3 ms·
False dichotomy, there are avenues of research that are outside of the traditional academy (and the 'new tradition' of state-funded science) and outside of indu
by dnautics 13y ago
False dichotomy, there are avenues of research that are outside of the traditional academy (and the 'new tradition' of state-funded science) and outside of industry. For example, Janelia Farms, run by HHMI. As I alluded to above, historically, Peter D. Mitchell's work (which garnered him a nobel prize), as well.
The story of how state-run science funding is broken is exemplified by the story of Douglas Prasher.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_Prasher https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_Prasher
- Fomite 13y agoSingle stories, while meaningful and often illustrative, are not particularly powerful ways of illustrating how a system is broken. And YC talking about funding startups in Biotech is talking about industry science, so calling is a "false dichotomy" is a little absurd.
- 001sky 13y agoIt's not a false dichotomy in the context of the discussion here. The 'bets' alluded to in the title are financial bets. And the first screen of any bet is "how big is the market" etc. In Academia science, the "market" is simply prestige...in "VC" backed systems, the market is simply "money". Basically everything in academic <as a system> is geared to polishing a reputation/presitge of the sponsoring institution. That prestige is the currency that allows the various non-profit entities to raise more money (ie, make money) so even this "prestige" is just another "invisible hand" of the market for donation or tax dollars. The marketing and propoganda around fundraising for universities, foundations, or tax-based government funding sources is "achieving our mission"...and the measurement of the execution along that front ("success"!) is the <term of art> called "prestige". As your story points out, "prestige", and the money that accrues to it, is only loosely correlated with "the truth" or "good science"...{etc}.
- dekhn 13y agoI wouldn't describe Janelia Farms as outside the traditional academy. It's just a foundation with great facilities and an extremely high bar to entry, but a low bar for continued funding.
- Fomite 13y agoEspecially as many HHMI scientists, both within and outside Janelia had very strong careers within "traditional academy" first.