowed to use it in most firms when recruiting. However, with that said, I think it's quite applicable in this case. MBTI; NT vs SF. Find women that fall into the NT category and your problem is solved. This isn't an issue with gender as it is with certain individuals. Although looking at the numbers, you will encounter more women falling into SF and more men falling under NT. But, let me throw this out there, don't miss the chance to hire some great women simply because you've encountered some bad apples. You should simply tailor the initial screening phase to catch some of these unwanted behaviors. Additionally, you can employ the try before you buy option and remove bad apples within the first 90 days before they rot the tree.
- bdisraeli 13y agoMBTI doesn't have tons of issues. It's entirely unscientific.[1] [1] http://www.indiana.edu/~jobtalk/HRMWebsite/hrm/articles/develop/mbti.pdf http://www.indiana.edu/~jobtalk/HRMWebsite/hrm/articles/deve...
- 3minus1 13y ago> There's a reason why HR folks aren't allowed to use it in most firms when recruiting Can you expand on this? I was blown away by MBTI when I first took the test, and I have considered talking about it in interviews.
- bitwize 13y agoDisclosure: Astrology has tons of issues and is not the end-all for evaluations, but she would do well to hire more people born under honest, steadfast signs like Taurus, Virgo, Libra, or Sagittarius and fewer drama-prone Geminis, Leos, Aries or Scorpios.
- stcredzero 13y ago“Wait”, I said, “So, I did thank you then?” – “Yes! But you did not elaborate on what exactly you liked about them! Why didn’t you?” She had bought them with the company credit card and I actually did not like them at all, but I digress. This is a startup? Why not just say: Actually, I don't like those. Also, why not just tell employees that you're not one for gossip? Did the author understand direct communications? How good was she at cementing close relationships with coworkers?
- pessimizer 13y ago>Also, why not just tell employees that you're not one for gossip? People have different definitions of gossip, the most common one being: 'something that other people do that's not as smart or interesting as what I'm doing right now.'
- ossreality 13y agoNo, not really.
- nsomaru 13y agoossreality: your account is hellbanned. I'm not sure how informing you of such things flies on HN anymore, but to see so much wasted time is saddening to me.
- DanBC 13y ago> Why not just say: Actually, I don't like those. Because that kind of deliberate demoralisation serves no purpose and causes harm.
- mediaman 13y agoI think this anonymous blogger should evaluate her hiring practices. I have hired many women and men. If anything I have had fewer melodrama issues with women. The women I have hired are focused, analytical, meticulate and disciplined. I had exactly one so far leave for "soft" reasons; she wanted to pursue nonprofit work in a developing country and we remain on good terms. In a manufacturing environment, I've had far more issues with gossip, melodrama and feuds with men. As I have brought more women in (not intentionally, but just because they were good candidates) many of those issues have disappeared and our production operations have become more upbeat with fewer personnel issues. In general, I find a much higher incidence rate of irresponsibility among male production candidates: outstanding arrest warrants, inability to resolve past DUI offenses with the courts, domestic violence that spreads into the workplace, absenteeism, etc. -- all actual issues we have had to deal with. Obviously not all male candidates are like this, and it would be wrong to draw the opposite conclusion. It is also fairly easy to weed these people out of the recruiting process, or, at worst, to part ways with them if we are not successful in catching it before hiring. But if you find you have hired a bunch of melodramatic and uncommitted women, you should probably ask yourself why your hiring processes selected people with those traits (hint: it is not because of their gender).
- SolarNet 13y agoIt could be an income level thing. Not that I like making generalizations (and this is just the observation of other people's experience, I don't agree with this personally as I have no personal data to support the majority of observations which lead to it): * At low incomes, women are responsible workers, men are irresponsible workers. * At higher incomes (middle class), men are responsible workers, women are irresponsible workers. It could come from the confluence of privilege and feminism, lower income female workers think they have to go the extra mile to prove they deserve the job, because feminism isn't ingrained in them, the communities they live in often force women into gender roles (they just happen to be the more responsible roles). Upper income female workers have ingrained feminism, but society still treats (via media, social interactions, etc) them like their old gender roles (ever see girls on teen TV shows? It's the most sexist shit I've seen on TV). This means they believe they are equal to men (which they are) but they also believe (due to society) that they can behave like society expected them to 50 years ago, which they can't if they want a job in the modern work place. Again, I blame society.
- vijayboyapati 13y agoShe writes: "I am also yet to have a single male employee come to my office to give me dirt on a co-worker or share an awkward gossip-like story. My female employees though? Every. single. one." The Economist had an article which tangentially comports with her comment above: http://www.economist.com/node/21551535 http://www.economist.com/node/21551535
- zenbowman 13y agoThat is a fascinating study. It's definitely true that at both companies I've worked at, HR has been totally dominated by women. So if it is true that women are discriminated against in the tech industry, why is that so, given that most people involved in the hiring process are also women? The fact that attractive women are more discriminated against than plain ones is something that never occurred to me, I always believed it was the other way round. And I never considered that attractive men were treated more favorably. I think at the very least the study shows that discrimination is very hard to root out, and simply hiring along certain quotas doesn't really solve the problem at all.
- zo1 13y agoI have absolutely no idea why you're being down modded. But it sounds like you've struck an uncomfortable observation, and people don't like it.
- zenbowman 13y agoI don't think I've said anything remotely offensive, I'm not suggesting that women are not discriminated against, I'm just saying that discrimination is not a simple issue as many people claim.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zo1 13y agoWell, you did also point out that HR is dominated by women. So that means that the hiring process is also dominated by women in quite a few workplaces. Combine that with the observations from the study, and all of a sudden we're put in the uncomfortable situation of explaining the apparently incongruent end-results of hiring processes favoring less-attractive women which doesn't fit the currently "accepted" paradigm of "men are sexist against women in the workplace". And you're completely right, the issue is not simple in any way. We're stuck making half-observations, trying to make connections between disparate points, etc. But what that tells me is that we're dealing with a very vague, soft, and ultimately subjective issue. Which people are trying to measure using quantitative, hard measurements.
- zachlipton 13y agoRight, because no men ever behave badly in the workplace? Sure, there are stereotypical ways in which a small number of people from each gender behave like assholes and create toxic work environments. The solution is to not hire jerks and to get rid of them if you've made a mistake, not blame all ones ills on a particular group of people.
- rokhayakebe 13y agoMan behaves badly "he is an ambitious dk." Woman, "she is a bch," maybe if we insert words such as perfectionist, ambitious, meticulous, etc.. before the b word it may be different.
- smrtinsert 13y agoIt sounds like women just hate working for "Enterpreneur".
- soneca 13y agoSounds a lot of bad luck (or bad hiring skills) that every single woman she hired was a failure. But every communication issue has two sides. I am pretty sure she reinforced - even if unwillingly - this behavior after reading this: "I have developed a different approach for offering constructive criticism to male and female employees. When I have something to say to one of the men, I just say it! I don’t think it through – I simply spit it out, we have a brief discussion and we move on. They even frequently thank me for the feedback! Not so fast with my female staff. I plan, I prepare, I think, I run it through my business partner and then I think again. I start with a lot of positive feedback before I feel that I have cushioned my one small negative comment sufficiently, yet it is rarely enough. We talk forever, dissect every little piece of it, and then come back to the topic time and time again in the future. And I also have to confirm that I still like them – again and again, and again." When you put so much effort on something that is not the focus, that thing becomes the focus. If a woman cries after a reasonable feedback and you spend a lot of time trying to justify and compensate on that crying, the crying become justified. So you just reiforced the behavior. But if you are sure your feedback was a fair one; just let it go. Let her cry on her own, without giving much attention to it. She will stop crying sometime, think about things more rationally and the next time she will take feedback differently. I think the case is just that women express themselves different from men. Women cry at the spot and go emotional. Men keep the things for themselves and talk trash about you later on the bar. If you, as a boss, could listen to the men employees and tried to get some confrontation about the trash talk men do, this would reinforce the trash talking and a lot of new issues would appear on the professional realtionship. It is just bad luck in this particular scenario that women express their emotion more strongly and vocational; so I think some conscious actions must have being taken so this particular behavior doesn't extrapolate in more serious issues.
- r00fus 13y agoBingo. I think the major issue is that as a self-proclaimed feminist, she seems to divide the groups purely on gender. Instead of putting them into different categories solely based on gender perhaps she should recognize that (in a simplified view) if there is a continuum of behavior, genders tend to have bell curves around areas, but that their distributions overlap. Ie, some women really just want the unvarnished facts. Understanding that some men also like to get "sandwiched" negatives while some women just want the facts and move one - and that varies by person, not by "gender" alone.
- fred_durst 13y ago> She had bought them with the company credit card and I actually did not like them at all, but I digress. She definitely sounds like someone I wouldn't want to work for. Apparently she didn't like the flowers "at all"? Who hates flowers? This is probably one of those cases where the person complaining might want to look inward as a first step. EDIT: Oops, it was butterflies. Either way, is a picture of butterflies really some to not like "at all"? Just sounds bitter and angry to me. And why does she feel the need to "digress" and let us know that she didn't like them?
- pessimizer 13y agoOnly if you think that there's someone wrong with people who dislike flowers, but not enough to mention it or to do anything about it. What's your diagnosis, doc? And how did you rule out allergies so quickly over the internet?
- tlrobinson 13y agoA "picture with butterflies", not flowers. From the article: "Remember when I bought the pictures with butterflies to hang in the front?"
- brazzy 13y agoThe word "flower" does not appear anywhere on the page. The passage you quote refers to "pictures with butterflies".
- MaggieL 13y agoConsidering that the writer goes on at length about how she feels she must treat women differently; "looking inward" would indeed be very much a good idea. I'm not sure it would be productive, because I'm not seeing evidence of a lot of understanding about what motivates different behaviors in people, which is a skill a manager must have. "Because she's a woman" is not an adequate explanation for why someone behaves in a particular way.
- chrisBob 13y agoThe flowers were "pictures with butterflies". I don't see any mention of flowers, and I bet you can find some awful artwork of butterflies.
- littlemerman 13y agoI completely disagree with the presumptions of this article. Hopefully not too many employers feel this way.
- rokhayakebe 13y agoMaybe women are too sensitive. Tell a girl at work her hairstyle does not look nice after she asks you, and she is mad at you. Maybe men are too sensitive. Tell a guy at a sports bar his team sucks and they should be put out of the league, and you are lucky if he does not punch you. So someone can write a post about women gossiping at work and how that creates all sorts of tension. And someone can write a post about how their boyfriend is so sensitive about his app that telling him the truth and saying it's kind of crappy will probably end up in break up. Who is more sensitive? I have my opinion, but maybe all of this is a matter of perspective?
- Atheros 13y agoThe man in your example is more sensitive and should be fired and then jailed for assault. It's not ambiguous.
- ignostic 13y agoAs a male who manages both men and women, I think the author is guilty of selective perception and unfounded bias. I have had women on my team cry in meetings, but I've had men on my team explode in anger. Neither is appropriate. Women on my team often want to "gossip," but I've learned to recognize it for what it is: a (misguided) attempt to build rapport with me. I'm learning to redirect the conversation to be more positive. The men on my team are more likely to be jockeying for position, claiming credit for things they had small roles in, and generally exaggerating the truth. I'm learning to ask follow-up questions to get them to think twice before making any claims. Males on my team are just as hard or harder to retain when compared to the women. I believe they're more likely to leave when they're passed over for a promotion or raise. Females at my company are perhaps more likely to leave because they aren't feeling close relationships. Keep in mind that the reason someone gives you for leaving is not always the real reason. The author doesn't seem particularly sensitive, so I wouldn't be surprised if she's getting "reasons" for quitting that are actually just evasions of hard topics. These are all just my observations and experiences, but I'm sure there are plenty of studies showing the pros and cons of hiring men and women. Whether biological or cultural, I'm positive there are both pros and cons to hiring either gender. Regardless, you should see my point: it's easy to get a little selective perception when you notice all the bad things about one gender. The fact that the author claims to be a woman and a feminist doesn't excuse a thing. That just means she's a woman and a feminist who stereotypes and wants to discriminate against women.
- jasallen 13y agoignostic, I agree with you completely. One of the key differences I think, is that you think as a professional manager of people. The author thinks like a "do-er", a contributor, and is looking for people who work like her. She may be an unusual woman that tends more toward the male pattern of behavior, but that is just happenstance. One thing you both agree on, is that (whether she hates it or not) there are common differences between men and women that extend beyond appearance. Where I differ with her: Whether chromosomes or upbringing or micro-biota I don't care, those differences exist, they are useful diversification and should be accepted, even though they each need to be managed in their own way.
- epx 13y agoIndeed sounds a lot like bad luck. I have been working with women, as subordinates, and superiors, and it is perfect.
- gravity13 13y agoThere's just as many idiot men as there are idiot women in the world. The issue stems from the fact that every time there's an idiot man nobody looks at him and says, "look, you're confirming a cultural stereotype!"
- BESebastian 13y ago> a feminist, ... I don’t just stand for equality – I have crashed the glass ceiling in every aspect of my life. > As a feminist ... > ... which is why I have decided not to hire women altogether. Something doesn't add up here!
- sp332 13y agoIf women acted like men do, she would hire them. So it's kind of pro-equality.
- zachlipton 13y ago???
- sp332 13y agoWell she's not inherently against women, or pro-men. But of course men (on average) have an advantage in acting like her ideal person, since it's closer to typical male behavior. So it's still not really equal.
- srdev 13y agoI can't say I've ever seen these problems with women at my work. I wonder if these issues stem from larger problems in the workplace. For example, if there was subtle sexism resulting in devaluing the women's work, I could see why they would be seeking positive reinforcement from their female manager.
- johngalt 13y agoI wonder if the author is judging other women for not making the proper feminist choices 'mooching off a boyfriend' etc... Putting a magnifying glass on other women while not even noticing a male who quit to pursue a video game addiction. Someone cried in a meeting. So what? Who yells and pounds tables in a meeting? Why don't we just cover all the stereotypes about gender? Even if everything this author says were true, it doesn't excuse prejudging individuals based on their gender. There aren't enough skilled people in the world. Don't cut the number available to you in half.
- wcfields 13y agoWtf kind of 1950's world is this person living in? It sounds much less a woman problem than a personal problem that this person is having. Our company is probably 60w/40m and the dev/tech teams are at 36% women and I can't imagine ANY of this happening.
- michaelochurch 13y agoIt is not men who sabotage women and stump their career growth – it is women themselves! I wonder if she is (subconsciously?) part of the problem. Now, I'm not saying that she overtly engages in that sort of passive-aggressive, competitive behavior (stereotypically female, but characteristic of the sexes about equally, if not more often by men, in the office context) against them... but it could be that she carries a subconscious bias that leads her to hire a different and possibly lower quality of women than the men she brings on. If it seems far-fetched, consider the casual misogyny of a high school or college campus, and the vicious cycle it creates for young men. We're not talking about a raving woman-hater. We're talking about the average-case college male who thinks women are irrational, flighty, and manipulative. He's actually right-- about most of the women he pays attention to. That's the misogyny loop: guys who think ill of "women" tend to hang around low-quality women (high-quality women just avoid them) and end up confirming their own biases ("misogyny loop"). If he stopped focusing on the bubbly/popular girls with broken personalities (who get away with it, because everyone wants them) and took a representative sample, he'd realize that women aren't any worse or better than men. Of course, such guys are usually blind to their own broken personalities. See, I've never seen these patterns she's described. I've worked with a lot of horrible people and only one of my top 10 is female... and, to her credit, she was pretty "active-aggressive" in her toxicity. I know that these behaviors exist in workplaces, but I don't think they're especially gendered. Passive-aggressive, gossiping men are out there as well.
- Dewie 13y ago> If it seems far-fetched, consider the casual misogyny of a high school or college campus, and the vicious cycle it creates for young men. We're not talking about a raving woman-hater. We're talking about the average-case college male who thinks women are irrational, flighty, and manipulative. What makes this an objective observation about men in college, as opposed to the selection bias that you think that these men (however many of them) have and the author of this article?
- stcredzero 13y agoWhat makes this an objective observation about men in college, as opposed to the selection bias... Are you assuming that he is making this observation in comparison to college women? I think the observation has to do with who holds the preponderance of power. In the artificial age-segregated school environments we've created, young, inexperienced people dealing with the full flush of their hormones and newly matured bodies create their own "Lord of the Flies" society, largely free of the influence of older, wiser people. Natural human instincts create concentrations of power in a minority of popular individuals, and this power corrupts. This is quite unfortunate, as young people in school are still forming their models of the world.
- kstop 13y agoIn a decade of managing teams on and off, I have had more melodrama from male staff members than female. The major flameouts and freak-outs have all come from men. Given that I never got to 50% parity and we're talking less than 50 hires overall it would be a mistake to draw any major inferences from my experience, but the same is probably true of hers. That said, different people need different management styles. But IMO this is mostly cultural, not gender-based. It happens that in Western culture there are gender behavioral norms that you have to allow for. This is something you just have to get over, because a) nowadays you'll never get away with only hiring people just like you and b) the benefits of hiring people from different backgrounds far outweigh the hassle of having to display some sensitivity and treat your reports as individuals.
- steven777400 13y agoOf the issues she describes, I have seen them in men as well. I have male friends who have quit with nothing in particular lined up next. I have a male coworker who cried in a meeting, and went to his manager to demand that I apologize for offending him and making him cry. Dirt and gossip? I get just as much from male coworkers as female. I don't mean to undermine or invalidate her experience, but I feel that the sample is too small. At least, my experience is not consistent with hers.
- GUNHED_158 13y agoThis is the essence : "It is not men who sabotage women and stump their career growth – it is women themselves!"
- Dewie 13y agoIt seems that she is swinging from one extreme - from being enthusiastic about lifting women up and helping them, to actively avoiding them. But maybe a more balanced approach would yield better results? Maybe the women just became spoilt by how accommodating she was? She says, for example, that she has to scrutinize every interaction with her women employees, for fear of the ensuing drama. Maybe she should just tell them to get over it? I don't know. But some people will readily bite the hands that feed them too eagerly.
- orthecreedence 13y agoCompletely agree. If you treat people like children they will act like children. To be honest, the author of the post sounds like a somewhat spineless person who's too afraid of hurting people's feelings to manage effectively. The women percieve this and react to it, as perhaps the men do as well by completely ignoring her (not alpha, not a threat, no problems). You can't tiptoe around people and also lead effectively. Yes, some people will cry. Some people will have angry outbursts. But you remain calm, let them cool off a bit, and then move on with life.
- keithpeter 13y ago"...we were two women, both mothers with very small children, opening a company in a very competitive industry." I'm a teacher in adult education in the UK. The students, mostly but not all women, with lots of children/parents and other care responsibilities are, in my experience, the ones who hand work in on time and who really focus in lessons. They have so little time that they have to plan things carefully. The younger students, mostly chaps, who have no responsibilities take the most management. "Go figure" as I think the Americans say. Seriously: good luck to Clarissa but she would need a really good HR lawyer in the UK. Edit: Just bought a copy of 'River of Shadows' as I'm into Muybridge. I could not give a kipper's dick about how the book's author behaved at a cocktail party (having never attended one), I'm interested in the content, you know, what she has to say on the subject. Good blog. Makes you think. Argue even. On my list. http://clarissasblog.com/2014/05/15/feminism-triviality/ http://clarissasblog.com/2014/05/15/feminism-triviality/
- chillingeffect 13y agoYes, an excellent blog entry. Here's my fave part "People’s Clothes Hurt Me" > "It felt as though that shirt was trying to single-handedly put me in my place—a distinctly inferior and foreign place.”
- keithpeter 13y ago"mind narrower than his trousers" is where I'm putting the shirt-wearer ("does his Mum know he is out") but then...
- dcre 13y agoFor once I'm satisfied with HN's reaction.
- tptacek 13y agoSame!
- swayvil 13y agoThe view that our gender (glands, various gender-related cues, etc) influences our mind and behavior seems to be surreally unpopular these days. Many well worded essays on such in the comments.
- chrisBob 13y agoEveryone is giving this woman a hard time, but I have heard my wife say something similar. I think a large part of what the (presumably male) posters here are missing is how differently women interact with other women.
- softatlas 13y agoDo you folks even know what gossip is? Small talk !== Gossip. God, it's obnoxious reading like 98% of you. You think "stuff I'm not interested in" is gossip, which is even worse than the assumption "Small talk === Gossip". Look, adding a qualification or narrative component (predicates not strictly quantifiable over the domain) is a mark of conversation. BUILDING RAPPORT is NOT GOSSIP. BUILDING RAPPORT is NOT GOSSIP. BUILDING RAPPORT is NOT GOSSIP. BUILDING RAPPORT is NOT GOSSIP. BUILDING RAPPORT is NOT GOSSIP. AGAIN: BUILDING RAPPORT is NOT GOSSIP. VAGUENESS is not gossip. It's SYSTEMATIC oppression. A laundry list of "why this, why this" at the end of a post COMPLETELY FAILS to grok what SYSTEMATIC/STRUCTURAL oppression MEANS. Learn how to more categories of conversation. LEARN what speech genres are. Stop reducing everything to "gossip/actionable". Stop the elimination of human spontaneity. Stop building the ideal language that the ideal person must speak. Stop. STOP.
- tptacek 13y agoPlease don't use all-caps for emphasis. Please don't repeat lines several times for emphasis. Please avoid assessments of the people writing comments (or call them "obnoxious"); focus instead on the arguments that dismay you. It's unfortunate because I think there are probably valid points in this comment, but they've been worded in such a way that even people who disagree with you will be repelled.
- sergiotapia 13y agoCan confirm, I've worked in a workplace where it was about 6 men and 48 women (no lie). The gossip dear lord the gossip and cliques that were formed. The cattiness among each other, the talking behind each others back - it felt like high school on TV. The guys were 4 on tech team and 2 on management. The rest were sales girls, making calls to close sales in the higher-education sector. (Think e-learning master degrees). Never worked in a place with that many women so I don't have any other measuring stick, but yeesh did that leave me with weird memories.
- devnonymous 13y agoI read the article and AFAICT, the basic problem is right there in there in the first paragraph: > I get extremely angry when I come across articles that insist there are > gender differences that extend beyond physiology. That's just ridiculous and ignorant. Of course there are differences between men and women that extend beyond physiology !! [1] Reading the comments and the replies, the author seems to deny this fact and wants everyone to be behaviourally uniform. On the one hand she is applying broad strokes and describing her own experiences with her male Vs female employees but on the other she wants to deny that some of these differences exist and can be explained 'beyond physiology'. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_differences_in_humans#Psychology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_differences_in_humans#Psych...
- dclowd9901 13y agoI don't think there's enough information here to make any judgments one way or another. I find non-professional behavior has far more to do with the position held than the sex of the person inhabiting it. I have a hard time imagining a female VP, for instance, behaving so unprofessionally. Conversely, it wouldn't surprise me to see a sales guy acting like a jackass. It's rather more likely that one's professionalism stems from 1) the professionalism that's expected from someone in their position and 2) the effort the individual has gone through to reach their position.
- peterwwillis 13y agoINSERT COMMENT GENERALIZING ABOUT ALL MEN OR WOMEN BASED ON SELECT PERSONAL EXPERIENCE BACK UP WITH STUDY FROM 1972 LINKING GENDER WITH PREDETERMINED BEHAVIOR CORRELATE THE TWO
- tptacek 13y agoIf you had simply not uppercased this comment, it would be snarky but useful. Instead, it reads like an assault; it's the kind of comment a reader looks at and knows they can't use as the basis of a civil discussion.
- peterwwillis 13y agoYeah, I figured that after I posted it. Oh well. (I'm used to using all caps on other mediums when I want to express meta-language/ideas and not natural speech, but I forgot that anything on HN that doesn't look 'respectable' gets downvoted quicker than INSERT JOKE NOBODY ON HN WILL LIKE)
- tptacek 13y agoIt's a guideline on HN. For emphasis, use asterisks, and your text will be bolded.
- breadbox 13y agoThis is all I can think of: http://xkcd.com/385/ http://xkcd.com/385/
- KerrickStaley 13y ago> I get extremely angry when I come across articles that insist there are gender differences that extend beyond physiology. This is backwards. There are certainly psychological differences between men and women (see e.g. [1]). However, assuming that statistical averages determine individual characteristics is also wrong. People are highly varied, and an individual's difference from the mean often dwarfs the mean difference between two populations (e.g. men/women). Add to this the fact that people are self-conscious and can change their innate behavior. Sex is a very poor predictor of an individual's psychological traits. [1] http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/21591157-new-technique-has-drawn-wiring-diagrams-brains-two-sexes http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/2159115...
- zo1 13y agoLooks like she's got an axe to grind, and doesn't like getting side-tracked by the topic you mention. As evidenced by her rant about it, and her comment-deletions.
- josephschmoe 13y agoThere could be some bias coming from the career paths these individuals are coming from. We can't know because she doesn't elaborate on her industry, but here's an example which would produce this kind of bias naturally: If she employs engineers (or some other equivalent), there's a good chance they will provide little issues as they tend to be better-educated and more stable than average. They are also predominately male. Other office jobs are a mixed bag and tend to employ average individuals, with a variety of education levels and backgrounds. This is often 50/50 or sometimes predominately female, such as in HR. In that case, it would be more accurately comparing average vs. unusually well-educated individuals. Gender would only be proportional to this because of her specific business case.
- lampe3 13y agoclick bait...
- ripb 13y agoHow is this HN appropriate content? If I could flag this, I would. This is an anonymous post on a completely irrelevant blog that has nothing to do with the world HN surrounds. Is it too much to ask that Reddit/Tumblr-esque gender wars not be dragged into every online discussion forum available? From the guidelines: "On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity." Just look at the quality of the discussion this has spawned - pure and utter trash.
- SolarNet 13y agoI'm on the fence, but to play devil's advocate: This is about start ups, it's about hiring and managing different genders, I've seen many great links posted which may help managers in start ups deal with gender issues. I've seen great anecdotal stories about managing different genders. Honestly I've seen very little gender flame war, perhaps because the original article was written by a woman.
- ripb 13y agoWell, how do we know it was written by a woman? The post has about as much credibility as an anonymous rant written on a Tumblr blog. It is an anonymous, anecdotal, generalised rant and little more and this type of content, as can be witnessed on a plethora of other popular online fora, tend to lead to the same things repeatedly: - People charging in to furiously counter the generalisation with other shallow personal anecdotes - "Well I have seen men/women do x,y,z!", "In my experience men/women are even worse than men/women at x,y,z!" - People charging in with the "not all men/women" argument - People charging in to back the generalisation up and commit a rant of their own on men/women - etc. But the resounding repeated behaviour is people charging in, emotions on high, to exclaim shallow, generalised and anecdotal stories of their own. Mainly not to discuss the matter, but to push their agenda in the matter. This drives the signal:noise ratio in the wrong direction and, if tolerated, degrades the forum as a whole. I'm not saying that there isn't space for such discussions, but this is not the format for such discussion and only bad can come of it. If anything, mainstream fora have proven to be completely incapable of having rational discussions on gender issues - the more mainstream the less capable (see Reddit.com for example) - and HN is becoming more mainstream as people flood from such sites due to said degradation of the content there.
- mblack68 13y agoI am very disappointed that one of my "own kind" is disparaging women. If that's what females in this field encounter, no wonder there are so few. My deep disappointment cannot be expressed in words right now. Hiring is hard to get right, period. Why are we worrying about gender traits--this article is generalizing to the point of absurdity. I feel motivated at this point, to change my name to a gender neutral one for hiring purposes. When people see articles like this, it is affirming, and others will follow silently.
- devnonymous 13y agoHeh, what I find mildly amusing is the fact that in writing the blog post and replying the comments the author is just reinforcing the very stereotype that leads her to conclude that women are not worth the risk of hiring. She is indulging the same type of drama she alleges is the cause of forming her opinion !!
- smtddr 13y agoWell... this doesn't match 95% of my experience. I've worked with several ladies(especially in my current gig) but only back in at&t do I vividly recall 3 very gossip-driven, melodramatic women. This was out from an org with like 40+ women in it. But those 3... those 3.... sheesh, you could see 'em coming a mile away. They just had issues in general and happened to be females.(sidenote: if any of you are reading this, you know who you are. The whole department knew who you were) I've worked with more unpleasant men than women, but this tech so there's just more men than women in general. Yeah... I don't know where I'm going with this other than this blogger's experience is not an accurate representation of the employee-pool at large.
- watwut 13y agoWomen she employs are entirely different then all women I ever met. I have never seen a women cry on meeting. I never knew any women that would "stay home to “figure out what to do next”". On the other hand, I have seen men leaving jobs without having another one lined up. I'm not sure whether she sees significant difference between the two or why she would care what employee is going to do. I find it fascinating that she hires outstanding women and somehow ends up with selection of worst possible personalities. All of them are so super sensitive, that she can not communicate with them without extensive preparation. Maybe, just maybe her criteria for "educated, intelligent and highly articulate" actually select emotional and manipulative people? It might be just my bias, but I suspect the "highly articulate" criteria. Highly articulate is advantage in some jobs (sales), but irrelevant in jobs like receptionist. Maybe she should look for "educated, intelligent, communicates as adult and in control of emotions" instead. She will get more introverts and less drama. I also met women managers they managed not to become therapists for underlying - not even for needy employees. So, I suspect there is something in her behavior that encourages them to come into her office again and again.
- Entrepreneur- 13y agoMost of my direct reports are indeed in sales; exceptional communication skills are an essential requirement for everyone on the team, including the receptionist, as there is a very high volume of people coming into our office on a daily basis. I do find the last paragraph in your comment quite valid!
- arctansusan 13y agoThis is such a bullshit misogynistic article that hurts women in the work force and makes sweeping inaccurate generalizations. If the HN staff have any once of morality and sense of equality, please delete this article from HN now and ban the author.
- chillingeffect 13y agowow - do you delete your posts shortly after posting them or do you just have incredible restraint which was suddenly broken by this post? (bg: this is arctansusan's first post after 399 days. Two more quickly followed within 10 minutes).
- arbutus 13y agoAnyone who was ever a teenaged girl at any point in their life can confirm that the people who complain the most about drama are generally the people who create the most drama.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- cbp 13y agoHoly shit this site. This crap is getting so much upvotes, the comments in here make me vomit. Where are the mods? surely they would never allow this kind of link on this site?
- Consultant32452 13y agoI read through a bunch of the comments and it seems like the author was a victim of her own attitude. She talks about how she intended to employ and empower women in her workplace. It sounds like she might have started with a pro-woman bias but it had the negative side effect of creating a more "casual" environment with the women than the men. The men continued to interact with her professionally but the women interacted more casually and therefore took feedback more personally. I've personally worked in a number of professional environments with men and women and never seen this from any woman that had any sort of professional job. I have seen it among low paid wage jobs, but no more often than the violent or other harassing outbursts from men in those types of jobs.
- eduardordm 13y agoExcept for me and my partner (founders, CTO and CEO respectively) all our directors are women. Females represent more than 60% of our company. We never had any of such events happening in the workplace. Immaturity is asexual. This situation happened months ago in my company: One female intern came to me, she was almost crying, telling she wanted to quit. She was about to tell me what happened but I only wanted to hear her only after she was a bit calmer. I told her to take the day off, since she had a son, she could use the day to do something more fun. At this point I thought that maybe it was some sort of problem with a phone call. She worked primarily answering calls and giving initial support to users. After a quick investigation: some employees had a whatsapp group for sharing reddit links, gossip. She asked for an invite and was in the group only as a reader, months later she never reads the group messages and didn't realize the group now became a porn-heaven. Three engineers forgot that she was there made some vulgar comments about her, she discovered. After she confronted them they did some nasty sexual comments about her being in a porn-only whatsapp group. The three nasty commentators were fired on the spot. Engineers often think code and their github account the is exclusive reason I'm hiring them. They argued about how that was their private, personal activity outside office hours, digging their hole deeper. After firing them I had a private talk with every engineer and explained what happened and talked about the event. The reason I did this was to find another employees with the same mindset as the ones who were fired, and I did. They were fired weeks after. One of the three nasty engineers was a woman, when confronted it was clear to me that she was either a sexist or some sort of misogynist.
- krainboltgreene 13y agoDamn that sounds like a textbook solution to a serious problem. Kudos on being that strategic and methodical about removing the real problems.
- malandrew 13y agoI can't find the links now (signal to noise ratio is low given the search terms I tried), but I've heard on numerous occasions that there are a few landmark studies where men were given estradiol and other estrogens and that resulted in behavior changes that ape the behavior patterns that most frustrate the author of this essay. Can anyone here point me to the experimental studies exploring the administration of sex hormone to the opposite gender and its effect on behavior? I've never read them myself and was curious as to their validity and the strength of the results.
- apta 13y ago> People in the past 2 hours I have had to Spam 63 comments from losers who tried to inform me that “men and women are psychologically / emotionally, etc. different.” Once again, anybody who embarrasses him or herself by chirping idiotically “yes, men and women are different” will be banned outright. "losers"? "embarrasses him or herself"? Yes, men and women are different, what's wrong with saying that?
- orionblastar 13y agoI worked with both men and women. Some women are really good at their job, really professional. Other women are not good at their job and unprofessional. It is the later that are being talked about here. The ones that paint their nails at work and then refuse to do any work until they dry. The ones that gossip and lie about other people to stir up trouble. The ones that refuse to do work and avoid doing work by reading romance novels, watering plants, making coffee, bringing in food, walking around with a clipboard and not doing anything, and wasting as much time as they can just to get that paycheck. Some men waste time as well as do some of the things some women do to be honest.
- digita88 13y agoIn most of my work environments, I've worked with a lot of females and I have to admit that some of the work behaviours outlined are behaviours that annoy me and actually drive me to move companies (citing it as a part of 'work culture'). HOWEVER I don't attribute this to a single sex because I can also see it in the males. Same goes regardless of race and age. However I do believe that your gender does play a role in the workplace, whether you would like it or not. The only thing is that personality trumps gender stereotypes.
- sequoia 13y agoBlog editor comment on TFA, referring to the post author ("Entrepreneur"): "In the spirit of full disclosure, Entrepreneur has been known to come to social gatherings with a list of controversial topics for the group to discuss so that the party wouldn't be boring." It's worth noting that the Entrepreneur's friend feels the need to point out that she has a reputation of stirring up/manufacturing controversy. In light of this, the post makes a lot more sense: i.e. 'I'm saying something controversial to stir the pot.'