9 ms·
Miracle health device crowdfunds $730k, but might be bullshit
- mkal_tsr 13y agoAs someone in the fitness tech industry, the lack of info on the device should be telling. Indiegogo and Kickstarter are becoming full of new HW devices that promise amazing results with very little proof. I really wish these crowdfunding sites required a prototype to independently verify in-house prior to accepting the campaign. Sure it's not a perfect solution (as there could be exceptions of experienced HW developers needing capital to execute and build their realistic prototypes), but it sure would cut down on a lot of "make big promises and flashy videos, excuses later"
- carlob 13y agoAre crowdfunding platform going to be the home shopping channel of this decade? There seems to be a lot of resemblance with the miracle products with dubious claims and ripoffs that are more expensive than the original.
- netcan 13y agoAt least that shows this is not a crowdsourcing specific issue.
- danieltillett 13y agoDo we really need the might in the heading?
- FatalLogic 13y agoIt's in the title of the original article. It still has most of the impact of saying 'It's bullshit', but it is a lot safer from a legal standpoint. edit: I think most of us will read a little of this and the other articles in the series, and then delete the 'might'
- danieltillett 13y agoYes but in this case the word is rather superfluous.
- Angostura 13y agoDo you mean superfluous, or rather superfluous?
- _Robbie 13y agoThis PDF has some test results and a more detailed description of the technology and science of the device. The article does not seem to reference it, so it was probably posted to the campaign after the article was written. http://healbe.com/files/Healbe_HistoryTechnology_04031-C.pdf http://healbe.com/files/Healbe_HistoryTechnology_04031-C.pdf
- Angostura 13y agoThe PDF doesn't actually describe the technology or science as far as I can see. It does include quite a lot of handwaving. There are tables of results, but none independently verified. From what I can tell, it all comes down to whether its claim to use impedance at different frequencies to measure blood glucose levels. There's no indication that this is possible. There's a lot of talk about secret algorithms, but algorithms are only as good as the data they can be fed.
- kamakazizuru 13y agois this journalism? the first paragraph is about how he isn't believable because he has a russian accent yet works in the valley. seriously? Isn't the valley largely made up of foreigners pursuing crazy ideas? This is subjective and fishy armchair journalism at best. Even if the product is junk - there needs to be more substance than "i dont feel like its right because he has an accent and my 2-3 hours of research from my chair didnt show up much". Try researching some biotech companies that are in super-stealth mode - you will find nothing - yet they've often raised double digit millions in funding for their products from VCs...
- MDCore 13y agoThe author seems to be highlighting the accent because after some research he discovers that the CEO actually isn't in San Francisco.
- Blahah 13y agoThere's a big section on the IndieGogo page about how he is a doctor in St Petersburg. The author highlights it as thought it were suspicious.
- MDCore 13y agoI don't see that in the article anywhere (^F doctor ^F Petersburg). I also don't sense any specifically anti-Russian sentiment. I think the references to Russia are to contrast the lack of presence in SF despite a claim to have one, or the lack of corroboration for the claimed references. I imagine the tone of the article would be the same if it was France or South Africa or Malaysia.
- tpeng 13y agoPeople located in non-US jurisdictions (particularly those countries which have a high level of corruption or can otherwise subvert international judicial processes) have less to fear in the way of legal consequences and therefore the likelihood of fraud is much higher.
- achalv 13y agoItBe BS.
- Codhisattva 13y agoGoBe A Sucker! (tm)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- graeham 13y agoNon-invasive glucose monitoring is a holy grail of biomedical engineering. For diabetes management alone, it would be a multi-billion dollar product. This questions why it would be launched in this sort of way - the credientials of the people involved in the project would presumably allow them access to the kind of capital needed to launch a real medical device. Also in that non-invasive glucose monitoring has had a considerable research effort behind it, it is suprising that the 'solution' would come without lots of press coverage of the science, let alone the product.
- atmosx 13y ago> Also in that non-invasive glucose monitoring has had a considerable research effort behind it, it is suprising that the 'solution' would come without lots of press coverage of the science, let alone the product. I've been talking with a Gerontologist doctor who has been actively monitoring patients with diabetes in my town. She is an incredibly up-to-date doctor. She told me that any kind of therapy or approach that doesn't bring $$$ back to the pharmaceutical companies (involving long term treatment with supplies) is immediately abandoned. Research from major players is money-driven and nothing more. She mentioned a couple of cases which I can't recall. I have high hopes for this project and for Google's Contact Lens[1]. Let's hope it flies... [1] http://www.sci-tech-today.com/story.xhtml?story_id=12300CTY4HHX http://www.sci-tech-today.com/story.xhtml?story_id=12300CTY4...
- cperciva 13y agoany kind of therapy or approach that doesn't bring $$$ back to the pharmaceutical companies (involving long term treatment with supplies) is immediately abandoned So... you're saying that they spend millions of dollars on clinical trials, and then they abandon these products? Because there have been plenty of trials for non-invasive glucose meters -- unfortunately, they all fail horribly at producing consistently accurate readings.
- atmosx 13y agoYes, but generally speaking what I'm really saying is: Technologies like the one in question, that can increase the life quality of a large part of the population have a better chance of being developed by minor companies, group of individuals (as in this case) or outsiders (Google, Apple, etc.) rather than a Pharmaceutical company that has an already well established product in the market with a positive revenue stream.
- scrollaway 13y agoThis was publishd 17 days ago. Clicking "more" reveals they wrote further articles about this: http://pando.com/tag/healbe/ http://pando.com/tag/healbe/ Wow. If this turns out to be a scam, and IGG is doing nothing about it and saying "none of this stuff that looks terribly like a scam seems to be a scam so just go ahead and give them money", they should be liable. Ok, if it's not a scam, I will happily eat my words. But if it is, I almost don't see the problem with the company itself but rather with how the platform is handling this. I am very curious to see how this develops.
- doesnt_know 13y ago> Ok, if it's not a scam, I will happily eat my words. But if it is, I almost don't see the problem with the company itself but rather with how the platform is handling this. So if this is all a big scam you "almost don't see the problem" with the company trying to pull off the scam? The blame should lay squarely on the platform? Are you serious? Like, I understand that the platform should take responsibility for their vetting procedures, but to suggest they are more responsible then the company that is trying to pull the scam is fucking nuts. I guess this is just another notch on the "fuck you got mine" belt that seems to be fairly common on HN. If you can think up a good business that doesn't have to deliver and you can get away with it or shift the blame to someone else, you get a pat on the back and are absolved of any responsibility!
- claudius 13y agoNobody trusts a Moscow-based company with a lawyer and PR office in the US. To see this, simply set up a single webpage with a Paypal button advertising for this product. You will get money, but probably not 1M$. On the other hand, people seem to trust IGG and Kickstarter (at least to some extent). This can be demonstrated easily by observing that content which would – on a normal website – not collect any funding seems to do well on these platforms. So, no, it is not entirely about criminal responsibility, but about a misuse of trust, trust that IGG has and which it conferred to some company by letting them use their platform.
- scrollaway 13y ago
- blazespin 13y agoIt's not a total scam, but their use of the word 'exactly' is obviously fraudulent. They admit themselves to measurement errors. That being said, it might be good enough and the next version even better. Crowd funding is about funding things that disrupt. If you want to buy finished and complete, go to your local best buy.. I've participated in a number of kick starters, they all have delays and overhype. That's ok with me. I love bleeding edge tech.
- Nursie 13y agoHow do you know it's not a total scam? The pattern on display here is a classic - make bold (but impossible) claims, attract a crowd of the faithful who want to believe, backpedal and prevaricate when called to back up your claims, collect as much hype and as much cash as possible and then never deliver. It's the same pattern as was seen with perpetual motion machines several times last decade. HHere's a question - what would make you change your mind?
- Morendil 13y agoI saw this campaign a few weeks ago, felt very tempted, ultimately decided it was prudent to wait for the final product to be available. The discussion here has raised some interesting points pro and contra. Much hinges on how well the research state of the art supports the company's claims. My default assumption is that people will jump to conclusions, one way or another, without doing enough homework. Googling for key words in Healbe's brochure has turned up this academic paper which seems to confirm their method for noninvasive BGL measurement is at least a promising path: http://www.eejournal.ktu.lt/index.php/elt/article/download/4566/2588 http://www.eejournal.ktu.lt/index.php/elt/article/download/4... A similar article reveals interesting information about an attempt at noninvasive glucose measurement ten years ago: http://www.engr.uconn.edu/~mam10069/Docs/NonInvasiveGlucoseMeasurement.pdf http://www.engr.uconn.edu/~mam10069/Docs/NonInvasiveGlucoseM... "Report shows the device had correlation with actual glucose level by only 35.1% and in some cases it gave potentially dangerous measurements." (Not exactly a confidence booster, but ten years is enough to improve a lot.) Half an hour of homework has substantially decreased my trust in people who say it's flat out impossible in principle to do what HealBe claim to be doing. ETA: further academic paper links I've posted in other comments: http://dst.sagepub.com/content/8/1/54.short http://dst.sagepub.com/content/8/1/54.short http://knowledgetranslation.ca/sysrev/articles/project21/Ref%20ID%207984-20090628225926.pdf http://knowledgetranslation.ca/sysrev/articles/project21/Ref...
- neverminder 13y agoJust wanted to pitch in regarding the first source - KTU is my Alma Mater and it stands for Kaunas University of Technology. In my country it's among the top universities and is highly respected. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaunas_University_of_Technology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaunas_University_of_Technology
- danmaz74 13y agoThey might have a correlation that is not good enough for diabetes (a life threatening condition) but good enough for dieting. That's also mentioned in the article.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kateho 13y agoI just tried to get a refund, but realised that indiegogo doesn't hold funds like kickstarter do. I understand that its my own fault for not waiting, but if Indiegogo doesn't do anything about this, I think their reputation could get quite badly damaged ...
- unreal37 13y agoBut you chose to donate in the first place. How is this anyone else's fault?
- steven2012 13y agoCall your credit card company and do a chargeback. It's easy, straightforward, and if you tell them you accidentally put money into a scam and that there is $1M invested in this, they might do an investigation on their end.
- notastartup 13y agoso how much does indiegogo make from this deal? is this why they are being tolerant while looking the other way?
- owenversteeg 13y ago4% if it's successful or 9% if it's not, so about $40k currently. I'm guessing this is a huge reason that they haven't pulled it.
- Shinkei 13y agoPhysician here. Yeah, this device sounds like complete pseudoscience. To echo some of the other comments, non-invasive glucose testing is a 'holy grail' of diabetes research efforts and would be hailed as a major breakthrough--something covered by major media outlets and aggresively pursued by all of big pharma and biotech. A red flag for me is the spontaneous development of something that would be completely groundbreaking. I mean all of the people involved are relatively unknown to the scientific community. There should be someone with some kind of credentials who tested and developed the device. A century ago, knowledge and raw materials was usually the limiting factor in discovery and a single genius scientist could make a giant leap in a field because there were a limited number of people total that had access to the knowledge and materials for furthering that area of interest. Today, nearly all of human knowledge lies at the fingertips of anyone with the internet. Everything from genetic sequencing to chemical engineering has become to prevalent and 'cheap' that almost anyone with a good idea have access to all the instruments necesary to achieve 'good science.' Now top this with the multiple Fortune 500 companies that are working to discover a means to non-invasively monitor glucose. Unexpected leaps forward in a scientific discipline, especially in medicine, should be met with great skepticism. As the saying goes, "extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof."
- fidotron 13y agoYep, the glucose thing is suspect, however, my working theory is this is exactly what Apple are up to. Some of the people they've hired are in precisely this area, and it's a suitably massive opportunity to cause an industry wide meltdown, even if a complete longshot. I'm obviously going to be seriously disappointed by the iWatch with expectations like that.
- ricardobeat 13y agoI have the same expectations if Apple were to come out with an iWatch. I'm also absolutely sure they won't be achieving that with a couple of piezos and impedance sensors.
- nebula 13y agoAgree with what you are using as a rule of thumb. However there is the other point of view also. Unexpected leaps forward in a scientific discipline, especially in medicine, should be met with great skepticism. Many advances in medicine also seem to have been suppressed by vested interests: E.g., http://www.ted.com/talks/deborah_rhodes http://www.ted.com/talks/deborah_rhodes
- pron 13y agoCalling this particular device "bullshit" misses the big picture. Considering how little we actually know (and I don't mean, "some studies on 200 people have shown"; I mean actually know) about how a healthy (as in non-sick) human body works[1], most of the products and techniques regarding health are pretty much bullshit, from miracle diets, super-exercises, wonder shakes and magic devices. This is not to say they don't perform their specific functions such as tweaking blood sugar or cholesterol levels, but that the relationships between those metrics and general health are more conjecture than knowledge. What is happening here is something else altogether. It is a psychological phenomenon that some might say resembles religion, but in any case touches on a very primeval function of our psyche. Jonathan Haidt says it's the manifestation of the "purity" value among liberals[2]. Whatever this health craze is, it is far from scientific. Even people who are otherwise very careful in interpreting scientific research, change their lifestyle based on two studies on 300 people in total, that found a decrease of 40% in the incidence of a type of cancer that affects 1 person in 2000. In fact, heated debates over findings of such dubious nature, and a far more dubious relevance to actual day-to-day living, is a common form "religious study" among the faithful, not unlike debates in Jewish Yeshivas. Entrepreneurs – some of them believers themselves – rush to fill the demands of this As a pseudo-scientific religion's worshippers. There is nothing wrong with that. But it should be clear that they fill a very real, and very serious, psychological need, but one that has nothing to do with actual health. As such, calling a particular magic device "bullshit" is not unlike criticizing the efficacy of a particular batch of Virgin Mary icons. [1]: To clarify: we know how it works, but not how each of a gazilion parameters – from weather to sleeping habits to genetics to diet to exercise – affects it. [2]: http://www.ted.com/talks/jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind http://www.ted.com/talks/jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind
- __david__ 13y agoNo. This device purports to be able to measure glucose levels non-invasively. That is 100% verifiable, and most likely BS (to an accuracy that a diabetic would need). Considering that diabetes is a real illness and that glucose monitoring is very important to keeping diabetics alive, this kind of thing doesn't get a pass by being "religious," like a magnetic anti-sea-sickness bracelet might.
- rdl 13y agoI hope the crowd funding sites crack down on crap like this before it poisons the pool for legitimate hardware startups using presales.
- plusfour 13y agoToo late.
- collyw 13y agoThe first time I heard about kickstarter was for some stupid non-science bicycle cranks: http://physicsbuzz.physicscentral.com/2013/01/bad-physics-bad-investment.html http://physicsbuzz.physicscentral.com/2013/01/bad-physics-ba...
- untilHellbanned 13y agoway too late, i've bought 3 things from Kickstarter before giving up. The place is overrun with fraudsters.
- marze 13y agoTo increase the odds of groundbreaking ideas succeeding, you'll want a system that allows certain fraction of junk idea to get funding. I don't know anything about this particular device, but as Ed Catmull says, if you try to eliminate errors you decrease an creative output.
- unreal37 13y agoPeople haven't seen the device yet, but they're judging these guys primarily because they're Russian. If they were a YC-funded SV startup, this article wouldn't exist.
- __david__ 13y agoNo, people are judging because they're claiming a huge medical breakthrough out of nowhere. People would equally skeptical of the kids down the block claiming to have cracked cold fusion.
- unreal37 13y agoIt's fine to be skeptical. (I'm skeptical too.) But where's the line between being skeptical and outright calling something a scam and asking for IGG to shut the campaign down?
- rdl 13y agoI would presume a bit of verification if it were a YC funded startup, or really any identifiable company with funding. Not a lot, but some. Ties to a reputable institution like a university, or a person known in a field, etc. would also be positive. If it's relatively anonymous, it has to stand on its own with whatever proof provided; I'd accept a claim from my neighbor-of-N-years that "your house is on fire" a lot more than I'd accept the same claim in email from Nigeria, but if someone had a live photo/video feed of my house on fire, I'd believe even an anonymous source to a reasonable degree (modulo photoshopping, etc.)
- ulfw 13y agoMIGHT be bullshit? M I G H T B E ?
- zanny 13y agoHow the fuck does obvious crapware get 7x its funding goal while Gooseberry is looking to not reach its goal in the next half month? Is it really just because the Blender Foundation tried to do their campaign on their own site?
- voltagex_ 13y agoMarketing. People who don't normally crowdfund things are finding out about a chance to get a "miracle" device. Meanwhile, who outside of Reddit, HN and LWN knows about Blender's campaign?
- lotu 13y agoBlender is doing a horrible job marketing this. First the video tells you nothing about the movie, from what I can tell it is going to be a movie about "close ups" strange characters faces, because that is what most of the clips were. No story or creative direction is mentioned. Why this movie is special, or important is also never mentioned, I think it has something to do with being "open". However they don't even explain what "open" is much less why it important, will the movie only use open source software, will the final movie be free to "share", will they give us access to all the model files? It looks like they try to explain it in the description but few people will bother reading it. Secondly perhaps more importantly the choice to self host the campaign was very foolish, and probably fatal mistake. I don't know if this was because Kickstarter is not open source, or they didn't want to give Kickstarter 5%. The value of Kickstarter is it's network effect, (not the code to host a video, and manage credit card transactions). If they used Kickstarter they would be exposed to way more potential backers every day, as people backing other film projects look around for other similar projects. If they were on Kickstarter they would be the most funded Film and Video project with the money they have raised on their own and the in the top 10 of currently funding projects.
- intull 13y agoOh, its the "calories" ! The things that people are ready to do to size down, stay healthy and look better; you won't believe it!
- acangiano 13y agoOK, let's assume that these guys created an amazing non-invasive glucose monitoring solution (unlikely). That doesn't tell you jackshit about calories. If I ate 3,000 calories of mostly fat and some protein, or I ate 300 calories of pure sugar, the insulin and blood glucose profiles would be drastically different. And the system would most likely think that I assumed more calories when eating the sugar.
- meritt 13y agoMight be? This thing is 100% snake oil.
- ufmace 13y agoI'm not too interested in the details of yet another probably snake oil medical device, but I am now curious about exactly what IndieGoGo's standards for fraudulent campaigns are. Can you say that it isn't IGG's responsibility to evaluate whether the product being sold actually meets claims that might be complicated and ambiguous? Is their side of the deal okay as long as this company actually manages to deliver some sort of device to the customers? Assuming they can verify that the company actually intends to deliver something, how ridiculous does it have to be before they say the campaign is invalid? In other words, can I make and sell a space-alien repellant on IGG? If people bought it and are happy with their purchase, well, you can't prove that it isn't repelling space aliens, and IGG gets their cut too.
- DonGateley 13y agoI've been following numerous fraudulent projects on Indiegogo and Kickstarter and have come to the conclusion that both are merely carefully shielded fronts for grifters. Both outfits should be taken down by the U.S. Attorney General until they can be regulated in their project vetting so as to eliminate or at least minimize consumer fraud. Currently the more attractive a fraud brought to them is the more they stand to make from it so there is a strong conflict of interest between them and their users. Someone needs to create a site that is a crowd funding wall of shame listing and reviewing projects that show the extent and profitability of fraud. There is KickScammer but it isn't very visible or complete at this point.