3 ms·
"What exactly is stopping us from doing this?" "...geometry." I've had too many conversations like this, where I pause to think "where do I begin to fill the
by mikestew 13y ago
"What exactly is stopping us from doing this?"
"...geometry."
I've had too many conversations like this, where I pause to think "where do I begin to fill the vast gaps of ignorance such that they will even begin to be properly equipped to understand the absurdity of their question?"
- dopamean 13y agoYou sound like a joy to work with.
- reitzensteinm 13y agoYou're getting downvoted because it's pretty rude to say it out loud... But honestly, I thought exactly the same thing. I consider myself pretty damn skilled in the areas where I focus, but in all others you could drive a Mack truck through the gaps in my knowledge. In any kind of fruitful working relationship, I'm expecting to be both on the giving and receiving end of those conversations more than occasionally... otherwise, what's the point of even collaborating? Either OP is a) working with idiots (in which case, quit yesterday), or b) he's not valuing the skills they're bringing to the table. If they are ostensibly in the same role as him and should know better, see (a).
- tedsanders 13y agoI think it depends on how you read mikestew's comment. I am a physicist and I can relate to his experience. Sometimes friends/family will ask me absurd, ignorant questions and I have to pause to figure out how to answer them. But just because the questions are absurd or ignorant doesn't mean I disrespect the questioner or their other areas of competency. I think it's awesome when people have the curiosity and the confidence to ask questions that risk being ill-posed. Taken at face value, mikestew's comment seems fine to me. I guess it depends on how much disdain you read into his usage of 'absurd' and 'ignorant'. Perhaps he meant them literally, with no connotation implied. I guess only he knows. And when the OP's intentions are not clear, it's probably not best to respond with a rude remark.
- mildtrepidation 13y agoYour (a) and (b) do not nearly cover the scope of possibilities here. They don't even address the (more realistic) situation suggested video: You don't have to be an idiot to have a less-than-complete understanding of the technical underpinnings of a project on which you're making decisions and to make suggestions that are impossible and, potentially, quite stupid from the point of view of someone versed in the tech. You also don't need to be undervaluing someone's skill set to see their lack of understanding of a project's limitations and requirements as a detriment and impediment to your progress; it is, and acknowledging it as such does not require being a jerk, nor does it necessarily make you a jerk. If you're saying "man, what an idiot you are" to people who suggest things that aren't possible, feasible, or sensible, then yeah, you probably have some growing up to do (of course, most of us do anyway). But that's not the same as addressing someone else's very real problem before it makes your responsibilities intractable.
- dang 13y agoYou're getting downvoted because it's pretty rude to say it out loud No, it was downvoted as a rude personal remark, and rightly so. That's just what downvotes are for. There are countless appropriate ways to raise any genuine concern.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoSo you're forming a negative opinion of him because you feel he lacks skills you feel you have? Sweet irony.
- tedsanders 13y agoJust to add to your response, I think absurd questions are totally OK. It's a fact of a life that non-experts will need to talk to experts, and when that inevitably happens it's best if (a) the non-experts aren't scared of asking potentially absurd questions and (b) the experts can translate their thinking into non-expert language. Both (a) and (b) are necessary for great communication.
- mikestew 13y agoGenerally speaking, I have no problem with absurd questions. Ask away. But if you're sitting on the other side of the table just waiting to hear what you want to hear, ignoring all else, and continuing to ask the same questions, then you're not doing your part on the "great communication" thing. That's my take on what the video is trying to get across. Too bad cnet editorialized the title, and incorrectly so, IMO.
- wglb 13y agoI agree with the absurd question point. However, I have been in a room much like that and the part of it that is indigestible are the absurd questions in the form of a demand for action, disregarding the fact that green lines are not red, for example. "So we can do this, right?"
- RangerScience 13y agohttp://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Charles_Babbage http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Charles_Babbage On two occasions [Charles Babbage] had been asked, — "Pray, Mr. Babbage, if you put into the machine wrong figures, will the right answers come out?" To which he replied: "I am not able rightly to apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a question." (I usually remember it as "I cannot rightly comprehend the confusion that would engender such a question"; either gets the point across.)
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoGeometry? But you can have 7 mutually perpendicular lines, even in a [7-dimensional] Euclidean space ... the ink thing is slightly misleading too, a yellowy-green will appear red under red-light. So that's doable. Just the transparency, oh and a choice of projection for the display in 2 or 3 dimensions of the lines ... ;0) It's a great video.
- geebee 13y agoI can get you the resources for a Euclidean spacer, if that's the issue.
- leishulang 13y agocoming back to say the same thing, then saw your post. The rest of the problem is easy for the engineer: how to get into 7 dimensional world?