9 ms·
Everything that is wrong with American capitalism, in one headline
- dba7dba 13y agoAfaik, the cable companies got virtual monopolies to certain regions/cities/neighborhoods with the claim that they were like utilities. Laying cables and maintaining them was similar to what power companies do. And now, we are finding out the rates of the cable companies are going up and up because we are basically financing their expansion into other businesses. It's like my local power company raising rates so that they can go into business of running data centers.
- rayiner 13y agoService businesses spin off and absorb blocks of customers all the time. If I sell someone else my paper delivery route, is that an indictment of American capitalism? Really, the title should be "everything that's wrong with state and local politics in one headline." If you want to blame someone for the situation in "such cities as Long Beach, Malibu" (that often, there's only one guy delivering papers), start here: http://www.cpuc.ca.gov/PUC/Telco/Information+for+providing+service/videofranchising.htm http://www.cpuc.ca.gov/PUC/Telco/Information+for+providing+s.... The state of California grants cable franchises,[1] and not with just an eye towards creating competition. Read the four bullet points on that page. Only the first has to do with competition. The other three are priorities that necessitate policies that discourage investment and competition.
- lisper 13y ago> If I sell someone else my paper delivery route, is that an indictment of American capitalism? It is if your customers don't have the option to switch to another paper.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jpadkins 13y agoand the reason you don't have the option to switch to another service provider is your state and local governments granting comcast, et al local monopolies. Please direct criticism to the proper source: government interference.
- exelius 13y agoNo, the reason you don't have an option to switch to another service provider is that running a wireline provider is really expensive. Building one is even more expensive: you literally have to run cables to every household in a city thanks to the FCC's equal access laws (i.e. you can't ignore the poor parts of town when providing service). Each household probably has a fully-loaded cost of around $1000 (this includes switches, routers, a few thousand miles of cable, teams of guys in trucks to run the cable across the poles, etc), so for a small city of 500k households (~1 million people), you're looking at a ballpark of $500 million. Even if the regulation allowed you to start your own cable company, what investor in their right mind would put up the money to do so? Trying to VC pitch a startup ISP would be the worst pitch ever. "Why am I going to give you a billion dollars for a 10% margin business that you're not even guaranteed to be successful in?"
- pdonis 13y agoIn other words, the reason you don't have options for service providers is that it's expensive to be a provider; and the reason it's expensive to be a provider is...government regulations.
- exelius 13y agoI think even without the government regulations you'd have a similar situation: it's expensive enough to serve even an affluent area that the market can't really support much more than 2 companies (which already exist in the form of Comcast/TimeWarner and FiOS/U-Verse in most wealthy areas). You'd probably also find that some middle-class suburbs would have no providers available at all. Though I do agree that subscriber pricing is much better in areas where you see both a cable company and a telco video provider like FiOS or U-Verse.
- exelius 13y agoWhat if there's not another paper because the margins are so low that neither of you would make a profit if you had to compete for customers (and your service was mutually exclusive)? And the government says that you have to drive by every house when delivering papers whether they subscribe or not? Even if telecom/cable were fully deregulated, this is the situation you would face. A cable company may make $1 billion in revenue off of a city, but it probably costs them $900 million to serve the city. If someone else comes in and is able to radically undercut their costs at $600 million while simultaneously winning 50% of the market, both companies would still only make $500 million and lose money. The incumbent cable company probably has enough of a war chest to wait out the challenger's funding. Infrastructure businesses are very expensive. There is no easy solution short of the government seizing the cable infrastructure, which would set such a dangerous precedent that it would probably destroy our economy.
- mullingitover 13y ago> There is no easy solution short of the government seizing the cable infrastructure, which would set such a dangerous precedent that it would probably destroy our economy. Sure, I mean, there's no way that the government could simply recognize the monopoly and regulate it as such.
- exelius 13y agoWhat does that regulation look like to you? It's easy to say "regulation is the solution" but regulation can mean a lot of things. What's the easy regulatory solution?
- mullingitover 13y agoExactly like it did before the cable companies were allowed to kick out all their competition. In 1998, when I leased a DSL line I had a full page listing all the ISP options I had. Now that we're 'deregulated' and have a 'free market,' I have exactly zero choice in broadband ISPs.
- 13y ago
- bane 13y agoThere's plenty of alternatives for internet everywhere in the country. Saying "but they only have 1 broadband provider" isn't the same as having only one internet provider. The home I grew up in still doesn't have any broadband cable provider and can't get DSL. Yet somehow my non-tech savvy parents figured out how to navigate finding, competing and buying a high-speed internet provider after years of dial-up. They've had "always on" 24/7 internet in their house since about 1997-98 if I'm not mistaken.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoWhat service do they use, exactly? I think most of us would be interested to hear about a high-bandwidth, low-latency option that isn't cable or DSL. The only things I can think of are satellite and cellular, both of which have huge hosts of problems for regular home use.
- bane 13y agoOh your want high bandwidth and low latency? Just like Tesla doesn't have a dealership in my neighborhood, providers aren't available in their area that offers both of those things either. They use to use pairbonded dial-up, then ISDN. Been on Satellite (high-band down, dial-up up then bi-directional) for the last 10 years or so. They've been thinking of switching to a 4g hotspot recently, which is similar bandwidth and half the latency (and similar cost for their uses).
- baddox 13y agoThey always have the option to stop paying for the paper.
- smsm42 13y agoIf you lack the option because local government banned all other papers from the city (and courts approved this since it's "public interest") then it's really not right to lay this at capitalism's doorstep. Capitalism didn't do it, voters that elected politicians who approved it did.
- renata 13y agoI'm not sure this is as much of a problem as he makes it out to be - if anything, we should be disturbed that the merger is being allowed to go through in the first place. Separating out some customers to prevent a monopoly is a good thing, if anything, and has been done before - when Verizon acquired Alltel, they were required to let AT&T buy the North Dakota portion of Alltel so there wouldn't be a Verizon monopoly here.
- enginerd 13y agoI agree that the merger approval is the original and bigger problem at large, however, unlike AT&T/Alltel this does not seem like 'monopoly prevention' but in fact just the opposite. Calling it 'saving-face' doesn't even do the situation justice. Sure, Comcast sells off 1.4 million viewers. The gap from No.1 to No.2 post-merge then grows from ~11m subscribers to nearly ~25m. Not only that, but as the LA Times article points out, this is "a fast-evolving industry that requires huge capital investments to maintain..." Competitors will be reluctant to enter an industry with such significant capital barriers, and why would they? Comcast owns their customers before they've even started.
- kar2014 13y agoBased on what I've seen and heard, Comcast has history of doing things like this. They have entered in contract with apartment complex across the nation and have mandated each apartment to have their service. The consumers have been at their mercy whether they like their content or not or even want it. Comcast has gotten too large, it is very dangerous when one company controls so much of media in the country. Where are the regulators?
- BillyParadise 13y agoI've been "owned" by three different cable companies in the last 3 years. In the same house. The worst part is, the big fish who "owns" me now hasn't bothered to upgrade fish #2's infrastructure to match their own. So I now have the worst of both worlds - famously crappy support, with poor selection. Thank Buddha for Satellite.
- zacinbusiness 13y agoI wonder how much of this buyout-without-investment behavior is just a method that big providers use to punish users for "cable cutting."
- Omniusaspirer 13y agoIt's a sad state of affairs when anybody is happy with satellite internet. So much expense for such an awful service in all respects.
- Loughla 13y agoAs a (very) rural satellite consumer, it's only awful in most respects, not all. With the latest incarnation of satellite, the speed isn't terrible. Really, it's not. If the weather isn't bad, and it's not spring/fall sunspot season, and you only use 15 gigs. But at least it's overpriced.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoAnd if you don't have hills or trees between you and the southern sky, and you don't have any interest in anything latency-dependent, like gaming or VPN/remote desktop. Oh, and uploading anything ever. Does satellite still use dial-up lines for all upstream communication?
- Loughla 13y agoUploading isn't terrible anymore. No dial-up lines. Not super fast, by any stretch, but it's not an the abomination it used to be. What kills me, personally, is that I have a fiber line running between two of the major metros in my state underground at the front of my property, and no feasible way to tie into it. Am currently taking suggestions on how to do that.
- andcase 13y agoIf its that easy to "switch" customer bases why can't I just choose an upstream provider and force providers to compete on service?
- hacknat 13y agoCan someone explain to me how this doesn't violate the Sherman Act (I'm being serious)? Comcast is actively engaging in trust behavior with another company in order to obtain a desirable merger ruling with the FCC. How is that not anti-competitive?
- vonmoltke 13y agoCable monopolies are state sanctioned and state controlled, and thus fall under the Parker immunity doctrine[1]. Its the same doctrine that permits tight state regulation of electric, gas, and other utilities. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_action_immunity_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_action_immunity_doctrine
- vonmoltke 13y agoI would like to correct myself. Cable franchises are state sanctioned and state controlled. Monopolies ("exclusive franchises") were also permitted under the Parker immunity doctrine, but as rayiner pointed out elsewhere in the discussion Congress explicitly prohibited them with various acts in the 90s.
- adventured 13y agoAnti-trust - violating the Sherman Anti-trust Act - is a strictly subjective determination. Comcast is a huge Democratic Party donor, and their CEO is a golfing buddy of Obama's. There was never a chance the Obama DOJ was going to stop the merger. Democrats traditionally are the harshest when it comes to anti-trust, and you can more often count on Republicans to look the other way, so when you have the Democrats (except Franken!) willing to look the other way too... forget about it. Subjective discretion rules anti-trust enforcement. If the DOJ simply chooses to not pursue it, then that's that. I'd also argue Comcast is the most convenient scenario for the US Government, from a control position (far easier spying for the NSA and piracy control for Hollywood political donors). Far better to have one large cable entity ala AT&T and Verizon in telephony. They love massive companies, when they're under their boot. Keep in mind there are plenty of quasi-monopolies that the government is more than happy to encourage or leave in place. From Intel, to Microsoft, to Cisco, to AT&T + Verizon, to Facebook, to Google. The Government has never had a problem per se with monopolies, just monopolies they happen to not like for whatever reasons at the time (often politically convenient reasons).
- ericingram 13y ago> in a free market, the customer is supposed to select the supplier, not the other way around Which free market philosopher expressed this sentiment exactly? None that I'm aware of. Free markets involve free choice of both customers and suppliers. Customers may chose to leave the supplier based on this move, and are absolutely within their right to do so. Customers might even be able to argue their way out of locked contracts. The idea that free markets should be sort of one-sided, consumer owns supplier, is just silly in my view.
- kar2014 13y agoFree market is where consumer has right to buy the goods they want and suppliers have right to produce goods they want. I agree to your point, both sides should have options to select what they want. But here consumers have no choice. It cannot be considered free market even remotely.
- nickff 13y agoWho is the guarantor of variety for the consumers (and suppliers) in your version of the free market?
- smsm42 13y agoTelecom market is obviously not a free market - there are piles of regulations, both federal and local. It looks, however, as the OP sees free market as "suppliers do what I want" - which may be a consequence of free market, sometimes, due to consumer's power to withhold purchase from suppliers that don't do what they want - but is not a condition. There could be free market where consumers have no choice - i.e., if for some reason there's only one supplier of said good. Simplest example would be unique non-commodity items - if somebody has the Picasso painting that you want, you can't just go to a competitor and buy it from them, you have no choice. Another example can be markets with very high barriers of entry and very low profit margins, where fixed costs of entering the market may outweigh potential benefits, and as such once one player has established itself there may be extended periods - with completely free markets - that there is no competition for them on that market. So, the absence of buyer's choice is not per se an evidence of the market not being free, and there's nothing in free market that ensures buyer would always have a choice - only a promise that in most cases, the choice would exist, supported by ample evidence.
- mikestew 13y ago"Not only is this the situation we are in, but we have somehow gotten here with only the feeblest of protests. " Feeblest of protests? I ditched Comcast years ago, and it apparently bothers them enough that they send a person to my door every month or two. What does he want me to do, storm the local Comcast office?
- dck273 13y agohttps://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/maintain-true-net-neutrality-protect-freedom-information-united-states/9sxxdBgy https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/maintain-true-net-...
- smoyer 13y agoCable (and other utilities) are not good examples of free-market capitalism since they operate under franchise agreements with the affected municipalities.
- 001sky 13y agoThis is mis-reading the thesis. Those franchise-agreements and associated rgulatory structures are the premise. The bit about "everything that is wrong with American Capitalism" more or less logically follows.
- smoyer 13y agoI read his thesis ... I'm stating it's wrong. Utilities are not free-market and don't represent American capitalism. This is one step away from government-owned utilities, closer to socialism and worse than both (capitalism and socialism). EDIT: Reading the sub-comments below, I think perhaps my mistake is assuming that American capitalism tends to be more like Tesla, Amazon, etc (maybe I'm deluded or just a hopeless optimist). But if "Bad American Capitalism" is the topic being discussed, utilities are a perfect example and perhaps we can agree that there are examples of "Good American Capitalism".
- pdonis 13y ago> Utilities are not free-market True. > and don't represent American capitalism Depends on how you define "American capitalism". I think they represent American capitalism just fine, because to me "American capitalism" very often means "companies that can't compete in the free market use their capital to get the government to pass laws and regulations that protect them from competition".
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 13y agoYou seem to be thinking of American capitalism as something other than "capitalism, as practiced in America."
- holograham 13y agoHow are these customers not free to select their supplier? If you dont like the new owner then you can switch to another service provider. Suppliers switch ALL THE TIME in the free market and consumers are none-the-wiser. Consumers care about the end product...is it up to par for what I pay? Think of the hundreds of suppliers that go into the computer you use. Did you select them? Do you care who provided the plastic for your keyboard?
- agscala 13y agoWith regards to cable/internet service providers, in a lot of locations there simply is only one option. If that's the case in the area where the customer trading is going on, then the only option is to cancel that service and go without the internet/cable. That's why it is bad.
- bane 13y ago> the customer is supposed to select the supplier, not the other way around Which isn't entirely right. Companies routinely chase after specific demographic groups. Porsche isn't exactly selling huge numbers of low-cost commuter boxes. Where you live is just as much a demographic category as anything else. It doesn't mean it's not a crappy deal, but the article doesn't get how things work from the company side.
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoWhat you're describing is companies choosing who they market to, not choosing who their customers are.
- NegativeK 13y agoExtending the metaphor is off-topic, but Lamborghini (or Ferrari -- can't remember which) picks it's customers. In order to get on the waiting list for their small run cars, you have to have purchased one of their cars before and not done anything to piss them off. When the supply is that low and the demand that high, the costs move beyond monetary.
- tn13 13y agoSo Comcast is trying to build a monopoly and people see it as a failure of Capitalism ? In non-capitalist societies monopoly is a default state. (India for example for a long had only one government telecom provider. It exists today with wages to turnover ratio of 103% where as for private companies it is 5%.) If Comcast actually manages to create an monopoly it will be able to dictate higher prices for poorer service. What prevents Google or someone else who has interest in cheap internet from entering the market as a new service provider ? One answer as usual: Government. All corporations are greedy and will do everything in their power to create monopolies and squeeze every last penny out of our pockets. This is true is all societies and the best way to stop them is not by letting government fix the problem but letting government out of it.
- NegativeK 13y agoThe answer to poor regulation isn't no regulation. I'm much more interested in government counterbalancing corporations instead of one of them grossly overpowering the other.
- nickff 13y agoIf you agree that the current system of regulation is poor, and you wish to improve it, you must ask yourself whether the regulators have/will improve. There has been no paradigm shift in regulation for a long time, and there is no reason to believe that the same regulators (or even different ones) acting under the same incentives will come up with more efficient or effective regulations, though they may come up with more numerous or novel rules.
- tn13 13y agoAsking government to come up with "counterbalancing regulations" is exactly same as asking corporations not to be ruthless in making profits. In one word: "Impossible". There is a good reason why corporations are ruthless in profit making. It is because the people who are responsible for making its decisions have a strong incentive to make more and more profits at all cost. Government out of all people have 0 incentive to come up with anything that acts as a counterbalance. Government employees including Mr. President have only one incentive. Keep that damn job. I worked in a department that was focused on improving certain aspect of engineering education. Very quickly I realized that our jobs and funding depended on painting a very sad picture of reality and getting lots of money from government. Improving education was the last thing we were concerned about. I do not see what is wrong with "no-regulation" at all. In fact all the empirical evidence suggests that no-regulation leads to far better outcomes in most areas.
- joshuaheard 13y agoLooks like an industry ripe for disruption.
- coherentpony 13y agoEverything that is wrong with this HN post, in one headline.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 13y agoWhen discussing the cable industry, one must acknowledge that it is unique in its government mandated monopoly. Trying to analyze it as normal capitalism is pointless.
- olssy 13y agoA lot more than that is wrong with capitalism like the fact that no value is given to anything you can't sell.
- steven2012 13y agoThat's because we don't live in a capitalistic society. We live in a plutocracy where the rich change the rules depending on whatever is most advantageous to them. We privatize our gains and socialize our losses. There was a time during the financial crisis where I thought real change was going to occur, but things like the Tea Party went upside down and started attracting kooks and racists instead of real fiscal conservatives.
- caughtexception 13y agoWait what ? hypocrisy: the practice of claiming to have moral standards or beliefs to which one's own behavior does not conform; Social Networking Platforms are know to treat and swap users as commodities. Why are people even complaining ? "I am not a Number; I am a Man!"
- cognivore 13y agoI did choose. I don't have cable.
- gcb0 13y agoThis was an unintentional bait and switch. Monopolies on tv? Who cares? I don't even watch it. ...and then overnight they steal internet from the phone companies and dedicated isp.