3 ms·
From a comment on CNET: by dennisheadley August 12, 2009 1:25 AM PDT The company in question is not a patent troll company. They actually were the first compan
by yread 17y ago
From a comment on CNET:
by dennisheadley August 12, 2009 1:25 AM PDT
The company in question is not a patent troll company. They actually were the first company to develop seamless use of XML from within word. This was before MS offered any such feature of its own in word. As a matter of fact MS at the time completely avoided XML, refused to support it and tried to do their own proprietary format version of it instead.
I4I the company had the world recognized top system out there for XML implementation and management in large scale companies and was the chosen to power such things as the, and this is ironic, the US patent system, the FDA's new streamlined submission system, which uses a open standard chiefly developed from two companies technologies, i4i being one of them.
While i do not usually condone these lawsuits. MS in this case realized that its efforts to avoid using XML were going against corporate customer demands, pretty much just took the best system available from a third party for this purpose and almost straight up incorporated it into word. I read quite a few articles on this when they talked about it earlier this year. And you have to remember that XML is common use now, but this was started years ago when it was not common in actual use and this companies solution was more than just a save to XML function, it was not an easy accomplishment like some of you would pretend it was.
This company made its fortune on servicing the majority of the fortune 500 companies, many of them software giants, as well as many government agencies.
Can anyone confirm?
- barrkel 17y agoStill sounds suspiciously like a "nickels in front of a steamroller" issue.
- tocomment 17y agoWhat does that phrase mean? I couldn't find anything using a google search.
- imichael 17y agoYou might pick up a few nickels, but you might also get crushed. (I'm not sure how it applies here.)
- billswift 17y agoHe obviously meant that if you add useful, basic functionality to a major system or app (iPhone in the original discussion, Word here), don't be surprised if it is directly incorporated into the system/app.
- liquidben 17y agoI'm not sure about sourcing, but it was recently used on the Stack Overflow podcast in Jeff and Joel's discussion of the profitability of creating plug-ins for another piece of software. Other considerations aside, one of the greatest threats to stability was if you created something so useful to the general userbase of the parent application, that the producers of the parent application would roll that up into the next version of their software, thereby rendering your cash cow redundant, e.g. a spell-checker for Firefox. Joel likened this to snatching nickel from in front of an oncoming steamroller.
- bmm6o 17y agothe phrase "picking up nickels in front of a steam roller" refers to doing something dangerous for little gain.
- bilbo0s 17y agoI have some insight into the FDA's submission system. There are some inconsistencies in what the commenter here is claiming, and the experience of my company submitting software to the FDA for approval. I would not call their new system streamlined, and as I have been told from time to time that their database is down I am curious how it could be using XML on the backend. Is XML over HTTP part of their patent? If the patent is for XML in Word, well, Word is not even in that web-based workflow. Further, and this is just a nit-pick I realize that the guy may have misspoken. That said, assuming there is XML on the backend, and it is using an "open standard chiefly developed from . . ." i4i's tech, then it is not really an open standard is it? In short, based on my knowledge, derived from extensive involvement in regulatory affairs in the medical imaging field, the second paragraph in that comment is highly suspect.
- cdr 17y agoHere's a reddit comment/thread on the patent: http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/99utb/judge_orders_microsoft_to_stop_selling_word/c0bxyul http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/99utb/judge_ord...
- joe_the_user 17y agoI can't confirm this but I don't think it matters. If it was true, it would prove "not patents suits involve patent trolls as plaintives" but this would not, by itself, even prove "some software patent suits have validity". Sure, they might have done something before MS and patented it. But processing XML is not rocket-science and thus, to me, this patent stinks. Further, if this validated either MS buys them and they go after everyone else OR they just go after everyone else on their own. Either way you get monopolistic rent extraction. Sorry if this give any new or exciting angles on this subject.