5 ms·
Twitter is not dying. It’s on the cusp of getting much bigger
- eddanger 13y agoSo now is a good time to invest... got it.
- diego 13y agoThere's an unusual amount of bullish articles about Twitter's stock these days, and one must wonder if it's related to the post-IPO lockup expiration coming up next week. http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2014/05/01/the-end-of-the-twitter-stock-lock-up-isnt-a-good-reason-to-sell-twitter-stock-now/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2014/05/01/the-end-o...
- fizx 13y agoThe quarterly earnings call just happened, TWTR got roasted, and we all love contrarian articles.
- bhouston 13y agoThese things do not just happen, there is usually a good PR firm behind these types of coincidences, probably pitching it as "everyone loves contrarian articles and don't I have a good one for you."
- hendzen 13y agoPump before you dump, right?
- mathattack 13y agoI think in a month we'll have a better view of Twitter's worth, less impacted by PR and market technicals like lockup.
- caseyf7 13y agoOk, so Twitter should be valued as a media platform instead of as a social network. Wall Street is still going to let out a collective ugh oh when they realize they gave an RSS platform a $22 Billion valuation.
- adventured 13y agoRecently a $40 billion valuation. It was trading at a mere 60 times sales or so.
- aaronbrethorst 13y agoI'm inclined to agree. I originally planned to not invest in Twitter until the lockup expiration next week, but tossed in a bit of money in November of last year. My investment increased by about 50% until a couple weeks ago when it ended up in negative territory. On the off chance that Twitter's last quarterly earnings ended up being awesome, I bought another chunk of stock on the afternoon before they reported. It immediately went down 10%, and so I bought some more. I'm now excitedly looking forward to getting to triple(?) down on my investment with the lockup expiration on the 6th. Call Twitter a social network, or whatever you feel like. I think it's essentially part of the fabric of the Internet today, and far less replaceable than something like Facebook, despite the significantly smaller user base. I'm bullish—and very long—on TWTR.
- gfodor 13y agoI think I disagree. Twitter's economic moat seems very narrow. From a user's perspective it's just a pub/sub messaging system. Facebook has a much deeper set of features. It feels very much like Twitter can be replaced by a decentralized, open alternative if executed well. If Twitter's ads start to get annoying enough, or the network itself becomes full of trash, people will be ready for an alternative at some point. (And in general, these types of networked messaging services fall in and out of favor every 5-7 years or so it seems.) I don't think the same holds true for Facebook (which has been tried before and failed.) But I look at something like the bitcoin blockchain and wonder if that concept is just a few conceptual degrees from something that could replace the twitter stream. In 5-10 years will we be using twitter or will all devices just have a way to broadcast out into the ether, with a 'distributed ledger' of messages maintained by agents on the network? I'm almost certain there is someone tooling away on this right now, the question is will they be able to make it accessible and easy to migrate onto from twitter.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- wellboy 13y agoVery unlikely to happen. Traction is such a huge factor why people use social networks that outweighs all the features such as ad-free or better usability by the amount of 10 probably. Twitter needs to f up big time to lose its current popularity.
- brc 13y agoI have read about 3 articles in the last few days which say the complete opposite. Including a 'Eulogy for Twitter'. I don't know who is right. I know I find Twitter has become a mess lately, with fewer people putting original thought into it, and more people using it as a 'I can yell louder than you' platform. I think considered thought, breaking news and wry humor is the only suitable content for twitter. But that's just me.
- seren 13y agoIt seems the crux of the article's argument is that Twitter is primarily a great tool for influential people to reach a wide audience. It is a sound argument. However, what will happen if these key people jump to the next big thing ? It seems like a pretty fragile strategy for the long term.
- rhizome 13y agoI believe a lot of the major players these days to be pretty fragile. All it takes is a good privacy policy and a "sign in with Twitter" button to move a person's environment over. Sure, you lose your messaging history, but I doubt that's a dealbreaker for a lot of people. All it takes is a crappy enough experience to motivate people to pick another corner to hang out and gab.
- bsder 13y agoWell, if the float is only 70 million out of 600 million available, the lock expiration is likely to dramatically increase the float. Since it doesn't look like Twitter has pent up buyers demand, that's likely to wallop the stock. Or, if you are feeling uncharitable, what better way to make all your employees hold onto their stock than to crash its price right before they can cash out their options (presumably a lot of that 600 million shares had to be allocated to service options).
- colinbartlett 13y agoWait, you can't really "make" someone hold onto their stock, can you? Like have a condition for continued employment be don't sell? I'm guessing it will just be market forces: a bunch of twenty- and thirty-somethings with credit card debt or an eye on Tesla deciding weather to cash in those pieces of paper.
- al2o3cr 13y agoI'm pretty sure having the stock priced lower than the strike price for the options would pretty effectively "make" people hold onto their stock. Related: I'll sell you this dollar for $2.50. ;)
- bsder 13y agoYou assume those people have stock. That is very unlikely to be true. Most of those people have stock options. Very different. An option means that I can buy a share of stock at some guaranteed price (strike price). So, I would actually have to cough up the money to buy the share. Only after that, do I now own a share of stock that I can transact as such. If the strike price is above what the stock currently sells for, I probably do not want to exercise the option. If the strike price is close to the option price, I probably would rather hang on to the option until the price rises some more. The option doesn't cost anything until I exercise it (or lose it, most options have a time limit) so I mitigate risk by waiting. So, unless the stock price is above the option strike price+some margin, people won't transact. My uncharitable speculation was: What better way to keep everybody from flooding the market with Twitter shares than to drive the price down enough to keep people from wanting to cash out their current options. To be fair, the depression in Twitter is probably just everybody getting a shock that "Gee, Internet companies can actually saturate a market and run out of growth." Amazon got zapped recently (imagine, adding sales tax to their prices dropped their sales). Google and Apple are showing some signs of deceleration (ad revenue is slipping because smartphones have saturated all markets with real money--so now everybody is actually chasing a competitor's customer rather than bringing in new users).
- therealarmen 13y agoFrom what I can tell, Instagram is eating Twitter's lunch: http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=instagram%2C%20twitter http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=instagram%2C%20twitte...
- marincounty 13y agoread 9780132302340 before investing.
- mapleoin 13y agoWhat are you, a robot? http://www.isbnsearch.org/isbn/9780132302340 http://www.isbnsearch.org/isbn/9780132302340
- snorkel 13y agoSeems like the article is wrestling with the semantics of "active user" and wants to focus on counting passive users instead. Either way, the audience size is the audience size, and growth generally means growth in audience size.
- mrweasel 13y agoIt's always weird to read article like this. The focus is always on "number of users" and stock prices, but rarely are we told is a company is making money. From the article: "direct timeline views by logged-in users are the form of engagement that Twitter can most readily turn into money." To me that seems to be the problem, Twitter can't readily turn logged-in users in to money. Just like with Facebook is pretty hard to tell how Twitter is suppose to make a decent profit.
- adventured 13y agoNot sure where Facebook fits in there. They're earning a massive profit, and a roughly 25% net income margin. Have you seen their latest quarterlies? Revenue was $2.50 billion, up 72% vs Q1 2013. GAAP income from operations was $1.08 billion, up 188% compared to $373 million in the first quarter of 2013. GAAP operating margin was 43% for the first quarter of 2014, compared to 26% in the first quarter of 2013. GAAP net income was $642 million, up 193% compared to $219 million for the first quarter of 2013. I'm skeptical Twitter can replicate Facebook's results due to the difference in the engagement, but it was never hard to imagine Facebook monetizing a billion highly active users via ads (just on volume alone).
- mrweasel 13y agoI hadn't actually seen Facebooks numbers, but that impressive. You're right, they don't fit in then :-)
- bsder 13y agoMuch like Google, Facebook has been squeezing the advertisers rather than generating more/better impressions. Revenue from advertising numbers for the endpoints (company with product to end consumer) are down across the industry, and everybody is trying to hide it. Once it becomes general knowledge, the advertising spend is going to drop and take the numbers from both Google and Facebook with it. From my personal experience: I always run AdBlock/NoScript. I am APPALLED by web surfing when I don't have those. If I'm stuck on an iPad or my Galaxy, I want to hurl the pad across the room after 15 minutes. I have uninstalled apps just because the advertising was so intrusive (to be fair--those app developers don't want me either--I'm not the fish that will make their revenue). So, now, I absolutely will not use web browsers on phones/pads unless I'm desperate (at which point ads will actively piss me off instead of get me to buy). Good job, advertisers. You've now ensured that you absolutely cannot reach me.
- aspidistra 13y ago> Don’t be surprised to see Twitter become more YouTube-like, turning its home page into a real-time news platform accessible to anyone, whether they’re logged in or not. I'm sure the home page (i.e. twitter.com) was like this at one point. There was a search box, a list of top tweets, some featured accounts, and a (scrolling?) list of top and trending hashtags for the region you were viewing the page from. edit - Wayback Machine capture of what I mean, from Nov 2010: https://web.archive.org/web/20101102183624/http://twitter.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20101102183624/http://twitter.co...
- Freestyler_3 13y agoA media platform without any potential audience is as usefull as a big paper add in a newspaper that never got published, but a few collectors got their hands on it.
- antidaily 13y agoFinances and stock prices aside, I can't imagine what would replace it. At least for me.
- jpswade 13y agoWhen someone explicitly says something is not dying, it makes me think it probably is...
- danielweber 13y agoSeparate the platform from the business. The platform will continue on. The business is in great doubt.
- jeffmanu 13y agoThe one reason I think Twitter will be valuable for a while is that there whole concept of getting your news in less than 200 characters will always be more appealing than many of the other options available. The future will center around focus.