8 ms·
And this is why I won't trust SaaS that doesn't provide a viable self-host solution (which for practical purposes tends to mean Free software, although I suppos
by e12e 13y ago
And this is why I won't trust SaaS that doesn't provide a viable self-host solution (which for practical purposes tends to mean Free software, although I suppose "binary" only self-contained jars might be a realistic alternative). And also why I can't see myself selling/working on such a solution without providing some form of viable/realistic exit strategy/alternative.
With traditional apps, you run the risk of eg: your laptop crashing/being stolen -- but if you need to work, you can just go and pick up a new laptop, burn an hour or so reinstalling your application(s) -- and hopefully get your work done by the deadline. With a self-hostable SaaS, you can spin up a vps/dedicated server and install, maybe even in less time -- but with "closed" SaaS -- you have no option.
Of course, with all (high-bandwidth) SaaS-solutions, network access becomes a single point of failure.
- rtpg 13y agoI don't have the data to back it up, but (for example) data loss as a whole have probably considerably gone down with transitions to SaaS. Sure you can self-host, but who do you trust more: some guy on your team who has other things to do, or a team that does only that? And a team whose livelyhood depends on uptime/data protection. Here people can't work, but imagine the amount of work if there was a data failure on your machine? Your example (laptop being stolen) means you probably don't even have access to your data.
- x0x0 13y agotime machine in the event of a theft, I can walk into an apple store, purchase an in stock macbook, let time machine recover for ~30 minutes, and get back to work edit: just to be clear, I bet the vast majority of users will, even after this 24+ hours, experience less net downtime. Nonetheless, when I need to hit a deadline, with installed software, I have a viable plan b. The viable plan b here appears to be to grovel before clients whose deadlines you've blown...
- rtpg 13y agogood point, maybe the minimum for backups and the like have gotten so good that Toy Story-style "We have lost everything" situations don't really happen as much anymore. Design tools are definitely a different category than some other enterprise-y software though. At least Evernote still allows me to use it if the servers were down.
- maccard 13y agoI'm sitting in work right now (PC repair shop) and they really really do. We get students coming in the week before thesis deadlines with dead hard drives and no backups of a years work. We get about 2 or 3 people daily coming in asking about replacing a dead hard drive and recovering data.
- redacted 13y agoCheck out Carbon Copy Cloner [1] if you haven't already. It will create a bootable clone of your drive, with deltas and versions and all that good stuff. During fast-moving projects I usually clone daily. In the event of a drive failure I can simply reboot the Mac from the clone as if nothing happened, cloning back to new internal drive (or machine in case of theft). [1] http://www.bombich.com/ http://www.bombich.com/
- damon_c 13y agoI recently spilled a little coffee on a MacBook Air. As the screen flickered its last flicks, I zipped up my .ssh directory and put it on Dropbox. Got off the bus, went to the Apple Store...I Was back to work in the time it took to install homebrew.
- vacri 13y agoThe other thing is that this outage is affecting whole departments. If you lose your laptop, that's one person out. If the SaaS goes down, all users lose out. In a department heavy with photoshop users, it brings that department to a halt.
- twic 13y agoActually, the situation isn't that bad: the outage hasn't affected whole departments, it's affected a whole industry. Which means that your competitors' design departments are just as screwed as yours, so you have nothing to worry about.
- FollowSteph3 13y agoWhat if the SaaS closes? Everyone but the people using non SaaS will be in big trouble, maybe enough to cause bankruptcy if they are very centric as that's all lost too.
- e12e 13y ago> Your example (laptop being stolen) means you probably don't even have access to your data. Err.. what? I confess I've not looked into Adobe too closely, but why would you keep your data (only) on their servers? You'd need backup -- just as you'd have to have backup in place for your personal machines. A typical scenario is a photographer that edits images -- you have maybe a terabyte of data you need access to, and have backed up, in the day-to-day -- and you need access to editing software. Also, you seem to misunderstand -- I'm not saying I won't use or pay for SaaS (be that Software or Storage as-a-service) -- I'm saying I want a viable self-host alternative -- where self-host might mean that I can pay someone -- anyone -- to get things up and running quickly if I need it, and not be limited to whatever support any one vendor is willing/able to provide. Now, personally, I'd probably take self-hostable to mean there's a tested ansible recipe that I can plug into a fresh vps, and be up and running. But not everyone wants to, or knows how to, be their own sysadmin -- but having someone guarantee that, yes, if you need it, this and that company can get you up and running in an hour for $amount. > Here people can't work, but imagine the amount of work if there was a data failure on your machine? Your example (laptop being stolen) means you probably don't even have access to your data. Ok, so lets say we're a small team of 5 non-technical designers, and I've lost my laptop. I have yesterdays backup, and my team mates can work. I'll have to spend an hour installing Photoshop on a new macbook pro I went to the store and got. Maybe an hour restoring backups or whatever. Lets say I loose 4 hours of work, and make up 2 in the evening. So we've lost one quarter of a total of 5 work-days today, due to catastrophic failure. Now consider this outage: the whole team is down, and we've lost (more than) 5 work-days. If there was a viable self-host option, maybe we could've all squeezed in 6 hours of work after throwing dollars at Whomever Inc to set up a fallback solution for us. Also much better than all eggs in one basket.
- Silhouette 13y agoSure you can self-host, but who do you trust more: some guy on your team who has other things to do, or a team that does only that? And a team whose livelyhood depends on uptime/data protection. I think this is the fundamental fallacy that SaaS companies are promoting. Objectively, the answer is quite obvious in my experience: self-hosted systems are much more reliable than external ones, as soon as you have a reasonably competent person to run them and a second person with basic competence who can take over in an emergency if the first person is not around. For a start, one of the most consistently unreliable things in many business environments I've worked in was the Internet connection. Workmen cut through underground cables while they're building the new office block down the road. Someone at your ISP accidentally disconnects you while they're in the cabinet hooking up their new customer. Someone moves in across the street with a badly configured wireless router and screws up the wireless frequency for everyone until the regulatory agency gets someone on-site to track down the problem and make them fix their router a week later. Relying on any Internet-based service for something you need full-time adds one more potential point of failure with a demonstrable risk that it will actually fail from time to time. That is quite separate to the unfavourable track record of many large cloud/SaaS/PaaS companies, including almost all of the big names, compared to running systems in-house. I was genuinely surprised by some of the comments when GitHub was down the other day, where some people were complaining about not even being able to push changes to production because they were so entangled in dependencies on GH and related on-line services like CI systems that they couldn't extricate themselves.
- DenisM 13y agoWe've learned to live with centralized water and electricity and banking, all outside of our control, rather than rely on on-premises solutions. SaaS, too, will win out after a few hiccups.
- na85 13y agoI sure hope not. It's rare for me to encounter SaaS that provides a better service than something I can install and run natively.
- DenisM 13y agoSurely there is something? E.g. Google Maps was a breath of fresh air after MapPoint.
- exodust 13y agoYou know what Google Maps needs? Offline downloadable map functionality. They had that feature, then removed it, then put it back... now I honestly don't know where it's at. Browsing offline maps is a breath of fresh air, it's so much quicker. Obviously you wouldn't download the whole world, only your home city or whatever. But it's lightning fast to zoom and pan around an offline map compared with connecting over mobile bandwidth. Browsing maps in Airplane mode should be possible. It's a map after all, not a website.
- ant_sz 13y agoSomething but not everything is suit for SaaS, not nothing either. I think Adobe CC is an example of useless cloud service. In fact I think the only reason Adobe insist on providing a cloud service is to avoid piracy.
- kybernetyk 13y agoAdobe CC is a sales experiment if you can extract subscription fees from tradition desktop software users. As a user I hope they fail. As a traditional desktop software vendor I hope they succeed.
- stephenr 13y agoOther companies have proven that subscription models work when you get it right. I pay a yearly subscription for my IDE so I can get major updates. If I stop paying the software doesn't stop working. Adobe is just doing what adobe does best - extracting the most amount of money with the worst possible product they can.
- Silhouette 13y agoIt is potentially relevant that Adobe are reportedly stopping selling traditional boxed versions of older CS versions in a few days, leaving CC the only option for new purchasers [but see edit below]. In the announcement, they claimed this was being done earlier than they had originally expected (implying in passing that they always intended to do this) and this was because CC had been so popular with their customers. However, they didn't seem to give any sort of data to back up that claim, which makes me rather skeptical about how much of this is driven by accounting and how much of it is driven by PR. I agree CC is a sales experiment, and as both a user and a software developer it's an interesting one. I do wonder how much of any initial success has been a honeymoon period, though. Another interesting dichotomy was seeing that on the one hand there was a related statement from someone at Adobe about how customers had been worried that they would double their price once everyone is locked in but of course they'd never do that because it would be a betrayal of trust, while on the other hand anyone who signed up on the $30/month plan is about to hit the end of their first year's special offer and go up to the normal $50/month (but this is OK with Adobe because the offer was always advertised as limited up-front). That may all be true and legally above board, but I'm not sure how many people who did the maths at the $30 price point are still going to be as happy in their second year as they were in their first. In other news, our existing installations of boxed CS products cost us nothing extra this month and didn't go down this week, and we're still waiting to meet either the client who we couldn't work with because we didn't have CC or the killer feature that Adobe have rolled out in a CC upgrade over the past year that would have made anything we do significantly more productive. Ironically, there are plenty of ways Adobe could have got more money from us without going the subscription route. There are several features on our wish list that would have justified the cost of a traditional upgrade alone, even with no other changes. However, since Adobe don't seem to be going in any of those directions with CC, we're quite happy to exercise our choice not to pay them for the (worthless, to us) changes they are making instead. Edit: It appears from other sources, including Adobe's own FAQ on their site, that CS6 will still be available to individual customers via download, just not in boxed media. It's the volume licensing programmes for perpetual purchases that are being discontinued on 30 May to push business and government users towards CC. There are some other interesting data points mentioned in this write-up: http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/enterprise/387724/adobe-to-halt-volume-sales-of-cs6-at-end-of-may http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/enterprise/387724/adobe-to-halt-...
- hrktb 13y agoI'm not sure to understand your point. Does it boil down to "single point of failure are bad"? There are alternatives to each of the Adobe products, self hosted and available offline. People going the Creative Cloud route for their daily job are in a situation where the alternative costed too much or doesn't allow them to do their job in a sufficient way, so there was no real viable options from the start. The problem is not really to trust Adobe or not. Adobe doesnt have any track record of great online services, I don't think they have an image of high quality software either, they do some amazing things and bring killer features, but I harldy heard anyone being loyal to Adobe itself. I think this whole discussion would have taken a different turn if it wasn't Adobe but Amazon AWS or Google. When S3 is down, I don't remember seeing more than a few comments in the 'you should have self hosted your data' line. Why is it so different for Adobe ?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- walshemj 13y agoFor professionals working in design there Is no real alternative to Photoshop.
- jon-wood 13y ago> I don't think they have an image of high quality software either, they do some amazing things and bring killer features, but I harldy heard anyone being loyal to Adobe itself. Having worked with designers I'm going to disagree. For most designers Photoshop or Illustrator are the only tools they'll even consider using because they're so much more powerful than the competition. That's changing a little with things like Pixelmator, but even then people have to learn a new workflow after decades of using Photoshop.
- hrktb 13y agoI agree with the power of Photoshop or Illustrator. But do you consider it highly well designed, solid and polished software ? I am not a Photoshop user so my image is from hearsay, feel free to state your opinion. But what I heard was it's bloated, doesn't fully integrate/take advantage of the OS and hardware potential, crashes every once in a while and you'll have nothing to do about it. To make a parrallel with coding tools, I feel it's on the same league as Eclipse. It's the very obvious choice for some application stacks, has tons of feature and it's plenty powerful. But I don't think most people love working with it (at least I don't), there's just no good enough alternative for the thing they want to do.
- patio11 13y agoIt should be noted that "just spin up a VPS/dedicated server" is not a serious competition for most SaaS companies, nor is it a requirement for most people who buy SaaS. Try explaining that process to Office Manager Milly, whose #1 feature request is being able to fax documents to the SaaS app rather than having to upload them. Milly may have heard about Heartbleed recently. She doesn't understand public key cryptography, SSL, servers, configuration files, or the command line. She does understand that all of her information being leaked to bad guys is not optimal. How would you go about advising Milly on what the consequences of Heartbleed are for her self-hosted SaaS product?
- maldusiecle 13y agoNaturally the hypothetical ignorant office manager is going to be a woman. This is ycombinator, after all.
- notwedtm 13y agoUgh, seriously? This is the input to this conversation that you decided was the most important? Try not being so hyper-sensitive to social issues and keeping the conversation on track within the context of the OP.
- nitrogen 13y agoIt should also be noted that sometimes you're not talking to Millie. Self-hosting is a viable option for a lot of people and businesses, even more so with the help of a friendly local CIO-as-a-service consulting company nearby whose rates are competitive with the SaaS+time wasted by non-tech users trying to manage the PCs that access it.
- mamcx 13y agoAnd a way to get the DATA. I'm building a POS app for the invoice. One of the main requirements (self impose) is that the data is local-first and sync with the cloud. THIS point is one of the hardest to implement for me, and I still have not figured how do it well. But still can't release this app without this. I believe that have a exit strategy for the app data is too important (the data is stored in a sqlite database, with decent naming and very simple structure).