5 ms·
Sad, but the first thing my sci-fi mind thought of was whether Earth would be able to establish relations with a perhaps-society there without establishing mili
by rhizome 13y ago
Sad, but the first thing my sci-fi mind thought of was whether Earth would be able to establish relations with a perhaps-society there without establishing military superiority first, just starting off with a Cold War.
- spcoll 13y agoAny planet harboring intelligent life would likely be several hundreds (like this one) if not thousands or millions of light years away, making any contact impossible at human scale. Even with this relatively close example of a possibly habitable planet, communications would take 1000 years to go back and forth. As for actual contact... many earth civilizations would rise and fall before a spaceship going at even 2% of the speed of light could reach such a planet.
- rhizome 13y agoWell sure, that's the sci-fi part...
- lugg 13y agoUs humans, so self centered. What you say doesn't mean we can't send a probe that simply says hey what's up and you're not alone but probably are by the time you read this.
- camillomiller 13y agoThat's what we did, more or less, with the voyager
- joe_the_user 13y agoYou're making the mistake of confusing totally unknown with very unlikely. We simply do not know enough to prognosticate one way or the other. Perhaps every habitable planet develops life but only our plant has developed intelligent life. Perhaps only our planet among all the planet in the universe has life. Perhaps every planet develops civilization life and all such civilizations destroy themselves within about 10,000 years, leaving only hunter-killer robots. In any case, interstellar space is so vast we couldn't practically other civilizations even if they turned out to be quite common in other solar systems.
- V-2 13y agoThere's also the possibility that not all intelligent life goes on to develop high tech civilization.
- Houshalter 13y agoAnything could be "The Great Filter". The best candidates for Great Filters are things which took a long time to happen on Earth (suggesting it may be a fluke or statistically rare event.) Conversely things that happen quickly, or things that independently happened multiple times suggest they aren't rare or unlikely events. On Earth, high tech civilization appeared relatively shortly after humans evolved. Agriculture was independently invented half a dozen times in different places, and cities and civilization at least twice in the new and old world. We were also moving in the direction of science and technology even before we discovered coal power so the "other planets don't have fossil fuels" doesn't seem like a great candidate either.
- jeremyjh 13y agoNo, our sample size of one tells us nothing due to selection bias - we could not even ask this question without having already achieved high tech. Edit: I agree we do know that human brings on earth are likely to invent agriculture.
- V-2 13y agoIt may depend on the availability on various natural resources, such as big (domesticable) animals, as hypothesized by Jared Diamond in "Guns, Germs and Steel". This is why native Australians were pretty much stuck in stone age era for thousands of years. They might have never developed beyond that level. Not because they're inferior, but because they had no means to start an economy capable of accumulating resources. One could easily imagine an Earth where the only continent is Australia (surrounded by oceans) and humans - even biologically identical to us - remain hunter-gatherers for eternity.
- joe_the_user 13y ago
- clef 13y agoPeople can be wary of new neighbours, i don't see why it wouldn't apply to space neighbours. On a brighter note, maybe we should welcome with open arms anyone, after all, better be nice than not nice!
- Houshalter 13y agoI'd be more concerned the aliens would be militarily superior to us, considering the millions to billions of years head start on technology. Or that there are no aliens, raising concerns that most civilizations inevitably destroy themselves. Or that there are, but they haven't made contact because they don't care about us. If they don't care they might wipe us out because they want our resources, or see us as a potential threat.
- gagege 13y agoOr they're just building a highway and Earth is in the way.
- flatline 13y agoOr that long-distance space travel or even communication is simply not feasible for any civilization at any level of technological advancement.
- Houshalter 13y agoIt should be possible to transmit radio signals between planets. Although it's possible we just aren't listening or they aren't doing it frequently enough. Space travel is more speculative but it seems theoretically possible to reach a significant fraction of c even with 20th century technology. Even today's spacecraft could reach other solar systems in a few thousand years, which is reasonable on a geological timescale. If probes are self-replicating, or the mother civilization simply sends a lot of them, they could cover the entire galaxy in a few million years at most.
- jotm 13y agoThere's really no point in either. A radio signal would need to be extremely powerful to travel 500 light years without degrading (not to mention that even the senders may not be able to decode it after 1000 years :-)), and sending spacecraft to navigate 500 light years hoping it will perform all maneuvers correctly and not get hit by something in order to reach a planet without being able to send any useful information back seems naive and pointless. If there's any space faring civilization out there, they're probably content with their own star system and maybe the ones closest to it - there are so many planets and asteroids to mine for resources (plus recycling would be a big thing) they could last for hundreds of millions of years...