3 ms·
Just abolish the FDA and let everyone go shopping with a radiological, chemical and bacteriological assay kit. Do you really think that having an "FDA" somehow
by mindcrime 13y ago
Just abolish the FDA and let everyone go shopping with a radiological, chemical and bacteriological assay kit.
Do you really think that having an "FDA" somehow alleviates all concern about the content/quality/integrity of the food you buy and eat?!????? C'mon, man...
I, for one, can't see why anybody assigns any particularly special level of trust to a government agency. Government agencies have been shown to be corrupt, incompetent, ineffective, and/or some combination of "any or all of the above" time and time again.
There are plenty of good reasons to get rid of the FDA, and "I just plain don't trust them" certainly belongs pretty high on the list.
- nfoz 13y ago> Do you really think that having an "FDA" somehow alleviates all concern about the content/quality/integrity of the food you buy and eat? In countries with reasonably effective/trustworthy government agencies, it does a pretty decent job. Can't speak for the US FDA though.
- mindcrime 13y agoIn countries with reasonably effective/trustworthy government agencies I'm still not convinced that such a thing exists. Of course, my direct experience is limited to the USA, but human nature being what it is, I'm skeptical that "government" in any place is much better than "government" in another place.
- Daishiman 13y agoSo you're talking out of your ass and that's the best evidence you've got? Because the person you're replying to apparently has some first-hand experience (which I've also seen but to a much lesser degree) and I'm sure as hell thankful that there's even a modicum of regulation in the food industry.
- mindcrime 13y agoSo you're talking out of your ass Actually, no. If you bothered to actually try and understand what I'm saying, you'd realize that's not the case. What I'm saying is, we know the "first principles" (eg, human nature being what it is) and we can reason from first principles using deductive logic. So you can call that "talking out your ass" if you want, but I don't think that's accurate at all.
- Daishiman 13y agoIf you think deductive logic is enough to reason about a system as profoundly complex, chaotic and difficult to model as the food industry + business and government interests then I suggest you step away from your naive mental model and look at how those entities are actually studied in real life and realize that data and evidence are substantially more important. And the data and evidence point to the fact that governments with strong and healthy regulatory bodies do a far better job at public safety than any commercial enterprise by itself. Even the very reason why commercial verification and safety inspections by companies like UL and reinsurers work is because there's a strong legal process behind that and government institutions that are willing to put the foot down given enough public pressure. Also, please, do me a favor and find me a social scientist who thinks that our "first principles" are anything but a crude and profoundly erroneous way to think about institutions and that those principles will do anything even remotely decent to approximate social reality. I stick to the facts of food safety, and from my empirical experience of what few places me and my loved ones have been to in the world, I'd rather eat food certified as safe by an EU state any day over, say, a commercial institution in Namibia, massive warts and all.
- mindcrime 13y agoBut that's not the point. This is much bigger than "food safety". But I get the feeling we aren't making any progress towards any shared understanding here, so I'm done.
- rdtsc 13y ago> Do you really think that having an "FDA" somehow alleviates all concern about the content/quality/integrity of the food you buy and eat?!????? C'mon, man... I do, if FDA worked better. I certainly do not subscribed to the idea of abolishing it because it is broken. I subscribe to the idea of fixing it. Closing the revolving door as much as possible, making it stronger. I have lived for many years in a country with an effectively missing FDA. It was there de-facto but it was a joke. So anyone could sell you anything. The joke about baby formula and chalk mixed with water was not a joke, it has happened. Other foodstuff is just like that. "Organic" farmers live there too. You know what they do, the spray the shit of their produce with pesticides and put those in a different garden plot from the real organic food they grow for themselves. I have seen it myself (a relatives' neighbor does it). "Organic" there is a joke. The best eggs and produce we got was a from a relative out f the "growing for yourself" lot not from the "growing for selling lot". Otherwise we just kind of guessed in the dark. The alternative without the FDA is many many times more scary and only those who have no idea what it looks like would advocate for it. This is not science fiction. You can buy a plane ticket and be within a day in a such a place in the world.
- mindcrime 13y agoThe alternative without the FDA is many many times more scary and only those who have no idea what it looks like would advocate for it. I don't see how the presence of the FDA alleviates any of the problems you just listed off. But, again, I plain don't trust them. If $MEGACORP wants an FDA rubber-stamp on something, I'm sure they have enough money to buy it.
- HeyLaughingBoy 13y agoAs an employee of a $MEGACORP that just spent two+ years on a Corrective Action to satisfy an FDA finding, I'd be ROFLMAO'ing all over the place if dealing with it hadn't been so aggravating on a daily basis. Seriously, where do you people come up with this shit?
- greggman 13y ago??? You said in your OP "Trusting FDA to police the industry is like trusting the industry to police itself at this point." Maybe it's something else that keeps companies from selling poison chalk milk as babyfood other than the FDA?