9 ms·
Android betrays tethering data
- mike-cardwell 13y agoWill Cyanogenmod fix this in their build?
- davidgerard 13y agoPer post, yes.
- pja 13y agoI've checked & CyanogenMod 11M5 on my Nexus 4 doesn't appear to be doing this - if I turn on tethering over bluetooth there's no extra route in the routing table. However, my current carrier allows me to tether the data I pay for, so perhaps it only does it in response to some kind of carrier request to split the data into tethered / non-tethered classes?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- reustle 13y agoI'm curious about this. These are exactly the types of "fixes" that people are willing to pay for with the OnePlus One
- blueskin_ 13y agoDirect link: http://danielpocock.com/android-betrays-tethering-data http://danielpocock.com/android-betrays-tethering-data
- dang 13y agoYes. Changed. The original url [1] was blogspam. Submitters: please double-check the article you post for links to an original source. If there is one, please post it instead. 1. http://lwn.net/Articles/596080/ http://lwn.net/Articles/596080/
- davidgerard 13y agoGoogle considers this a feature, not a bug, and that you are the product and the carrier is the customer: http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=38563#c105 http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=38563#c105
- bad_user 13y agoQuote from that email: > IS NOT A BUG. IT IS A FEATURE. It's not a feature for users like you and me, it's a feature for manufacturers like Samsung and HTC, so they can in turn build devices that carriers can have more control over. The reason why I switched to Android was precisely the control I have with it, with the primary annoyance I experienced with iOS being that the carrier has to give approval for tethering (amongst other bullshit precisely like this one). This happens for Windows Phone too. Was pleased with Android precisely because it's the only OS in which the feature cannot be turned on/off by the career. Apparently this is no longer true. A bug BY DESIGN is still a bug. UPDATED: corrected sentence, iOS is not a carrier :-)
- jacquesm 13y ago> iOS being the carrier that has to give approval for tethering What do you mean by that?
- lsaferite 13y agoYou quoted the post out of context. They were saying they experienced that with iOS devices the carrier was the only one who could enabled tethering while with android devices that was not always the case.
- jacquesm 13y agoIt's a literal quote of a part of the comment, I simply don't understand how iOS could be a carrier in any context.
- 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- eli 13y agoThere isn't and really hasn't ever been wireless net neutrality. Carriers used to (and perhaps still do) get at this data through deep packet inspection. It's discrimination in the "price discrimination" sense.
- blueskin_ 13y agoThat's why you use a VPN.
- eli 13y agoOr just pay for a tethering plan if you want tethering.
- mindslight 13y agoOr just pay for answering machine rental instead of hooking your unapproved device up to Ma Bell's wires. Demarcation points were invented for a reason.
- blueskin_ 13y agoGood luck doing that without being massively price gouged.
- rahimnathwani 13y agoYes, but how can you tether your tablet/PC to the VPN connection established on your phone?
- bananas 13y agoInteresting! I'm on a Moto G on giffgaff in the UK and data is 100% free and unlimited (within some vague definition of "fair use"). They shoot your network access for 30 minutes if they find you tethering because it's against their terms. How they detect this is a closely guarded secret and a big mystery. Perhaps this is it. However, the asshole carrier tactics come out pretty sharpish: if you want a tablet SIM or data only SIM, they charge a fortune for a capped data SIM (£12 for 3Gb/month). No thanks! Data is data. that's what net neutrality is about isn't it? The penalty for breaking the terms is temporary disconnection so screw it, I tether all the time. If you use HTTPS only or a VPN connection then it doesn't cut you off at all. DPI anyone? The irony is that I've snagged a 3.5Gb ISO image off MSDN onto my handset's USB OTG (at a nice 800k/sec) with the free data and can push 6-8Gb a month which doesn't apparently bother their fair use term but if I start up a download on a tethered device, bang instantly. Obviously they're device-ist!
- davidgerard 13y agoWhen I moved house last year, we didn't have broadband at home for a few weeks. Coincidentally I got a new phone on Vodafone (on contract - S3 Mini on £21/mo plan), with three months' unlimited data. I tethered the shit out of it, including work-from-home; many gigabytes downloaded. Not a squeak from Vodafone. So YMMV.
- 1_player 13y ago> How they detect this is a closely guarded secret and a big mystery. I would guess packet inspection and checking user agents. You could bypass it with an iptables rule on the handset (is there iptables available on Android?) and/or changing your browser's user agent string. That's just a theory, I wanted to test it but never find the time.
- thefreeman 13y agoyes iptablesis on android but our most likely need root to update it
- d0ugie 13y agoYes for me, I have iptables v1.4.11.1, 2008-08-01.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kclay 13y agoSorta like how Verizon tries to block tethering on grandfather plans. If you are rooted its not a problem. But I never understood it if you are paying for it why have to go through these tricks. What needs to happen is all the money that these mobile networks are raking in they need to invest it in a better infrastructure, its only going to get worse.
- lnanek2 13y agoAT&T does the same with grandfathered unlimited plans. When I first bought the plan and a phone I was able to tether unlimited. Now they want me to upgrade to a tether plan that only supports 5GB max and phones using stock software refuse to tether unless I do.
- ledneb 13y agoNabbed from the comments of the post, this is how you disable the "feature" without being rooted: http://vinhboy.com/blog/2013/12/27/how-to-tether-the-nexus-5-on-t-mobile/ http://vinhboy.com/blog/2013/12/27/how-to-tether-the-nexus-5... ... still though, I'm interested: what actually is this second device which things get routed through? How can the carrier tell which device your phone is using? Even then, how do they tell which one is the 'normal data' vs the 'tethered data' device?
- kzahel 13y agoI spent a day trying to overcome the tethering restriction on my T-Mobile unlimited data prepaid Moto-G. I tried changing some tether_dun_required setting (mentioned in parent), which required me to root my phone. That didn't have any effect! I ended up running a SOCKS5 proxy on my android phone (the app is called Proxoid, and is unfortunately rather buggy). That at least works, though with the app being rather prone to crashes and hangs, it is not the ideal solution.
- blueskin_ 13y agoDifferent devices go to different APN gateways as I understood it.
- thefreeman 13y agothe different devices are assigned different IP addresses
- higherpurpose 13y agoIt's such a shame people have allowed carriers to get away with this. Yes, this is all on the people, because they are the ones that should be outraged when carriers want to charge them twice for the same data, simply because you decided to use that data with another device. Common sense says you should be allowed to use that data however you want. But the carriers got away with it, and now it's status quo. What the carriers are doing is like your electricity provider telling you that you can only use that specific amount of electricity with certain appliances, but if you want to use it with others, you have to pay extra. It's insane, and I'm starting to believe more and more that declaring carriers and ISP's as utilities is the right way to go to have strong net neutrality in US. The Internet is every bit as important as electricity in today's modern world. It's about time we start treating it like that.
- couchand 13y agoYour service level only comes with the fixtures package. Oh, you'd like to plug your own appliances into this outlet? That'll be another $29.95 a month, please.
- mschuster91 13y agoIt's your own fault if you use Vodafone. Overpriced, fucked up consumer support, and at least in Germany, multiple occasions of fraudulent behaviour by the sales agents (e.g. signing you up for stuff you didn't ask for etc). Oh, and a fucked up network, too.
- davidgerard 13y agoAs I noted below, I'm a Vodafone user and they didn't squeak when I tethered and hammered the shit out of my three months' unlimited data on a new contract. (I presume they were letting me run loose so they could try to sell me a data package on top.) In my experience the UK's a cosy oligopoly between Voda, O2 and EE, with approximately equivalent fuckery between them. YMMV of course.
- gcb0 13y agoSmartphones taught me that even when you pay, you are the product.
- zatkin 13y agoThere's a lot of guilty surrounding the topic of tethering if the data plan doesn't allow it...
- jpollock 13y agoCouple of comments. First, this is caused by "unlimited", or other large plans (1GB+) plans. Unlimited can never mean unlimited, anymore than it does with electricity. Carriers are selling those plans to give people comfort around billshock. It's much, much easier to give people an unlimited plan than it is to try to get them to pay for a huge post-pay data bill. However, since this is about customer comfort, carriers are working on an average usage, and assuming an amount of "breakage". Breakage is the unused portion of a balance, and it is factored into the profit the carrier expects. It comes from calling card days, where there would be a balance at the end of the card that couldn't be used ($1 on the card, and 35c/minute). Unused prepaid balance at the end of the month? Breakage. We're atypical users, and even then I'm using <500MB/month. However, this is changing - people are frequently staying on mobile and not switching to wifi when it is available. That's why I hear about people complaining about mobile data coverage at home! Next, mobile carriers are doing anything and everything they can to avoid becoming a dumb bit-pipe. Mobile is more competitive than fixed line (no regional monopolies), so customers have more power. Personally, I think there is an insane amount of money to be made being a simple bit pipe, mostly through cost reductions. Finally, they're not only tracking this through separate APNs for tethered traffic, they're tracking the hop counts of packets and detecting packets who's hop count is unexpected for the device. So, running a VPN client on the laptop and tethering won't help, but running a VPN client on your phone and tethering traffic through _that_ connection might.
- mikeash 13y agoI agree about unlimited plans. I believe they're the cause of much woe in the internet world, and I don't understand why the tech community generally fights to keep them. Things would become much better if we paid for usage. But I don't understand why you lump 1GB+ plans in with unlimited. I'm currently paying for 4GB/month of data and I should be able to use it all for whatever I feel like.
- eli 13y agoMoreover it bugs me that people keep conflating net neutrality with all-you-can-eat data plans. There's nothing inherently wrong with charging consumers per-byte. I probably use a below average amount of data on my phone, it would be cool if I could pay less.
- sscalia 13y agoData is data is data is data. Youtube blocking "mobile playback" of videos is the same as carriers blocking tethering without a specific plan or arbitrary caps (3GB mobile data, 1GB tether) This is something, across all mobile platforms, we should be fighting tooth and nail.
- Crito 13y ago> Youtube blocking "mobile playback" of videos Do they still do that? I thought the issue was the ability to play required ads, which the mobile youtube applications now have.
- toxicFork 13y agoYep, they still do that. I run into a few of these videos every now and then. It tells me to "save to 'watch later' playlist to watch on your pc".
- scott_karana 13y agoThey still do for some content in Canada, at least, with messages along the lines of "UMG Music has not authorized this video for mobile distribution".
- andrewflnr 13y agoSpotify has different rules depending on what kind of mobile device you're using to listen. My phone is significantly more restricted than my tablet or PC.
- w1ntermute 13y agoIt's not something "they" do, it's an option that any video uploader has. Of course, you can sideload unauthorized YouTube viewers to get around this.
- gopalv 13y agoI found out that setting the IP TTL of my machine to 65 usually bypasses most tethering checks in most ISPs. Like T-Mobile has a special case where they allow :443 from tethered hosts, while disallowing :80. That disappears when the TTL is 65.
- chimeracoder 13y agoDo you do this on your laptop, or on your phone? I know that (older versions of) Cyanogenmod would set the TTL of packets to be (2^n + 1) for this exact reason, but it happened on the phone. Also, FWIW, I have T-mobile and haven't experienced issues tethering on my stock Nexus 5. I'm curious why some customers are experiencing these and not others.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoOn a Galaxy Nexus on T-Mobile in Chicago; they subvert my :80 requests to a "you should be paying for tethering" portal.
- gopalv 13y agoI set that on the laptop actually - android's TTL is 64, so +1 hop is 65. I'm sure they could filter that if I upgraded my phone & the tether got a different gateway host (like in the blog).
- Groxx 13y agoOn my Nexus 4 it worked fine for a few months, but then they started blocking it (I used it lightly during my commute, probably <1gb monthly, I have the $30 5gb-fast/unlimited-slow plan). Give it time, it'll probably happen to you too.
- gxs 13y agoI'm getting used to this circus show. I watch the xfinity comcast app on my Galaxy S3 - unfortunately I'm not allowed to "tether" the phone via HDMI and watch the app on my TV (it's actually disabled and you get an error message). This sort of artificial scarcity is really frustrating to certain users, but it is an absolute gold mine for corporations like this.
- rickisen 13y agoThis is why I love my Jolla phone !
- mkonecny 13y agoThis "feature" was introduced in 4.2.2. Android is at 4.4 now.