3 ms·
Is it true that the government doesn't allow them to operate? My understanding is that, if these companies were to operate within China's laws and regulations,
by rahimnathwani 13y ago
Is it true that the government doesn't allow them to operate? My understanding is that, if these companies were to operate within China's laws and regulations, particularly as they relate to censorship of user-generated content, they would be allowed to operate.
Sina (a 'Chinese' internet company) was recently the target of regulatory action (suspension of a key licence) because they fell foul of those censorship laws. Action isn't targeted solely at non-Chinese companies. However, non-Chinese companies are less likely to want to comply (either due to the cost/complexity of doing so, or because to do so would be at odds with their core mission).
As an example of a company with a different approach, look at LinkedIn, which recently launched a Chinese interface to target mainland Chinese users.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoThe government doesn't acknowledge that the services are actually blocked in China. If you ask your ISP why Facebook isn't available, they'll tell you "it must be Facebook's fault." The government hasn't declared them illegal, so understanding how to make them "legal" is quite impossible. The government selectively cracksdown on Internet companies when it wants to make a point, and turns blind eyes on others, arbitrarily, porn is quite common in the China market and very available...and even necessary for these companies to make a profit. They just choose one to slap on the wrists occasionally to make sure they don't get out of control. In contrast, you'll find less porn on Facebook, G+, and YouTube then you will on RenRen, YouKu, Sina, and so on. Heck, WeChat is well known as the hookup app (so my wife won't let me go near it). But then this is similar to how prostitution is ubiquitous in the PRC vs. how it is very much underground in the US. How would a legalistic American company operate in such an environment? China is not yet very much governed by rule of (impartial, fairly applied) law, so it is just impossible to do much without being able to live in the grayness (as most Chinese internet companies are able to do!).
- jackvalentine 13y ago> WeChat is well known as the hookup app Hah what? This is the first time I've heard this, so I asked a male, mainland chinese friend, using Wechat itself. His reply: "Ew nope,kinda of.but I think all the social media tool has this function of hookup it really depends on the intention of users" It's pretty much the default messaging tool for my social group in China. Married people, university students, even a mid-50s government official. If you're not on Wechat you're missing out!
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoDepends on the area (wechat has geo broadcast features); in Beijing's sanlitun it is mostly guys and girls looking for fun. Also a lot of even educated professionals don't realize what is going on around them. There is a lot of cognitive dissonance as well as successful propaganda ("these western problems can't happen here") going around, but entire huge subcultures that are out of control (like the mid-50s government official with 5 mistresses).
- jackvalentine 13y agoI think you're overselling it as a hookup app, I presume you're referring to the 摇一摇 feature? In any case, it's a texting-first hookup-distant-third sort of thing. Like my contact said, it depends on the intent of the user. I'm so curious why your wife is so suspicious! If I was going to point out a Chinese app for basically hookups and nothing else, it'd be 陌陌。That thing is pure, 100% Tinder/Grindr.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoFair enough. My wife won't let me go near WeChat even if she uses it herself (I'm happy to oblige, I'm not much into chatting). Some of my expat colleagues on the other hand...
- rahimnathwani 13y agoI always thought 陌陌 was only a hookup app, but was recently told that it started as a way to connect people with common interests (e.g. I could use it to find nearby python users or nearby HN users.) I'm scared to install it!
- rahimnathwani 13y agoI think most of the people using the geo feature are looking to flirt or hook up. However, even in Sanlitun, I would imagine most people are using it for the same purposes elsewhere: 1. Checking where a group of friends is meeting or telling them they'll be a few mins late. 2. Sending groups of friends photos they've just taken of themselves and/or food. 3. Ordering taxis, which they will later pay for using the wechat payment feature, as that way both the passenger and taxi driver get a small subsidy from Tencent.