28 ms·
One word of warning, the product timeline says you should expect your product in 7-11 months. That is a long time when you are talking about device compatibili
by slg 13y ago
One word of warning, the product timeline says you should expect your product in 7-11 months. That is a long time when you are talking about device compatibility. All Kickstarters have risks, but buying an accessory for a device that may not even exist yet is a larger than normal gamble. There were plenty of Kickstarters for iPhone accessories that didn't arrive until after they were already obsoleted by the lightning cable.
Will this work on your next laptop? Probably. Can the Dart team guarantee that the device will "work with all major PC brands" manufactured in the next year? Probably not. Is that risk worth the extra money you save on a pre-order? That is up to you to decide.
- x1024 13y agoNote that it powers a usb device. Every single iOS device and every Android device that I know of have a USB on one end of the cable. Also, is anyone really innovating in Laptops these days? Is there a reasonable expectation that something like "A new type of charger" can even happen in the next 12-24 months?
- nostromo 13y agoIt powers one usb port and a laptop. Nobody is buying it just for the usb port; it's bigger and more expensive than existing usb outlets.
- stoev 13y agoI don't think that there is much that the major PC brands can do to prevent the device from powering their future devices. However, you are right that a certain a certain amount of risk exists and I don't think that one would actually save a lot of money by ordering early. Given that they use no custom electrical components (according to the project description), $89 seems like quite a hefty price. I assume that by the time the device is mass produced its price will be lower due to pressure from competitors.
- userbinator 13y agoUnless some radical change happens to laptop power supplies in the next few months - a change from designs that have remained the same for over a decade - it's very likely this adapter will work with the newest (normal) laptops available when it comes out. Also, laptops have very flexible power input circuits that will accept a wide range of DC input: they'll start running from ~12V (the voltage of an almost-dead battery), and go as high as the voltage specs on the input components allows - 25V (filter caps) is the usual absolute upper limit. Higher voltage means lower I^2R losses but manufacturers like to leave some safety margin, which is why 20V is somewhat of a de-facto standard given the parts available. The general power distribution circuits in a laptop are like this: there's a main power rail, whose voltage varies with battery voltage when running on battery, and is the DC-IN voltage with the adapter plugged in. The voltages for the CPU, GPU, chipset, etc. are all generated by DC-DC converters supplied from this main rail. There's a set of diodes/MOSFETs that wire-OR together the battery and DC-IN to the main rail, preventing current flow in the wrong direction. It also powers the battery charger. I've read a lot of laptop schematics, and all of them use very similar power circuitry, often with the same components. The only real concern with device compatibility is in the ID schemes that some manufacturers use, either to "lock out" third party adapters or encode wattage selection. The simplest ones are nothing more than a resistor in the plug, different values for different wattages (IBM/Lenovo is one example). More complex ones use a 1-wire interface to an EEPROM or other storage element (Dell, Apple) (http://www.laptop-junction.com/toast/content/dell-ac-power-adapter-id-chip-died http://www.laptop-junction.com/toast/content/dell-ac-power-a... http://www.righto.com/2013/06/teardown-and-exploration-of-magsafe.html http://www.righto.com/2013/06/teardown-and-exploration-of-ma... ). Then there's all the others that have no ID at all, just +/- input, and these are the most compatible. About the Dart itself: the technology used here (VHF SMPS) has been around for a long time in military/aerospace applications, where size/weight is more important than reducing switching losses. http://www.eevblog.com/forum/crowd-funded-projects/vhf-laptop-power-supply/ http://www.eevblog.com/forum/crowd-funded-projects/vhf-lapto...
- sitkack 13y agoIs this a USB 3.1 supply? Because that is where everything is going.