28 ms·
Japanese railway operator to license maglev tech to US for free
- markbao 13y agoJapanese railway operator to license maglev tech to US for free
- stingraycharles 13y agoSo that means they can use the tech, but not redistribute it to anyone else? Sounds pretty fair to me.
- arrrg 13y agoThe technology has existed for so long but never really went anywhere. After half a century there are 30km in Shanghai, that’s all. Maybe it will work out better in the future. The biggest problem I see is that the gains of this technology would be rather small anywhere with conventional high-speed rail or existing infrastructure that can be upgraded to that. With Maglev everything needs to be built from scratch. That’s just not very attractive for any place that has consistently expanded its rail network ever since the height of the industrial revolution. And for what? A 180km/h faster train? I personally very much want that, sure, but is it worth it for anyone building it? I’m pretty sure I know the answer in Western Europe (though I can always hope that maglev has a future there), I’m not so sure when it comes to the US.
- meddlepal 13y agoIf the NEC could do 200MPH consistently Boston-NYC-DC ... that would be huge. Boston to NYC in 1 hour and Boston to DC in 2 hours would be amazing and would be far faster than airport or vehicle travel.
- ericd 13y agoIf this was reasonably priced, it would increase travel between those cities by a large amount.
- willholloway 13y agoI ride the North East Corridor rails often and have clocked the Acela at 130 MPH via GPS going into Boston, and the Northeast Regional hits 115 MPH in spots from Eastern CT to NYC. The route is just too winding for those speeds in so many places and you end up going 60MPH for much of the trip. The best views going north are past the Connecticut river, rolling through Niantic, to New London and the small coastal villages like Mystic, and heading south the rail bridge that runs next to the Triborough gives you a fantastic panorama of Manhattan's east side. I love the train.
- ddrmaxgt37 13y agoVery sad since IIRC Acela was supposed to have its own high speed rail but runs on existing track due to budget
- tcas 13y agoI've clocked Acela at just below 150mph on my GPS in between Providence and Boston. As I understand it, they would like to go faster in other sections, but the track / catenary isn't able to sustain that speed on most of the journey. Still way better than flying for BOS<->NYC or NYC<->WAS. It's a shame that the ticket prices are 2x what the regional is though. Never heard about having dedicated rails. It would be nice, since the FRC requires any train that travels on track shared by freight to be basically built like a tank, which makes them much more expensive to make an operate.
- Brian-Puccio 13y ago> and heading south the rail bridge that runs next to the Triborough gives you a fantastic panorama of Manhattan's east side. For anyone else interested, that's the Hell Gate Bridge[0]. It's odd, I'm in the generation that will always think of the Triborough as the Triborough, not the RFK, the same way others still think Interboro, not Jackie Robinson. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hell_Gate_Bridge http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hell_Gate_Bridge
- seszett 13y agoYou don't need maglev for that, though, high-speed rail can reach those speeds. And a big advantage of rail is that the trains can just run on conventional track and progressively go faster while portions of the track are converted to high-speed, while maglev needs a complete run of maglev track before it starts being usable.
- zhte415 13y agoHigh speed rail is often implemented using dedicated track wherever possible - either brand new or upgraded and restricted to other traffic types: A closely sitting and smooth train wheel gets damaged pretty quickly traveling on track that is accustomed to freight traffic. That now-damaged wheel then goes on to damage the polished high speed track, which then further damages other trains' wheels in a vicious circle. China's new high speed train network, for example, is almost all dedicated track (a large part newly constructed routes) with existing track used only where there are space constraints (for example, a city centre station).
- seszett 13y agoFrench TGV runs on a significative amount of non-highspeed track though, and it seems to work good enough (about the same speed as China's HSR, and it has been working for decades).
- zhte415 13y agoI understand the TGV uses weight limitation and careful scheduling to mitigate the cost of other traffic (both wear-and-tear and scheduling), and as in the case of China also has sections of line that are unavoidably mixed, but used, as cost effective alternatives are not attractive. And I think that's the crux: a trade-off between cost and benefit. A new high-speed line is still margins cheaper than a maglev, though that's not to say I'd not like to see maglevs.
- rayiner 13y agoThe northeast is as dense as western Europe.
- Tuna-Fish 13y agoThe density isn't really the issue, it's that high-speed rolling stock is simply too good for the massive investment to replace it to be worth it. In the US, the railway system was developed for freight primarily, and is not suitable for high-speed rail. So, if you want faster trains, you have to lay new track regardless. In that situation, maglev is not necessarily a terrible choice.
- danielsiders 13y agoOr even the Taiheiyo belt in Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiheiy%C5%8D_Belt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiheiy%C5%8D_Belt
- bpicolo 13y agoAnd yet nowhere close to as dense as Japan.
- biot 13y agoQuite a long time... I rode the maglev train at the Japan pavilion at Expo '86. It was so smooth you almost couldn't tell you were moving.
- melling 13y ago"And for what? A 180km/h faster train?" Going an extra 110mph(180km/h) would be a huge win. It greatly extends the distance where a train wins over a jet. Also consider, for instance, in the NYC area, you could live 100 miles away from Manhattan and easily commute to work. That means you could live in downtown Philly and work in Manhattan, 30 minutes away. The world becomes a lot smaller.
- cafard 13y agoIt seems to me that you would need to exercise a fair bit of eminent domain, and there you might find that the world is indeed smaller. The article mentions Washington to Baltimore as the first segment to be built. The existing rail lines pass over a number of level crossings, and pass under some bridge spans that are fairly snug for the existing track. And the mile or two before you get to Baltimore's Penn Station are in tunnel. I doubt the tunnel has much width to spare--how much would it cost in 2014 to widen a couple of miles of tunnel under a densely built city?
- bazzargh 13y agoYou could get a ballpark figure by looking at Crossrail: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossrail http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossrail 73 miles of track, 40 stations, 26 miles of tunnel under London. £16bn ($27bn-ish). So, for your project, I'd handwave at $1-5bn.
- ekianjo 13y ago> Going an extra 110mph(180km/h) would be a huge win. It greatly extends the distance where a train wins over a jet. Not really, because jets will go much more places that your single maglev line ever will. That's the problem with hi-tech trains. They are extremely costly to deploy in terms of infrastructure, they go over land that could be used for other purposes, and because of the large investment required they only go in very few places. Jets win everywhere else.
- melling 13y ago"Jets win everywhere else." Of course they don't. Getting to an airport 60-90 minutes before a flight that's only 60-90 minutes doesn't make much sense
- tunesmith 13y agoI don't think the appetite for train travel is a linear thing. For instance here in the Seattle/Portland corridor, the train trip is both slower than by car, and more expensive than the car's gas bill. If it were consistently faster and/or cheaper, I can't help but think that the demand would spike dramatically.
- Istof 13y agoJapan also offer loans to USA for building maglev trains http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/japan/10555330/Japan-offers-to-lend-US-half-the-cost-of-Super-Maglev-train-between-Washington-and-Baltimore.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/japan/1055533...
- jlj_20 13y agoWhat about Elon Musk's hyperloop venture, are they in the running?
- stcredzero 13y agoElon Musk's Hyperloop makes sense from first principles. Most people and therefore most governments don't think that way.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- brenschluss 13y agoThere was a time when maglev was a theory - until it was tested, prototyped, and implemented. Let's wait and see. If we said "but it's never been done!" to every new idea, we'd be lacking a lot of interesting/important thing.
- omegant 13y agoYes, Hyperloop Transportation Technologies exists (I'm volunteer), they are going to design and build a prototipe using crowdsourcing engineering (not capital as far as I know). Also they have contact with several universities and companies that are interested in partnering and developint part of the systems. Right now they are working in the legal parts of the company and mean while there is a brainstorming at the engineering part with calculations beyond tha alpha document. It's a hard process as the technology is so new, but amazing non the less. The idea is to start building and testing a scale prototipe for 2015 in LA.
- ChrisNorstrom 13y agoJapan's maglev technology (EDS) is very different from Germany's maglev technology (EMS) that's being used in Shanghai. One pulls the train up electromagnetically to a steel track and the other uses permanent magnets to push the train away from the track. Both are still going nowhere. And it's for good reason. ● Both are extremely expensive per mile compared to HSR (high speed rail). Sure it's faster than high speed rail but a technology doesn't make it because it's better, but because it's more practical to implement. ● Service is not as tried and trusted as HSR. Germany's test facilities have been torn down after the Shangai maglev was built and Japan's maglev hasn't been expanded. On an emotional human level it just doesn't feel trustworthy. If you're not growing you're dying. ● Both technologies are proprietary whereas HSR has more companies and manufacturers to chose from. ● HSR could probably compete with maglev speeds by building a wider gauge track, using larger wheels, and implementing more aerodynamic designs to reduce drag and power consumption. ● Germany and Japan are pitching their maglev trains while they themselves aren't avid users of them. === Lessons === If you want something to succeed sometimes you have to set it free. If you're not expanding or growing you're dying. If you want people to use your solution, instill trust by investing in and using your own solution.
- rangibaby 13y agoA full Tokyo-Nagoya-Osaka maglev (SCMaglev) line is under construction in Japan right now, with the Tokyo-Nagoya leg due to be in operation by 2027.[0] As if late, traditional HSR is getting a lot of competition (in Japan at least) from domestic flights that cost almost exactly the same and take about the same amount of time. This has led to a resurgence of the "old" airports in Tokyo, Nagoya and Osaka. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuo_Shinkansen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuo_Shinkansen
- snogglethorpe 13y agoYou don't appear to have kept up with Japanese maglev development in the last decade or so. Japan actually is going ahead with a major maglev line, to the tune of almost $100 billion (privately financed by JR central).
- ulfw 13y agoJapan is spending a crapload of money building their maglev line between their two biggest cities. How is that being 'no avid users' of them?
- denzil_correa 13y agoIs there a specific reason to license it for "free" or is there something more to it than meets the eye?
- fredgrott 13y agoIts not the speed, its the distance between the stops.. Let me give you an example...in the midwest USA there is a short commuter line called South Shore that runs from SouthBend Indiana to southern shore of Lake Michigan and up to the Loop in Chicago Most of the stations on the South Shore are either blocks apart or a few miles apart..which negates a high speed rail solution
- ThePhysicist 13y agoI think the problem with the US railway system is not the lack of technology, but politics: People seem to love bold and mostly unrealistic proposals like Elon Musk's "Hyperloop" or the Maglev technology but seem to be a lot less passionate about making existing infrastructure better (which understandably is much more boring): As an example, I just took the Amtrak train from NYC to Montreal to attend PyCon (which is awesome!), which took all in all 11 hours to cover a distance a little over 530 km. For comparison, going from my hometown Saarbrücken in Germany to Paris (which is about the same distance) takes less than two hours (1:40h to be exact) with TGV or ICE trains. Arguably for the latter there is no border to be crossed (OK actually there is but none that is patroled) but still, this kind of makes you wonder why a high-tech nation like the USA doesn't have a similar system of high-speed trains in place, and I think that the answer has more to do with political unwillingness and lobbying than with lack of technology. BTW, in Germany there once was an attempt to build a Transrapid (our version of Maglev that is deployed in Shanghai, developed by Siemens http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transrapid http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transrapid) track to connect the Munich airport to the city centre (see "Munich Link" section in the article above), but calculations showed that the achievable time saving compared to the latest generation of ICE high-speed trains would be only 3 minutes, whereas the additional cost would have been around 3 BN €, which lead to the project being eventually ditched.
- johansch 13y agoSlightly off-topic: I've noticed that public transport from city center to airport kind of suck in larger german cities. In e.g. Berlin (for SXF at least), Frankfurt and Munich there's only the fantastically slow S-Bahn, with ride times around 40-60 minutes.
- ThePhysicist 13y agoAgreed, Frankfurt and Hamburg are pretty ok though. And in Berlin it's not only the transportation to the airport but the airport itself that sucks ;) * *the announced opening date of the new airport has been delayed by several years to the point where it's questionable if it will ever open...
- 13y ago
- fsckin 13y agoIf you ever have the chance to ride the Shanghai maglev from Pudong airport into the city, splurge a little bit for first class. It's incredibly relaxing before or after a long flight and watching the world fly past at 270mph and not feeling crowded or touching other people for 8 minutes. Oh, and don't trust any taxi driver who speaks English, you're extremely likely to be scammed. Don't ask me how I know.