9 ms·
Man's high-tech paradise lost: bionic eye removed
- edward 13y agoWired Magazine article about him having the bionic eye installed: http://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/10.09/vision_pr.html http://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/10.09/vision_pr.html
- gfodor 13y agoOne of my friends is "one of the techs" in that article when the dude has the seizure. He doesn't like talking about his adventure to Portugal with the insane mad scientist surgeon.
- e12e 13y agoThank you for that -- I've been looking for that link for years. I remember reading it when it came out, but for some reason was unable to find it in the archives the few times I went looking for it since.
- edward 13y agoAlso: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_prosthesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_prosthesis
- Aardwolf 13y ago> He says the loss of his sight, the second time, was more profound to him than the first, because it was permanent. Why was the first time non-permanent while the second time was? Did the system damage his visual system in his brain?
- Udo 13y agoThere is most likely extensive damage now due to taking the interface out, so there might not be enough neural substance to attach anything to anymore. > Did the system damage his visual system in his brain? I know of no working system that attaches directly to the optic nerve, and the article is very light on details. I assume these implants worked by projecting light on retina remnants. In cases where the eye is destroyed but some of the light-sensing apparatus is still intact, there is the potential for a device that sends light directly into the remaining rods and cones. This is different from a direct electrical interface, which remains the holy grail of brain-machine interfaces.
- canjobear 13y agoThe old Wired article posted by edward has more details. It looks like the machine sent signals directly into electrodes in V1. Seems crazy to me!
- pocketstar 13y agoI doubt they would have removed the Microelectrode arrays from the brain, that would have caused serious damage as the MEAs would be encapsulated in glial scar tissue. The article made it sound like they just removed the two jacks from his skull. The devices were probably Utah Microelectrode Arrays(MEAs) the MEAs were no doubt implanted on the visual cortex on the cerebral cortex to induce phospehnes. This is no holy grail, and MEAs have provided computer-brain interfaces since the 80's. check out my other comments in the thread for more information
- Gracana 13y agoI don't think he means that it is technically impossible, just that before he had hope and an opportunity, and now the opportunity is gone and there is no other one like it.
- oakwhiz 13y ago>He had the jacks removed from his skull at Kingston General Hospital in 2010 as they were infecting badly, due to being made of titanium. I was under the impression that titanium was one of the few materials considered to be safe for human implantation.
- serf 13y agotitanium is safe. the jack part is unsafe. to have a subdermal anchor for external hardware is extremely tricky. flesh pockets around the anchor and has tons of potential for infection after prolonged use. I , too, was confused by the wording.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- waps 13y agoThe way I understand it is this : if an implant is nice and smooth and well integrated with it's surrounding tissue then a titanium implant is safe. Safe in the sense that the immune system won't attack it just because it's there, like it would with metal or frankly almost any substance (the 2 exceptions are titanium and gold, just ask someone with earrings what happens if you insert a silver or metal earring near a scratch). If the implant has sharp edges, or rips into the surrounding tissue, or otherwise causes cells to die or prevents repair of damaged tissue somehow, the immune system will go looking for a culprit[1]. If it decides that the implant is the culprit, bad luck. It will attempt to surround the implant and expel it. Depending on the size this may or may not work (this is what happens to splinters of wood that get into your body, for example). This can even cause the immune system to decide a bone is the culprit, if it does you have rheumatoid arthritis (it's a condition that you are very likely to get if you live long enough) Furthermore, implants may actually infect, as in a bacterial colony may develop on their surface (because the contact surface with the immune system is much smaller, an infection has a bigger chance to maintain that position. Always keep in mind that the immune system wins against bacteria not because it's better or smarter, but because it has 80kg of cells working logistics for it). The same can happen to bones. [1] To be exact, cells have an "alarm" signal molecule floating inside them. If the cell is ordered to commit suicide (apoptosis), it will put out an enzyme that neutralizes this alarm molecule before ripping itself to shreds, the same will happen if the immune system orders a cell to eat itself (autophagy). But if the cell dies for some other reason (e.g. getting ripped to shreds, explosion due to infection, ...) the alarm signal will be spread into the surrounding tissue where the immune system can find it. When it finds it, it will come in force to check out the situation. If it keeps seeing this signal without finding a cause, the immune system will go insane/react badly.
- dm2 13y agoWhy did the devices start to fail after 8 weeks? Was it because of the infection? Are there any similar devices that have been installed in people that have been more successful? $100,000+ for 8 weeks of sight is very sad to think about. What was the approximate resolution of the image that he saw? WEAR YOUR SAFETY GLASSES!
- userbinator 13y agoThat works out to ~$100/hr. > What was the approximate resolution of the image that he saw? From the article it says he saw well enough to drive, so it must've been pretty good. > WEAR YOUR SAFETY GLASSES! "Carol never wore her safety goggles. Now she doesn't need them."
- dm2 13y agoThe Wired article that someone else linked to says that the resolution was 32 x 32 (1024), if that's the same person. The amazing part is that the brain quickly learns to interpret the signals and can create an image. I wonder if the brains image is a higher resolution than the camera considering it's basically processing the raw data and can apply very complex "algorithms" to the data to present an image. I wasn't saying the price was too high, just that it's interesting to think about how lucky we are to have sight for free and that people with not very much money would spend everything just for the chance to regain a small amount of vision.
- rikacomet 13y agoThere is more. Perhaps its better to encourage the research of methods that can restore vision partly. If you think about it, the low vision is workable to a lot of these people, who have known the complete darkness called blindness. Maybe start off in the same manner as the television research. First black and white, low resolution then onwards to full sight. It shouldn't be "All or Nothing" always. Low cost procedures are really the need of the hour. Some people do think like this indeed, but majority of people don't. Articles like this are nice reminders for this.
- watson 13y agoTalk about bad luck! Loosing the sight in one eye at a time in two separate, but almost exact incidents
- jzwinck 13y agoI'm sorry to say this but it sounds like bad risk management. At 17 he lost one eye to flying metal. At that point he might have chosen to be more cautious with his remaining eye, e.g. wearing some form of glasses at all times. But just three years later he lost the second eye...in the same sort of accident. It's not good luck, but it isn't only bad luck.
- Gravityloss 13y agoThe important takeaway is that the social effects of being blind are very big. They could be mitigated entirely without technology, with cultural changes.
- pmr_ 13y agoThis argument can be made for many different disabilities (mental as well as physical). While I don't think we should stop pursuing development of cures we should refocus our efforts on enabling the afflicted to live the life they want.
- leoc 13y agoYou can actually do prosthetic vision without surgery, thanks to the magic (and I use the word advisedly :) ) of sensory substitution: http://www.seeingwithsound.com/ http://www.seeingwithsound.com/ http://www.cs.utexas.edu/~kuipers/readings/Bach-y-Rita-nature-69.pdf http://www.cs.utexas.edu/~kuipers/readings/Bach-y-Rita-natur... . The latency of sound-based sensory-subsitution systems is very high though.
- jaekwon 13y agoI remember the story of a guy who could ride a bicycle by using his tongue to make a loud sound that bounces off of objects. Not sure if it's real, but it sounds plausible. And this. All of these are amazing.
- JonoBB 13y agoHere we go: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-19524962 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-19524962
- twic 13y ago> But the biggest problem facing the 16 patients who had signed up for the surgery was that the lead doctor, William H. Dobelle, was ill. He died while the 16th patient was still recovering from surgery in hospital. > The project ended with his death. > “When he died, there was no medical journal on the 16 patients, with myself being the first one implanted. Nothing was ever written and documented. What the fuck? An experimental surgical procedure is being conducted, and nothing is recorded outside on elderly doctor's brain?
- Retric 13y agoI suspect he may have had encrypted his notes/HDD and with his death the information was lost.
- pyronite 13y agoWhat reason do you have to suspect this extraordinary measure?
- Retric 13y agoI have seen it happen and know of several cases where large amounts of valuable data was 'lost' until someones password was cracked. PS: Escrow services and wills are something that many people don't use. It's the old if I am gone I don't really care mentality.
- hueving 13y agoIt's like a two-step procedure on OSX. Hardly extraordinary and most likely an obvious first step on machines that will contain patient records.
- jakobe 13y agoIt's also odd that the patients had to pay for the experimental surgery. This doesn't sound like a serious clinical trial, it sounds like a hack performed by some back-alley doc in a dystopic science fiction story...
- danford 13y agoWhat's going to happen when things like this become common and they're attached to storage devices? Like when we have BMIs and neuro prosthetics, how will copyright law be enforced? will there be a special "data control agency" that has access to my BMI to make sure I don't copy any information I don't own? Hopefully we'll have some sane laws regarding copyright and software patents by that time. IMO we're on our way to a point where the government needs to step in and keep this kind of hardware/software open source and imho they also need to make laws that make not reporting a bug a semi-serious crime, and very serious crime for agencies that exploit bugs in secret.
- userbinator 13y agoOur eyes are already attached to a mass storage (and processing) device, and although it has a very high capacity, it tends to be rather lossy and have high error rates. :-) It will certainly be an interesting future, and I hope it is one where information becomes even more free.
- NolF 13y agoI think copyright would be the least of the worries. Think about the implications it would have in courts for common traffic offenses, non-violent crimes (including drug use), and maintaining corporate and state secrets. Then also consider other the privacy considerations day to day kind of stuff to even child pornography (minors with this implant). Ideally the BMI would be as protected as the brain in a 5th amendment sense, but it's a very quick and tempting slippery slope...
- nnq 13y agoPeople do realize that this technology is now proven to work, right? And because you can now do everything the wireless way (including the charging part), and using off-the-shelf components (you just need to find a subset of components that can be easily "approved for medical use"), and you'll have 99% less risk of infection! Basically the successors of this technology should already be on the market now! They aren't simply because nobody found a way to make a huge profits and medical doctors are too technophobes and/or drowning in other problems that need their immediate attention to afford take risk* and make the effort of begging the government to fund this.
- gus_massa 13y agoThis is still unproven. There are only a few (¿one?) anecdotes of the experimental subjects, and they can’t show how amazingly good the result were because the device no longer works. Another comment says that the device resolution was 32x32 (this article says that they see “dots”), it’s much better than a 0x0 resolution, but it’s the resolution of an icon. If you have ever drawn an icon, you’d know that 32x32 is not too much. There are similar device for audition, but the wires don’t go directly to the brain. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cochlear_implant http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cochlear_implant Let’s hope that this camera device or a similar device gets fixed until it’s useful in the long term. But it’s important to remember that there are a lot of technical details that need to get fixed, and a lot of clinical test to prove that it’s not a scam, snake oil, an optimistic misrepresentation or any combination of them.
- nnq 13y agoTo be honest, it was probably a dead-end tech that could've worked, but will probably not be developed because other approaches are kind of safer and worked on by more reputable scientists: http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/278/1711/1489.short http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/278/1711/1489... (this one is 38x40, and it's probably easier to get it higher res too :) ) But when it was first tested, it was what seemed to work best, but was abandoned because of the place it was developed in and the (lack of) scientific reputation of the person working on it. The thing with these kinds of things is that you need "proof by engineering and experiment", so if you don't throw money at them before knowing how well they work, you'll never know if they work at all... or you'll never have more than one working technology to choose from. The whole "fund just the best ideas" approach in medical engineering is disastrous imho because the problem space is so huge that you never know what might turn out to work and for what, and at the same time, you obviously can't just do "garage/basement experiments" on these kinds of things, so any equivalent of "wacky garage experiments" actually needs to be funded... this technology was a nice "exploration" of one way to solve a problem.
- jrochkind1 13y ago> “There I met people who were blind as well. (Blind) people over there were so included in society I almost didn’t think about my blindness for a time. > “Then, when I came back here I realized that part of why I was chasing these dreams of seeing again was because that’s the way, in this society, I can be included. Despite the fact that when I’m right here working on my property, I’m not traumatized by my vision loss because I’ve moved on. I’m able to do what I need to do. It’s just that when I’m among society, I’m told I am not really allowed to eat, because we will not give you a job, because you cannot see.”
- pocketstar 13y agoIve done quite a bit of research on this recently. The device is a microelectrode array (MEA), Id hazard a guess that it started failing after 8 weeks because of glial scaring that isolates the device from the nervous tissue. For those interested I just wrote a paper about these and proposes some solutions to these issues: https://www.dropbox.com/s/93nfqy9luojfwa3/MECH%20450A.rev0.pdf https://www.dropbox.com/s/93nfqy9luojfwa3/MECH%20450A.rev0.p... There is a boat load of research going into MEAs these days.
- Terr_ 13y agoDeus Ex: Human Revolution borrows from some of that current-science for its somewhat-dystopic world of the 2027. People with augments are reliant on Neuropozyne, a drug to prevent scarring and rejection.
- T-A 13y agoThis kind of implant is commercially available now: http://2-sight.eu/ee/home-ee http://2-sight.eu/ee/home-ee
- mindcrime 13y agoInteresting that your nick is "T-A". Tessier-Ashpool?
- 0800899g 13y agobionic eye