6 ms·
Dept of Health and Human Services spends $146 per month per user for email [pdf]
- rodrodrod 13y agoRelevant bit (footnote 8 on pg. 4): HHS told us that HHS pays $146.64 per month per user for e-mail; that this charge covers connect ivity, storage, and other e-mail services; and that this charge is independent of the number of e-mails that are sent or received. HHS also told us that the Office of the Secretary pays $10.44 per month per telephone line, that this charge covers all featu res associated with the lines and the phones, and that this charge is independent of the number of phone calls made per month. Each phone call, whether local or long distance, is charged at a unit cost of $0.014 per minute. I wonder what the breakdown of the costs is. That number seems way steep.
- frankydp 13y agoIf I was to guess a little. -Email Certificate -Outlook License -Online Outlook license -Remote VPN services and remote dialup + support Which is a big pile of money off the top. -Help Desk -Hardware/Cloud storage and what not, probably a small portion.
- cdcarter 13y agoLet's all just hope that "connectivity" includes internet access and a workstation for that user as a whole?
- a3n 13y agoThey probably have specific requirements. They may or may not be worthwhile. They may or may not make sense. But any vendor is going to satisfy those requirements, and charge for knowing, implementing and demonstrating those requirements.
- vidarh 13y agoMy first question would be what archival requirements they have for e-mail. Some governments have legal requirements for incoming official mail - whether on paper or electronic - to be printed off and stamped with the time and date, and manually entered into a journal and archived in multiple copies in separate locations for audit and open access purposes. Others may "just" require an electronic journal, but tend to still have very strict requirements on access, and particular security mechanisms to prevent modification of the journal. Archival requirements can easily make up the vast majority of cost of processing mail if the rules are complicated enough. Depending on the extent of "unusual" requirements like that, it may not be that bad. In any case, without more details about exactly what is included it's not very easy to assess whether or not the cost is unreasonable...
- rdtsc 13y agoWelcome to the world of government contracting. There is lots of money to be made in this area if you know how/who to talk to, and the red tape to jump through. Lockheed, L3 and Northrop, make a pretty penny, along with many many bottom feeders (some hiding behind a shell companies that fit labels like "disable business veteran" owner or other such preferential categories). It is a multi-billion dollar world, with its own rules, players, business cycles, customers, marketing and so on. You get to use exciting technologies such as Window Vista (still XP up until not too long ago) and RHEL 4 and 5.
- colinbartlett 13y agoI had a government customer once. And they had another vendor I met which was "owned" by a woman. But the real operator of the business made no bones about the fact the the entire thing was setup in his wife's name solely in order to enable contracting with said government agency.
- re_todd 13y agoYeah, I know a couple that is "owned" by the woman to get government contracts. She basically does light human resources stuff while her husband runs the business.
- cfontes 13y agoI don't live in th US so this is not clear to me. Could you explain why would they do that?
- WalterSear 13y agoAffirmative action requirements.
- malyk 13y agoThe government has certain contract set asides to help various types of companies get contracts. It's basically like affirmative action for contracting (vary broadly speaking). Basically if you have a female/minority/veteran owned company you can sometimes get a leg up in the procurement process. The government also has these things for size of the business and I'm sure many other categories.
- JumpCrisscross 13y agoMy first job out of college was at a large investment bank. As a trader, I spent much of my time on the phone. I remember discovering that we paid several hundreds of dollars a month for those lines. The contract was signed in the seventies and nobody had thought to revisit it. That is a story about how sensible constructs drift apart over time. Splitting costs into line items is difficult and expensive. Sometimes it isn't worth the hassle. If the HHS overpaid for email but underpaid for something else, that is okay for now. Cost-effectiveness should be calculated on the aggregate for complex contracts.
- pmorici 13y agoI can pretty much guarantee that this is some government contracting company taking advantage of the government's quirks to overcharge. Not some oversight in a contract no one has reviewed in 20 years.
- sliverstorm 13y agoThe contract was signed in the seventies and nobody had thought to revisit it. Or perhaps it hadn't been worthwhile to revisit it?
- mschuster91 13y ago> Or perhaps it hadn't been worthwhile to revisit it? With public agencies, big companies, medics and anyone associated with higher salaries comes one thing: consultants and service providers WILL bill you until a normal person's eyes would bleed. Only that in some spheres, a) decisionmakers don't worry about money and b) they don't worry about money even more when you fill them up with tasty buzzwords.
- grecy 13y agoI work for a small Telco. We charge two state governments ~$10k a month each for ~200 phone lines. They both pay well over $25k/month for Internet - and it's about 50 5Mbps DSL lines, with capped usage. This is today.
- 13y ago
- source99 13y agoWho are they paying $146 / month for email?
- jliptzin 13y agoCompuServe
- pmorici 13y agoIf you've ever worked for or with the government this isn't shocking news. In fact I also wouldn't be surprised to find that their email is also unreliable. There just isn't much accountability with these things it's a HUGE problem. I don't know what the solution is.
- jeffdavis 13y ago"I don't know what the solution is." Not have such a massive federal government that is always spending other people's money? When people spend their own money, they often find much more efficient use of it.
- pmorici 13y agoYeah, sure, but we all know it is inevitable the government is going to spend some money so as a practical matter just cutting government doesn't really address the problem of making the remaining parts more efficient.
- jeffdavis 13y agoThe smaller the government (or any entity) the fewer things look like a "drop in the bucket that's not worth looking at". So reducing the size of government will (I believe) increase the efficiency.
- pmorici 13y agoI think you misunderstand the fundamental problem. Even if the Federal government were cut by 50% in terms of $ spent it would still be massive. they wouldn't all of a sudden have an epiphany and realize they were being ripped off by all these beltway bandits. They would just do less stuff in the same inefficient way. You might feel better about it because you would be paying lower taxes but the taxes you are paying would still be spent inefficiently.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago
- damian2000 13y agoThere's some data on the FY2011 contracts available here http://www.hhs.gov/grants/servicecontractsfy11.html http://www.hhs.gov/grants/servicecontractsfy11.html CSV (a few mb): http://www.hhs.gov/grants/hhsfy11scinventory-c.csv http://www.hhs.gov/grants/hhsfy11scinventory-c.csv
- pmorici 13y agoLooks like "Lockheed Martin Services" might be the company providing their IT. They have 3 contracts with HHS totaling over $200 million described as, "CONSOLIDATED INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY INFRASTRUCTURE CONTRACT" http://www.hhs.gov/about/smallbusiness/smallbusiness/pdf/cms.pdf http://www.hhs.gov/about/smallbusiness/smallbusiness/pdf/cms... Edit: It looks like the 200 million is only for IT services for the Center for Medicare and Medicaid so HHS as a whole probably spends even more on IT.
- nppc 13y agoHey startups, stop wasting your time on those crazy mashups and 'Yet another XYZ clone with a twist'. Try getting a Govt contract or two !
- technotheory 13y agoAs someone who is working with HHS in their innovation fellowship, I'd like to point out that HHS is very much moving to lower their email costs. I'm not certain the public information available, but much has happened since this information here was published: http://www.federalnewsradio.com/536/3384131/HHS-pacing-its-move-to-the-cloud http://www.federalnewsradio.com/536/3384131/HHS-pacing-its-m... Any high price for HHS mailboxes is related to the fact that there are several agencies with different rates (NIH, CDC, FDA, ACF, HRSA, etc are all part of the departmental umbrella of HHS) and some likely have different (and not as competitive) rates. My guess is that the rate quoted above is from one of the smaller agencies with a less competitively negotiated rate...but that's only an educated guess because if I knew the exact numbers I wouldn't comment on them publicly. What's worth noting here though is that HHS is well aware of their costs, and if the procurement documents referenced above are any indication, then they are working to actively address this.