5 ms·
I'm curious, how does it compare to Java with a good IDE (eg. Eclipse or IntelliJ)? One thing I really missed when I abandoned the Java world and went to C++/P
by nostrademons 13y ago
I'm curious, how does it compare to Java with a good IDE (eg. Eclipse or IntelliJ)?
One thing I really missed when I abandoned the Java world and went to C++/Python was the refactoring and formatting tools available in the IDE. I could set it up so it'd auto-format my code on save, so that I could rename methods with a single keystroke, so that I could pull out classes or add getters/setters, so that I could add parameters, etc. I know Go supports some of that through gofmt and go fix, but I'm curious if anyone is both an experienced Java dev and an experienced Go dev and can compare the continued maintenance costs of the two.
BTW, I would put the productivity premium of Go over Python at about 50%-2x, not 10%. I did a mid-size (~6 man-months, though much of that time went into interactions with other teams) green-field prototype in Go at Google, and found myself really missing constructs like list comprehensions, dynamic typing, strong support for literal data, ability to treat user-defined types just like the built-ins, etc. I do think you'll make some of that back in continued maintenance - I actually really enjoyed working with Go - but I didn't experience the claims of "Go is just as good as Python for prototyping", as someone with a fair amount of Python experience.
- MBlume 13y agoDoesn't Go come with an executable that reformats .go files to a canonical format?
- nostrademons 13y agoThat's the gofmt tool that we're all talking about.
- micro_cam 13y agoThe availible go ide's are still young but go includes a lot of really nice tooling in the core distribution. The gofmt tool enforces a canonical format for go code and I have sublime text set up (via gosublime) to reformat on save and use the gocode autocomplete/linting daemnon. Gofmt is actually one of my favorite parts about go and I feel that it, along with the simple documentation system and godoc.org save me a ton of time making my code ready for others to read/use. The code base behind gofmt and gofix can also be used for other tools, i haven't felt the need for a powerful refactoring tool but I'm sure one will show up eventually. I do miss list comprehensions and operator overloading but I understand the dev's arguments against those.
- stcredzero 13y agomissing constructs like list comprehensions, dynamic typing, strong support for literal data, ability to treat user-defined types just like the built-ins, etc. Of those, I only see comprehensions as something that's severely lacking, though I am not a Python guru by any measure. Dynamic typing: Go has duck typing, which gives some of the same benefits. Different refactoring strategies that take advantage of duck typing over other things you'd do with dynamic languages (like just substituting an object of a different type willy-nilly) will probably make up for the rest. I don't see strong support for literal data as a big productivity gain. Go also does a rather good job of treating user defined types like the built-ins and vice-versa, with a few exceptions like maps. I didn't experience the claims of "Go is just as good as Python for prototyping", as someone with a fair amount of Python experience. A lot of your competence with Python for prototyping probably has to do with your competence with Python. A lot of the advantage of Go is what it doesn't have. It's a much simpler system, so it's easier to design around, especially as one needs to get closer to the metal.
- nostrademons 13y agoThe use-case for dynamic typing was that I was decoding a large JSON data structure that could easily have thousands of different fields nested 10+ levels deep. Go's standard json library usually recommends that you define a struct type to hold the result of the decode, tagging field names with the `json` annotation. This obviously doesn't work when you only care about a few dozen of the several thousand possible fields. There is fortunately an escape hatch where you can declare a field as interface{} to say "Any type of data goes here; I'll downcast it later, and just trust me on the type", but then you have to litter your code with downcasts. Python just hands you back a dict of lists, and you pull out the information you want, no type declarations needed. The "user-defined types like built-ins" lets you build libraries where you can use the basic language structures on the data structure itself, without having to convert to an intermediate form. For example, the Python bindings to Amazon S3 let you access files through dictionary notation. BeautifulSoup lets you iterate over child nodes with a for loop, or access attributes as a dict. NumPy lets you use standard arithmetic operators on matrices. Judicious use of this in libraries makes the resulting code much briefer.
- jbooth 13y agoExperienced Java and Go dev here. On formatting, gofmt is awesome. There's an IDE called LiteIDE which automatically calls gofmt for you, or you can just run it yourself whenever. Additionally, because there's deliberately no room to customize gofmt, you don't have to spend time in pointless meetings when "that guy" decides it's time to rewrite your company eclipse templates and argue over all the minutiae. As far as refactoring, nobody's built an IDE integration that comes close to eclipse/IDEA for that as far as I know. It's totally doable in Go, in a way that it wouldn't be for Python (yay types), but I don't think anyone's done it. On the upside, doing it manually is less painful than it would be in typical Java code, due to type inference and having less code to begin with.
- kasey_junk 13y agogofmt is the single biggest feature of Go that might make me try it out. Such a great idea, I wish every language would adopt it.
- nostrademons 13y agoA lot have: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7600130 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7600130
- michaelmior 13y agoThis isn't the same. Go defines a standard format for all code written in Go with nothing left up to programmer opinion. While a lot of great formatting tools exist for other languages, they require choices to be made which inevitably results in disagreement.
- to3m 13y agoIf you use C# in Visual Studio, you can press Ctrl+K, Ctrl+D to have the entire document reformatted. Surprisingly few people seem to know about this, judging by how often I've found myself using this on other people's source files and had everything shift around. (Or maybe I'm just unusual and everybody else has just played with the settings.) The reformatting is actually quite aggressive (it will add/remove blanks and move braces and bits of code around), and so does a good job of keeping everybody's code looking consistent. The Visual Studio text editing functionality only occasionally reaches even the lofty heights of "pretty good", but I do think the document reformatting actually even exceeds that. (Shame the settings are are per-user rather than per-project, but there you go. It wouldn't be Visual Studio if they didn't manage to fuck something up at the last moment.)
- jaimeyap 13y agoThere is actually a decent open source, third party Go plugin for Intellij that works pretty well. Our team has been using it successfully on a fairly large project. It's slightly annoying to setup, but absolutely worth it.