6 ms·
I think what goes on in plea bargains is more of an issue. If I am arrested for a minor crime and the prosecutor decides to pile on dozens of parallel charges s
by danieltillett 13y ago
I think what goes on in plea bargains is more of an issue. If I am arrested for a minor crime and the prosecutor decides to pile on dozens of parallel charges such that I am now facing 50 years to life if convicted, but offers me 3 month if I plead guilty, then no matter how innocent I am I am going to take the plea. Unless you can prove beyond reasonable doubt that you are innocent what rational person can afford to take the risk of going to trial.
- baddox 13y agoThe government does everything it can to avoid having a jury trial, and when a jury trial does happen, the government does everything it can to prevent the jurors from being educated about their role and abilities as jurors.
- danieltillett 13y agoThis is why I never try to get out of jury duty even when I could. Everyone willing to go to trial deserves at least one person on the jury smart enough to at least be able to get off.
- blueskin_ 13y agoOf course, demonstrating intelligence, knowledge and willingness to do the research is one of the primary ways to get yourself excluded, as the prosecution wants room temperature IQs who will say 'guilty' when prompted. If you want to get out of it, all you really need to even do is say the words "jury nullification". Myself, I've never been asked yet, but if I was, I think I'd do it for most cases as someone has to be there who understands the powers a jury actually has, but get out if it was something really bad or one that's likely to last for months and months.
- dredmorbius 13y agoA citation or reference would greatly strengthen your argument.
- DannoHung 13y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/11/opinion/sunday/go-to-trial-crash-the-justice-system.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/11/opinion/sunday/go-to-trial... Non-comprehensive, but gives an indication of how fucked jury instructions are: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_instructions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_instructions
- dredmorbius 13y agoThanks.
- rando289 13y agoThe justice system is ripe for reform in many ways.
- danieltillett 13y agoIt certainly is. If you wanted to design a system for getting innocent people to plead guilt you would be hard pressed to come up with a better system. I wish that some prosecutor would "go rogue" and start applying all these tactics on nice middle class people. The outcry after a couple of weeks would be so great that something might be done about changing things.
- a3n 13y agoWhy would any prosecutor do that. They're as smart as you are, and they know they'd kill the golden goose by doing that. There is a never ending supply of poor black men to add to a prosecutor's career tally; no need to rock the boat.
- danieltillett 13y ago>Why would any prosecutor do that. They're as smart as you are, and they know they'd kill the golden goose by doing that. I know :( In my heart I always hope there are people out there that will put doing the right thing ahead of their material comfort and status. Right or wrong Snowden did show there are some people who do.
- dalek_cannes 13y agoCould I raise a somewhat academic question? The idea of conviction is binary: either you're convinced beyond reasonable doubt of guilt or you let the man go. In a way this is good, but in a way, because of it, prosecutors end up putting a lot of innocent people behind bars while defense attorneys get a lot of guilty people off the hook. What if there is a slight -- repeat slight -- spectrum? Personally, I would not mind being theoretically "conditionally detained/penalized/sentenced" provided: 1. The penalty is low -- police surveillance, fine that will be returned if exonerated 2. You're compensated if exonerated 3. These penalties carry no more stigma than jury duty A scheme like this might allow the criminal justice system to move a bit faster. Or does this sound completely outrageous?
- higherpurpose 13y agoIt annoys me that people keep saying in such cases "yeah, but you won't really get 50 years, even if they succeed". Imagine yourself talking to those prosecutors and being threatened with 50 years, and then given that 3 months deal. What would you do? Would you think "yeah, I'm not really going to get 50 years" - or would you be scared as hell about spending the rest of your life in prison? So yeah, I think such threats absolutely do matter, and the system should be changed so this doesn't happen anymore. I've also recently heard that something like 98 percent of people charged take the plea deal (I think it was from some documentary). That's INSANE. That's not how the justice system is supposed to work. Everyone should be getting a fair trial, regardless. I mean, even if the guy is guilty - wouldn't you rather have him in a fair trial to make sure he gets what he deserves, rather than have the prosecutors offer him a much smaller prison time?
- danieltillett 13y ago>It annoys me that people keep saying in such cases "yeah, but you won't really get 50 years, even if they succeed". If convicted you can certainly get 50 years because the of minimum sentencing rules. This is where you get juries saying after the trial "I had no idea he would be sentenced to 50 years - I thought he would only get a couple of months". As a defendant your lawyer can't tell the jury the sentence you face if convicted - apparently if the jury knows you face a minimum of 50 years for a minor crime they might not be so keen to convict you!
- blueskin_ 13y agoThat's why jury members shouldn't be the average, possibly dim, possibly outright stupid, possibly just apathetic person, but actually be required to posses at least a modicum of intelligence, so as to be able to research minimum sentences etc.
- danieltillett 13y agoYes, but if we make it easy for anyone who can fog a mirror to get out of serving in combination with throwing anyone off who the prosecution thinks might be able fog a mirror, then we can expect that who ever is left will have few problems. My feeling is serving on a jury it is a bit like voting. I know it is unlikely that I am doing any good, but it is my duty to do my best in both circumstances.
- blueskin_ 13y agoWhen I first heard about plea bargains (much rarer over here), I honestly thought it was a bad joke.