4 ms·
Apparently LIDAR does work in rain albeit with degradation in it's effectiveness. Regardless I wasn't aware of this before. Why would Google chose this technol
by threeseed 13y ago
Apparently LIDAR does work in rain albeit with degradation in it's effectiveness.
Regardless I wasn't aware of this before. Why would Google chose this technology ? It's bizarre.
- ghaff 13y agoFor Google, sensor technology is pretty much an implementation detail at this point. I imagine their interest is much more in vetting out the basic concept and understanding where the gaps are than it is on pushing toward getting a near- to mid-term product on the roads. On the other hand, I imagine that auto manufacturers are much more interested in getting to viable product--whether it's improved assistive driving features (collision avoidance, speed matching, etc.) or, in the somewhat longer term, autonomy for some limited range of conditions. Hence, for example, Volvo's involvement of government as well.
- glenra 13y agoA car that only reliably self-drives in good weather conditions is still (a) quite a hard problem, (b) almost certainly a commercially viable product on its own (c) a pretty good start on a car that reliably self-drives in any weather.
- aianus 13y agoI'm not sure about (b) since you'd need to buy two cars unless your boss will accept "but it was raining" as an excuse not to show up for work.
- ceejayoz 13y agoA self-driving car hardly has to be only self-driving.
- aianus 13y agoYou're right of course, I feel silly now. It wouldn't be as cool, though. I was imagining something like a limo without the driver compartment.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoEventually for cities like Beijing to optimize congested transportation infrastructure, it would have to be.
- ceejayoz 13y agoSure, but that's not going to happen until the sensors can work in the rain (and smog).
- jareds 13y agoAs someone who is blind I'd buy a car if it could drive me where I need to go 75% of the time. This assumes that it weather forcasts would be accurate enough to let me know the car could get me to the grocery store and dry cleaner any time during the current day rather than leaving me stranded at my destination unable to get back home.
- glenra 13y agoI have two use cases in mind: (1) Delivery-bot. A car that drives itself to drop off a package and only delivers on non-rainy days. (if you need delivery on a rainy day, you pay extra for a person-driven delivery service. Otherwise the package waits at the warehouse) (2) Transport option for people who can't or shouldn't drive themselves - too old, too blind, too young, or physically impaired. The self-driving car takes them where they need to go when weather permits, otherwise they have to call a cab or van service as a backup option. (Much of California only has a couple weeks of rain per year.)
- warbastard 13y agoWhile in England, the delivery bots would work 2 weeks a year.
- nabla9 13y agoThere is nothing else that gets the accuracy Google needs. Sensors are currently unsolved problem. Multi wavelength radars don't yet have the accuracy and they don't work well with nonmetallic objects (There is limit of how much radar can use power (safely) and how expensive it can be. What works for F-22 don't work for Google) Google is not planning to monetize this technology anytime soon, despite the hype. The difference between crude human/animal intelligence and top notch AI-research is still huge. If people would need the accuracy that Google's car needs to move reliably and do split second decisions, we could never leave our house. We operate using just two cameras and accelerometers. The clear picture and spatial recognition is done using top notch heuristics in the unconscious. With self driving car it's the opposite. They need millions of very accurate distance measurements per second to drive. Driving like Google car does with cameras only is not happening yet.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 13y ago> They needs millions of very accurate distance measurements per second to drive. I was with you up to there.
- nabla9 13y agoLIDAR Google uses takes more than a million measurements per second and has ~11 cm resolution.
- jacquesm 13y agoRight, my camera takes more than a million measurements in 1/100th of a second and has a spatial resolution comparable to that or better depending on the distance. 'A million measurements' sounds really impressive but it does not have much to do with anything. What's a measurement? A single distance measurement in front of the car? Ok, at what opening angle, how many returns, how many pulses / second and so on. As it stands that's just a 'big number' but those are not impressive at all without context.