8 ms·
Let's just take a step back and note something: This is about human lives. Once you eliminate birth-defects, car accidents are the leading cause of death for
by Pxtl 13y ago
Let's just take a step back and note something:
This is about human lives. Once you eliminate birth-defects, car accidents are the leading cause of death for people under 35. Particularly for young kids, who obviously aren't driving.
Car accidents kill 34,000 Americans per-year. That's like if 9/11 happened once a month every year.
And speed matters. Stopping distance and kinetic energy go up with the square of velocity. A pedestrian hit by a car going 20 mph will almost certainly live. A person hit by a car going 40 mph will almost certainly die.
- GrinningFool 13y agoDriving like an idiot while speeding causes accidents. Speeding itself does not cause accidents. Speeding does mean that in the event of an accident, the outcome is likely to be worse for all involved. And there's no excuse for speeding in a residential area, or anywhere you might see pedestrians (or expect them and be unable to see them). This qualifies as "driving like an idiot".
- mikeash 13y agoI'd like to clarify a bit on "speeding itself does not cause accidents". You're mostly right, but it's not strictly true. There are realistic cases where speeding itself will cause a crash, such as poor visibility where you're driving too fast to stop within the distance you can see, driving fast enough to lose control on poor surfaces, being too fast to take a curve, and such. I don't know how significant it is, I just want to say this because people shouldn't think that they can go as fast as they want as long as they drive well. Sometimes you simply have to slow down. (I got reminded of this last year when I wrecked my car by hydroplaning on the highway. Technically I was within the posted speed limit, but clearly I was going too fast for conditions. Speed definitely caused the accident unless you want to blame the highway department for poor drainage or mother nature for the weather. Which, of course, I do, but I still should have gone slower.)
- GrinningFool 13y ago> to stop within the distance you can see, driving fast enough to lose control on poor surfaces, being too fast to take a curve, and such. Agreed, but I classify that as "driving like an idiot" - driving too fast for conditions is in a category beyond speeding. Part of driving well is knowing - outside of concerns for a ticket - when it's possible to speed safely (and by how much), and when it's not.
- yongjik 13y agoI doubt how anybody can claim they're "driving safely" when the only observer is oneself and there is no baseline to compare against. This is about as statistically meaningful as people buying homeopathy stuff because they "know" it works. At least homeopathy doesn't kill bystanders.
- bryanlarsen 13y ago93% of drivers think they're a better than average driver. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_superiority#cite_note-26 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_superiority#cite_note-...
- azth 13y agoWhile I know what you're getting at, it is possible to have X > 50% of a sample be better (or worse) than the average -- just being pedantic :)
- nb4hnp 13y agoPeople who complain about motorists being incompetent often fail to remember the thousands of other cars that they pass every single day without incident. 93% actually sounds low for people who are probably decent enough drivers. It's the rest of them that cause the problems that everyone loves to dwell on.
- bagels 13y agoAmazingly... (assuming normal distribution) more than half of them are probably correct.
- bradleyjg 13y agoThis attitude is exactly why I think that vehicular assault and homicide should be prosecuted even if alcohol isn't involved. Every jerk with a fast car thinks he's god's gift to driving and the rules shouldn't apply to him. Then when there's a crash it's described as an accident. In the overwhelming number of cases it wasn't an accident, it was negligence, often criminal negligence. You want to drive fast go to a track, on the public roadways follow the damn law.
- harshreality 13y ago> You want to drive fast go to a track, on the public roadways follow the damn law. The "jerks with fast cars" group that you're targeting is breaking the same laws that 99% of other drivers break. In some ways, other drivers are worse. Nobody obeys posted speed limits, except on side streets. Very few people pay enough attention to their driving; they're mostly talking on cell phones or daydreaming or talking to a passenger. Jerks with fast cars, at least, are focused on driving. Collisions at those speeds may not be survivable, but I don't want to get into any collision at highway speeds; their driving patterns are more predictable, and I prefer them over distracted or ADHD drivers who make quick lane changes without proper awareness.
- aeturnum 13y ago>Jerks with fast cars, at least, are focused on driving. Maybe they are, maybe they aren't, but I doubt speed is a good predictor of attention or skill. Poor drivers have a greater risk of causing an accident than skilled drivers at all speeds. We still punish skilled drivers the same as poor drivers because it's hard to differentiate between them. Take a driver of unknown skill who's driving 1 standard deviation above the speed limit. He could be above-average, and be just as safe as an average driver going the speed limit. He could also be below-average and believe he's safe - but would actually need to go one standard deviation slower than the speed limit to match the safety limit of the skilled driver. So, we punish them both the same, because we can't know.
- thaumaturgy 13y agoYeah. I don't generally care too much if somebody's going a bit fast, so long as they aren't driving erratically. What does cause a lot of swearing and the occasional close call: - People merging on or off the highway at unsafe speeds (usually, too slow), without looking and picking a spot in traffic to merge into; - People "being polite" at intersections; - People not using their turn signals; - People cutting in traffic, swerving, cutting off other cars, tailgating, or otherwise driving too aggressively; - People trying to beat the light; - People talking on the damn phone -- I don't care who you are, you can't do that and pay full attention to the road at the same time; - People daydreaming, hanging out with their passengers, otherwise not paying attention to traffic both ahead and behind them. Fast drivers are almost the least offensive nuisance on the road.
- danbruc 13y agoThis just raised the question in me how efficient speed limits are. Being from Germany with no speed limit on the Autobahn I expected to see at least a slightly higher number of road fatalities in Germany. A quick look at Wikipedia confirmed that speed limits in the USA and in Germany are roughly comparable besides the unlimited Autobahn where people driving at 130 mph and more is not uncommon. [1] USA Germany Towns 25 – 45 majority 31, some 18 - 43 Single Carriageway 55 62 Dual Carriageway 65 - 80 unlimited, 80 advisory To my surprise I found the following numbers for road fatalities per million inhabitants in 2010. [2] USA 105 Germany 45 Any ideas how this could be explained? Could it matter that Germany is way smaller and the way to the next hospital is often shorter? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_limits_by_country http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_limits_by_country [2] http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verkehrstod#Dimensionen http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verkehrstod#Dimensionen
- Pxtl 13y agoMore likely it's the lower number of driving-hours per-person. The longer you drive, the greater the odds that something can go wrong. Germany, like most of Europe, has dense old urban cities and good transit infrastructure compared to American suburban sprawl. That means the average German doesn't spend as much time behind the wheel, if at all. I wouldn't be surprised if Germany is substantially more dangerous per-driving-kilometer than the USA, but with far fewer driving-kms per person. Also, remember that in many locations the "speed limit" isnt' really the defining thing that controls how drivers handle the road - many dense twisty urban environments are tight-enough to navigate that drivers instinctively take it slow and never even approach the speed limit. This tremendously reduces the odds of a fatality, although it does make minor scrapes pretty common.
- danbruc 13y agoYou might be spot on - 7,500 kilometers per capita and year in Germany (2011) and 15,000 kilometers per capita and year in the USA (2013). This gives the same ratio as the road fatalities do.
- michaelochurch 13y agoSpeeding in a residential area is a lot worse, for the reason you described. New York City's speed limit of 30 is way too high (should be 20, without the 10mph tolerance). Most highways are underposted and should be 70-90. Bizarrely, 40mph in a residential zone is a minor offense while 100mph on the freeway (which isn't exactly good, but not as dangerous as it sounds with a good car) with zero traffic can cost you your license in almost any state, and put you in jail in some.
- bluedino 13y ago>> Most highways are underposted and should be 70-90. Maybe in the middle of Montana or Texas where it's 50 miles between towns, but not anywhere with off/onramps. People are very bad at merging and it'd be very difficult for many vehicles, especially trucks to get up to speed if 90 was the limit.
- rmc 13y agoDon't trying going on the German Autobahns (motorways). Unlimited speed limit, and unlike USA bendy roads, and lotsa on/off slip roads.
- michaelochurch 13y agoYou make a good point when it comes to merging. Speeds of 90-120 mph are reasonably safe on German autobahns, because people have a regimented driving style (absolutely no passing on right, but the left lane really is the fast lane) and follow it to a T. Most Americans aren't trained to drive those speeds, though, nor do they follow lane discipline.
- drcube 13y agoThat's what on-ramps are for. If traffic is congested enough to demand merging (rather than just making sure the road is clear), you shouldn't be driving at 90mph. On the other hand, you probably shouldn't be driving at 60 either. Speed limits should be limits, not averages, or worst-case.
- sliverstorm 13y ago
- Fizzadar 13y agoThere's a fine balance here; speed isn't necessarily a problem, but speeding in the wrong places/at the wrong times. It's all about driving to the given conditions, which sadly many people do not do.
- jedrek 13y ago34000 is a record low for the past 40 years, btw.
- nostromo 13y agoBefore 1995, the federal government restricted speed limits to 65mph and lower (and prior to 1987, 55mph and lower). When those limits were raised or lifted, those opposing the change howled about how many additional Americans would die with higher speed limits. The decline in auto fatalities (and pedestrian fatalities) has continued, even as speed limits went up dramatically in many states.
- thaumaturgy 13y agoCorrect! The 55mph law was first started during the gas crisis of the 70s. Its impact on traffic safety has been argued back and forth ever since, but so far there is zero concrete evidence that the increase in speed limits has caused a likewise increase in fatalities. (I have heard some good-sounding arguments that 55mph on long stretches of road is actually more dangerous than 70mph on the same, but I cannot find any studies to back that up, either.)
- malandrew 13y agoI'm curious how that number has changed for people in the cars versus people hit by the cars. I would imagine that the rate has dropped precipitously for people in cars, but has been rising for those outside the cars. FWIW I've been hit twice as a bicyclist, both were the fault of the driver. One turned into me while I was in the bike lane and the other tried to overtake me and clipped the front of my bike dragging it under the front tire. I was very lucky both times.
- robomartin 13y ago> And speed matters. Nope. Delta-V, delta-t, crumple zone energy absorption and airbag/safety device deceleration capability matter. The only energy that can do damage starts with the difference in speed between vehicles. Then you have to take into account how much time it takes for the difference in speed to reach zero (that's the delta-t). This is a combination of braking (if any), grinding, sliding (tires sideways, rubbing against barriers, etc.) and crumple-zone deformation. And then you have safety devices such as airbags and seat-belts which are mostly about reducing the rate of deceleration. Of course, initial velocity is important. However, focusing on that alone, I think, is focusing on the wrong variable. Road conditions, for example, are crucial. I've ridden in taxis in Munich at 180 mph. The roads and traffic supported it. No issues. On the other hand, a couple of months ago I was on a BMW on the north-bound 5 fwy just before the Grapevine. I started a lane change when a crack/level difference between the lanes grabbed the tires. This caused a violent unintended lane change. Had my reflexes been any slower or had another car been there it could have been a horrible accident. I wasn't going much faster than 60 or 70 (I was about to get off the freeway to get gas). And, BTW, this is a section of the 5 that was repaired under the American Reinvestment (...) act. Well, they actually managed to cause more damage rather than repair the road. On this section of the 5 it feels like you could loose you kidneys even while riding in a minivan.
- Pxtl 13y agoThe people you run into may not have crumple-zones. Anywhere but the interstates/expressways you have to consider pedestrians as well. Even rural highways have pedestrians and cyclists. Even on the interstate, there are road workers, tow-trucks, and (ironically) police-officers pulled over. For them? Delta-V is just V. And they do have to get out of their vehicles to do their work, so crumple zones are irrelevant too. And this isn't hypothetical - accidents when pulled-over on highways are a major cause of death for all of those professions.