11 ms·
Daniel's review of Flash Boys: A Wall Street Revolt
- girvo 13y agoMost of the complaints I've seen are to do with the fact that HFT is t "fair" to Mr. Joe Trader, in terms of them having an advantage. My argument is that Mr. Joe Trader is at a disadvantage compared to professional traders, regardless of trading mechanism...
- glesica 13y agoJust because the game was rigged already doesn't mean that rigging it even more doesn't make a difference.
- yxhuvud 13y agoBut then you have to make an actual argument stating why HFT would make it more rigged than the alternative would be. The collapse of spreads is a lot more important than speed, for small investors.
- williamcotton 13y agoI asked a similar question below... Can you explain how the smaller spread is better for the entire system? I'm not convinced that anyone really gains much from these very marginal gains in liquidity other than the HFT entities. Personally, I'm fine paying 2% more for something if it means that the person I'm buying it from is keeping the money as opposed to some middle-man taking a cut. There seems to be a lot of unquestioned dogma in the financial world about the efficiency of the marketplace on a macroeconomic scale. But again, please correct me! I'm honestly trying to learn more about this.
- consz 13y agoWhy do you think there wouldn't still be market makers if the spread widens by 2%?
- williamcotton 13y agoWell, what's the difference to me if the spread is 0.1% or 2%? Am I really not going to buy? If I want to buy a security, don't I have to buy it at whatever price is being offered? Sure, some dude can cover the spread on both sides, but if the guys selling it to me just passed it through 50 hands going from the firm that issued the security to get to me, what's the point of all that? Like, I get the point of the liquidity offered by market makers, but I'm just questioning the marginal utility. How much less likely am I to buy or sell a security based on the marginal decreases in the spread? It doesn't seem like it would be linear. And what effects are caused by having so much complexity between the issuer and the investor?
- tptacek 13y agoThe difference is whether you pay middlemen 0.1% of the value of your trade of 2% of your trade. If you can't get worked up over a 100+bp difference in cost of trading, you shouldn't be worked up over HFT, which is operating at much smaller price deltas.
- williamcotton 13y agoIs a marketplace designed for retail investors that disallows HFT something that would be better or worse for retail investors? Let's pretend that the marketplace only sells securities with dividends. The people buying them are not interested in their liquidity, only in their ability to store value as well as ofter a steady return. Why would I want to buy shares in companies in any other type of marketplace? Can you explain how this hypothetical market would function differently than how our current markets function?
- tptacek 13y agoWorse. You don't have to guess: there are two compelling pieces of evidence you can use to evaluate. First, you can look at spreads since electronic traders wiped out the 1/8ths market makers in the 1990s. Second, you can look at the Canadian experiment that increased cost of trades and drove spreads up. "Type of company" and "marketplace" are orthogonal concerns.
- yxhuvud 13y agoBut the person you would buy from is just as much a middle-man as the HFT! Market makers have always existed, and the only difference is that the new middlemen are taking a lot smaller share than they did before. You are no longer paying for fatcat brokers, and HFT bots are a lot less likely to give inside information to friends.
- williamcotton 13y agoBut what about the spread between the actual issuer of the security and the actual investor looking for a long term value store? How does that change? Isn't this minute spread just a result of speculators trading amongst themselves? Pardon me for not making it clear, but I assume that at least one simple market maker is required for the transaction. I'm talking about it passing through more hands than theirs. How does it magically reduce what the fundraiser is willing to sell at and what I'm willing to buy at?
- yxhuvud 13y agoHuh? The fundraiser would get money at the price at the lower end of the spread, and the investor would buy at the upper end, so your question is nonsensical. The difference is what the market maker takes for providing liquidity (in exchange for providing money now and for taking a risk that the price may change out of the spread range). Spread == price of liquidity.
- williamcotton 13y agoWhat I'm asking is, how does HFT lower the spread? The spread is just the difference between what one person is willing to sell and another willing to buy. If it's Monday and I'm trying to raise money for a venture by selling shares at a certain price, and some other dude has extra money laying around but wants to buy it for less, that's the spread, right? I either sell for less directly to the retail investor or a market maker happens to come in to the picture and I happily get to sell to him at the price I wanted to. He thinks my price will go up by Friday and that these other dudes will definitely be willing to pay more for the shares that he did by then. At which point he will profit, right? But that never changed what I was willing to sell and some dude was unwilling to buy at on a Monday. How does HFT affect all of this?
- tptacek 13y agoNo, but when the new "rigging" actually improves the situation for retail investors at the expense of increased costs for hedge funds, it becomes hard to make simplistic comparisons. The public markets are a series of zero-sum games. When you fully understand this, it becomes apparent that almost any profit-making strategy for engaging with them can be described as a form of "rigging". Every dollar Virtu makes has to come out of someone else's pockets. The important thing to know is "whose pocket". People on HN love to play six-degrees-of-Mom's-retirement about this issue. That game doesn't actually work. Consider two scenarios: (a) By increasing the cost for billion-dollar broker/dealers to shop blocks, electronic trading systems are making it more expensive for mutual funds to trade and thus extracting rents from the hides of pension funds; the pockets picked are ultimately those of ordinary Americans. (b) By preying on naive market-making strategies, electronic trading systems are disrupting an entrenched cartel of billion-dollar market players, and in the process driving trading spreads to historic lows without measurably impacting volatility in the market; the pockets picked are those of other, more brazen pickpockets. The difference between (a) and (b) is crucially important. If the status quo ante is bad, and the new situation is better, then organizing against that change is a positive action taken in favor of unfairness. Significant evidence points to (b).
- tom_b 13y agoSince I noticed previously you were also reading Dark Pools (commented in another thread), I found that book to pile up evidence for (b) as well. Do you have similar takeaway from Dark Pools? In particular, in the early days of electronic trading, that book clearly makes the case that the hackers (or maybe mainly Josh Levine) were completely focused on disrupting a corrupt and "good old boy" network driven trading system. But (and I say this after having read both the Lewis book and Dark Pools), I'm not entirely sure what to think about HFT (or more broadly, electronic trading in general) and market volatility. It kind of seems like there is going to be some popularly accepted government regulation of electronic trading that my gut tells me will be more acceptable for the "other, more brazen pickpockets" than the new, despite the fact that we think choice (b) is better for investors.
- tptacek 13y ago
- Volscio 13y ago"Mr. Joe Trader" might need some definition. For instance, I felt that HFT didn't change the game for "Mr. Joe Trader" as much as the rules limiting daytrading ($25k minimum for margin, restriction on round-trip trades per quarter) did. Now you need to be fairly well off or trade pretty much full-time to be able just to enter the game. Fees may be down but fewer players can play.
- igl 13y agoPity, it is a bad book. Im still very much against HFT.
- aet 13y agoThere is no point to being "against HFT" -- you need to support an alternative market design and explain why it would be better.
- fsk 13y agoThe best proposal I've heard: Instead of continuous trading, have an auction every 1-60 seconds. One trade per minute is plenty.
- yxhuvud 13y agoWhat problem would that solve?
- kasey_junk 13y agoA couple of issues with this: 1) most of the arguments for call auctions instead of continuous trading assume a centralized call auction that in and of itself adds no cost above our current decentralized exchanges. This seems like an extremely troublesome assumption given that we have seen the negative impact of centralized monopoly exchanges. 2) If it isn't a centralized auction there needs to be some price sync. mechanism. The most obvious one seems to be either latency arbitraging HFT (which for some reason people don't like) or a governmental central auction block the type of which is already causing legislative arbitration in the current markets. 3) Call auctions in and of them selves do not solve the major issue with our current prioritization system. If the auction algorithm has several prices that match the same amount of participants, or if the price it determines has an uneven number of buyers & sellers, who gets priority? 4) Price discovery is currently harder in call auction instruments. That could be because they are only done in illiquid markets and liquidity itself will fix that, but it is an issue with the current examples of this style of trading. 5) "Market" order mechanism. Many, many market participants are more worried about making sure they buy/sell than about high fidelity price fairness. If I say, "I want out of Goog no matter what", that complicates any auction methodology and introduces opportunities for gaming. At the end of the day, I can't figure out who will actually be protected in this style of market and to whose disadvantage. That is a lot of added complexity for a very vague benefit.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Bootvis 13y agoWho is this mister Daniel?
- omonra 13y agoThat's exactly what I thought. Why should I care what some random guy called Danny thinks about a clearly controversial issue (and it only seems controversial to those who have a vested interest in this business).
- consz 13y agoMaybe you should attack his actual argument instead of dismissing it by appealing to lack of authority.
- tptacek 13y agoYou shouldn't care about Daniel. You should evaluate the content on its own merits. Have you done that? What is your response?
- Bootvis 13y agoI do, I was just confused by the title. With that out of the way: not reading this book. Any critique should at least get its facts right and if I want to be entertained I prefer other authors.
- tptacek 13y agoOh! The reason this was submitted was that someone found it during a previous discussion of Lewis' book, and then 'yummyfajitas (a long-time HN contributor and former HFT person) wrote a comment about how good the review was. It was submitted to keep it from being lost in the shuffle of a long, noisy thread.
- Bootvis 13y agoWhich leads me to that thread, thanks :)
- Tycho 13y agoCan anyone elaborate on the secret bail out of Canadian banks ?
- lingben 13y agohttp://www.cbc.ca/news/business/banks-got-114b-from-governments-during-recession-1.1145997 http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/banks-got-114b-from-governme...
- unreal37 13y agoI wondered that as well, so thanks for posting this link. This claim seems dubious. This CCPA report is saying the majority of the "bail out" was from the CMHC (our FNMA) buying mortgages (which were already insured by them) from banks. Thus, assets were exchanged for cash at a fair market value. Is that a bail out? A fishy anti-business report quoted by a supposed wall-street trader. Michael Lewis' book has brought some strange groups on the same side of the issue I guess.
- dodyg 13y agoFelix Salmon from FT wrote this review and has similar criticism about the book http://www.slate.com/articles/business/books/2014/04/michael_lewis_s_flash_boys_about_high_frequency_trading_reviewed.html http://www.slate.com/articles/business/books/2014/04/michael...
- mathcop 13y agoI work directly on this at the SEC and as such cannot comment on the matter publicly. I post here only due to the correlation between people who would read the comments of this post and those who might be interested in getting involved... because we are hiring. Specifically, we're looking for 1-2 core devs (hacker/generalist types honestly). Python's our main language now & I'm trying to incorporate Haskell as well. Green card/Citizen required + NYC only (sorry, not up to me), salary 120k-190k/yr, 40hr/wk, awesome team run like a research arm. martinow at SEC dot gov.
- williamcotton 13y agoI'm always told that HFT makes the bid/ask spread go from 0.25 to 0.01. I'm always told this is a good thing... But why is that? Let's say we didn't have HFT and we had a larger spread... That means that one of the parties is overpaying, right? But, aside from the burdens of the individual overpayer, doesn't it make more sense for the overall ecosystem to at least keep that money in the pockets of people who are interested in the long term value of the equity? What are the overall economic marginal returns on squeezing the spread so thin? Is it possible that it might make more macroeconomic sense to NOT have some other entity profiting off of having created a minutely more liquid marketplace?
- strongvigilance 13y agoThere have always been middlemen, as, especially with less liquid instruments, there won't necessarily be equal supply and demand from "natural" buyers and sellers. As markets have gone from floor trading, to point+click on computer screens, to automation of different levels of sophistication, efficiency has improved - people complain about HFT stealing pennies, but in the past, someone was stealing quarters. The difference is that the skills required have changed tremendously - a few years ago, it was all about being well connected or going to the right school - now it's all about how good your code is. It's not particularly surprising that the loudest anti-HFT voices are guys whose profit margins have been killed by it. Disclosure: my profit margins have been killed by HFT...
- tptacek 13y agoThe spread is a fee charged by liquidity providers (market makers) to traders. Whether you trade every day or only once a year, the spread is effectively money taken from the trader and put in the pockets of market-makers. If you want to disincentivize active trading (more than the market already does, by awarding outsized returns to funds that don't rely on active trading), a tax on trades performs this function more effectively than high spreads do. Worth noting: during the times when spreads were as high as 0.25, that was in large part the result of collusion between the market makers, who were eventually taken to court over it.
- 13y ago
- vishaldpatel 13y agoOn Canadian Household debt (as of July 16th, 2013): http://www.td.com/document/PDF/economics/special/CanadianHouseholdDebt.pdf http://www.td.com/document/PDF/economics/special/CanadianHou... "• However, the most commonly cited debt-to-income statistics in Canada and the U.S. are not directly comparable. There are differences in the methodologies used to calculate both debt and income. There are also differences in how health care is funded in Canada and the U.S. that should be fac - tored into the amount of personal disposable income households have to help service their debt. "
- ccurtsinger 13y agoDaniel claims that volatility is actually lower with HFT when you look at implied volatility, a predictive measure of volatility. Lewis uses actual historical volatility in his argument. You shouldn't use a predictive measure when analyzing past performance: Implied volatility is computed base on the difference between an option's selling price and an algorithmically-determined price. That's exactly the sort of information any trader would rely on to place bets. When the calculated value is higher than the price, there is profit to be made. Any decrease in trading latency will allow traders to buy up instruments selling below their estimated value a bit quicker, driving these numbers closer together.
- tptacek 13y agoThat's not the only distinction being made here; the other argument is that Lewis is capturing a lot of factors other than HFT when considering volatility; for instance, the collapse of the collateralized debt market.