6 ms·
But there's little to no positive connection between who does the hard work and who gets rewarded for it. Nobody in China nor other country is working their as
by pessimizer 13y ago
But there's little to no positive connection between who does the hard work and who gets rewarded for it.
Nobody in China nor other country is working their ass off to make cheap stuff for developed countries. They're working their asses off to feed themselves and their families. The effort: very high. The value: not so much for them.
I get what you're saying, but covering the effort in valor and moral superiority as opposed to the value realized from that effort just seems to be a way to separate the worker from the fruits of their labor.
- crusso 13y agoThe value: not so much for them. How is a "dramatic reduction in poverty" not of much value? http://filipspagnoli.wordpress.com/stats-on-human-rights/statistics-on-poverty/statistics-on-poverty-in-china/ http://filipspagnoli.wordpress.com/stats-on-human-rights/sta...
- mrow84 13y agoI think pessimizer was saying that the relative return to the labour at the bottom end is low. It is like (to be hyperbolic) living a life of luxury, but on giving the starving man who labours for you a bit of food, suggesting that that is ample reward for his efforts, because of how much value that bit of food has for him. Then, you can top that off by saying that it doesn't matter how much food he produces for you, it isn't of much value because you have so much already. People reject the labour theory of value, probably correctly in fundamental terms, but the marginal and subjective theories of value both seem to promote (and justify) this kind of structural inequality. An example from the relatively recent NPR Planet Money t-shirt project [0] suggests that for that product just under 12% of the cost (6% of the sale price) went to the people who made the yarn, cut the cloth, and sewed it all together. [0] http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/12/13/250747279/episode-503-adding-up-the-cost-of-the-planet-money-t-shirt http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/12/13/250747279/episode-...
- crusso 13y agoI think pessimizer was saying that the relative return to the labour at the bottom end is low At which end of the economic ladder do you think improvements occur for there to be a dramatic reduction in poverty within a whole society?
- mrow84 13y agoThat's simply a rhetorical question, because it is obvious that poverty can only be reduced by providing more wealth to those in poverty. Your rhetoric doesn't address the point though, which is simply that there are (quite dramatic) unequal returns to labour which in turn persist poverty.
- crusso 13y agoYou call it "rhetoric", I call it "evidence that what you're focusing on isn't important". All this focus on economic inequality is misguided. The focus should be upon breaking chains of economic mobility.
- mrow84 13y agoWhy do you think it is misguided? You "break the chains of economic mobility" by providing people with enough wealth and time to allow self-improvement; if you withhold that wealth and time by dictating terms from the powerful side of an economic relationship then that absolutely is significant. You state "all this focus on economic inequality is misguided" very brazenly, but what evidence do you have that the two aren't linked? From my position they intuitively are linked, and pretty strongly - sure, intuitions can be wrong, but why are you so confident that we can ignore the effects of inequality on poverty? At the most basic level, wage growth for those in poverty provides better housing, better nutrition, better healthcare, and better education, which all in turn lead to better economic prospects, because those things make you significantly more employable in all sorts of ways (you're more reliable, you're not weak, you're more healthy, and you're not stupid).
- pessimizer 13y ago>How is a "dramatic reduction in poverty" not of much value? Value relative to effort. Compare your level of effort to your level of PPP received in return. Would you consider 1.25 USD@2005 a day to be an achievement for them in comparison to you, or an abysmal failure of society to justly allocate its rewards to the people who put in the effort? In other words: is a just reward for doing the work that supports the lifestyle of the developed world a 'reduction' in the worst sort of abject poverty?
- crusso 13y agoValue relative to effort. society to justly allocate its rewards Your arguments ignore the failure illustrated by history of the strategy of society proactively allocating anything. Decades and decades of programs that spent billions of dollars giving money and sustenance impoverished groups across the globe, yet what finally begins to pull China out of poverty? Capitalism. Letting people trade freely within a legal framework that protects everyone's property rights without regard to political and financial power is just. Everything after that is gravy.
- tsotha 13y ago>Value relative to effort. I'm not sure what you think Chinese people did before they moved to the cities. Farm labor is backbreaking work, and they did it from sunup to sundown. Working in a factory for ten or twelve hours a day is a step up.