7 ms·
S.F. ballot measure would severely limit short-term rentals
- dvcc 13y agoI still think it is crazy that Airbnb has an evaluation of $10 Billion, when in its most active markets it is against the law. If the penalties come to pass, which they probably won't, I wonder how it will actually affect usage.
- scythe 13y agoThe investors who are valuing AirBnB so highly are the same people with access to lobbyists and the sort of money that talks loud enough for government officials to hear. I doubt they'd be investing so heavily if they didn't believe they could game the system (for better or for worse).
- truelson 13y agoYou're giving VCs and institutional investors way too much credit. The amount of educated people who buy things based largely on the fact they are popular and growing is still pretty large, especially in a frothy environment like this one. They're more interested in getting out when it looks like growth is over than fighting the legal system to ensure a business can stay in operation.
- frandroid 13y agoIf the law is not enforced at all when there are rampant, clear violations, then it's irrelevant whether it's technically illegal or not. Now the game's about to change though...
- baddox 13y agoAnd in fact, I would argue that a law which is not consistently enforced is by definition not a good law.
- fleitz 13y agoYou may want to read up on Pablo Escobar and how much money you can make from a product that people want, but which is illegal.
- dang 13y agoWe changed the url from [1]. Submitters: please double-check what you post for links to more original sources. 1. http://gigaom.com/2014/04/30/a-reward-for-turning-in-airbnb-users-new-sf-proposal-is-harshest-yet/ http://gigaom.com/2014/04/30/a-reward-for-turning-in-airbnb-...
- timr 13y agoI submitted this yesterday under the current URL, so that probably would have failed. I think a lot of people submit alternate URLs for articles that failed to get traction due to bad timing or whatever.
- protomyth 13y agoActually, I submitted because I liked how it was summarized and linked to the new york story. Original sources don't seem to be valued by folks up voting. [edit] can moderators change the submitter to the person who originally submitted this article?
- timr 13y agoHaha. Don't worry about it. I was just pointing out why someone might not have submitted the original. (One of these days I might be able to trade in my karma points for the really big stuffed animal, but for now, it's just mustache combs...)
- protomyth 13y agoI was hoping for a go cart, I remember those from the back of comics..... On the article, Reason Magazine's article is http://reason.com/blog/2014/04/30/san-francisco-new-airbnb-snitch-plan http://reason.com/blog/2014/04/30/san-francisco-new-airbnb-s... "San Francisco May Wind Up Paying Residents to Snitch on Neighbors Using Airbnb" - nice for the headline to be the tldr
- dang 13y agoYes, that's an issue. We've got a bunch of ideas for working on this, and related problems with story quality and original sources. Perhaps one day I'll even be able to write a line of code again. :)
- anigbrowl 13y agoI predict this will make it onto the ballot easily and give it a 60% chance of passage. EDIT: Downvoters, a prediction is not the same thing as an endorsement.
- rdl 13y agoWhat happens if both this and the Chiu proposition pass?
- Crito 13y agoThe downvotes were probably more about the worth of your comment. Your opinion and some off the cuff percentage aren't really interesting without some sort of accompanying justification or analysis. Why do you think it will make it to the ballot easily, and why specifically 60% odds of passing?
- anigbrowl 13y agoIt's a hunch, for sure. I actually wrote a few hundred words on why I thought so, but scrapped it because it's basically just rationalization rather than based on specific data. The pros and cons of AirBNB have been debated to death on HN for the last few years, so I saw no point in repeating those arguments. But to flesh it out a bit: the threshold for getting something onto the ballot is around 9500 signatures, while the # of registered voters is in SF is just under 500k. Getting 2% of the electorate to sign a ballot petition on a hot-button local issue is easy in SF. As for passage, I've written at length before on the conflicting economic interests of landlords, renters, and other property owners, and how SF's restrictive geography leads to the adoption of zero-sum strategies. For a better and fuller explanation; I'd refer you to that long TechCrunch article on SF's housing crisis: http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ I predict passage with a healthy margin because the larger problems are rather intractable, but it suits all stakeholders to make AirBNB a scapegoat for the city's structural economic problems. There are a lot of landlords, renters, and property owners who don't like AirBNB for different reasons, and short-term rentals give them something to agree about and lower political tension. Also, everyone knows someone with ludicrously cheap rent thanks to rent control, and punishing people who exploit that for personal gain will be popular (even though the number of people who do so and get away with it is tiny). If the proponents of the measure take out the 'snitching reward' mechanism and instead direct that 30% of the fines go to some popular local hobbyhorse like (much-needed) road repairs, support will probably go up. Opponents of the ballot initiatives should avoid characterizing it as a dark horse backed by the hotel industry or service workers union, whether or not that is actually the case, but push the Chiu measure instead. Short-term rental proponents have been almost comically tone-deaf about how their arguments sound to people who can't/won't participate in the STR market themselves.
- brryant 13y agoI hope SROs in San Francisco get as much administrative attention as short term rentals. Decade old legislation severely hindering the development of downtown SF.
- dougmccune 13y agoAs an SF resident, I'd support something that allowed short-term rentals only if the host is present and the host is the owner. Permanent AirBnB units don't help the housing market in the city. I find it funny that AirBnB's justification is that their users rely on the money to make ends meet. But at the same time, if you're taking a unit off the legit long-term rental market to put it on the permanent short-term AirBnB market you are by definition driving up rents for everyone in the city by reducing the supply of rentals. So the justification is: "San Francisco is so expensive, our customers need the ability to drive up rents even more because rents are so high!"
- enjo 13y agoPermanent AirBnB units don't help the housing market in the city. I could see that it might not help, but does it hurt?
- dougmccune 13y agoIt takes what would otherwise be rental units for SF residents off the market and instead provides them to tourists. So my opinion is that yeah, that hurts the residents of the city. You could make the argument that increasing tourism, or increasing the available footprint of where tourists stay (ie not just downtown where all the hotels are) is beneficial. I would actually love to see legit bed and breakfasts open in many more parts of the city. As it is your hotel choices are basically limited to downtown and Fisherman's Wharf. But I don't think helping tourism in SF should come at the cost of making the city less affordable for residents.
- baddox 13y ago> It takes what would otherwise be rental units for SF residents off the market and instead provides them to tourists. So my opinion is that yeah, that hurts the residents of the city. By lowering the supply of long-term rentals, it would drive the cost up, which would incentivize the production of more long-term housing.
- 13y ago
- geuis 13y agoAs a SF resident, I'm opposed to any regulation at all. I'm a long term renter (same house, 7 years) and my lease prevents subletting. That's exactly where the responsibility and regulation should lie, at the feet of the home owner. If I own a piece of property or have a lease that allows it, then I should have the free choice to do with that property what I want in regards to something like Airbnb. In my case, the owner of my house doesn't want that. Other owners do. A friend just purchased a condo for a lot of money. He should be free to do with his condo what he wants. How far does this line of thinking extend? What about small startups that work out of someone's house or apartment? They're doing commercial activity in an unzoned area, so that should be banned too. How about coffee shops? Coffee shops are generally licensed to sell coffee and non-cooked (on premises) goods. Want to sell sandwiches made on site? That's a different (expensive) license. Beer and wine? Same thing. So coffee shops aren't licensed to be places of business for customers to perform commercial activity. We should ban engineers working from cafes too. I've always liked the petition (http://bastiat.org/en/petition.html http://bastiat.org/en/petition.html) Bastiat sent to the French Parliament proposing that they block out the sun to benefit French candle makers. Its in the same vein as a Modest Proposal from Swift about the Irish poor. We're seeing government protectionism of new competing services against established and entrenched businesses, i.e. taxi medallions vs Uber/Lyft, hotels vs Airbnb, city-built fiber vs Comcast/Time Warner. This is dangerous. It limits competition and competition is almost always good for customers. We need to stop this from happening in SF.
- wdewind 13y agoWhile I generally favor a less-regulation approach, you're missing the core issue here: short-term rentals have a negative effect on neighborhoods because they change the incentives of the people living the house from those of a neighbor to those of a visitor. This is precisely what zoning regulations are designed to protect. > How far does this line of thinking extend? What about small startups that work out of someone's house or apartment? They're doing commercial activity in an unzoned area, so that should be banned too. The difference is that no one around the startup is going to complain because they aren't impacting their neighborhood negatively. Short term rentals are decisions you make for your neighborhood without their consent. The feedback mechanism that would replace regulation on Airbnb is unfortunately limited to only the guests who stay, which are not all of the stakeholders affected by any means.
- calbear81 13y agoWhat if we changed the equation and brought landlords in on the action without having to evict renters? Having followed this topic for quite a while, I think these points are generally accepted: - People are more okay with host-present room/couch rentals than full apartment rentals. - Landlords are pissed about rent-controlled units being arbitraged by their renters. - Everyone just wants to make some money Landlords can agree to a renter doing AirBnB if they are willing to profit-share with the landlord via some type of 3rd party rental management service. The landlord would have to ensure that everyone in a building agrees to this or at least you set up floors for "sublet-allowed" units so folks know what they're getting into.
- rsgalloway 13y agoAnother reason to never own property in SF or NY.