9 ms·
The limits of "unlimited" vacation
- ChuckMcM 13y agoWe have a pretty flexible vacation policy and I've observed one person (no longer with the company) who was pretty abusive of that policy. That persons behavior definitely had a negative effect on other's perception of them. There is a certain type of person who will push the limit for the limit's sake. And they will inspired others to push it. Have you sat in a line of cars with a shoulder open, when somebody decides "hey I'm just going to pass everyone on the shoulder" and once they decide that a bunch of other people jump out into the shoulder because they don't want to be "chumps" waiting while some "not chump" gets away with driving on the shoulder? Group dynamics can have a huge effect on these sorts of policies (for good and bad).
- brownbat 13y agoWe're essentially swapping simple guidelines for a test of people's ability to correctly judge social mores. There's an ideal number of days of vacation per year. We aren't going to tell you what that is, but if you guess incorrectly, everyone will hate you. Good luck! This is why I also prefer signs on the road saying either "stay in your lane" or "merge now." Why coordinate behavior by instinct when we have all these nice methods of communication?
- afterburner 13y agoNo I haven't seen that while driving, because passing on the shoulder feels dangerous enough and you usually can't get ahead of the jam that way.
- j79 13y agoBefore I moved to California, I lived in a state where passing in the breakdown lane (during certain hours) was permitted. I had coworkers who were unaware of this rule and felt those passing were "jerks". Even explaining that it wasn't illegal, they still felt they were "jerks" for not waiting with everyone else... I guess it's similar to lane splitting by motorcycles. Moving from a state where this is illegal to one where it's legal was a shock (although I see a ton of people lane splitting at insanely dangerous speeds...)
- afterburner 13y agoI admit I've never heard of legal shoulder passing (other than obvious common-sense exceptions).
- baddox 13y agoThat surprises me. I've seen it dozens of times, so much so that not really notable.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoHacker news has an American/west Europe bias. It is definitely common in many third world countries, especially by elites.
- baddox 13y agoBut I've seen it dozens of times in the USA.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoBeijing China speaking, ya it does work. The black Audi's use the breakdown lane often to get around traffic, it's dangerous and they don't get tickets.
- baddox 13y agoDid anyone warn that employee that they were considered to be abusing the policy? If not, then that's horrible, and I won't blame that employee at all. If so, then why not count how many days of vacation that employee took before it was considered abuse, and just set that as the vacation policy?
- badman_ting 13y agoYes, agreed. If you have unlimited vacation it shouldn't really make sense to talk about someone "abusing" the policy. You might say that someone takes so much vacation that they don't actually contribute any value to the company, that would make sense to me. There are lots of ways of failing to contribute value, and that would be one of them.
- lnanek2 13y agoHe advocates tracking so everyone can take equal amounts...that kind of removes the whole point of people taking as much as they need, which will be different for everyone. I think he completely misses the concept that the manager right above the employee is going to see everything and talk to the employee if there is a performance problem anyway. It's not like you can fire someone without paperwork indicating that anyway nowadays.
- ulfw 13y ago'Unlimited' vacation is the biggest BS trend ever. How is it unlimited? Can I take 365/6 days a year off? No? Well - then it's NOT unlimited, is it? Can I take 100 days off? No - most likely I'll lose my job then. How about 50 days? Can I take 50 off? Nope. Highly doubt I'd still be part of the team/company then. How about 20? That's not much, right? Little 4 week vacation in SE Asia or so? No? We have deadline? Team 'depends' on me? Hm... Unlimited... riiiiight
- umanwizard 13y agoThe Netflix slide deck makes it clear that the company seeks to reward performance only, not poor proxies for performance like number of days worked. So if you took 100 days off, yet were still as useful to the team as the guy who didn't take any, you'd be treated the same way as him in reviews. Whether this is possible is up to you. Also, having not worked at Netflix or Heroku, I can't speak to how well it works out in practice.
- petilon 13y agoThe problem is that it is often very hard even for experienced managers to guess how long a software development task should take. So you do end up measuring proxies such as how many hours a day you have been working, plus your reputation and so on.
- overgard 13y agoEstimation is hard, but, In most places I worked, after a couple of days it was very obvious which people were the solid contributors and which people were just along for the ride. Granted, those jobs were in the trenches where I was working along side people so I would see what they were doing day in and out, but I think that if you're a programmer, it's pretty obvious whose productive and who isn't.
- baddox 13y agoIf there is a candid performance tracking system in place, I don't think any of our complaints about vacation policy would hold. But a candid performance tracking system is probably at least as difficult to implement as an "unlimited" vacation policy. How do you quantify individual performance? How do you decide what the minimum acceptable performance is? What do you do if one employee has 1.5x the performance of another?
- georgespencer 13y agoWe have unlimited vacation at Rentify. Actually the policy is "take enough vacation to avoid burnout, we don't count the days". The expectation established when people join is that if work is being done, we don't care if you take a few extra days of vacation. The policy exists because I was once declined an extra vacation day by a company I worked at which meant I had to take a flight costing an additional $150. The extra day they got out of me in the office was my least productive day of all time. Vacation time is still approved by a line manager and is occasionally still declined. Generally people act in the company's best interests but sometimes we have to give context on why we can't allow a holiday. The policy gets tricky when people leave the business, because we have to have a formula to explain to them what the calculation is for their remaining holiday pay. We try to be generous here and not simply take the UK statutory minimum (iirc 28 days). One person asked for ∞ accrued vacation days to be paid back to them which gave us a fun conversation about the difference between "infinite" and "unlimited".
- JimmyL 13y agoIf you don't count the days, how do you make sure that people are taking/compensated for the statutory minimum - or do you mean "we count the days, but we don't say no just because your count is above a specific number"?
- georgespencer 13y agoThe latter -- but "we don't count the days" is catchier :)
- icelancer 13y agoThat's also disingenuous.
- crystaln 13y ago"Generally people act in the company's best interests" This is exactly the reason this policy is bad. People need to act in their own interest and take vacation they need, which may not be in the company's best interest. Your language here is a huge red flag for this policy. This policy presumes, incorrectly, that what is good the employee is good for the company. While that is sometimes true, it is often not true. The basic premise and expectation is that people should take only as much time off as they need to remain good little not burnt out workers. That is not something I agree with.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoArticle advises setting policies about what is normal, and then tracking. How does this resemble an 'unlimited' policy in any way? It's nearly what we have at every company now: a company vacation policy. No, instead I'd advise setting a vacation minimum ("Everybody has to chill for 2 weeks minimum!"), then saying "take more if family contingencies come up" such as debate tournaments, sick parent etc.
- eli 13y agoRAND Corp pays employees extra for days they take off. Though of course it's therefore tracked.
- cyberpanther 13y agoMy experience with unlimited time off is that it almost always still needs to be approved by your superior so whether it works or not depends on her. This is means you can have widely varied results. I like your suggestions but they inch closer to just having a set policy on PTO. So my suggestion is just be generous with PTO but have a limit. If you don't have a set limit then people who are intimidated by their superior will always ask for too little PTO. Set the social norm in your company and don't make it so up in the air. Open vacation policies kind of feel like the theory behind offices with cubicals and open office spaces. Open offices and cubicals were originally created to encourage collaboration between employees by tearing down walls between people. Sounds good right! In practice this doesn't work because people are scared of being too loud or of interrupting other employees. I worked in an open office for a while, and it was horrible. It was such a boring place because everyone was trying to be so polite not to make noise for others. I would love to see some numbers on whether open vacation policies encourage or discourage people to take more vacation. It may be positive now, but I have a feeling as it gets implemented by bigger companies it will turn into the cubical of our generation. Office Space 2, The Endless Vacation? You heard it hear first!
- snowwrestler 13y agoFinancial companies force certain employees to take 2 uninterrupted weeks off. This is to reduce fraud--to get the employee out of the system so they auditors can look for irregularities. But if course it's a great way to force otherwise driven people to check out for long enough to reduce burnout. Some companies also close entirely at times--usually the week between Christmas and New Years, but I have heard of a few places that pick a week in the spring or summer to close.
- cwp 13y agoI wonder what would happen if vacation time were tracked and made public (within the company). I'm sure outliers would come under social pressure to conform to group norms, but it'd be interesting to see where the norm stabilized. It probably depends a lot on other aspects of company culture.
- JimmyL 13y agoIt depends on the jurisdiction, but a lot of the "guideline amount + tracking" philosophy is driven by the law (and financial accounting). For example, here's an except from some guidelines around the Ontario Employment Standards Act: Employers are required to keep records of the vacation time earned since the date of hire but not taken before the start of the vacation entitlement year, the vacation time earned and vacation time taken (if any) during the vacation entitlement year (or stub period), and the balance of vacation time remaining at the end of the vacation entitlement year (or stub period). So at least in Ontario, your employer is legally obligated to record your vacation time each year, and on demand, produce a report on it. There are also rules around when an employee has to take their vacation by, for example: The vacation time earned with respect to a completed vacation entitlement year or a stub period must be taken within 10 months following the completion of the vacation entitlement year or stub period. The employer has the right to schedule vacation as well as an obligation to ensure the vacation time is scheduled and taken before the end of that ten-month period. Since Ontario is also a jurisdiction with legally-mandated vacation time, at any point in time the vacation that an employee has accrued but not yet taken (or has rolled over from another year) should also be recorded as a liability on a company's books, since it could be forced to pay out the equivalent vacation pay (if the employee leaves, for example). The obvious way to get around this - and I've seen it done in a few places - is to pay everyone their full statutory vacation pay every year and then not count the vacation days taken, but that's basically giving everyone a 4% raise, and isn't even an option in some jurisdictions. All of this is to say that unlimited and untracked vacations may not even be a legal option everywhere, regardless of what we think of them.
- pbreit 13y agoAnd this is why we need less government.
- walshemj 13y agoAgreed employment law should be reformed and have one binding federal set of employment laws instead of 52 state + Federal Laws. with say 4 weeks stautory leave plus public holidays. Of course thise meas a few less jobs for HR and lawyers but hey thats what you call a win win suitation.
- rdl 13y agoI think I'd be happiest with 4-12 weeks of "vacation" per year, but in a way which is minimally disruptive to the company. This isn't necessarily part of the "unlimited" aspect of vacation, but can be related. 1) Flexibility to take short vacations whenever there isn't anything to be done at work. This doesn't often happen in an early startup, but it's not too uncommon in a larger company to have a day or two where there is some external block. If you can work from home or otherwise be on email, there's no particular reason to just sit in the office that day. 2) I personally count most conferences, even when speaking, as vacation -- even if the company is paying expenses. Essentially, if it's something I'd go to myself, I'm happy to be going on the company dime, and it serves a lot of the purpose of vacation. 3) When long distance travel is involved, I'd usually strongly prefer to take a day or two before/after as vacation, particularly if it's somewhere interesting (which, for me, could be a lot of places). Sometimes this is at employee expense, but there are a lot of cases in consulting where flying someone back for the weekend is more expensive than paying for a weekend hotel. "Be reasonable" seems like the best policy for the expense part, but if you don't have kids or another reason to go home on the weekend, why not spend the weekend in Berlin or LA or something? (relatedly, I'm willing to use my frequent flyer miles to help the company on travel when it's expensive, in exchange for getting to use preferred carriers when the price isn't unreasonable.) 4) In ops, it's often useful to have people show up on weekends (for a consumer service, sure, you can push updates on Tuesday at 9am, but for enterprise stuff, weekend upgrades are actually pretty common); offering 1:1 comp time for that is the baseline, but I'd probably go to 2:1 or 3:1. Similarly with covering emergencies (higher premium if unscheduled) or holidays (I personally love working on most holidays, but if I had to get someone else to do it, I'd expect to pay at least 3 days of vacation per day).
- tptacek 13y agoIt seems like there's no reason companies can't do both: have an official good-as-money PTO allocation for employees, like most companies do, and have the policy that employees can take any reasonable number of vacation days. That policy works exactly like "unlimited vacation", while also (a) maintaining a minimum annual number of days that every employee is entitled to, regardless of how their team is managed, and (b) provides a fair cash payout when the employee leaves. This may be all the author is arguing for; I can't quite tell. Unless there's some legal reason this policy can't work, the absence of a formal allocation of vacation days in an "unlimited vacation" policy would fail a sniff test for me --- your policy might be "unlimited" as a devious way of not committing to any particular number of vacation days. (Full disclosure: we just do a normal accrued vacation day policy.)
- munificent 13y ago> have an official good-as-money PTO allocation for employees, like most companies do, and have the policy that employees can take any reasonable number of vacation days. This is google's policy except that the latter bucket is non-vacation time off. Vacation -- time off work for your own enjoyment -- is tracked using regular PTO. If you're sick, need to wait for a delivery, have a dentist's appointment, had some errands run long, etc., that's all untracked. I really like the policy. If vacation was untracked, what that means is that it would be effectively be socially tracked. There would be informal mores about how much you can take, and people would spend time observing how much their coworkers take to get an idea of what an "OK" amount is. I think that would be stressful and likely lead to vacation shaming. At the same time, it really makes my life simpler to be able to schedule appointments whenever it's convenient and not have to worry about "stealing" time from work or having to think about burning PTO on it. In practice, I haven't seen abuse of the policy.
- eitally 13y agoThis is how most exempt jobs work in the US. Paid vacation but untracked personal time. generally speaking, untracked overtime offsets the cash value of the benefit, which is sort of the point.
- 13y ago
- thelastpizza 13y agoThis seems like a great way to avoid giving accumulated vacation time when someone leaves the company.
- throwaway58142 13y agoThis is a great article with some interesting proposals. It mirrors my experience with the "unlimited" vacation policy at my cargo-cult startup employer quite strongly. The article didn't touch on one of the biggest selling points for pseudo-unlimited vacation policies at startups: It frees the company from having to account for and, depending on state laws, compensate employees for unused vacation time. Unused vacation time is a financial liability in many circumstances, so pretending you don't track vacation time frees you from owing employees any extra compensation when they leave. Also, it makes your job offers appear more attractive in comparison to other companies' offers. Unlimited vacation time, in theory, is more desirable than even a generous offer with 5 weeks of vacation time. Unlimited > limited. In theory. Honestly, after deeply burning out within a company with a supposedly unlimited vacation policy, I wish we had just had a defined and tracked vacation policy. We're allowed unlimited vacation, as long as we don't have any big outstanding tasks to finish. The catch is that we're a startup trying to accomplish too much with too few people, so everyone is always too busy to take vacation. This has all sorts of unexpected consequences that leave the company worse off in the long run. Smart employees quickly learn that taking on new responsibilities will quickly lock them out of taking vacation time. The solution? Don't take on new responsibilities so you can justify vacation time when you need to. Meanwhile, a few bad apples will always exploit the unlimited vacation policy, leaving the remaining employees with more work. Naturally, this makes the remaining employees even less able to take the vacation they need. To make matters worse, management responded by strongly and publicly discouraging any use of vacation rather than addressing the few people who abuse the system. Compounding our problems, the new unspoken anti-vacation sentiment from management drives everyone to conceal their vacation plans until the last minute. If you announce your intent to take vacation a month from now, that gives management an entire month to come up with reasons to deny your vacation. But if you announce on Thursday that you'll be out all next week and the flights are already booked, there isn't much that can be done. As a result, we have to scramble to make ends meet every time someone disappears for 1-3 weeks without notice. And of course, management tightens the strings even further on anyone who formally asks for vacation time in advance because we're already short-handed due to other's vacation. Finally, the unlimited vacation policy is strongly at odds with our management's strong stance against any form of working from home. Those of us who aren't disappearing at the last minute for 3 week vacations to foreign countries have attempted to alleviate the resulting burnout by working from home a few days per week. Management clamped down on that as well, demanding that we spend our days physically in the office. As a result, it's now more advantageous to not work at all than it is to work from home for a couple days each week because working from home is taboo while spontaneous unlimited vacation doesn't actually conflict with policy. Burn out abounds. Those who need vacations never have the opportunity to take it or feel too guilty to force it. Those who need to work harder are M.I.A. all the time. Employees are choosing to switch companies or quit outright as the strings are tightened further on working from home or actually taking time off. In short, poor management and the resulting unintended consequences and misaligned incentives from a poorly executed unlimited vacation policy can have disastrous effects on the well-being of the team. Like any management-style fad, it must be implemented with attention to the details. Cargo-cult implementation that cherry-picks only the pieces that are convenient to the company (no tracking, better sounding offers, less financial liability) will quickly burn out employees as the unfair elements of the system come to dominate. This article has some interesting suggestions that I would love to see implemented by my company, though.
- nraynaud 13y agoI would do a simplified minimal french system: five week paid, and if you want more, it's unpaid. The boss approves the vacation, but in a collective code ownership, that helps the bus size.
- 7Figures2Commas 13y ago"Unlimited vacation" is largely an accounting trick. Unused PTO is an accrued liability on a balance sheet. By replacing PTO with "unlimited vacation", companies are simply eliminating this liability from their balance sheets. When you have a large, highly-paid workforce, this adds up.
- logn 13y agoAbsolutely true. I used to work at a company that was begging us to use our PTO because it was impacting the books too much.
- afterburner 13y agoJust offer 5 weeks of vacation minimum already (or more). Fixes the burnout problem, satisfies those who like vacations.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoI find it an unnecessary gimmick that leads to complications (some of them mentioned in the article), especially in countries that already have a considerable amount tightly regulated vacation days. (I.e., every Western country besides the US.). For instance the legal obligation to pay out remaining vacation days if someone leaves means you have agree on a number and keep track of them. In practice, 25 days vacation (with the option to save at least some of them up over time) is more than enough for most people, and you'll be hard pressed getting most motivated workers to actually use them all up. Especially if you are a decent employer that allows people to work from home if convenient and doesn't deduct vacation time for trivial matters.
- walshemj 13y agoActualy in the UK employers can and do enforce a use it or lose it - Reed Elsiveer for example did not alow any carry over. And its common to limt the carry over to a week.
- 6cxs2hd6 13y agoI often found it discouraging to contemplate how much time and energy is spent thinking and arguing about PTO (paid time off) policies. It turns everyone into a FlyerTalk forum member. Worrying about how to game the system, or prevent it from being gamed. Worrying that someone else is getting a better deal. It's a huge time and morale suck. Sometimes I wonder how much of the problem is the "P" in PTO. When you're paid not to work, you're effectively getting a bonus -- being paid more for the time you do work. This also makes it a hot button for labor law -- if you leave with unused PTO, you need to be paid for it. Because it was never really about the time off. It was about the money. Instead, what about simply having "UTO" -- unpaid time off? Take as much time as you need or want. Everyone will understand you're not getting something "extra" they're not getting. You're simply choosing to work somewhat less and to be paid somewhat less. And to be clear, if an organization switched from PTO to UTO, they should give a one-time equivalent raise to make people whole. I definitely don't claim this will resolve all the issues (humans in an organization will always find something upsetting). But wouldn't it eliminate a very big chunk of the ill will?
- callahad 13y agoA UTO plan sounds enticing, but it wouldn't address individuals who are reluctant to take time off at all, leading to burnout. This is listed as Jacob's first "Con." Perhaps a combination? A minimum number of annually expiring PTO days, with an open policy of UTO beyond that?
- Fishkins 13y agoI agree this would be a major problem. It's one of the biggest problems listed with unlimited vacation, and that's when you're still getting money for it. I think the underlying problem is the conflation of hours worked with value to the company. I think most people will be more productive for a company working reasonable hours for at most 50 weeks a year than working all 52 (minus holidays in both cases). Accordingly, I think it is appropriate for a company to pay you to not work some of the time. I think that fits with your suggestion pretty well: give an employee 4 weeks PTO (or whatever you think will optimize their productivity and happiness), with the option to take more UTO that might not be an upside for the company. edit: There should probably still be some reasonable cap on the additional UTO. Not pay their salary during vacation still doesn't account for fixed costs like health insurance and office space. In practice I don't think most people would take enough UTO for this to be a real issue, especially with the work culture in the U.S.
- nawitus 13y agoFor starters, there should be unlimited sick days. In fact, that's the norm in most Western countries, but not in the United States.
- michaelochurch 13y agoThis is in stark contrast to the trend of lumping both sick time and time off into a single limited “PTO” bucket. Having an unlimited budget of time off means you don’t have to worry about “banking” time in case you get sick. Those policies are fucked-up. It's Enron-style accounting, a way for a company to say, "we offer 15 days off" while lying through its fucking teeth. Counting sick days against vacation is evil. By effectively forcing people to come into work when ill and making the whole office sick, they're fucking with my health (and everyone's, most of all the people who are already sick and deserve rest). Companies that have that pooled "PTO" bucket end up with people getting more colds because sick people come in to work. So, even though people are in the office more days, nothing gets done all winter. Like most mean-spirited HR policies, the bulk effect on productivity is negative, but it enables HR douches to look like they're saving money while externalizing costs to the rest of the company. Whoever came up with that "innovation" deserves to be sold into Roose Bolton's captivity. If unseen opportunities or obligations come up – invited to speak abroad? Companies that expect people to count conferences against vacation time should be burned to the ground. (Figuratively speaking, of course, or literally but only at 2:30 am when no one is in the building.) Professional development is part of the fucking job, assholes. If you're a scrappy startup and can't pay for conferences, that's one thing. Making people take vacation to go is just mean-spirited and horrible. What there should be is: (1) two week mandatory vacation, every year. Banks have this, to prevent repeats of the SocGen disaster. (2) 4 weeks vacation. That should establish 4 weeks as "the norm". If people need more, they can take time unpaid. If they use a little less, they can carry it over. (3) sick time unlimited. If you suspect abuse, ask for a damn doctor's note. (4) no vacation penalty for conferences related to the job. (5) no stigma against unpaid leave, which should be unlimited as long as it doesn't directly hurt the company. (Obviously, the CEO can't take 3 months off without pay.) If there's no stigma against unpaid leave, why is (2), the 4-week allocation, so important? First, because in reality, unpaid leave will always carry some stigma. So it's better to set the "official" PTO at 4 weeks, rather than at 2 while paying 4% more. Second, because I don't think there's any benefit to the company in someone working 50 vs. 48 weeks per year and so it doesn't deserve to be compensated as a general principle. (I'm all for people being paid back for unused vacation when they leave, but I think that people should be discouraged from taking less than 4 weeks off per year.)
- WalterSear 13y agoA former large corporate employer of mine switched to this, a did this a while ago, and it was clearly a thinly veiled way to replace actual PTO and recuperative time with the odd extra three-day weekend. The H1 staff weren't going to complain about it - they just waited until they had a critical mass before switching to this. I'd be equally critical of a start up that offered unlimited vacations. The idea of there being a 'good time to take a break' runs directly contrary to most start up's raison d'etre, and strikes me as equally disingenuous.
- borplk 13y agoTell me "unlimited vacation" and I will run as fast as I can and never look back.
- leccine 13y agounlimited PTO is saying that "we would like to give you something that you can't potentially use". the sad reality is that in countries like France or Brazil where you have 30 days, it is actually guaranteed that you can take that many days off, while unlimited PTO startup employees end up using 10-15 days per year of the "unlimited PTO". it is like a bait to get more people to work for them without actually giving anything. I would argue that we need 4 days work weeks that would be fair. The reason why we have 5 days is purely based on the greed of the corporations. if i open my startup I am going to offer 4 days workweeks instead of unlimited PTO, that is a better way to respect your employees that giving a useless bait.
- jusben1369 13y agoIt's an interesting statement that something as completely awesome as unlimited time off whenever you want can be turned into a negative. I mean people in other sectors would kill for this. Yet here it's viewed as a potential tool of sxploitation. I think this is a symptom of a much bigger problem worth discussing. If I state unequivocally that there is an open ended no asterisk vacation policy and you say "you need to go further than that" am I really the one with the problem? Or do you need to look inward a little more and ask if you're at the right company/industry etc
- baddox 13y agoDid you read the article? There are clear examples of how it could very much be a negative, including it causing people to take very little vacation time, and enabling managers to discriminate against minorities or other groups.
- jusben1369 13y agoI read it thoroughly. Ask yourself two questions. I) if your company discriminates or exploits its workforce you've got bigger problems than set time vs unlimited. II) it confuses causation. Companies with set time off will still discriminate against employees if that's their DNA. So your back at "hey If my company gives unlimited time off and I still feel uncomfortable maybe I need to make a change" vs going on and on with ever more tweaks.
- baddox 13y agoDiscrimination can happen unintentionally, and it doesn't have to be limited to specific groups of people. A manager could have a rough month due to some family issues, and end up turning down more vacation requests during that month. That sort of thing. If you have a set number of vacation days, it becomes a lot harder to unintentionally discriminate, and a lot easier to notice intentional discrimination.
- jusben1369 13y ago
- dmourati 13y agoMy last two companies have offered or will shortly offer this benefit. I read the Netflix benefits deck a while ago and mention it frequently in conversations with colleagues. One benefit to this policy that goes unmentioned is the decrease in friction in tracking PTO. In previous companies, I've had to find a PTO form, fill it out, submit to manager for signature, submit that to Payroll/HR for tracking and then finally take the time off. Payroll/HR has had to submit this number to ADP who has had to track it on my paystubbs. My manager has had to track my vacation and make sure I wasn't taking off without filling out the forms. When I left, we had to reconcile PTO banked but not taken and pay that out. With an "unlimited" vacation policy, all that friction, or at least most of it is gone. The one part about PTO I strongly dislike is getting "approval." If PTO is offered as part of your job, you shouldn't need approval to take it. Notice, yes, sure. Letting your team know you will be out is just good professional ethics and behavior. But requiring your manager to "approve" has always bothered me.
- Namrog84 13y agoI was never a huge fan of taking full days off weeks in advance. I've always preferred half days off. Some places won't always let you do this but my last job of 5 years. Let me go home on a 1 minute notice or email my boss in the morning that'd I'd be taking a half day off. Coming in late or not at all. This was discussed with him beforehand and he did the same with his boss. I was only give about 2-3 weeks total a year and I was always ahead on my work and never did it during busier crunch like times. I can't imagine having to fill out that kind of paperwork to take time off. That just sounds miserable. Where I worked agreed with your statement. It's your assigned pto. You can take it anytime you want because that's what it's their for. Obviously everyone was ethical and respectful of timing. But it was a very relaxed and low stress work environment with the ideal that the work will be done when it gets done.
- smm2000 13y agoIn two companies I worked at it was completely automated. You go to some web page, change status and click Submit. Your manager gets email (no signing/confirmation required) and that's it - no manual steps. You can see how much vacation time left on the same web page.
- badman_ting 13y agoI work for a company that offers unlimited vacation, and I am skeptical of the skepticism around this. To me it feels like some kind of backdoor justification for the standard, shitty two weeks most American firms offer. While I certainly agree that unlimited vacation can become a defacto way to prevent employees from leaving at all, why would you work at a place that does that to their employees? In the case of my company, it's a long-standing practice and works very well. People just say they're not gonna be around, and then they aren't. There's no grousing about who takes too much time off. That actually would be working against one's own interests -- I don't bitch about people taking time off because I want to take time off too. (And yes, people can take really really long vacations to pray on a mountain in India or whatever) I agree about the decoupling of unlimited and untracked, though. It could be useful to have numbers about who takes how much time, as long as it's used to encourage people who are working too hard to take time off, and not in the other direction. I think a company thinking of offering this benefit should make sure they really mean it. Because if they don't, that's where all the trouble starts. You probably need to be big enough to be in a position where Steve or Grace can take a week or two off without dire consequences. High bus numbers.
- m0nastic 13y agoI wonder if we're going to eventually wind up with policies similar to commercial aircraft crews. Like, for every N weeks of work you are required to take Y time off. It seems like the logical endgame (even though I hate vacations, and would be annoyed by being required to take them). I don't think that the companies who are advertising unlimited vacation are doing so as a way to covertly pressure their employees to not take vacation; even if it might be having that effect unintentionally. Or maybe some are, but I can give most of them the benefit of the doubt. I still have this nagging feeling in the back of my head that the eventual makeup of businesses is a sea of 1099's, self-organizing around particular projects and then dissolving at the project's conclusion. People seem to have way too adversarial a view of employers for this not to seem like the future.
- gsk22 13y agoAs a relatively recent graduate now working for a startup with an unlimited vacation policy, I find there are a whole slew of other uncertainties related to unlimited vacation. Am I expected to take as much time off as the 20-year industry veteran? Is that equitable? What if he only takes one week per year? As a recent hire, when is the socially-acceptable first time to take a long vacation? Not the first month, certainly, but what about after three months? Six? A year? In my first four months at the company, I have seen one employee take two days off. I live in a city with bitterly cold winters, so I understand many vacations are taken during the summer months, but I find it hard to believe the average vacation time per employee will exceed two weeks per year. Unfortunately, I would prefer to take more than that (3-4), but I don't want to be seen as lazy or less invested in the company than everyone else. I love the flexibility of unlimited vacation, but I find the lack of consistency or limits to be mentally draining.
- wmt 13y agoThe big problem of unlimited is that those who need it the most take it the less. If they want to go all in, why not just give 6 weeks of vacation + unlimited paid sick days? This gives everyone a healthy time off without the problems of fairness.
- mattbee 13y agoHas any company with "unlimited" but tracked vacation actually revealed how many days their staff take? And what disparities there are between individuals and departments? I'd bet that it's overall _less_ time than companies where vacation is metered, but compulsory. e.g. mine in the UK is 25 to 32 days depending on time at the company, plus bank holidays, and you've got to take it. Peer pressure must conspire to _reduce_ what people take, especially in companies that do "360 degree" peer reviews. And it would only take a hint of management pressure to make staff feel guilty about booking holidays (or cancelling those that they'd already booked). For me "unlimited holidays" translates to "unlimited work hours", and I'd be suspicious of companies that promote it as a perk.
- 0x0539 13y agoI don't know of any official revelation but I did get a little insight into the amount of vacation taken at the company I work for when I had taken 'significantly more' vacation than the rest of my coworkers. The most anyone else took was around the 4 weeks mark. I had taken a little over 6 weeks and that was the upper limit that had my boss telling me I was taking too much vacation. I felt a little shafted by than since my last job was 5 weeks + sick time + bank holidays. So that's not a lot of information for you but that would confirm your suspicion that it is less. That said it does not translate to unlimited work hours but our work is contract work. We get contracted out to other companies so though we are expected to get the work done and sometimes work >8 hours the expectation is that it will average out to 8hours a day. Be it 4hours one day followed by two 10 hours days or what have you.
- thrush 13y agoWhy not educate potential employees on how they should utilize unlimited PTO? This could be taught in school or some other non-biased source. If people aren't taught how to utilize their PTO (or vacation days for that matter), then there will always be the option for abuse.