6 ms·
Google Revenue Jumps, But Misses Forecasts
- whoismua 13y agoGoogle is overpriced IMO, their PE has been at around 30 for quite a while. At their size it's extremely hard, if not impossible to keep growth at level to justify the high PE. Google's PE should be around 15-20, max. Personally, I'd rather own MSFT, better diversified and offers a dividend. Their SE is unbearable without ad blockers already.
- encoderer 13y agoThere's a metric for this, the PEG ratio. It's P/E divided by real growth rates. Googles PEG is about 1.5. "1" is considered ideal, less than one is a "deal", over 1 is not. But 1.5 isn't bad. Amazon, for example, is around 4, even now after the correction.
- marvin 13y agoIt doesn't really make sense to compare this number with other companies in the same sector. Long-term, the stock price needs to reflect the actual income and growth of the company. Otherwise we are in "greater fool" territory. There is good reason to be skeptical of Amazon's valuation, and that of many other tech companies. (Not that for the record, I am almost exclusively a growth investor in the speculative part of my portfolio). Google still has room to grow, though. I am actually more worried about Facebook's risk/reward profile.
- whoismua 13y agoBut I think their growth is artificial and not sustainable. It's obvious that their growth has been achieved by adding more ads to the pages even as their CPC is crashing. .
- encoderer 13y agoIt sounds like what you have is an investment thesis :) Put some money behind it! Maybe you're right..
- whoismua 13y agoPut some money behind it! Maybe you're right.. "Markets can remain irrational a lot longer than you and I can remain solvent." comes to mind ...I was right two years ago but Google continues to surprise me with their audacity and ability to suffer no penalties by users and governments. But eventually everything will be ads and someone might notice ;)
- applecore 13y agoGoogle has huge cash reserves ($60 billion), so you really should look at P/E adjusted for cash and cash equivalents on their balance sheet. Ex-cash, it's about 19.
- johansch 13y agoAh, this is why we've seen so many google-related tech successes being publicized today...
- nraynaud 13y agohow do they plan that? they would want the technology news to come before the result news to soften the landing? or they would do it after to try to cheer up the stock?
- 001sky 13y agothe term of art is 'headfake'... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Head_fake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Head_fake
- dannyr 13y agoYup, everything is a conspiracy. They have a bunch of these projects and app releases on hold for a long time and announce them before they release their earnings. Ah, HN. #sarcasm
- rebel 13y agoThere are billions of dollars at stake. They know what the estimates are the whole time, and they have a pretty good idea for weeks/months on whether or not they are going to hit them. They would be borderline insane to not have PR plans in place. It would be naive to think otherwise.
- IBM 13y agoI'm glad I'm not the only person that notices this. There's a reason why these puff pieces came out when they did: http://www.theverge.com/2014/4/15/5615880/building-blocks-how-project-ara-is-reinventing-the-smartphone http://www.theverge.com/2014/4/15/5615880/building-blocks-ho... http://www.fastcompany.com/3028156/united-states-of-innovation/the-google-x-factor http://www.fastcompany.com/3028156/united-states-of-innovati... It's about managing investor sentiment. Core profitability of their ad business (as indicated by CPC) has been declining for I think 9 or 10 quarters in a row now? They're aggressively monetizing all their services and products because of this to keep driving aggregate clicks up. "We'll make it up in volume" They need shiny baubles to dangle in front of investors in the absence of creating real new markets and businesses that generate cash flow. It's not just for investors either. They're attempting to be perceived to be an innovative company in the eyes of their various stakeholders (employees, potential employees, tech press, the general public, regulators, etc.) even though they're pretty much the new Microsoft in terms of milking their one hit (advertising). Funny enough, Google's core business is being disrupted by the mobile revolution ushered in by Apple (you won't read that particular narrative in the tech/financial press because Google X and other high-profile "moon shots" have been effective in accomplishing the PR objective). Android was a completely defensive move about making sure the erosion to that business was limited and that they'd have a slice of the advertising pie even if it's fundamentally less rewarding than desktop advertising. If Google had attempted to sell Android it would have never been as successful, so there was no choice, it was purely about staunching the bleeding. This is why Google has been so acquisitive for so many years; they're desperately searching for new businesses that make money (and also clearing the market of anything that could threaten their existing one). The tech media interprets this as being "bold" and "innovative" (which really doesn't make any sense when you think about it) but it's really out of fear and desperation. Companies that have defensible moats around their business don't need to overpay or rush into deals. The media cheerleads it because it gives them something to write about and the resulting boom in Silicon Valley has flowed to them as well. VCs cheerlead it because they rely on these insecure companies to provide ample exits for their portfolio companies at lofty valuations (https://twitter.com/cdixon/status/427602474086584320 https://twitter.com/cdixon/status/427602474086584320). Follow Marc Andreessen on Twitter to see him try to justify valuations in technology and dispel any comparisons to the Dot Com boom. Facebook does this as well, but fortunately for them they have a stock that is insanely overvalued which allows Mark Zuckerberg to use it as currency. Google's valuation isn't as generous, but more importantly these acquisitions have been diluting Larry and Sergei's controlling interest (something they recently rectified with a new class of shares). So I'm sure they'll be matching Facebook's pace in no time.
- nraynaud 13y agoI love the title. As far as I know, it's the forecast that missed the reality. When the weather is not as planned, it's the weather service that missed, not the sky. It was not an engagement form google. It's incredible how twisted some vocabulary has become. What do they say when they forecast on agricultural prices and the actual weather influenced the production? corn production missed the forecast?
- bonaldi 13y agoEr, yes? "Corn yields fell short of forecasts" is a common phrasing. "Temperatures failed to reach record highs set in 19xx despite the longest heatwave since records began" is another type of thing you'll see.
- nraynaud 13y agothat's just wonderful. I'm still debating between Wes Anderson/Bill Murray or Tim Burton/Johnny Depp to shoot a movie where those sentences would be uttered. Maybe I'm just not made for this world.
- gfodor 13y agoThe reason it is phrased this way is because when a company misses forecast this usually results in the selloff of stock. This is generally the primary focus of earnings report reporting: the direction of the stock price.
- higherpurpose 13y agoI think that is also one of the reasons why public corporations are so heavily influenced by Wall Street in their decisions, and why they strive to reach certain quarterly goals in order to "meet the forecasts". If it was reported more like "forecasts miss the revenue", I think companies would be under less pressure from Wall Street to perform "at least as well as the expectations" every quarter.
- nostrademons 13y ago
- ChuckMcM 13y agoInteresting results. I've remarked in the past how the decreasing CPC numbers were being papered over by creating massive amounts of inventory (more ads per page to click on) and paid click growth has largely been facilitated by adding distribution "partners" which is code in the search business that shove traffic your way. Early on in Google's history it was all organic but this last quarter they were spending nearly a billion dollars a quarter to have people send them traffic. Looking at the numbers for the last 12 quarters its like this: Paid Click deltas (%) Traffic Spend Y/Y Q Prev Q ($m) y/y q/q Q1FY2010 15 5 265 -- -- Q2FY2010 15 (3) 269 -- 1.5 Q3FY2010 16 4 285 -- 6 Q4FY2010 18 11 333 -- 17 Q1FY2011 18 4 337 27 1 Q2FY2011 18 2 355 32 5 Q3FY2011 28 13 383 34 8 Q4FY2011 34 17 442 33 15 Q1FY2012 39 7 468 39 6 Q2FY2012 42 1 507 43 8 Q3FY2012 33 6 556 45 10 Q4FY2012 24 9 634 43 14 Q1FY2013 20 3 680 45 7 Q2FY2013 23 4 706 39 4 Q3FY2013 26 8 755 36 7 Q4FY2013 31 13 824 30 9 Q1FY2014 26 (1) 845 24 3 Who would have thought between Microsoft and Google that sending search traffic artificially to a search engine would be a > $4B/year business? I don't think it is sustainable long term.
- whoismua 13y agoWhy isn't Google suffering a backlash and lost share due to this http://digitalgrowth.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/google-uk-hotel-ads-1024x639.png http://digitalgrowth.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/googl... ? I cannot use them without ad blockers, I suppose I'm not the only one ;)
- dave809 13y agoBecause the ads are usually relevant and useful. in your example, the second card is a nice summary of hotels with all the relevant info right there
- zmmmmm 13y agoI always fear what will happen to all of Google's well-intentioned businesses and ethical thresholds when / if the river of money starts to narrow. Will they try to bring back their revenue with ever more desperate measures? Will they slash and burn their investments? Or will they stick by their guns and keep plowing money into new projects, continue walking the thin line between "creepy" and "useful" without ever erring across it, even while their kingdom crumbles? We've never had to ask this question because on the back of an expanding internet Google has risen with the tide regardless of their own performance (and I'm not saying their performance has ever been poor, just that we have no way to know in absolute terms). This particular instance may be nothing, but every time they miss a mark I wonder whether we'll finally find out where their principles truly lie.