8 ms·
Medicare Millionaires Emerge in Data on Doctor Payments
- fredgrott 13y agodoes the AMA realize that if we follow their objections a to a logical conclusion that the American Public and Gov will ask to release more data not less? Some context, Medicare rates and fess are not adjusted on a timely basis to adjust for changes in medical procedures and technology ..procedures become less time consuming to complete and things become less costly to have completed.. But that is only one context of many that has to be exposed and we need more data to do that This is why the overhaul of Medicare data via the billing system is so vital to improving the benefit the government gets per dollar it spends on Medicare. A very complex CS and Engineering problem that no statup has adequately tackled yet
- bhousel 13y agoDoes any one have a link to the actual data being discussed? They are big numbers but it doesn't necessarily seem to be (except in a handful of cases) outrageous. The numbers are just annual billings, not annual take-home pay, right? For example, I just had a surgical procedure last week to have an otologist repair my eardrum. The breakdown in cost is: Surgeon charge: 7,043 Facility charge: 10,200 Anesthesiology: 1,000 Now, the surgeon is very good at what he does and I feel he certainly deserves that $7000. His surgical schedule has him doing procedures twice a week, probably some more complicated than mine, and I'm sure he easily brings in several million dollars to his practice, some non-trivial amount of which comes from Medicare. Other specialties (like oncology and ophthalmology) are obviously going to make up a bigger share of the amount paid by Medicare because they are disproportionately treating older patients. Until we know more, I think it's silly to be outraged about this.
- danso 13y agoHere you go: 1.7GB uncompressed tab-delimited text, as a 414MB zipped download http://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Statistics-Trends-and-Reports/Medicare-Provider-Charge-Data/Physician-and-Other-Supplier.html http://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Stat... (link goes to the overview download page with context, not directly to the ZIP) Here's a good overview of the limitations of the data: http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2014/04/09/300857727/dose-of-caution-prescribed-when-evaluating-new-medicare-data?utm_source=npr&utm_campaign=nprnews&utm_medium=twitter http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2014/04/09/300857727/dos...
- refurb 13y agoThe numbers being discussed are the physician fees, not the facilities or supplies charges. This is the cash going directly to the docs to compensate them for their time.
- Retric 13y agoThey still need to pay malpractice insurance etc and more than one person is often billing to that same number so it's not really direct to doctor pay.
- refurb 13y agoTrue! It's not a straight salary and docs do have expenses they need to pay out of that money. I was just trying to call out that the cost of supplies and facility fees are paid by Medicare separately.
- riahi 13y agoThis does not include cost of injectable or infused drugs. These are not paid separately by Medicare.
- refurb 13y agoSure they are! If you're an in-patient then drugs are paid for via the DRG payment (all costs associated with treating the patient). If you're an out-patient, they are reimbursed through ASP. The physician fee is separate from these payments.
- riahi 13y agoI'm skeptical for these ophthalmologists to be billing those numbers and NOT include the average sales price (ASP) of their injectable drugs. For those looking in, ASP is how medicare reimburses outpatient drugs. The physician practice buys the drugs up front, then bills Medicare the "average sales price" + 6%. The issue at hand is that Lucentis runs $2120 per injection. If you have a decent or large sized macular degeneration patient population, you'll be doing a lot of these injections. However, the number the practice collects is $320. Out of that number, you have to pay overhead / office staff / supplies etc.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lurchpop 13y agoIf that physician did just 3 of those procedures per day, every day, 5 days a week for a year: $7,043 x 3 x 5 x 52 = $5,493,540
- salgernon 13y agoExcept that OP said he worked twice a week, so even if he did 3 a day (probably more like 2) and assume two weeks cavaction a year, then 7043250 = 704300. Figure malpractice insurance at $50, and he's netting $650k. Figure 10% for billing and business expenses, accountant, etc, and he's netting $600k/year. Is that still unreasonable for a highly specialized surgeon?
- bhousel 13y ago$7,043 x 2 x 2 x 50 = $1,408,600 But anyway I don't think any of the numbers are unreasonable. These are ballpark estimates, and I'm pretty sure my tympanoplasty was a relatively boring procedure for him, compared to stuff like cochlear implants and other basal skull surgery that he does sometimes. My main point was that I don't think it's unexpected at all for some surgeons to bill several millions to Medicare in a year. They can easily clear several millions already with a very light schedule and, depending on the specialty, some or most of that may be from Medicare patients. Honestly I think there is no story here.
- pmorici 13y agoThis isn't the first article I've seen on this and they all seem to imply that something unscrupulous is going on because some doctors make so much from medicare. In some cases there probably is but is data on total payments received alone enough to tell people anything meaningful? I would think you would also need to know what their percentage of elderly patients were vs. private insurance patients. You would also need some measure of their operating costs. Absent that kind of information this seems only useful as a political tool to plant the idea in people's minds that hey these doctors make a lot of money and some of it might be fraudulent.
- arbuge 13y agoI am curious about that one opthalmologist who made $21m in a single year from Medicare alone. That's top hedge fund manager or Fortune 500 CEO territory... Is it possible that this is a businessman with many clinics collecting payments in his name, or is that really one individual who somehow billed this much?
- vonmoltke 13y agoWhile that is a very large number, its the gross Medicare payments to the ophthalmologist's practice via doctor/surgeon charges, not his salary. He personally only gets a fraction of that. Granted its a multi-million dollar fraction, but still a fraction.
- mikeyouse 13y agoThe FBI is asking the same questions of this doctor: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/10/business/doctor-with-big-medicare-billings-is-no-stranger-to-scrutiny.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/10/business/doctor-with-big-m...
- riahi 13y agoThe way Medicare for these high-reimbursement specialties (Ophthalmology, Radiation Oncology, and Medical Oncology) is that the Doctor's practice will pre-purchase the medications/injections/treatments before administering to patients and then Medicare will reimburse the practice. These doctors are certainly not taking home anywhere near a fraction of that number. See: http://oig.hhs.gov/oei/reports/oei-03-10-00360.pdf http://oig.hhs.gov/oei/reports/oei-03-10-00360.pdf The executive summary discusses how two injections used for treatment of Age-Related Macular Degeneration are purchased.
- refurb 13y agoThat's called "buy and bill" and that is paid separately from the physician fees discussed in the article. If you did include the cost of drugs, you'd be correct that physician salary is only a small fraction of the cost of treating a patient. Since some cancer drugs cost over $10,000/month, some clinics spend 90%+ of their revenue just on drugs.
- jaymon 13y agoMedicare and medicaid have traditionally underpaid regular commercial insurance with the result that more and more doctors have dropped it over the years. So it makes sense that payments would concentrate around certain doctors that are still accepting it because more people on medicare will go to them simply because they don't have any other choice, especially in areas that have high concentrations of the elderly, like Florida.
- orky56 13y agoGreat point. It should be stipulated (perhaps speculatively) that doctors have left Medicare to go with private insurance to make more. Thus some of the ones who still accept Medicare do so since it is still worth their time and effort (i.e. still making the big bucks).
- inthewoods 13y agoWe're still only talking about 12% of total Medicare spend - so there's no doubt some fat in there, but you're not going to significantly affect the overall system working on a 12% slice.
- saraid216 13y agoDo you never change your salary unless it's by more than 12%?
- inthewoods 13y agoAre you ignoring the simple math that you can't change the Medicare picture on the back of a 12% allocation?
- saraid216 13y agoChanging pictures isn't math, dude.
- inthewoods 13y ago"Changing picture" = "Make a significant difference in the current financial health or structure of Medicare". In other words, let's say you can change that number to lower it by 25%. Now you've affected 3% of Medicare's cost - hardly the main problem.
- saraid216 13y agoHow is it that you're incapable of recognizing that 3% is larger than 0%?
- vinhboy 13y agoThis is a really cool tool: http://projects.wsj.com/medicarebilling/ http://projects.wsj.com/medicarebilling/ Does anyone here know much about Ophthalmology? What is a "Ranibizumab injection"? It's making bank! The top guy does 37,075 of these are year, at $320 a pop. That's about 100 a day....
- rememb1 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bevacizumab#Uses_in_eye_disease http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bevacizumab#Uses_in_eye_disease Probably why there is a lot of controversy surrounding this and the price of this drug.
- riahi 13y agoRanibizumab is the generic name of Lucentis, an injection into the eye that is used to treat age-related-macular-degeneration. The way Medicare works is that Lucentis is pre-purchased by the ophthalmologist and then reimbursed by Medicare. The doctor is taking home only a fraction of that reimbursement, as the majority of that reimbursement is going directly to the manufacturer. I posted this elsewhere, but the way Medicare for these high-reimbursement specialties (Ophthalmology, Radiation Oncology, and Medical Oncology) is that the Doctor's practice will pre-purchase the medications/injections/treatments before administering to patients and then Medicare will reimburse the practice. These doctors are certainly not taking home anywhere near a fraction of that number. See: http://oig.hhs.gov/oei/reports/oei-03-10-00360.pdf http://oig.hhs.gov/oei/reports/oei-03-10-00360.pdf
- vinhboy 13y agoOk. That makes sense. I'll put away my pitchfork. But a follow up question. Why are some offices doing so many of these? 100/day. That's like a Ranibizumab assembly line.
- vinceguidry 13y agoThe article states that many of the offices getting the largest reimbursements have all of their billings going through one doc. So a large-ish ophthalmology clinic with fifteen eye docs looks like one doc according to the data.
- grantlmiller 13y agoI'm not a data scientist but I'm guessing this data is somewhat normally distributed with a long tail on the right side. I would also venture to guess that if we looked at individual patient spending we'd see some patients spending millions per year. (Though w/ HIPPA maybe anonymized data isn't even available.) Both patients/doctors that are outliers should draw additional attention as the chances of fraud are increased, but the distribution is probably somewhat normal.
- viggity 13y agoI wrote a neat visualization of medicare spending last year. It doesn't go down to the physician level, but I think it is a cool way of viewing the data: http://stonefinch.com/Projects/Medicare http://stonefinch.com/Projects/Medicare It'll take a while to load, there is a 19MB file that gets loaded into your browser. Chrome suggested.
- hoopism 13y agoI have a question. Seems like the practice of billing for a single physician is problematic in understanding potential fraud/inefficiencies. Is there a reason why it can't be mandated that the physician responsible for care not be the one who is on record for payment?
- fsk 13y agoThis is one problem with the current healthcare system. Doctors get paid based on the amount of stuff they do to you, and not based on whether you get better or not.
- zaroth 13y agoThe problem with sysops is they get paid for the number of CVEs they respond to, and not based on whether CVEs stop being issued.