4 ms·

I take 1800mg of DHA a day and on those days my joins don't hurt. I do martial arts and that takes a toll on my knees but when i take fish oil they feel better.

by knodi 12y ago

I take 1800mg of DHA a day and on those days my joins don't hurt. I do martial arts and that takes a toll on my knees but when i take fish oil they feel better. Placebo? Maybe, but it works for me.

seanmcdirmid 12y ago
Placebos work in general as long as the problems are psychological. The whole field Chinese Medicine depends on that.
- DanBC 12y ago
  Be cautious with the phrase "psychological problems". Placebo seems to work well for pain, and peoe will get very angry if you describe the pain they feel as a psychological problem.
- spacehome 12y ago
  Not really. The placebo effect is real and strong and works even on some maladies that aren't psychosomatic.
- Semaphor 12y ago
  > Placebos work in general as long as the problems are psychological. There was a study [0] about the placebo effect in heart failure patients: "In a 1999 Swedish Study, doctors implanted an active pacemaker into 40 heart failure patients. Another 40 patients underwent the same surgery, believing they were receiving active pacemakers. But their pacemakers were never turned on: they were, in essence, placebo pacemakers." - [1] Now as a disclaimer, I did not complete read or understand this study nor do I know if there are counter studies, but it's my favorite bit of information about the placebo effect. [0] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10190407 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10190407 [1] http://blog.placeboeffect.com/reverse-heart-disease/ http://blog.placeboeffect.com/reverse-heart-disease/ (laymen conclusion)
- epo 12y ago
  But wishful thinking is a powerful influence, it triggers all sorts of internal processes which may indeed be more powerful and beneficial than medicine. Similarly, religion is nothing more than placebo, but that has influenced (and perhaps benefited) mankind since forever.
guruz 12y ago
Seth Roberts would agree. http://blog.sethroberts.net/ http://blog.sethroberts.net/ Look for his postings on Omega3, Flaxseed oil etc.
cincinnatus 12y ago
I discovered by accident that it reduced my wrist pain. I wasn't looking for that benefit so I'd say not placebo effect.

by knodi 12y ago

I take 1800mg of DHA a day and on those days my joins don't hurt. I do martial arts and that takes a toll on my knees but when i take fish oil they feel better. Placebo? Maybe, but it works for me.

seanmcdirmid 12y ago

Placebos work in general as long as the problems are psychological. The whole field Chinese Medicine depends on that.

DanBC 12y ago
Be cautious with the phrase "psychological problems". Placebo seems to work well for pain, and peoe will get very angry if you describe the pain they feel as a psychological problem.
spacehome 12y ago
Not really. The placebo effect is real and strong and works even on some maladies that aren't psychosomatic.
Semaphor 12y ago
> Placebos work in general as long as the problems are psychological. There was a study [0] about the placebo effect in heart failure patients: "In a 1999 Swedish Study, doctors implanted an active pacemaker into 40 heart failure patients. Another 40 patients underwent the same surgery, believing they were receiving active pacemakers. But their pacemakers were never turned on: they were, in essence, placebo pacemakers." - [1] Now as a disclaimer, I did not complete read or understand this study nor do I know if there are counter studies, but it's my favorite bit of information about the placebo effect. [0] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10190407 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10190407 [1] http://blog.placeboeffect.com/reverse-heart-disease/ http://blog.placeboeffect.com/reverse-heart-disease/ (laymen conclusion)
epo 12y ago
But wishful thinking is a powerful influence, it triggers all sorts of internal processes which may indeed be more powerful and beneficial than medicine. Similarly, religion is nothing more than placebo, but that has influenced (and perhaps benefited) mankind since forever.

guruz 12y ago

Seth Roberts would agree. http://blog.sethroberts.net/ http://blog.sethroberts.net/ Look for his postings on Omega3, Flaxseed oil etc.

cincinnatus 12y ago

I discovered by accident that it reduced my wrist pain. I wasn't looking for that benefit so I'd say not placebo effect.