7 ms·
Soylent gets tested, scores a wholesome nutritional label
- cordite 13y agoI would not say "Surprising" as in the title, it was designed to fulfill nutrition from the beginning.
- jaksmit 13y agoexactly what I was thinking
- dang 13y agoThanks. We usually take out modifiers like that anyway, as a way of reducing linkbaityness.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoIt is surprising to the haters on this site. There just isn't any other word for the treatment and unjustified skepticism soylent has received here.
- collyw 13y agoI wouldn't say I am a hater, but I really don't understand the enthusiasm for this product. Eating is one of lifes pleasures. Why reduce it to the most processed forms possible? (I would make a bet that if it is launched in Spain, it will fail miserably. People here have a real passion for good food.)
- ekianjo 13y agoSame here. It's probably popular because it's new and it's an experiment challenging the concept of "Food", but apart from that there's no way I'd want to eat that stuff either. Actual food at home or outside is, as you say, one of life's pleasures.
- DanBC 13y agoUnethical and deceitful claims deserve hate. > "For anyone that struggles with allergies, heartburn, acid reflux or digestion, has trouble controlling weight or cholesterol, or simply doesn't have the means to eat well, soylent is for you." > "Soylent frees you from the time and money spent shopping, cooking and cleaning, puts you in excellent health," > "By taking years to spoil" > "there is much evidence that it is considerably healthier than a typical diet." Those are the claims they made during the kickstarter. Those would be unlawful in the UK - I have no idea what the equivalent US regulators would make of those claims if Soylent continued to make them. Using those misleading deceptive claims to raise money puts them firmly in the sham charlatan space and they thoroughly deserve harsh treatment.
- 001sky 13y agoJan 29, 2014 10:54 pm UTC "will begin shipments on a rolling basis at the beginning of March" so, any updates?
- nammi 13y ago"Orders projected to begin shipping 4/21. Backerkit orders will be locked down 4/11. First batches of Soylent 1.0 will not be certified gluten free. Some Backerkit add-ons removed." This was posted last week, so it seems like they will actually ship next week. http://blog.soylent.me/post/82129644711/weekly-update-4-8 http://blog.soylent.me/post/82129644711/weekly-update-4-8
- yaddayadda 13y agoFrom rob earlier today, >Update coming today -- starter kits scheduled to start shipping by Friday, first Soylent shipments will be next week, though probably wed/thurs rather than Monday. - http://discourse.soylent.me/t/soylent-update-4-8/12022/95 http://discourse.soylent.me/t/soylent-update-4-8/12022/95 So the first shipments should be rolling out of the dock by Apr. 24th. Still no word on speed of delivery, but I'd expect the first shipments to start arriving the week of Apr. 28th - May 3rd.
- PythonicAlpha 13y agoJust asking: Is this some kind of weird humor? Can anybody tell the story of this in short words? I am fearing, that those predicted times will come up, but that somebody would name his product after a product that in a science fiction story was made out of human bodies, is really a little beyond my comprehension. Some kind of self-irony, perhaps? Or reverse marketing?
- eurleif 13y agoWhy is it named Soylent? Because it made you ask that question.
- deckiedan 13y agoI believe in the original book ('Make Room! Make Room!'), soylent was not specified as cannibalistic - that was added in the movie.
- nodata 13y agoYes, you're right. Soylent = soya + lentil steaks in the book.
- yaddayadda 13y agoFrom the horse's (rob's) keyboard: >I don't know anything about marketing or branding but I'm a big fan of underpromising and overdelivering. You're right it doesn't sound that amazing, but it is to me. >Soylent is supposed to disrupt the food that is all marketing and nutritionally disastrous. I'd like to differentiate by being honest and up front. Most food sold is all branding and taste. I feel there's a wealth of science and chemistry to food and nutrition that is largely ignored by the main players in the industry. They just make what they know people recognize and want. Fatty, salty food is sold because that's what people demand. There is a serious gap in the market for cheap, convenient, healthy food. >The name kind of fades in to the background after you say it enough too. My brain has become accustomed to a positive association with the word 'soylent'. If I've had 'real' food for two meals in a row my mouth waters at the mention of the word soylent. Your body learns. The stomach is connected to the brain. Think about 'coffee'. That's a terrible name. It sounds like 'coffin' or 'coughing'. But no one notices because it's become its own idea and most people have formed an association with it, good or bad. >I own the trademark. It could be sold under a different name in addition to soylent for marketing purposes. That's pretty common. Some conservative people may never be able to get past the name. I considered the name 'manna' but it's heavily trademarked, and a little cheesy. I'm open to suggestion. - http://discourse.soylent.me/t/changing-the-name-to-something-less-bland/372/9 http://discourse.soylent.me/t/changing-the-name-to-something...
- robobro 13y agoAs a type 1 diabetic, this could be handy for eating out / backpacking / regulating glucose. Wish I could have gotten in on the alpha...
- ryanmerket 13y agoIt's high glycemic, so probably not the best for diabetics.
- yaddayadda 13y agoI don't see a glycemic value on the label, so how do you know it's high? (I'm not a diabetic, I'm just genuinely curious.)
- ballard 13y agoPage with ingredients, don't know how to interpret: http://blog.soylent.me/search/Ingredients http://blog.soylent.me/search/Ingredients
- Sammi 13y agoMain ingredients are: Oat Flour (110g) Maltodextrin (165g) Brown Rice Protein Isolate (102g) Canola Oil (56g) Fiber (38g) I'm worried about how much of that is Maltodextrin, as it's really just a chain of glucose molecules, and so would give an extremely high glycemic load. It's somewhat mitigated by the fiber, as fiber hampers sugar uptake in the digestive system, but it's still a lot. I'd like to see some proper data on the what the GI score of Soylent is derived from actually testing it properly.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Hytosys 13y agoI agree that 8gb of fiber should be more like 10g a serving, but the amount of fat is actually just over 23g once you add the provided oil packets (which would also boost the unsaturated fat content).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- yaddayadda 13y agoAccording to this Harvard Heath article [1] a 10-to-1 ratio of carbs to fiber indicates a healthy whole-grain food, so what's the problem with Soylent's 84-to-8? [1] http://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/the-trick-to-recognizing-a-good-whole-grain-use-carb-to-fiber-ratio-of-10-to-1-201301145794 http://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/the-trick-to-recognizing-...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- fidlefodl 13y ago> 84g of carbs with only 8g of fiber and 5g of fat is NOT healthy at all. Can anyone expand upon this point? If his goal is to make meal replacements, optimized for health, why are the meals lacking on this point? I'm dying to give this a try.. but i also don't want to hurt my body. To be frank, i've got no clue what the health risks are, i just hate eating 90% of the time, and as a result i eat very poorly. I don't go fast food or anything, but i often skip meals or substitute some random protein (cheeses/etc) just to make the hunger go away. I'm ready to order 2 weeks of this stuff tomorrow, would better minds than mine care to elaborate more on the health risks/points that coolsunglasses brought up? Thanks
- riffraff 13y ago
- george88b 13y agoThis article is from months ago. I thought they had to change suppliers for a few things, wouldn't the nutritional info change also?
- parag_c_mehta 13y agoHow long does it lasts ? Does this mean we have perfect food replacement for the apocalypse ?
- mikenon 13y agoUp to a year, according to [1]. A staff member on their forum said similar, [2] "We're probably going to stick with 1 year shelf life when kept in cool dark place, thought it'll likely be much longer in actuality." [1] http://www.rosalabs.com/about/ http://www.rosalabs.com/about/ [2] http://discourse.soylent.me/t/official-word-on-shelf-life-of-soylent/10203/5 http://discourse.soylent.me/t/official-word-on-shelf-life-of...
- spullara 13y agoYou know you have an interesting article when the #1 comment has been deleted.
- zvrba 13y ago> a lot of people are seeing reduction in triglycerides or cholesterol I suspect that the powder may be oat-based. Oats is a very nutritient-rich cereal, and does in fact lower cholesterol. It has high carbohydrate content, but it is also a rich source of minerals and proteins. See http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/cereal-grains-and-pasta/5708/2 http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/cereal-grains-and-pasta/... If I were to mix my own "soylent", I'd base it on oat porridge, probably some protein supplements, some vitamin and mineral supplement, and a can of fatty fish. At probably a fraction of the soylent price.
- thisishugo 13y agoIf you are interested in creating your own Soylent, there's a dedicated subsection of the website[0] for sharing recipes. Frankly, I doubt you could recreate, or equivalently replace, Soylent-the-product for as little money as it will cost to buy[1], but it's definitely possible to replicate Soylent-the-idea yourself. It's much easier if you don't intend to replace every meal with a Soylent-like, as you can substitute the harder-to-source ingredients with foods that already contain them. [0] http://diy.soylent.me http://diy.soylent.me [1] Partly because of economies of scale, partly because some of the ingredients are complicated to source.
- gabemart 13y agoMy concern about Soylent has never been about the macronutrient ratios, nor the quantities of (comparatively) well-understood micronutrients like vitamins and minerals. The amounts of these substances seem relatively easy to get right, or at least within the range of "healthy" accepted by a consensus of mainstream nutritonal experts. My concern is about the thousands or millions of micronutrients and phytonutrients that are poorly understood or even yet to be isolated by nutritional science, and the subtle and complex way they interact with our bodies and each other. To me, the entire premise of Soylent is predicated on the idea that we know, on a compound-by-compound basis, what's good for our bodies nutritionally. The more I learn about the state of nutritional science, the less I believe this to be true.
- ekianjo 13y ago> To me, the entire premise of Soylent is predicated on the idea that we know, on a compound-by-compound basis, what's good for our bodies nutritionally. The more I learn about the state of nutritional science, the less I believe this to be true. Well Soylent is going to be an interesting test to confirm what we know and do not know about nutrition. As long as there are some willing volunteers to put their health at risk, I'd say why not. It will benefit mankind as a whole to know more.
- gabemart 13y agoI don't know if that's really true. How much can an uncontrolled, unrandomized, unmonitored nutritional experiment really tell us? OK, it can confirm that i) Soylent isn't poisonous, and ii) Soylent isn't the key to everlasting life. But I'm not sure what other data it can yield outside of a clinical trial setting.
- ekianjo 13y agoI'm not going to say you will have a ton of valuable data, but safety confirmation is certainly something you will get from large numbers of participants. If nobody gets extremely sick, dies or develops some kind of illness after years of Soylent consumption, at least you'll know that it could be an acceptable form of food.
- ColinWright 13y agoAmongst all the comments about poorly-understood or unknown micro-nutrients, and whether or not this is healthy in the long run, I see here a sense of bewilderment from some people: fidlefodl : i just hate eating 90% of the time riffraff : ... why do you hate eating most of the time? ekianjo : [hate eating] two words I have difficulty associating ... collyw : I really don't understand the enthusiasm for this product. Eating is one of life's pleasures Personally, I'm with fidlefodl. I cannot understand what pleasure people get from eating. I cook, I eat, I share meals with others, but if I could get away from eating and never have to eat again, I'd take it in a heartbeat. I derive no pleasure from eating, and a great deal of negative pleasure from cooking. If takeaways weren't a combination of unhealthy and unpleasant then I'd never cook again. I freely admit and acknowledge that some food tastes great, but on the whole, I'd much prefer not to spend the time eating.
- aianus 13y agoSeriously, I'd trade 10+ years of my lifespan to never have to eat again and still maintain my weight / muscle mass.
- pliny 13y agoThe shitty years at the end, or would you immediately deteriorate your current health ten years into your future?
- fidlefodl 13y agoYup, and i expanded upon my thoughts [here](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7604201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7604201). I'm honestly surprised so many people are shocked by this concept. I've rarely known people to eat great food, and overly healthy food, for 90% of meals which a healthy appreciation of the whole process. Most people i know eat "real meals" on random dinners through the week, and everything else is just things getting in there way of doing what they want. Plus, if Soylent ends up being what they are promising (100% perfect meal in each drink), then you're talking about a meal with zero negative aspects. If you're greedy, this lets you sort of eat of in reverse.. Rather than spending all week struggling to eat things you can tolerate so that you can eat something you like in a bit of excess (splurging), you can sort of go nuts with every "real food" meal (assuming most meals are Soylent). There will be very little guilt in having a burger with bacon.. you've had 100% health food for the last 3 days. Go nuts with your burger!
- torrent-of-ions 13y agoIf there is a demand for this the only thing I can wonder is what is going on with people's mental health?
- aianus 13y agoIt's an expensive and frustrating struggle to maintain my weight and this sounds like a promising alternative to dropping ~$800 a month (in money or wasted time cooking and cleaning) on merely staying alive.
- fidlefodl 13y agoNot sure why you would question my mental health over simply wanting to consume a quick, easy, and healthy meal. Why is that crazy?
- billrobertson42 13y agoThere are a lot of mystery carbs in there. 84g carbs, 8g in fiber and 2g in sugar. The remaining 74g?