4 ms·
Step 1, find 0% humidity, where are you going todo that where people are living? Strawman.
by sitkack 13y ago
Step 1, find 0% humidity, where are you going todo that where people are living? Strawman.
- ghshephard 13y agoEven the Desert Playa, which cracks your skin, and causes throats to dry out, has a low of 17% humidity, and an annual average of 45% humidity.
- shadowmint 13y agoThe point is that this is a fog harvesting device; it collects tiny droplets of water in the air efficiently. Fog is where you have > 70% (roughly) humidity, even if its only for a period of time. Deserts have highly variable humidity, often 10-30% during the day, and great at night; maybe 50% ... but you dont get fog in deserts, or, for that matter, in many other places. In some very specific regions, like Ethiopia, where you have misty mountainous regions; this is a useful device (see the article for the other very misty locations they talk about deploying this in). If you put it in your backyard, you'll probably get a tiny trickle from it occasionally, unless you live in Wales. The refrigerative water generators (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_water_generator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_water_generator) can work in places with relatively low humidity; these ones do not.
- clhodapp 13y agoI believe that my argument remains a solid, semi-logical rebuttal (it does depend on some physical intuition) to the claim that we can fully trust the original article's claim that the effectiveness of the device depends only on the temperature differential at the location where it is deployed. At the very least, the claim needs to be demonstrated in the field or explained by some documented physical phenomenon before I'll completely trust it.
- sitkack 13y agoSay that instead. Arguing that it only works in high humidity environments while using 0% humidity as your basis isn't sound.
- aaron695 13y agoAntarctica. Space is another, but a bit more pedantic. But both are places that water would be valuable.