6 ms·
Free healthcare will never survive one fact: The fact that scarcity exists. The fact that healthcare are so expensive in America are numerous. The limited supp
by kiba 17y ago
Free healthcare will never survive one fact: The fact that scarcity exists.
The fact that healthcare are so expensive in America are numerous. The limited supply of doctors due to medical cartels, patents on drugs, overusage of the system by medicaid users, insurance companies being used for paying everyday medical cost, and more.
But in Canada and other places where social medicine or universial health care exists, there has been rationing of improtant services. It is also where capital structures simply rot.
I believe wealthy nations' medical system are going to crash and burn decades from now because government deemed healthcare too improtant to regulate or control, never mind the consquences of unintended effects from regulations.
The only solution is to return control of the healthcare to individuals, which are embodied in a free market. Only individuals have any chance to find a solution where centralized regulatory power and decision makers fails miserably.
- gdp 17y agoMy experiences of the New Zealand health system and the NHS in Britain have been nothing but positive. What's all this talk of crashing and burning? Really, the free market and the individual as the fundamental unit of society rarely act in the best interests of the society as a whole. That's why many governments provide centralised healthcare. They can essentially take all the money (as taxes) that would have been spent on health care or insurance in a given year, and use it to build hospitals and medical facilities that the public own. The public then gets to use these facilities that they paid for at no cost, or at a heavily subsidised rate. If more people need more health care, taxes go up, and more hospitals are built. It's a surprisingly efficient way of doing things. Much more so than having lots of private companies, each with shareholders demanding profits be returned on top of something as basic as healthcare.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoIt's a surprisingly efficient way of doing things. Much more so than having lots of private companies, each with shareholders demanding profits be returned It's remarkable how our historical examples of this efficiency are so often ignored by all. I mean, consider how the soviets of the USSR succeeded in making that nation an economy to be reckoned with. And Chairman Mao's great leap forward was able to engineer a populace that succeeded in its grand goal of vaulting beyond the waste of the capitalist West. If only the industry of South Korea could prosper in the way that Kim Jong Il has guided his people into a paradise of plenty, then all Korean people could join hands in brotherhood.
- jives 17y agoSeriously, I would like to frame this post and put it on my wall :)
- olefoo 17y agoStrawman much? I'm pretty sure you're responding to someone who was thinking more of Denmark, Sweden or Canada. None of which are dystopian totalitarian societies that can't afford the political freedoms necessary to running a modern society. If that's the level of discourse you are sinking to, you are a sad example of what is happening to this country and this site. You should be ashamed of yourself. Right at the moment, the cost of health care and health care administration is crippling the American economy, it prevents many people from taking entrepreneurial risks because they can't afford to jeopardise their health coverage. The cost of health coverage and care and the financialization of the housing market are two of the factors most responsible for the disappearance of the middle class in this country. And if you're worried about the United States falling prey to disastrous political ideology the lack of a stable middle class is a far greater risk factor than socialized medicine.
- kiba 17y agoThe tensions are between centralized authorities(command economies) and individuals(free market) making decisions. The crux of the debate is whether the system should be centralized more or move toward individual human actors, whether these system could do better than the other, or whether it is something in between.(Ethical and political views are another story) I believe the pundit was arguing that the most extreme example clearly demonstrate the fallacy of using central planning to do resource allocation. Swedens, Denmark, and Canada are mixed economies which make it difficult to discern the effect of free market economies versus socialist system.
- gdp 17y agoErm, yeah, about that. You understand the the US is atypical in the way that it treats health care? The implication that pretty much the rest of the western world is communist because they ensure that everyone has access to at least some kind of health care is completely insane. You're using the "labelling it" technique, which is essentially, "If I can give a name to the thing I'm arguing against, then it's wrong!" (see what I just did there?) A legitimately elected government providing services that its citizens may choose to use or not use is not communism. It's also not nazism or the boogeyman. See, I would consider healthcare a much more basic service than a huge standing military, but nobody seems to question that that should be government-operated. The USSR also had a 100% government-operated military! Wow, so does China! And North Korea! And Iran! My word, the USA must be the most terrible country on earth!
- kiba 17y agoThen explain to me the mechanism by which the universial health care allocate resource? It is one thing to have a guranteed source of revenue via taxation, it is quite another to manages the allocation of resources more efficently than a free agent in a free market. Even in a socialist system, scarcity still exists. The free market have an obvious mechanism and it is called profit and loss.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoUniversal health care rations treatments based on medical need - the most serious medical needs get treatment first. Private health care rations treatments based on ability to pay. I know which rationing system I prefer - for both ethical and pragmatic reasons.
- ksvs 17y ago"the most serious medical needs get treatment first" If that's the definition of universal health care, no country I know has it, because there is no country I know of that has successfully banned cosmetic surgery.
- adw 17y agoTell that to a burns victim or a kid with a harelip. Or a breast-cancer patient post mastectomy...
- billswift 17y agoReconstructive surgery and cosmetic surgery are not the same thing even though they use similar, and often the same, techniques.
- adw 17y agoI think that might be a usage thing: over here in the UK they're both plastic surgery, but you see it qualified as reconstructive plastic surgery or aesthetic plastic surgery. Still, take birthmark removal: it's purely cosmetic, in a sense, but it makes such a difference to peoples' quality of life psychologically that it totally should be on the NHS if you ask me.
- philwelch 17y agoYou'd think so, but why is healthcare so different than everything else? Most human needs are cared for by markets, albeit with government assistance as needed. Why should the government centrally run a health care monopoly rather than simply giving financial assistance, as needed, to people to pay for health care on an open market? That's how we've accomplished "universal food".
- jimbokun 17y agoI believe the Netherlands does something like this.
- billswift 17y agoI'm not sure how accurate it is, but the description I saw of the Dutch system is that everyone has exactly the same plan for exactly the same costs, but the gov't does it through the fig-leaf of "private" insurance companies.
- stanleydrew 17y agoFirst of all I don't think Obama is suggesting setting up a health care monopoly. I think he's suggesting supplementing the private market with a government-provided option. As for how health care is different from everything else, it's very expensive sometimes, and society has kind of decided that everyone deserves a basic level of care regardless of the ability to pay. By that I mean people will generally respond negatively to a statement such as "If you can't afford it, you can't expect to receive treatment when you break your arm." In contrast I think it's pretty reasonable to say "If you can't afford it, you can't have a car." I don't think the government should run a health care monopoly, but there are significant flaws in the market system that require government intervention in many cases, and health care is certainly one of them.
- philwelch 17y agoPeople will respond negatively to "if you can't afford it, you can't eat". But the government doesn't run farms and groceries, not even by "supplementing the private market". They give you food stamps. Why can't the government give you healthcare vouchers? Why do they have to set up their own insurance plan?
- jimbokun 17y ago"The public then gets to use these facilities that they paid for at no cost" They paid for them, but there's no cost? I see what you mean, but you see what I mean, too, no?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- coffeemug 17y agoMedicaid users overuse the system because of unintended consequences of medicaid regulations. In order to continue being eligible for medicaid you have to prove that you have serious medical conditions. What would you do? It's simple game theory. From anecdotal evidence I can say that Medicaid costs could probably be reduced by a factor of ten if people weren't forced to participate in fraud.
- krying_krab 17y agoYou could have saved keystrokes by saying "I totally believe in the Capitalist version of Marx's Socialism-Wins theory. All socialist things will fall! MUAHAHAHA" Please, approach the debate with some sensibility or an eye to analysis. This isn't a debate of ideologies, this isn't Marx vs. Smith, this is real people trying to get real health care, and not being able to.
- sixspeed 17y agoWhen I was laid off a few months ago, I was told to call a Plan Administrator if I wanted to continue my health insurance plan out of my own pocket. Of course I wanted to - I've a family with 3 kids. When I called the woman she said she would send me the forms. The cost, she said, was around $600 per month for my Family Plan. "And let me give you some advice", she added. "If you are even one day late with a payment, your insurance will be canceled." "Don't be late with a payment." That $600 is right around my total Unemployment Compensation. So yeah, I've little interest in debates on ideologies. I doubt any of the windbags above would be interested either if they had to decide between providing healthcare insurance for their family or paying their mortgage.
- bitdiddle 17y agoWell don't lose hope. Look into a high deductible catastrophic policy that will cover you for the god forbid large events. That deduction requires you pay out of pocket for wellness care, visits for shots, strep throat, etc., but if you can buy one for a year out of savings it may be a cheaper option. Never underestimate the kindness of strangers and don't be ashamed to let your doctors know your situation. Offer to trade services, presumably your reading HN so you can work with computers. I know a good number of doctors who get a lot of severely discounted home maintenance services from folks who got free or reduced payments for care. But above all don't ever hesitate to sacrifice the mortgage payment for the sake of your children. They come first. You can swallow your pride and keep the mortgage and bank wolves away from the door for a good period of months by knowing a bit about the law. I agree with you about ideology. This "healthcare" debate is really about a lot of issues boiling over in our society and it's not really a debate or discussion. There seems to be no common sense left.
- cubicle67 17y agoFree healthcare will never survive... Except for all the free healthcare in numerous other countries, you mean?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]