2 ms·
For example, if an honest blockchain solved a problem of great importance to me (value = x) and even by putting a small amount of work (value < x) into mining t
by wmf 13y ago
For example, if an honest blockchain solved a problem of great importance to me (value = x) and even by putting a small amount of work (value < x) into mining the blockchain I could protect myself (say withdraw from action during double action attacks) then you can create a system where many people are mining, making the entire blockchain more secure each while guarding their own interests.
Wouldn't a rational actor free ride instead of mining? Also, the total hash rate needs to be high enough to prevent 51% attacks, so there's no guarantee that your cost of mining would be smaller than your benefit. A blockchain that doesn't pay miners seems to have an equilibrium where trolls 51% it into oblivion (as has already happened with some scamcoins AFAIK).
- 3pt14159 13y agoThe 51% attack isn't a global problem, just a bitcoin problem due to it being a currency. There are other blockchain uses that do not suffer from it.
- thefreeman 13y agoHow so? With 51% of hashing power you can essentially rewrite the block chain to say whatever you want. What possible use could you have for a block chain that is not accurate and controlled by a single entity?
- Dylan16807 13y agoNo you can't. With 51% hashing power you can exclude/remove transactions at will, and nothing more. You cannot forge transactions.
- lostsock 13y agoActually yes you can. If you have > 51% hashing power for a long period of time then you could theoretically choose an arbitrary block some time in the past (the further back you go the more difficult and time consuming it will be) and begin mining from that block. Including (or making up) whatever transactions you want as you go. Eventually you will have a longer chain than the "main" block and unless manual intervention is made you will orphan all of the other blocks and be able to rewrite history.
- eridius 13y agoDylan16807 is correct. You can't forge transactions. You can create an alternative history, but each transaction still requires holding the necessary private key to sign the transaction. If you're trying to make up new transactions out of whole cloth, you can only do so if they're transactions that you could have otherwise legitimately created. What the 51% attack lets you do is remove transactions, which lets you double-spend. And of course there may be other benefits too. For example, if someone is using the blockchain for purposes other than sending money to people (e.g. notarizing a document, proxy transactions that represent movement of physical goods, etc) then removing transactions may be beneficial without double-spending.
- lostsock 13y agoYou (and Dylan) are spot on, thanks for taking the time to correct me.