4 ms·
Stack Exchange owns the question & answer niche? I don't hardly think so. Yahoo Answers, as bad as it is, is massive, and shows up throughout Google's top resul
by adventured 13y ago
Stack Exchange owns the question & answer niche? I don't hardly think so. Yahoo Answers, as bad as it is, is massive, and shows up throughout Google's top results; ditto answers.com; and Quora is a top 500 site.
Stack has seven sites getting at least 100,000 visits per day. One is a break out homerun (Stack Overflow obviously), and it drastically dwarfs the other sites. All but a few of their top 20+ sites are strictly technology focused, and the others are geek friendly (math and video games), so they cross over conveniently.
Most of their network is flailing. Photography is 3 years old and gets a whopping seven questions per day - that's what most of their network looks like.
Stack doesn't even remotely own the Q&A category. They own one piece of it, and will never own anything more than that, because they can't translate success in technical Q&A to other categories well. You can beat StackExchange at any given of their smaller niche sites, because they can't do them as well as someone that is dedicated to just that niche - the same reason Quora et al can't compete with Stack Overflow.
- meritt 13y agoFair points. Quora though seems pretty well aimed at the same subcategories which Stack Exchange excels.
- collyw 13y agoTo me Quora excels at the areas where Stack Exchange fails miserably. Intelligent discussion over a subject (rather than "closed as not constructive").
- codinghorror 13y agoSure -- you're right that the SE engine is definitely only good at specific things (namely, fact/data/science based questions), but it is arguably the best in the world at those particular things. What is the Quora engine the best in the world at? I'd look at growth, too. Even the less popular SE sites grow at very respectable rates. How much is Quora growing?
- namenotrequired 13y agoSince neither his comment nor his profile mention it, I'll mention here for those unaware that this guy is co-founder of Stack Exchange.
- tyang 13y agoIf true, thanks for disclosing. Amazed commenter failed to disclose. Transparency and conflicts, people!
- FajitaNachos 13y agoI would imagine most people reading HN have read at least one blog post on his site, if not many more. It's not that amazing he didn't disclose it in my opinion. I agree it could be mentioned in his profile though, just for the curious.
- gojomo 13y agoIf that bugs you, think a bit about how the conflicts of upvoters/downvoters are totally obscured.
- gus_massa 13y agoWell, he resigned from S.O. two years ago (http://blog.codinghorror.com/farewell-stack-exchange/ http://blog.codinghorror.com/farewell-stack-exchange/ ) and most of the users here know that the founders of S.O. were codinghorror and spolsky.
- vishnugupta 13y ago"coddinghorror" gives it away though :-)
- namenotrequired 13y agoOnly to those who already knew. Edit for clarity in case I was misunderstood
- cookiecaper 13y agoConsider that Quora is almost exactly like Yahoo! Answers, except that it has a more professional color scheme.
- collyw 13y agoThe quality of the answers is way higher. I don't know what to attribute that to.