11 ms·
Tremor-cancelling spoon for Parkinson's tremors
- fletchowns 13y agoHeard about this on All Things Considered this week: http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2014/05/13/310399325/a-spoon-that-shakes-to-counteract-hand-tremors http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2014/05/13/310399325/a-spoon...
- logicallee 13y agoLet's entertain the notion, prevalent here, that this idea itself (like all ideas themselves) is worth absolutely nothing, and that any one of the teams in the world who have access to gyroscopes, servos, and microchips, should have the right to reproduce this hack at unit cost and drive these guys out of business. Its cost is listed at $295.00[1] and this is their only product. It's huge compared to what the best facilities and teams in the world can produce to the same specifications, relatively unaesthetic as a utensil in its present form as compared to what a better-funded team can produce in a matter of weeks, and is clearly first-generation. They have no brand in the medical space. It is an eating utensil, yet it is not waterproof. It is, however, patented.[2] This single fact allows this company (in its present form) to exist, to have done its research, to have raised its investment, and to bring their prototype in the form we currently see to market, at the price that it is currently listed at. But patents are "wrong" and "stifle innovation". Granted it's pretty obvious that this makes a huge difference in people's lives. So perhaps we should leaven our desire that their margin disappear, with hoping that more teams are somehow magically and irrationally in a position to do the world's R&D before losing their shirts as their margins disappear from under them. Having seen the size of this thing, the fact that it's not waterproof, the lack of an existing trusted brand-name behind the product, and a lack of any distribution except their web site (see their FAQ) shows that there is no way that is the best that any team in the world can build now that they've seen how it's done. Therefore, lacking protection, this team would no longer be competitive in a short number of weeks/months. We can, however, agree that it is good that this has been made. So, how shall we reconcile this? Well, perhaps we should simply hope that funding, such as they have raised, would magically continue to be available even without any any margins that are guaranteed in the results (should they succeed in embodying their claims), which would allow the investors to recoup their investment. In short, we need investors to be crazy enough to keep funding innovations such as this one, while we remove the protections that would justify that craziness. Basically, we would have to hope that investors never catch on. This is crucial for our purposes, as otherwise ideas such as this would not exist. Someone could have had this idea in 1999 or 1989. But without the investment, it might have stayed at the "worth-nothing" idea stage, rather than what we might call the "worth-nothing-but-has-now-actually-beend-developed-and-actually-been-built-and-proven-and-it's-no-longer-a-pipe-dream" worth-nothing stage. Which the rest of us deserve to access for free without investing anything. There is an analogy to be made here with Tesla, who died nearly penniless: his meager earnings had come from his patent royalties. Imagine if we had the ability to rewrite history and take even this away from him, along with the food from his stomach and equipment from his labs, so that Edison and the rest of the world's teams would have full access to all of his inventions, working or impractical, without any protection. Imagine what progress that would have led to. In summary: 1- ideas like this deserve no patent protection 2- teams should prove incredibly speculative techniques such as this for free and with no compensation or protection 3- investors should continue to invest in such ideas forever, even after it becomes abundantly clear that there is no way to recoup the investment in such a fledgling idea.; </sarcasm> Just kidding!! Phew. I hope we can all agree how ridiculous the above position would be. It's great that these guys brought their patented, high-margin product to the world. All this could have been done in 1984 - 40 years ago - if someone had had the 'wortheless' idea then -- and we would all have access to it today. It took a team's phenomenal genius and dedication today to bring this to market, and the whole world will have it soon - unlike any of the Idea Sunday ideas that have no such protection, were never fully developed, and for which the entire program was crapped. Here's to sane patents and to the progress they bring! [1] http://store.liftlabsdesign.com/ http://store.liftlabsdesign.com/ $ 295.00. Note that my estimated margin at this price: (for copycat) 98.64% margins - ex assumed "worthless" idea - assuming a COGS at scale of $4, which is enough for several batteries, gyroscopes, microchips, cases, what have you. If we assume a $20 cost of goods that margin shrinks to 93.22% gross profit, again excluding the idea (which we assume is "worthless") or its development (which we assume the world should have access to for free, now that they've proven it.) [2] http://www.cnet.com/news/smart-spoon-helps-stabilize-parkinsons-tremors/ http://www.cnet.com/news/smart-spoon-helps-stabilize-parkins...
- rosser 13y agoI didn't downvote you despite my almost reflexive tendency to downvote posts bitching about being downvoted. That said, I was strongly inclined to ding you for the sarcasm. Any point you might have been trying to make is obscured by the cloud of superiority and smugness your tone radiates, and, personally, I find that both off-putting and un-constructive. You could most assuredly use this invention as a means of starting a discussion about crap patents — a position with which I probably even agree in this instance — without burying your point beneath your invective.
- logicallee 13y agoThe fact that one of the responses, ronaldx, completely agrees with the point that I put in sarcasm, stating "The problem is that your sarcastic position sounds pretty good to me", shows that while the position seems smug and superior to you, it is actually a reasonable one around here. The sarcastic part literally sounds pretty good to people here, and two posters have expressed agreement with it. And look at the result. We have two very good comments agreeing with the sarcastic part (or denying its premise), and which we can now turn to.
- rosser 13y agoAgain, I'm not saying your position is wrong. I'm saying that your point is buried beneath your sarcasm and your ceaseless series of edits and revisions.
- logicallee 13y agorosser: please bear in mind that while you are saying "I'm not saying your position is wrong", two respondents actually agree with the position taken in the marked "sarcastic part" :) so this certainly identifies an avenue for discussion, even if you do not prefer this way of bringing it up.
- yownie 13y ago
- stevesearer 13y agoMy grandfather has Parkinson's. My dad has slightly noticeable hand tremors - no diagnosis at this point. I haven't read up on the likelihood that I'll get it, but I assume that I'm at high risk. That said, this looks pretty neat and seems like basically a spoon version of Canon AF lenses. Will definitely look into these for my grandpa :)
- doktrin 13y agoLikewise, my grandfather most likely had Parkinson's towards the end of his life. My father has had essential / familial tremor for 3 decades or so. I did at one point did check out my genetic risk factors as determined by 23 and Me, back when they provided trait mapping services. Turns out I have a higher than average lifetime risk. It's all ugly shit. Even essential tremor is non-trivial. I'm glad innovations of all kinds are being made in this field.
- lyagusha 13y agoNo shit. ET is set off by everything - exercise, alcohol, caffeine, lack of sleep, etc. In a perverse way it forces you to stop addictions to stimulants, otherwise you can't help but look 50 years older in front of friends and family because your fingers shake nonstop.
- srean 13y agoI think some will remember the news story that Sergey Brin has the Parkinson's mutation. He is keen to fund technologies that makes progress in this field. That would indeed be welcome. Diagnosing Parkinson's with confidence with a specific authoritative test is no easy task. For my dad, the doctors cannot decide if it is essential tremor or Parkinson's. I recall a post on HN which showed that our vocal signals have enough information to help wwith such diagnosis. Voice as carried by phone's now dont have the spectral resolution for this. However it might have enough bandwidth if voice is coded for that purpose. Seems like a worthy problem to take a stab at. I think the corresponding NPR story https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7752627 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7752627 was posted a few days ago but did not make the front page. So I am glad this made it.
- flyfishcxy 13y agothank
- srean 13y agoNow what did I do ?
- darkmighty 13y agoThis video left a deep impression on me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBh2LxTW0s0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBh2LxTW0s0 I didn't realize how this sort of tech can be so life changing (or life giving)
- sirdogealot 13y agoThat video is incredible to watch. It is so amazing that I am slightly worried that it might be faked. I really hope that this technology becomes an economically-viable and long-term means of helping parkinson's tremors.
- caycep 13y agoThis is interesting, but IMHO, will not be as useful in most cases of Parkinson's disease. 1) Parkinsonian tremor is typically at rest or with distraction. When you actually engage in purposeful action, such as using a spoon, the tremor usually dampens or goes away. 2) The main problem in Parkinson's is actually "bradykinesia" or slowness of movement. A more accurate term, in my opinion, is slowness of motor planning, that is, the brain systems cannot process the information require to, and then generate, a plan of movement for the limbs fast enough. The spoon won't fix that. 3) Parkinsonian and other forms of tremor do have relatively safe and effective treatments in medications or deep brain stimulation implantation. My thoughts are - this spoon, if it works and isn't a mechanical nightmare, would be useful in a limited subset of cases where the tremor resembles another condition known as essential tremor, where the tremor instead is an intention or action tremor, where purposeful activity amplifies the tremor. Even so, these would only be in those patients who cannot get deep brain stimulation surgery for some reason. The reason being that DBS, while brain surgery, once done, is the more elegant solution. I.e. your tremor goes away, rather than requiring a superficial "hack" like this spoon.
- RhysU 13y agoMy father being an ET sufferer who has had a useless DBS device implanted that he now leaves disabled at all times, I concur with your assessment.
- caycep 13y agoI have seen the dark side to some of this. I think a lot of hospitals are rushing into implants without a lot of experience, and are either mis-implanting them or not selecting the candidates appropriately. IT's similar to another procedure like carotid endarterectomy in that it's very surgeon-dependent; you don't want it done by someone who does less than 25-30 cases a year.
- RhysU 13y agoMost frustrating part for my father was the doctor claiming a historical 95% success rate and then never being willing to admit that my father'd drawn the lot of the 5%.
- caublestone 13y agoMy brother has downsyndrome and struggles with muscle control. When he eats he tremors quite a bit losing food on his plate forcing him to take a desperate eat fast approach to his meals. He has gone through quite a bit of muscle therapy to help. Needless to say, I will be buying this for him and can't wait to see what other types of people find an improvement in their lives with this product.
- 97s 13y agoThings like this are just a total blessing to people who need them and its awesome to see affordable technology like this taking place for people who can't even take part in the one of the most important functions of life. A lot of people are talking about if there is a big enough market/etc, we should probably assume the creator only wants to cover his cost since this invention was probably created by people who had family suffering from such a thing. Any profits would probably make the inventor(s) delighted.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bigmattystyles 13y agoThis sort of filtering should also be put in a mouse driver
- cshimmin 13y agoApparently user gottebp did just that: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7753993 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7753993
- logicallee 13y agoI made a point about the importance of patents for this invention, but it is better to receive it straight from the source: http://imgur.com/Q99L8V3 http://imgur.com/Q99L8V3 (the bottom just quotes my letter, already visible) This product and company would not exist without patents on what amounts to an idea.
- throwawaytremor 13y agoHuh? All your e-mail exchange proves is that he believed, at one point, patents were a good idea. In fact, it doesn't even prove that: If a stranger approached me about my company's patents, you can bet I'd smile and nod say, "Yes, they're important", like he did -- regardless of what I actually believe. Establishing a written record of anything else sounds like a great way to throw that investment -- valuable or not -- in the trash. Especially when the remark is made to someone like you who then turns around and posts it to the public! As someone who both holds several patents and has actually seen this device in person, I think you're trying way too hard to craft your point. (throwaway because my anti-procrast is on, oh well)
- logicallee 13y agoOf course the email isn't meant to prove anything, I was just curious how long his development time took. I only asked about the length of time of development, nothing else, he volunteered the extra information, which is that he would not have been able to raise any money without them (including what sounds like a research grant) and that it was crucial to getting to market at all (or whatever he said). As it's all in the past, I don't see that this would help his patent case today in any way. ("Please uphold the patent, because I really needed it back when it was just an idea" doesn't seem a convincing reason to uphold a patent today, as they are now on the market.) So I read the information he volunteered as stemming from his experience and perspective, rather than his interests. I also see projects fail completely every day which could have succeeded with a minimum level of patent protection on their narrow inventions. So there may be a built-in survival bias, and you will not necessarily hear about these projects, which fail to raise even a preseed research grant "round" to complete development, but are abandoned isntead. Page Rank was also patented by Larry Page. In stark contrast to the view presented on Hacker News, ideas are extremely worthwhile and patents are one of the most important tools any entrepreneur has for getting to market with real innovation, which is unsure and costly, and requires people to buy in at a pre-revenue stage. The mechanism patents due this via is a full monopoly for a limited time. We can see this in the price set on this invention (that we're discussing), which is a monopoly price and will be upheld due to the fact that competitors are not allowed in the same space. In countries that do not acknowledge these patents, a $79 equivalent could appear shortly. It can even be objectively better. Nevertheless, this is the price we pay for this invention to exist at all, and but for the patent system this invention would not exist at all. (In reality.)
- gottebp 13y agoI'm a little late commenting, but I developed a Windows app [1] that does exactly this for the mouse. It basically applies some fancy FIR filters to the x and y deltas. [1] www.steadymouse.com
- gone35 13y agoWonderful; like OS X's "Slow Keys" but for the mouse pointer instead. This should be included as a built-in accessibility option in every operating system. Have you thought about open-sourcing your implementation to encourage others to take a jab at it and port it to other platforms?
- gottebp 13y agoHey, thanks! I'd also love to see it built in to operating systems someday. It'd be much cleaner and easier to implement there as well. When I wrote steadymouse I had two choices: 1) Implement a driver (which is overkill if you ask me) or 2) Use a mouse hook in a very convoluted way (As is, the low level mouse hook doesn't easily let you "modify and pass on" mouse data). Applying DSP math to the mouse would be much easier within the OS. As for open sourcing the project, I've considered it and may eventually go that route. I'd like to clean it up first though and have the time to stay a part of the active development...maybe it's just hard for me to let go.
- praneshp 13y agoThanks for the product, and thanks for considering to make it opensource. If you decide to go that route and have issues deciding what license to use, etc, please let me know, I can put you in touch with an expert in licensing, etc who can help you for free. And contribute code, ofc.
- gottebp 13y agoWow, I really appreciate that! /I must admit, the community here really impresses me with comments like this.
- rubyn00bie 13y agoHoly crap was I confused for a minute, I misread the title as "Tremor-canceling spoon for Pakistan's tremors." I was just thinking "there must be A LOT of earthquakes in Pakistan." ... Anyway this is a great invention, even if it's not intended to be used during earthquakes ;-)
- jmadsen 13y agoThis is wonderful! I have to wonder - why is it that it took so long to come up with such a simple idea for such an obvious problem? I'd like to blame it on the "get rich, web app startup" mentality, but really, that's a fairly recent thing. Perhaps this is a harder problem than it seems? Or is it true that all our new inventors are chasing riches?
- atrus 13y agoMany things are obvious once you've seen them done.
- jmadsen 13y agoI realize that, and know my comment sounds naive - but. We have people who study earthquakes, and gyroscopes, and nerve disorders. And we have the internet so they can all easily share ideas & research. Is this idea REALLY so "un-obvious"?
- cshimmin 13y agoDo we have people who study all three?
- TeMPOraL 13y agoIt is, in my opinion, an obvious solution. Or at least it should be for anyone who took control theory classes (or learned it by itself). So I guess is that a/ people who know engineering don't know what medical problems are, and (more likely) b/ there's a long, long way from an idea to working product.
- logicallee 13y agoDon't mean to put too fine a point on it, but could you give me any example of a consumer solution throughout history that you would not class as obvious? I'm wondering what your standards are.
- maddisc2 13y agoWell done, Really great work!
- jablan 13y agoI wonder why wouldn't be possible to use some kind of passive method for tremor cancellation, like a miniature version of a steadicam. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steadicam http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steadicam
- brianbreslin 13y agoMy grandfather had parkinsons and this would have been a true blessing to him. I watched in frustration many times as he had a hard time doing tasks like this. Seeing this kind of GOOD being invented makes me happy. This made my day.
- Jim_Neath 13y agoAs a sufferer of early onset parkinson's, it's great to see products like this being developed. Hats off.
- asgard1024 13y agoI like the idea, but I think the spoon is a bit shallow. It would be hard to eat soup with it.
- purephase 13y agoThere's multiple attachments for the spoon. One of them might be a larger spoon.
- enjo 13y agoI would like to "sponsor" a few of these for folks. Does anyone know of a resource, non-profit, or...something that can help facilitate that?
- toomuchtodo 13y agoTheir homepage says they match dollar for dollar for those in need. Get in touch with them.