67 ms·
SF’s Housing Crisis Explained
- kzahel 13y agoThis has a ton of great information and background but could definitely use some splitting up and organizing IMO. I don't know anybody but the most dedicated who could spend the hours it would take to digest this. It reads almost like a wikipedia page.
- computator 13y ago> This has a ton of great information and background but could definitely use some splitting up and organizing Page length issues seem to bother a lot of people. I wrote a long one-page web article myself recently, and everybody said it was too long and needed to be split up and organized. So I split the article at the section headings into separate web pages. Everybody who had complained earlier said that my "reedit" was now much better. But really I didn't make any change other than splitting it into separate web pages. Now, I do understand the value of paragraphs, spacing, and section headings. It's much easier visually. But I never understood the distaste for long web pages. (Obviously, it should be related material, like a story.) It seems that some readers prefer 5 separate web pages (that must be read contiguously) rather than a single page with five section headings. Maybe I'm in the minority, but I prefer the single page.
- intortus 13y agoI actually did read through the entire article in one sitting, but to be honest I'm surprised I did. My time spent is usually too fractured to permit this long a focus on anything that isn't either work or passive entertainment. I can see how one can become dependent on more episodic consumption, designed to give clear break points and bring one comfortably back into the context at a later point when ready to continue. Those crutches would be comforting even if one ends up "binging" on the entire piece anyway.
- manicdee 13y agoPerhaps the problem was the navigation of the page? Perhaps there's something psychologically satisfying about being able to finish five smaller reading tasks than one larger reading task? I have found that if the text doesn't fit on one screen, it's more enjoyable for me to read the content as an ePub than as a long scrolling web page. This doesn't mean I enjoy reading "news" sites which split the content into 25 pages of one paragraph each, just so they can squeeze a dozen more adverts into the page.
- dotBen 13y agoReading such long-form content and then being able to process + critique it is an important life skill many of us have sadly lost. I don't think the article is unnecessarily verbose, in fact I think it successfully covers many inter-connected issues by only illustrating the relevant depth without burdening the reader with the superfluous. It's actually a really quite incredible piece of work, and arguably the best thing ever published on TechCrunch.
- collyw 13y ago"Reading such long-form content and then being able to process + critique it is an important life skill many of us have sadly lost." Sadly everything seems to be going the way of buzzfeed and infographics. You think you are getting information, but its the equivalent of a newspaper headline, compared to getting all the details.
- tedsanders 13y agoFor another great take on the housing crisis in SF and elsewhere, I recommend a book that I first heard about on Hacker News, Matt Yglesias's The Rent is Too Damn High: http://www.amazon.com/The-Rent-Too-Damn-High-ebook/dp/B0078XGJXO http://www.amazon.com/The-Rent-Too-Damn-High-ebook/dp/B0078X... The over-regulation of home building by cities is an issue not really on the public's radar, unfortunately.
- pchristensen 13y agoWell, the 30-70% of population that are homeowners do have homebuilding on their radar - they're investors in the housing stock and have an incentive to cap/limit supply.
- cft 13y agoI think building more upscale condos/housing will attract even more money, and there will be a positive feedback loop, so the housing will become even more expensive. This can be observed in Manhattan.
- fiatmoney 13y agoDownvotes for this are unwarranted. This is a plausible mechanism, even if it's wrong, and should be engaged with. The key thing is the margin for "even more expensive". Fundamentally, yes, development makes cities more valuable / expensive, in aggregate (after all, that's why cities exist in the first place). The key thing is how many units that value is spread out over. If you tear down a slum and replace it with $1M condos in a supply-constrained market, rents will rise. But, there are a limited number of people who can afford to buy 7-figure condos, and it is possible to build enough housing to saturate that demand all the way down the curve. If you're actually able to tear down a single-family unit and replace it with 4-unit low-rise apartments, and rent / sell them at a decent price since people want to move into the city, and all your competitor landlords can do the same, you'll see more units, more total dollars going to landlords, and lower prices per unit. The key thing is to make it cheap to build. Excessive regulation of the kind the article talks about often does the exact opposite - they make it so you can build, eventually, but it's only worthwhile if you can be sure of extracting large rents. Even worse, the high value of land & rent in a supply-constrained environment puts a lot of vested interests in keeping supply low, in a vicious circle. A sure sign you're trapped in that vicious circle is if developers have "community engagement" and "affordable housing" dollars to throw around.
- com2kid 13y ago> But, there are a limited number of people who can afford to buy 7-figure condos Of course, but if the total possible supply of 7-figure condos in SF is smaller than the total number of people who want to buy 7-figure condos in SF, then it would indeed be possible to fill the city with nothing but 7-figure condos and have thusly dramatically increased the price of housing!
- hindsightbias 13y ago
- peterwwillis 13y agotl;dr poor people don't want to be forced out of their homes or have their affordable local businesses shut down, and rich people want to make/keep a lot of money (partly by pushing poor people out of their homes and closing their affordable local businesses) From my perspective SF does not have a housing crisis. They quite obviously have a culture crisis. Two opposed socioeconomic groups are at war, each trying to push the other out of the city. Housing remains plentiful, though obviously not affordable. You want to make housing really affordable? Introduce a large drug trade and a couple dozen gangs to bring up the mortality and crime rates, and you'll see those housing prices rocket downwards. If you would rather live in a city with plentiful, affordable housing - 16% of which is abandoned or unliveable - come on over to my side of the country. You might want to bring a car and some pepper spray, though.
- krasin 13y agothis tl;dr misses the import part: "Homeowners have a strong economic incentive to restrict supply".
- peterwwillis 13y agoWhat homeowner has a strong economic incentive to flood the market with more affordable housing, driving down the value of their own?
- selmnoo 13y agoVery interesting, that Piketty's "Capital in the 21st Century" is introduced in this article: A lot of other VCs and founders are also digesting Thomas Piketty’s new book, “Capital in the 21st Century.” With more than 200 years of data, it chronicles an inexorable rise in inequality that was punctuated in the middle of the 20th century by the Great Depression and World War II followed by 30 years of evenly-spread prosperity. Ultimately, it advocates a globally-coordinated tax on wealth. I know that it's taboo on HN to get overly political, but I think because of Piketty's work we should talk about it (particularly, because Piketty's new piece is so groundbreaking [1] and incredibly well-backed with data). What do you guys think of his "global wealth tax" -- tax on capital (including real property), in the context of the new SV riches? [1]: The book is being received as "the most important economiscs text of the decade" by a lot of high-placed economists, etc.: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_in_the_Twenty-First_Century#Reception http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_in_the_Twenty-First_Cen...
- ericd 13y agoI don't like the idea of a tax on wealth - it seems like it would discourage savings, as you have to use it or lose it. If I save up a nest egg, my tax bill shouldn't increase as my nest egg increases, eventually reaching an equilibrium where I have to keep working just to keep my savings constant. Much better would be a much higher top marginal tax rate like the one we had pre-Reagan, and including investment gains in that.
- collyw 13y agoI personally think a tax on (unearned) wealth makes a lot more sense than a tax on work / earnings.
- wutbrodo 13y ago> a tax on (unearned) wealth Doesn't the estate tax fully cover this case?
- 100k 13y agoIncluding capital gains in regular income taxes _would_ be a tax on wealth, though, wouldn't it? Certainly more so than it is now. To avoid discouraging savings, the wealth tax could be progressive. The tax on the average citizen's savings is negligible but rentiers pay a substantial portion. I think an inheritance tax is especially important to prevent the formation of generational wealth.
- kijin 13y agoJust pack up and leave the damn place already. Sorry to be blunt, but that's how "supply and demand" is really supposed to work. If Seattle supplies the same quality of housing for half the cost of San Francisco, buyers/renters should flock to Seattle, thereby reducing demand in SF and eventually causing SF housing prices to come down until the market finds an equilibrium. Trying to lobby for "below-market-price" housing is always going to be a losing game; the only long-term solution is to make the market price lower. Unfortunately, competition among cities to attract residents is not like competition in other industries. A lot of people are stuck in a relatively small geographical area their whole lives due to employment, their children's education, various kinds of emotional attachment, and the sheer difficulty of uprooting themselves from a familiar neighborhood. This creates a captive market, severely limiting the effectiveness of inter-city competition. And of course, whenever there's a captive market, there's somebody who profits from it. In the case of SF's housing market, entrenched neighborhood groups and "below-market-price" renters enjoy benefits at the expense of newcomers to the city. Perhaps they actually deserve those benefits. Still, it's unfair to everyone else. But there's one group of people who can afford not to be bound by the usual excuses that keep people stuck in a captive market. That's us, the techies. We don't need to be in any particular city in order to write code. Most of us are young and don't have kids. Few of us have any "root" in the Bay Area, so we couldn't care less about being uprooted [1]. There is no reason for us to be a part of San Fran's captive housing market. We can pack up and leave, all 8% of us if possible. That would be "supply and demand" doing its work. Of course, there are a few problems with this proposal, including the fact that there really is such a thing as social networking of the offline kind. The Bay Area undoubtedly has one of the best tech "scenes" in the world. But I see it as a problem that needs to be fixed, not merely an advantage that we're free to exploit. HN, for example, requires everyone to move to the Bay Area, perhaps for a good reason. But in doing so, they directly contribute to, and exacerbate, the hideous distortion of the Bay Area's housing market. It's like mandating that everyone meet at a particular Starbucks. It makes sense when everyone you want to meet is already a regular of that Starbucks, but when the manager of Starbucks begins to take advantage of its captive clientele, you should seriously start considering an alternative. Remember, the only vote that the market respects is a vote with your feet, i.e. a realistic threat to do business with a competitor. [1] Disclaimer: I've lived in at least seven different cities in three continents, and harbor no particular emotional attachment to any of them. Apparently I'm incapable of developing an emotional attachment to geographical coordinates. But I must confess that I kinda like it that way.
- atgreen 13y agoI love the Mountain View burrowing owl reference. Here's a '96 usenet news article I posted about the endangered burrowing owls I would bike past every day in Mountain View. It just happened to be right where SGI was about to build their new HQ, and is now the heart of the Google campus. I had just moved to Silicon Valley from Canada when I posted this.... https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/rec.birds/vPvrRW_fVXE https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/rec.birds/vPvrRW_fVX...
- beachstartup 13y agoi find it interesting that there's always such willful disregard for analytical inclusion of los angeles, the 2nd largest city/metro in the US, with a housing market that dwarves all other metro areas but new york. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/15/business/more-renters-find-30-affordability-ratio-unattainable.html?hp http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/15/business/more-renters-find... los angeles leads the nation in out-of-whack median rent/median income ratios. what does that suggest to me? that it's one of the last of the major US cities with poor and lower-middle class people living in it.
- rweba 13y agoImportant quote from that article: “Increasing the supply is not going to increase the number of affordable units; that is a complete and utter fallacy,” said Jaimie Ross, the president of the Florida Housing Coalition. As the article explains, the reason is that builders are going to prefer to build "luxury" units to "affordable" ones. So having a whole bunch of construction is not necessarily going to lead to anything affordable. A construction boom may bring the high end rents down a little bit, but they'll still be out of reach of most people.
- taiki 13y agoThis is why the Free Market just doesn't fucking work. The "invisible hand" just doesn't care about marginal actors. Who cares if there's people being displaced? Free markets!@#*(_!@)# jesus I need a drink
- mmorett 13y agoAnd replace the free market with what? Communism? Where people like you try to show your brilliance at dictating how things "should be"? GTFO.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 13y ago
- flomo 13y agoI think this quote really nails the mentality in the city: > As political scientist and longtime San Francisco observer Richard DeLeon puts it: San Francisco has emerged as a “semi-sovereign city” — a city that imposes as many limits on capital as capital imposes on it. Mislabeled by some detractors as socialist or radical in the Marxist tradition, San Francisco’s progressivism is concerned with consumption more than production, residence more than workplace, meaning more than materialism, community empowerment more than class struggle. Its first priority is not revolution but protection — protection of the city’s environment, architectural heritage, neighborhoods, diversity, and overall quality of life from the radical transformations of turbulent American capitalism.
- jvm 13y ago> protection of the city’s environment, architectural heritage, neighborhoods, diversity, and overall quality of life from the radical transformations of turbulent American capitalism ...and ironically creating some of America's highest market rents in the process.
- flomo 13y agoSure it's semi-ridiculous to frame this in terms of left "progressivism", especially as the waterfront battles are being fought by rich people who live in skyscrapers who do not want other skyscrapers blocking their views. But I think the sentiment is broadly popular because it gets the heart of why people fall in love with San Francisco. It's not just the community (whatever community), it's the housing stock, the 'perfect' density, the hills, the views, the shops and restaurants, the smell of the air. That's what makes San Francisco San Francisco. One hundred years ago, Los Angeles looked a lot like SF. But they replaced 90% of the victorians, they flattened the hills, they built freeways everywhere. San Francisco was spared that, largely because the people fought back, and now the people want to fight to preserve what was saved. I'm of mixed-feelings about it. The Bay Guardian always warns of "Manhattanization", but the alternative endpoint is turning into a huge version of Carmel By The Sea.
- jvm 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- danols 13y ago"one of the world’s most valuable cultural treasures" Travel much outside of the US?
- d23 13y ago> Sorry, this isn’t a shorter post or that I didn’t break it into 20 pieces. Sorry, I didn't read it because you're a lazy writer who can't be bothered to consolidate the piece into a cohesive, easy-to-digest narrative. Oddly enough, I should be fish in a barrel, -- a mid 20s moving to SF for career; yet you couldn't take the time to work on maintaining my attention for more than a couple bullet points. The hilarious part is that you self-righteously reject that which you ultimately give in to, ("sorry [...] that I didn’t break it into 20 pieces") presumably under the continuing theme of "look at me for being better at not being better than people." So yeah, sorry I didn't read. Let me know how your blog post does.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 100k 13y agoThis is by far the most comprehensive overview of the Bay Area's messed up development priorities I've seen in one place. Kim-Mai Cutler does a great job stringing all the threads of the housing crisis together. I don't think San Francisco can build its way out of outrageous rents alone. The other cities in the Bay Area need to step up and provide the type of urban housing close to transit that people want. No more surface parking lots next to train stations.
- bcantrill 13y agoAgreed -- an amazingly good piece. I doubt that many will actually read all of it, but if you're curious about why San Francisco is in the state it's in, Kim-Mai Cutler gives you no excuses for not educating yourself. Also, for those that believe there is no alternative: the East Bay remains the best kept secret in San Francisco. When we moved here from the City for schools, we were braced for a let-down -- but having been here for six years, we know now that we will never return to the City, even when the kids are grown and gone...
- hyperbovine 13y agoSssh. The last thing we need is the SV army marching over here and ruining our half-priced rent, real cultural/economic diversity, better food/weather/everything, etc. Sssh.
- bcantrill 13y agoCrap -- you're right; sorry. Never mind, everyone! It's terrible over here -- crime is even worse than they say (I'm writing this while being carjacked), the cities can't function (two Occupy protestors have been camped on my front lawn since last year, and 911 redirects me to a recording), and the commutes are horrific (I have started working the graveyard shift just to avoid traffic). So save yourselves -- stay in the West Bay!
- dasil003 13y agoToo late you selfish bastards. I'll see you in January!
- capkutay 13y agoI think that SF's proud antiquity is coming back to bite it. The older generations fought against development for decades, now the demand for property is so high they can't afford to live here anymore.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lsiebert 13y agoOne of the things the article addresses is the fact that other communities need to build affordable housing, not just SF. I for one am going to speak to some local political figures. If you live in any city in the SF bay area, you may as well do the same. Write a letter. Express your interest in the creation of apartments in the city. Because if you build housing in the area, people will live there.
- spikels 13y agoAlmost every city in the Bay Area has a range of affordable housing programs - from public housing to income restricted rentals and ownership opportunities to rental and purchase assistance programs. Some are federal, some state, some local and many are operated by non-profits. Just search for the city and "affordable housing".
- lsiebert 13y agoAnd yet rents continued to climb, even between the dotcom bubble and the recent boom, when there was a downturn. plus many programs have a gap between abject poverty and the working poor/lower middle class americans. Lower rents and increased availability benefit almost everybody.
- orky56 13y agoJust to play devil's advocate here, what if affordable housing diminished? Would the higher rent prices put pressure on employers to raise incomes and salaries? It seems right now affordable housing is for employees who receive minimum wage. These employers are paying artificially low wages for the luxury of having their business in the Bay Area. If these employees had such a living wage, then they could find market rents that they could afford. They might have to commute longer than they currently do, but so do the infamous tech workers. More than enough of tech workers who are making 6 figures are commuting more than an hour. It might be in air-conditioned buses with wi-fi and door-to-door but once again this puts pressure on the transportation agencies to step up their games to support more travelers.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- timr 13y ago"But this paper conflates correlation with causation. He argues that when there is a decline in new housing units, there is also a decline in price." I knew this was going to happen: people have heard a trite sound-bite about "counter-intuitive" statistical logic so many times that they ignore that correlation is usually a pretty damned good signal for a causal relationship. To wit: of course there's a correlation between price and new housing units -- because it is causally related. When prices go up, developers have greater incentives to build. More importantly, in a city with as high a density as San Francisco (and yes, folks, it is dense -- the second-densest city in the US, in fact), with as many architectural challenges (seismic, geographic, etc.) the limiting factor for new construction is land and materials, not red tape. Nobody wants to hear this, but it's true. The fixed costs of building here are so high that developers won't do it unless rents go up. That's why new construction costs upwards of $4k for a 1-bedroom unit, and why new construction in SF doesn't place any real downward pressure on rents -- except (perhaps) in the very long term. At best, you're treading water. Developers don't build into a falling market. But really, the best response for the people who keep asserting that "building up" is the magical solution is to point to Manhattan: it's the densest city in America, yet it's just as expensive as San Francisco, if not more so. There are no magic bullets. San Francisco is expensive because there's a lot of money chasing a tiny little bit of land. You don't need a dissertation to explain it.
- onion2k 13y agoTo quote XKCD #552, "Correlation doesn't imply causation, but it does waggle its eyebrows suggestively and gesture furtively while mouthing 'look over there'." :)
- krashidov 13y agoCan somebody give me a perspective on how much they pay for housing ? I did a quick craigslist search expecting studios to be 2500 a month but it only took me a minute to find a very reasonable 950 A month studio apt. https://sfbay.craigslist.org/sfc/apa/4423411641.html https://sfbay.craigslist.org/sfc/apa/4423411641.html
- sAuronas 13y agoThat's because you're way out on the edge of the city in a commuter ghetto and by the looks of it you'd still be paying more than $2/SF to live in squalor (that unit is a dump, sorry). I apologize for the negativity but no one should be paying that much to commute without a nice spec (floors, kitchen and bath). You deserve better than that kitchen.
- krashidov 13y agoYou're not being negative. I'm just trying to understand the extent of the problem. I'm a student, and I've lived in worse than that for about $820. (It was right next to campus). According to google maps, this was about 10 minutes away from the heart of San Francisco (when there was no traffic). I'm guessing google doesn't paint the whole picture, and it really is as far as you say it is. Personally, if I had gotten a job in downtown SF with 6 figures, and no family, I'd have no problem living there and saving up. It doesn't look THAT bad does it? It's even got an outside area. Just my opinion though.
- taurath 13y agoI lived a block away from that apartment. Note 2 things - theres only 2 or 3 of those available in the entire city (and you have to compete for them), you will have a slumlord-style landlord who won't tolerate any noise or usually a single guest, your fixtures won't work, there will be stabbings and shootings within a block of you (not west/east oakland, but enough to have to be careful at night).
- sAuronas 13y agoLook into a small place downtown or downtown/Uptown Oakland which is a lot closer on Bart than many places in the city. It might be 10 mins driving but there's a lot to consider. Always visit the city and spend time getting a feel before you commit to a place.
- timr 13y ago"But in places where zoning regulations create artificial limits on home production, the final prices to home buyers jump far above construction costs. In the 1980s and 1990s, they found that virtually all of San Francisco’s home prices were at least 140 percent above base construction costs." The papers she's citing here exclude apartments from the analysis. They're talking about single-family homes: http://www.nber.org/papers/w8835.pdf http://www.nber.org/papers/w8835.pdf "The housing price data used in this paper to create the relationship between home prices and construction cost comes from the American Housing Survey (AHS). We focus on observations of single unit residences that are owner occupied, and exclude condominiums and cooperative units in buildings with multiple units even if they are owned" Probably not incredibly relevant to a discussion of rental prices.
- CmonDev 13y ago"... one of the world’s most valuable cultural treasures, San Francisco..." - oh, Americans :).
- pearjuice 13y agoQuite ironic how a blog constantly zooming in on the successes and ecosphere of the Valley attempt to explain the problem. The reason people are flocking to Silicon Valley is partially found in the overly-positive media reporting by Techcrunch and the like.
- rwmj 13y agoThe whole thing is ludicrous. Why can't tech workers work from home, from anywhere in the world?
- tdicola 13y agoSometimes the fastest solution to a problem is to get everyone in a room with a whiteboard and deal with it. There are ways to collaborate online, but none are as efficient as person to person. Also not everyone has a good internet connection or home office condusive to working 8 hours a day. I'm not saying people can't work from home ever, just that its not practical for the vast majority.
- lukasm 13y agoSure, but you need 2-10 people no 30 000. You definitely make remote teams work from remote offices. Also is the problem with executives in companies like Google. I believe a lot of them bought properties and they have no incentive to change the market dynamics. They working against company best interest.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rwmj 13y agoOh I don't know. How about using something like a Google Hangout? I wonder if Google could use that?
- jophde 13y agoYou could always just buy or move to a place with good internet. Comcast Business class 50/10 is about $99/month. It's still a bit cheaper than commuting.
- eloisant 13y agoSome do, actually, but the reason why startups are in Silicon Valley is because that's where the VC are. VCs want to be able to drive their Tesla from Atherton or Marina to check how the company is doing. So a startup can hire remote tech workers, but it still needs to be somewhere with capital in order to pays those remote workers. And most VCs are in SV, in particular VCs willing to invest tens of millions in a startup.
- dnr 13y agoFinally, an article on the situation that puts an accurate (i.e. large) amount of the blame on the cities of the peninsula and south bay. Also, prop 13 is the worst thing ever. Reading that section was really depressing.
- patrickg_zill 13y agoTLDR "Stupidity combined with an unwarranted trust in government to over-ride reality".
- gojomo 13y agoThis piece is very perceptive in portraying Prop 13 property-tax caps and rent-control as sibling policies, each feeding destructive "I've got mine" politics. They both bribe incumbent owners/renters/voters with an economically valuable seniority privilege, at the expense of the future and flexibility. Children and young adults suffer the most: they move the most, and none have the benefit of paying frozen base rates established 20-30 years ago. I wonder if both rent-control and prop-tax-caps could be knocked down in an equal-protection lawsuit. Why does the person who moved in yesterday, perhaps far needier than the longer-term resident/owner (and just as deserving of basic civic services) have to pay so much more? Is duration-of-residence a legitimate basis for such strong civic discrimination rooted in law?
- blueskin_ 13y agoThis is why the whole concept of renting seems bad to me. If you don't have rent control, you are condemned to a future of uncertainty, as you can never retire in case prices go up. You also pay money but never see any permanent return, as it doesn't matter how long you've been paying, you can never stop.
- alandarev 13y agoTrue, renting does not give you rights, and I see no reason why it should. But do not risk believing that buying a house for youself is a true investment. I have been renting for last five years, and I see nothing bad in renting. Though my opinion might be irrelevent to the subject, as I do not live in SF and there is no "frozen property taxes" law in UK.
- cscheid 13y agoIn the US, the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_mortgage_interest_deduction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_mortgage_interest_deductio... on your first home makes a huge difference when making rent-vs-own plans. It wasn't obvious to me when I first started making rent-vs-own plans (I'm not a US citizen). In 30-year mortgages you are realistically paying more than half your monthly payment as interest, and doing that with pre-tax money means you're conservatively looking at 15% total reduction in monthly payments compared to renting.
- Houshalter 13y agoThat was a very long but very good article. I still don't get protests over evictions or for rent control. They are literally forcing the landlord to subsidize their cost of living. But why make only landlords pay for the subsidy? Why not tax everyone? I'm ok with income redistribution, but not when it is done so inefficiently and at the expense of a specific group.
- lilsunnybee 13y agoBecause the landlords did their building in 1970 or earlier when building costs were cheaper, or bought the property rent-controls considered. The article also points out the drastic cut to property taxes a while back, from which savings generally didn't get passed on to tenants.
- madamepsychosis 13y agoHN, tell me why this wouldn't work: tax anyone renting an old property (i.e. built more than 15 years ago) for 50% of the difference between the rent now & before the tech boom. Put this to subsidise development of affordable housing in under-developed areas like SOMA. Really, the lowest hanging fruit is just building reasonable transport through the whole city. At the moment it seems like only 30-40% of SF is actually being used. Demolishing freeways & replacing them with housing would not be a bad area either. Smaller houses, like the ones in European cities, would help a lot as well.
- raldi 13y agoBecause there are way too many people exploiting the existing system; even if such a change were enacted, it would be immediately overturned via ballot proposition. Remember not just Prop 13, but also Gray Davis.
- wil421 13y ago$8,000 and month dollars for a two bedroom apartment, that is ridiculous. You could own several large house where I live. I am tired of hearing about these silly SV-SF problems. Build more and the problem will stop.
- orky56 13y agoThat's Mountain View and just the most desirable part of it. I live in the same city with rent below $1400 for a 1 bed/1 bath and just a 5 min drive from the same Caltrain station.
- nostrademons 13y agoWhere's your apartment and when did you sign your lease? I was just looking and couldn't find anything under about $1650, and that was older family-owned apartments in either the California/Escuela area or Shoreline/Wright area.
- orky56 13y agoActually California/Escuela area and signed about 1.5 years ago. On month-to-month with no rent increase since initially signing a 1-year lease.
- nostrademons 13y agoI think you've lucked out in that your landlord hasn't bothered to keep tabs on the current market. A year and a half ago $1400 was reasonable in the California/Escuela area; now, Craigslist shows a minimum of about $1700 for a 1BR, up to $2600 for 2BRs. Enjoy it while it lasts; sometimes the smaller owner-operated apartments can be nice specifically because they don't raise rents as rapidly as the professionally-managed ones.
- mathattack 13y agoVery long story. Only halfway through the original referenced article, and I can tell the writer has some solid economics chops.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- forgottenpass 13y ago>Today, the tech industry is apparently on track to destroy one of the world’s most valuable cultural treasures, San Francisco, by pushing out the diverse people who have helped create it. At least that’s the story you’ve read in hundreds of articles lately. >It doesn’t have to be this way. But everyone who lives in the Bay Area today needs to accept responsibility for making changes where they live so that everyone who wants to be here, can. I don't know if drastically changing the housing landscape of SF will destroy the culture that made everyone want into the city in the first place, but asserting that it won't is just as tenuous as asserting it will. All I ever see is rationalization that it won't, because the tech community takes it as axiomatic that they must pile into the city. By debating the conclusion we are tricked into accepting the form. For example: "But everyone who lives in the Bay Area today needs to accept responsibility for making changes" That's a lot of people. Including ones hostile to your goals. You would need to get a smaller and friendlier set of people on board to make a slightly-more geographically disperse tech scene work in the Bay Area. The self-fulfilling business "common sense" about SF is much more momentum than sense.
- overgryphon 13y agoA lot of the tech employees that are being protested are young, single, and much more willing to move for economic reasons than families. The ability to buy a house in the future, not deal with protesters, and probably make more money overall in a city with lower rents is pretty enticing. Silicon Valley has a lot of tech companies, but now Seattle and Austin do too- not as many, but growing. At some point the hatred misdirected at tech employees could result in San Francisco suffering from less tech investment than other more stable cities.
- vghui 13y agoWell, I just bough a house for $100k, life is good.
- blaurenceclark 13y agoI feel privileged to be mentioned as the homeless guy who was living on a couch at the end of the article :)
- malandrew 13y agoI wonder if SF could experience some tech detroitification in about 10-20 years, or possibly sooner. As a tech worker here, I and others engineers I know are becoming disenfranchised with the housing prices around here to the point that I'm casually exploring where I might want to move next in 4 years or so if this situation doesn't reverse itself. With the number of engineers all feeling the same, it's possible to find enough people to willing to be a co-founder and move to a much cheaper part of the world during the formative months/years when your company is pre-profit. Take Silicon Valley investing connections, a mobile workforce, rising housing prices and you basically have a confluence of forces that will accelerate a diaspora of engineers to more places in the world without necessarily giving up on the tech community that makes SF so desirable. Once decent sizeable tech communities show up in more places, the greater the likelihood that engineers in the Bay Area look around and tell themselves "This just isn't worth it. I'm paying a premium to be around colleagues, but now my colleagues are everywhere and it's just not worth it anymore." At the end of the day every engineer without rent control is going to face a financial decision once a year when rents are raised that could make moving elsewhere more attractive. What's the point of improving at your job and earning raises when most of your raise ends up going into your landlord's pocket. Do that 2-3 times and you are either going to look into someway of getting into rent control unit or you're going to start considering other options elsewhere. All you really need to stay in the area for is to create a solid enough professional network that you'll gain access to the smart capital in the region. Once you have that, you can go anywhere since investors will know you, what you're capable of and that investing in you and your business is a good idea. If this happens often enough, you're going to start to see more VCs comfortable with this approach that they'll be able to tell offer job candidates coming through the VC hiring offices positions in portfolio companies located in places that might be more desirable to a tech worker than SF. I stay in SF because some of the most interesting tech jobs are here. Once that is no longer a valid assumption and my professional network is sufficiently geographically distributed, I no longer have anything tying me solely to San Francisco. I can't count the number of conversations I've had with other engineers about thinking about moving to Berlin or Portland or even trying to set up shop in some cheap remote paradise where we would have the financial liberty to invite friends to come out and hang out in a guest room for weeks to months at a time so long as they pay the airfare and living arrangements. Top places on my list when I entertain ideas like this are small beach towns along the Northeast of Brazil. I'm often amazed at how many of my engineer friends are onboard with this ideas, more than willing to exchange San Francisco so long as they know they will have engineering peers and interesting engineering problems to solve in some other locale. Even the cultural attractions that made San Francisco awesome have been co-opted by the hipster culture and gone mainstream enough that SF no longer has the strong lead on novel cultural innovations that it once had. "It's an odd thing, but anyone who disappears is said to be seen in San Francisco. It must be a delightful city and possess all the attractions of the next world" -- Oscar Wilde All the attractions of the next world are starting to crop up everywhere more and more and here in SF less and less. Eventually the barrier to going elsewhere and still working on fun engineering problems will be easily surmountable.
- hippich 13y agoit kinda make sense, why existing population of SF tries to oppose any new building, but I still can't understand why bigger companies need to be there physically except may be top managerial stuff? It still make sense to start startup there, since this city filled with like minded people, but for bigger companies - why pursue it? Me and quite a few of my (married and with children) friends refuse even considering moving to SF exactly for this reason - too inadequate housing situation.
- melindajb 13y agoAs a 12 year plus SF Resident, married to a native San Franciscan, who has both rented and now owns property, and who follows local politics closely; I can report this is one of the most complete, articulate, and accurate summaries of the situation I've ever read. Please encourage others to read this.
- firstOrder 13y ago> parts of the progressive community do not believe in supply and demand Wow, those left wing progressives must really be crazy. It's not like tech CEO's would ever say there is a shortage of good technicians. They obviously believe in supply and demand, and that if demand, salary, working conditions and long-term career viability were good enough, the supply would arise.
- stcredzero 13y agoSanta Clara Valley was some of the most valuable agricultural land in the entire world, but it was paved over to create today’s Silicon Valley. Exact same move the Maya pulled. At their tech level, that plus climate change ended their civilization.
- tizzdogg 13y agoOne thing the article doesnt really touch on is how rent control, as well as San Francisco's many other pro-tenant laws, actually incentivizes landlords to keep rental units off the market. It's basically impossible to evict bad tenants in San Francisco for reasons other than non-payment of rent. I'm not a real estate lawyer, but my impression is it can take years and tons of legal fees to get a bad tenant out, even for reasons that in most other cities would be easy cause for eviction. I personally know a lot of mom-and-pop landlords with vacant rental units who cant be bothered to rent them, because dealing with bad tenants in SF is such a pain. These are middle-class people who bought multiple-unit buildings 20 or 30 years ago when it was affordable and dont need the rental income, and dont want the hassle. I would guess that there are thousands of units like this across the city.
- wankerrific 13y agoMore anecdata. If I had a dollar for every time I've heard this one. I refuse to believe that professional landlords are keeping units off the market when the current rental market may well represent the top of what they can get for the next 5 years. Most of the long term landlords who bought 20-30 years ago have gone through at least 3 down markets from the late 80s to now. The current employment gold rush in SF is just that, and I suspect long term owners recognize that and want to strike while the iron is hot. I am willing to change my opinion if anyone could provide any tangible data, but I only see this argument bandied about with no actual proof. So in my rebuttal, I would say that I guess that there are less than 100 units like that across the city. I have no proof, but I feel thats the case, therefore rent control not bad. See how that works?
- tizzdogg 13y agoIf you're hearing it a lot, then perhaps there might be some truth to it? You can refuse to believe whatever you want though. I agree I'd like to see a real study about this, but yeah anecdotal evidence is all I've got. I know of at least 4 landlords like this, and the set of people who I know is an extremely limited sample size. How many you encounter probably correlates to how many homeowners over the age of 60 you know. These are people who have already paid off their buildings, which is usually also their home, and have decided that the potential income stream is just not worth the hassle of renting out their extra units and potentially getting bad tenants. Especially if they have been vacant a long time and would need some sprucing up to put on the market. They are retired and comfortable as it is and just dont want to deal with it. Better to just use that unit as storage or an occasional guest house for family or whatever.
- dredmorbius 13y agoA great companion to Cutler's piece (which is excellent in its depth and analysis) is Andreas Schou's G+ post "So, why is Silicon Valley studded with an implausibly large number of abandoned barns, shacks, and other things that don't look like they belong here?": https://plus.google.com/112482032780181267192/posts/FLUkbf4kdDN https://plus.google.com/112482032780181267192/posts/FLUkbf4k... This details a great many seemingly illogical (but actually financially sensible) consequences of California's 1978 property "tax reform" measure, Proposition 13. Schou (recently hired by Google) is among the brightest lights on G+ in my experience. Much as I try to avoid the site, he draws me back at least to look.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- worklogin 13y agoI wonder what would have happened to the "Yuppie Eradication" project had the owners of said vehicles possessed defensive means such as firearms.
- Pro_bity 13y agoThis is the best TechCrunch article ever written. I wish they let their journalist spend more time doing well researched pieces like this.
- alxndr 13y agoAnd now, the KQED version of the article: http://blogs.kqed.org/newsfix/2014/04/14/San-Franciscos-Current-Boom-Repeats-an-Old-Story http://blogs.kqed.org/newsfix/2014/04/14/San-Franciscos-Curr...
- qthrul 13y agoItem 7: Move to Raleigh, NC
- 205guy 13y agoI haven't finished reading all the comments, but here's my take on the article: Great for mentioning the prop13-rentcontrol duality, a lot of people conveniently forget one side or the other. Great for delving into the politics of it all, including the neighborhood associations. Not-so-great: it was touched on but not really elaborated: why the peninsula (Palo Alto, Mountain View, Cupertino, the heart of SV) are not densifying to provide housing for the corporations they have. Some of the downtowns are very desireable, but still full of single-family homes. Some of the commercial space could be built up with housing over the businesses, and then these towns would develop even more character. I think the tech industry got a free-ride (heh) in building huge campuses in towns that have little residential growth (and even the towns' resistance to growth is mentioned). Google, Apple, etc, should be pushing on Mountain View to build 10,000 residential unites in the area. It's happening a tiny bit, but not nearly as fast as the companies are expanding. Most people don't choose 1-hour 40-mile commutes if they can avoid them. But the corporate buses make that commute feasible. I actually wonder if bus transport is reported by the employees as income for taxation purposes, and if not why? Finally, this issue really seems to stem from regional politics. SF has to compete with suburbs on tax breaks to companies, yet the suburbs can offload all the residential problems to the city. Seems like there should be state-wide rules that make this fairer.
- blazespin 13y agoPeople are choosing the 1 hour 40 mile commutes because they want to be hip and live in SF. It's going to be decade+ before the valley is hip. If you're earning 150K plus, do you really want to live on campus? Yikes. No, you are a young, urban professional that wants to dine, go to the theatre, and socialize at expensive bars on the weekends.
- sirdogealot 13y agohttp://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ >The true culprit behind our housing problems: let us deflect blame to Mountain View’s burrowing owl! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoreline_Park,_Mountain_View http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoreline_Park,_Mountain_View >City of Mountain View evicted a pair of burrowing owls so that it could sell a parcel of land to Google to build a hotel at Shoreline Boulevard and Charleston Road. ...wtf?
- lstamour 13y agoAm I the only one who thought 6,000 new homes was an extremely low number? Maybe. Here in Toronto, we've had a rough average of 35,000 new homes each year. I'm used to seeing new buildings and cranes all over town. It's not a boom town, but I've yet to hear of a shortage either... And Toronto's population is roughly 3.1x that of San Francisco, but it's held steady for roughly the last decade at least. 35/6 is 5.8x less, and given the population growth in SF, the number of new builds should be at least double; 12k perhaps. Equally funny, Toronto also had a freeway revolt and succeeded. So we have a relatively livable downtown, plus growth. Go figure. Some corridors in Toronto are nothing but skyscrapers. Height restrictions do exist, but are raised on a case-by-case basis (e.g. public art, parks can help negotiate). Even areas that fought expressways, while mostly single-dwelling, have allowed high rises along nearby major streets. That said, we're still trying to make plans to destroy the Gardiner Expressway, our Embarcadero it seems.
- akgerber 13y agoY'all got this to balance out NIMBYs: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontario_Municipal_Board http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontario_Municipal_Board Do you know what kinds of stories you never hear in California: "the OMB, against the City's wishes, approved development of a condominium/townhouse complex near a low-density residential area immediately west of North York Centre."
- QuantumChaos 13y agoSF Housing Crisis Explained: Money allows one to buy things that other people (sometimes even people poorer than oneself) might have wanted to buy themselves. From this, two things follow: (1) we should redistribute money so that the very poor can at least buy something, and (2) nerds shouldn't be allowed to have much money, since no one likes them, and so why should they be allowed to buy things that other people want to buy.