3 ms·
No form of advertising captures intent like search advertising. No data source, statistics, or demograpic information comes close to a user saying "I want to b
by patio11 17y ago
No form of advertising captures intent like search advertising. No data source, statistics, or demograpic information comes close to a user saying "I want to buy widgets, show me your widgets." Until Amazon or Facebook or whomever capture intent like Google does, their advertising will be doomed to being fractionally as effective.
- trapper 17y agoUmm... just think about what you have said, and how amazon has a search button and you'll realise they know more about intent than google.
- patio11 17y agoThey know intent when people are shopping for things on Amazon. For them to threaten Google's dominance in advertising, they need to be able to predict the intent of (and, in doing so, effectively target ads ad) people who are not shopping for things on Amazon. Google can predict intent for people using the Internet because Google has become, essentially, synonymous with online usage in most markets they care about. Yes, Amazon knows when you type in "Wii" at Amazon, you personally are interested in Wiis more than PS3s. This article says that because Amazon knows their customers, in aggregate, prefer Wiis over PS3s, then some magic happens and now Amazon can effectively deliver advertising at people who did not search for anything on Amazon. When browsing happens off of Amazon.com, Amazon gets to know that Americans prefer Wiis to PS3s, and Google gets to know that Bob Smith just typed "buy ps3 online". Which party is more effective at predicting Bob Smith's intent to sell Bob Smith's attention to the appropriate advertiser?
- sfphotoarts 17y agoyou're not thinking this through...
- solutionyogi 17y agoHow about some real argument? His 'Bob Smith' example makes a lot of sense.
- noelchurchill 17y agoWhen/If Amazon positions amazon.com as the place you go to search for anything you want to buy, that's when Google really needs to start worrying.
- dflock 17y agoThey kind of already are, for me at least. I know that if I decide I want to buy something that I think Amazon probably sells, I'll just go a look it up on Amazon directly. I have a couple of other sites that I also know and trust for IT stuff but Amazons prices and fulfillment are generally very keen, especially now with that they do 2nd hand and marketplace stuff. Even if you could save a currency unit or two somewhere else, it's not really worth the time investment to find out - Googling for random products is a massive pain - you just get way to much shopping/price comparison/aggregator type crap back. On reflection, this is the only time that I actually use a 'vertical' search engine for anything. Although Amazons massive product range belies the term vertical, everything else that I search for goes through Google, basically, so this would make Amazon - roughly - my vertical 'purchasing' search engine.
- potatolicious 17y agoDisclaimer: I work for Amazon, but my opinions do not necessarily reflect the company, yadi yada. One of the things that you touched on that needs to be fleshed out more is the fact that Googling for random products is a massive pain. Not only in the sheer volume of data you get back, but also because so little of it is trustworthy. Say I want to buy a new digital camera. I look at the Nikon D40 and wonder "is it any good"? I Google up "Nikon D40 reviews" and I get a gigantic list of pages. Some are clearly spam, others clearly astroturfing for Nikon, and others look like they could be legitimate reviews... but you really don't know. Signal to noise for consumer-level research really sucks on Google. Now take Amazon on the flip side (that I use all the time, and not just because I work there). I trust the reviews that are there - because I know that bad/good reviews are not removed or otherwise manipulated. The star rating isn't spam, isn't fake, isn't bought and paid for like millions of "review sites" scattered across the tubes. Yes, there are ways to break Amazon's review system, but for the most part it is a trustworthy metric, and although not a complete replacement for in-depth research, particularly for big-ticket items, it is still extremely helpful for everyday shopping.
- wildwood 17y agoBut all Google can really tell when someone searches on 'widget' is that the user wants to know more about widgets. Isn't Amazon's data, knowing who searches on 'widget', and then buys a widget, substantially more valuable?
- patio11 17y agoAmazon knows quite a bit about me: they know I bought a Canon camera in 2000, that I have a bookshelf full of fantasy books, 4 entire seasons of 24, and most everything Joss Whedon has ever made. They can reasonably extrapolate from my book purchases that I'm a trilingual Republican Catholic computer programmer. They know everywhere I've lived for a decade. Google knows a bit about me, too, but pretend they only see one search from this morning: [air fares Nagoya to Okinawa]. If you can tell me why Amazon's decade of data is more valuable than Google's single data point in predicting my purchasing behavior in the near term, you will make a few billion dollars.
- Retric 17y agoGoogle potentially has every search you have made, every email you sent and received, and every You Tube video you have watched, and every phone call you have made, most sites you have visited, and knows which adds you have already clicked on. Over months to years, heck they know which addresses you have gotten directions to. Finding ways to use that information is hard, but it's a lot wider than what is this search. Amazon might have a lot of information about some of their customers, but Google has an insane amount of information about some of their customers. Which is more useful across the total web is a several billion dollar question. But I don't think Amazon can scale advertising information into that level yet.
- gdp 17y agoMy search data is likely to be spread around huge numbers of IPs. I'm rarely logged into google. Plus they really have no way of knowing whether I "converted" once I leave the search results. I may open tabs for the top 10 results, but it doesn't mean that I like what I've found, or that I would want to be presented with that kind of information again. My amazon account, on the other hand, has been tied to me for at least 7 years, and likely has every search I've done, every product I've viewed, and everything I did up to and including eventually making a purchase. I've gotta say, based on my own experience as a reasonably typical internet user, Amazon probably have less data on me, but it's bound to be better-quality.
- hooande 17y agoThat may or may not be true. Every search has a stimulus. Most people don't wake up with a craving for widgets and go straight to google. Something that they encounter offline or online leads them to believe that they need to buy widgets. The problem with traditional display advertising is that it takes a shotgun approach...the goal is to show people as many banner ads as possible in the hope that you can make an impression with one of them (and prompt someone to search for your product). Someone with the amount of data that amazon or facebook has could do a lot to improve the general quality of those ads.
- mbrubeck 17y agoAmazon Product Ads already lets advertisers buy space in Amazon.com search results (as well as product pages): https://www.amazon.com/gp/seller-account/mm-product-page.html?topic=200296930 https://www.amazon.com/gp/seller-account/mm-product-page.htm...