3 ms·
This was submitted earlier today, but didn't get much traction: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7586285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7586285 The f
by nkurz 13y ago
This was submitted earlier today, but didn't get much traction: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7586285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7586285
The full title (which doesn't fit in 80 characters) explains the story better:
The inventor of everything:
How an egotistical genius convinced Silicon Valley to
invest hundreds of millions in his shoddy science
It's an account of how Mike Cheiky, the founder of Cool Planet, has an almost uncanny ability to repeatedly raise large amounts of investment based on pseudoscience that doesn't ever pan out. It's one of the most negative pieces on a company that I've ever seen in print.
- funkyy 13y agoVery interesting read indeed. They guy seems to be trying to sell perpetuum mobile. I am amazed that large, well known companies invested in him. Did they failed to do proper research?
- adventured 13y agoScience-technology has always had hucksters / snake oil salesmen, and always will. They combine optimism, passion, enough science-speak, futurism, and an aurora of 'this is going to change the world.' Those things will always sell.
- jasonlaramburu 13y agoGood investors recognize that markets>technology. With enough time and money, virtually anything is possible. If Cool Planet does succeed, they will change the way the world uses energy. Chieky is definitely eccentric but he's no more of an a$$hole than Jobs was.
- kazagistar 13y agoDang, that is some strong coolaid they are passing around.
- wlievens 13y agoMarkets are still susceptible to the laws of physics. "Virtually anything is possible" is a pretty meaningless statement.
- DennisP 13y agoIt's not quite perpetual motion, the energy would come from the sun. Start with organic material, use pyrolysis to produce biochar, which you work into soil, along with flammable gases (which Cool Planet wants to turn into liquid fuel). Here's someone else describing the basic concept: http://biocharfarms.org/biochar_production_energy/ http://biocharfarms.org/biochar_production_energy/ The problem is that it won't produce near as much fuel as Cool Planet claims. According to the article, it turns out a lot of big technology investors don't actually consult engineers during due diligence.
- mathattack 13y agoI suspect that a lot of biotech and green energy investors are very good at other things. They came into the money by being good IT entrepreneurs and investors.
- Fasebook 13y agoStrange, no writing about the idiot people with money who keep wasting money on this guy. Don't hate the player..
- jordan0day 13y agoWhile I understand your sentiment, and to a certain degree, agree with you, you're implying "the game" is "how to extract the most money from other people", and not "how to build the best stuff for humanity, and hopefully get rich in the process". If the game really is "extract the most money", then yes, we should hate the game. I certainly hope most of us are playing the latter game, rather than the former.
- gamerdonkey 13y agoThey actually do get a mention in the article. The venture capitalists who’ve sunk tens of millions into Cheiky’s startups have a lot to lose if his suspect science is discovered — exposing Cheiky might stop him from raising money again, but it would also tarnish their reputations. None of the firms who backed Cheiky would speak with The Verge about him on the record, but several shared negative impressions on background. Unlike many serial entrepreneurs, who return to previous investors for favorable terms, Cheiky’s last three startups all have a very different set of backers. Seems they're just playing the same game.