6 ms·
Yet another major fuckup in the education space by Bill Gates. His flagship high school, which he wanted to model every other school in the nation after, litera
by Alex3917 13y ago
Yet another major fuckup in the education space by Bill Gates. His flagship high school, which he wanted to model every other school in the nation after, literally got shut down after having a graduation rate around 20%. And yet he has yet to pay even a dollar in reparations to all those kids whose lives he destroyed. Diane Ravitch has a good quote about the Gates foundation in her book:
"To advance its agenda, the Gates foundation increased its spending on advocacy. From 2005 to 2009, the foundation quadrupled its annual spending on advocacy to $78 million. Accord to Sam Dillon in the New York Times, the foundation will pump an addition $100 million into advocacy over the next five to six years. That kind of money buys a lot of advocacy and support. Gates funded the groups that wrote the Common Core standards, the groups that evaluated them, and the groups that advocated for them. Gates funded liberal groups such as Education Trust, centrist groups such as the Center for American Progress and the Center on Education Policy, and groups on the Right such as the American Enterprise Institute, the Thomas B. Fordham Foundation, Jeb Bush's Foundation of Educational Excellence, and the Media Bullpen. It funded groups that advocated for charter schools, such as the Education Equality project, and groups that argued against seniority and tenure, such as TeachFirst, TeachPlus, and the New Teacher Project. Kenneth Libby, then a graduate student known for poring through tax filings of foundations and advocacy groups, commented, 'It's easier to name which groups Gates doesn't support than to list all of those they do, because it's just so overwhelming.' [...]
Writing in Dissent, Joanne Barkan described the challenge that the aggressive venture philanthropists pose for American society:
'Can anything stop the foundation enablers? After five or ten more years, the mess they're making in public schooling might be so undeniable that they'll say, 'Oops, that didn't work' and step aside. But the damage might be irreparable: thousands of closed schools, worse conditions in those left open, an extreme degree of 'teaching to the test,' demoralized teachers, rampant corruption by private management companies, thousands of failed charter schools, and more low-income kids without a good education. Who could possibly clean up the mess?'"
If you want to read about what happened the last time billionaires got involved with the school system, John Taylor Gatto does a pretty decent job documenting it in his Underground History book.
- nopinsight 13y agoDo you have a reference about that supposed flagship high school with 20% graduation rate? I searched and couldn't find it. At least the info on why and how they failed would be useful to many education innovators here.
- Alex3917 13y agoYeah Ravitch talks about this in her Death and Life of the Great American School System book, in Chapter 10 on p. 207. That page and a bunch of the previous pages are available to read for free on Amazon. The basic gist though is that all the research shows that medium-sized high schools are the best for students, because they're big enough that students can find classes and activities (and friends) they're interested in, but not so big that they get lost. But despite this research Gates decided to make having extremely small high schools his main educational priority, with results that were basically exactly what the research previously suggested they would be.
- GabrielF00 13y agoI know a lot of big cities have implemented small schools by essentially breaking up big high schools and putting three or four smaller schools in the same building. How does this effect how small schools perform?
- nerfhammer 13y agoDoesn't mention the graduation rate but see the "The Small-Schools Movement" section of this article: http://nsmn1.uh.edu/dgraur/niv/TheMostDangerousEquation.pdf http://nsmn1.uh.edu/dgraur/niv/TheMostDangerousEquation.pdf
- Alex3917 13y agoIt looks like that's just about one study. If you want an overview of the research, grab a copy of Riordan's book Equality and Achievement, or else Hattie's book Visible Learning.
- 13y ago